anchorm4n - I like it mechanically, it's a neat effect. however it should definetly have a mana cost limit similar to Vast Wisdom. However, i don't really feel how this has synergy with either beasts or mechs. Might as well say random minions, doesn't require or encourage tribal decks.

Moondreamer - awesome idea tbh, 10/10 flavor. Gameplay wise tho… no one would play dragons in their decks i think. Super super rarely do you ever want to kill your own minions in HS, cause 2 bodies is almost always better than 1 big guy. If this card were real people would just play beast face hunter i think. Only a rush or charge dragon would make it somewhat playable as intended.

AeroJulwin - neat idea, if we ever get undead rogue. Until then this is only gonna be seen in pirate decks. But it's a good card. As for the reanimator, change the art. Nothing resembling necromancer or scourge or evil there, just some elf. Also i think it's not really a Zombeast then? Maybe just "Stitch together and undead and a beast"

Demonxz95 -  cool idea but i worry slightly about priest and summoning 7 of this dude over and over. One of those cards that has the potential to be nasty if he gets the support for it.

Neoguli - simple enough card, nothing to criticize but also nothing that really impresses me personally. But since a simple "discover stuff, keep all 3 if" card won last time perhaps the wider audience enjoys simpler things.

Wailor - Are there really that many totems that you'd want to copy their effects? Most are just add cards to your hand or buff something. Don't think there is enough reason to play the totem guy.

Regarding balance, my initial feeling is that it's too cheap, but you need a lot of preparation for it to work, and power level nowadays is a lot higher than when I used to play. So I guess it's fine? Dunno, listen to other people in this regard.

I like the effect of triggering Battlecries from your hand and I think 7 Mana is quite appropriate, given how strong the effect can be. That said, it makes me wonder a couple things:

• Do effects that target the user (like Twilight Guardian's) taget Constellos instead?
• If you're only holding a single Dragon and it has a "hold a Dragon" requirement (again, like Twilight Guardian), does it count itself and always triggers?

I'm guessing the answer for these is yes in both cases, but I wanted to know.

Regarding Captain Shivers, I think it's your better card and I like it quite a lot. I like how it can be used with just Pirates or just Undead, but it's much better if you combine both (what I tried with Deadmoon Raider, but much better executed).

I think 3 damage isn't too much, as you need to do a lot of heavy lifting to maintain the chain going. Plus, 2 damage AoE is very weak at turn 6, even if you can potentially go infinite.

Linkblade: I'd bump him up to 5 mana, for future balancing reasons. Having a 3-mana Mech with Deathrattle die and summon King Krush on turn 3 feels bad, and could be a possibility as is. At 5 mana, that's still a possibility, but feels… well, bad, but in line with current large minion cheats, at least. Flavorwise, setwise, otherwise, it's a fantastic and interesting card. I'd love to play with it.

Wailor: Lord Amethos makes me think, at least, which I like. But it's not a long think. Any Totem deck with 5-10 Elementals won't rely on Totem synergies, so you'd be choosing Totems like Mana Tide Totem with general effects. In which case, maybe you can get a 4-4 with Taunt that heals 1 and draws a card and gives +1 Attack at turn end and gives +2 attack to neighbors. If it's turn 6 and you're very lucky. Totems are a tough type to build a multi-class card for. They don't play nice with others.

On the flip side, Deadmoon Raider feels solid. It could work. A minion-heavy Pirate Rogue could want it, if such a thing exists. It doesn't feel exciting in an existing-deck-completion or a power-fantasy sort of way, though.

Oop. You posted another one. Blackgill Cultist is the strongest card for sure. The deck he promotes feels real. Creating a gateway between small Murlocs and tall Demons feels very Warlock, very doable. As everyone knows, Team 5 loves to tease us eager boys with big Demons that never see play - any excuse to make that happen sounds good to me!

Neoguli: It's a solid card. Resource generation. Stats. Fits with the themes (though I'd change it to a Dragon, as said above). I'd be more excited about it if a Dragon-Naga deck existed or felt relevant. Is there such a deck out there that I don't know about?

Demon: You put this at 7 mana so I could play it with Drakkari Enchanter, didn't you? Heheeee. I like it. I guess it'd be most powerful in Druid or Shaman, with Bearon Gla'shear or Topior. There isn't a glut of exciting high-cost Elemental battlecries, though. Maybe if it were costed lower and the cards it draws from were mana-capped?

Aero: Captain Shivers is the more straightforward, strong card. Exactly what such a Rogue deck would need, I suppose. Crafting a custom Zombeast is more exciting, though. While the lore doesn't work currently, as noted, I'd enjoy a card that explored that more than a card which explores Pirates and Undead for Rogue. Maybe there's another way to do it. (Note that Reanimator would be spelled with an o, though.)

As an amusing sidenote, the artwork you chose for Shivers deserves an award for most used in fan competitions. Somebody oughta tell the artist.

Moondreamer: As noted, the flavor is on point, but the idea of eating your own minion feels irredeemably bad. Maybe it would feel better if you specified 'original stats' instead, but then why buff the Beast? Maybe there's another way to swing the same flavor, whether through a repeating effect with all Beasts, a minion or weapon that triggers a similar mechanic, or such.

anchorman: I'm not sure. On one hand, it's an exciting swing that can miss and is gated behind the opponent's actions (somewhat), so I'm not calling for a higher mana cost. But it also doesn't promote a specific style of deck. A solid 3 star card for me, since it seems workable but I don't think it promotes a deck or flavor that I enjoy.

Basil: I love it. Wouldn't change a thing besides the artwork and the first blank line of text. Favorite card in this thread, promotes an interesting, new deck and makes me rethink lesser-used minions. Think up some good flavor text for that beastie! I want to see him win.

Anchorm4n: I actually really enjoy the idea behind this card's effect (though I agree it pushes its luck a bit when it comes to the rules) but I feel like you are going to need to find a really good artwork to sell the card, which is always quite difficult. That's why I think, for custom cards, a top-down approach where you start from the artwork and then think of the effect is pretty much always better.

Wailor: I like this effect and I've quite enjoyed the addition of the Murloc package to various Reno Warlock decks. With that said, I think you could actually push this a bit more considering the deckbuilding cost. I feel like this could be pushed to 4 mana, maybe at the cost of a stat point somewhere. Not many ways you can break Demons by cheating them out on turn 4, anyway. Warlocks have been doing it since Naxxramas!

linkblade91 - sorry for skipping you. I like your card because it fits both hunter themes (mech and beasts being main tribes) and it implements an effect that appeared in the class before but in a new way. Still i think it's the sort of deign to be either broken or worthless, like with a lot of recent hunter legendaries (Wing Commander Ichman, Tavish Stormpike).

Me0203 - Honestly i feel using amalgams here is a bit of cheating the intended point of the contest. That aside the cards are also kinda… weird. I don't get what Volatile Experiment even does. It gives tribes from the board to minions in your hand? if so it's a really bad way to formulate it. Tur'ribe is just bad. Bad stats for the cost, asks you to have played 2 of 6 amalgams that exist in the game and the payoff is not worth it.

Wailor - Like it a lot but please put it at 4 mana. We already have Gorloc Ravager with same stats and similar effect. If you wanted to make like a warlock version of him… fine. But this card is already heavily played in warlock to tutor Mutanus and gigafin so it's like you have 4 of the same minion almost.

Battlecry: If your deck contains exactly two minion types, give both types to all minions in your hand, deck and battlefield.

It should have vanilla stats, as it's not a very strong effect. Alternatively, you can make it so that it also gives +1/+1.