New Neutral Minion - Southsea Scoundrel

Great stats, net you a card - love this

Great stats, but not sure like it sees play. I don't think Mill decks will use it either. You really don't want to give your opponent a free draw.

pack filler, you don't really want to give your opponent draw.

Nice storytelling here. And a nice sunset!

I mean you get a good card but depending on the mana cost, your opponent gets to play that good card before you do.

If only  Shenanigans worked on your turn

bah ... don't see how can it be useful

Pirate Waifu, but the effect is rather bad.

Drawing a card for your opponent is not good. Drawing a good card for your opponent is even worse.

We don't really have a deck that relies on not drawing a specific card.

If it was a 2 or 3-mana card I would consider it, but 4 is just too slow.

Strong stats and not that big of a downside

Mmmaybe? dunno the drawback seems weird

Good stats, and not that much downside. It also fits thematically for the card. 

Seems super cool! Love it big time.

I dont get it. it says discover, not discover a copy. so you gonna steal from his deck but then he also draws... a what?

hmmm, not really that powerful. Good arena card.

It might be alright? Could be used for value while also pushing your opponent toward fatigue at a greater rate than you.

I don't know what to make of this card. On the one hand it is a 4 mana 5/5, on the other hand it gives your opponent a card, but it also gives you the same card, but the card came from their deck which means they are probably better suited to use it than you, but you also got to pick the card out of 3 which means you have some agency over what gets drawn, but this card also doesn't really do anything to advance your own personal game plan, so I really have no idea with this card. I don't think it will see play outside of meme decks like casino mage, thief priest, or some silly shudderwock deck. 

Fill their hand then play this and get they win conditions?

Poor value for its cost

opponent draws a card is never good

good

The pirate tag works, but not sure if it's very useful

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, 4 mana 5/5 both players draw a card that I choose, seems good

maybeee useful for overdrawing idk

seems like whichever good card u pull will likely be better for you opponent, no?

Super weird value pirate since pirates are mostly aggro/weapon orientated. Doubt it'll see play in constructed. Might be more viable in arena 

Drawing your oponent a card makes this kinda good enough but not that much to see play

i don't see the value here

Nice

I love the design on this.

Nah. I don't think you want your opponent's cards bad enough to run this. 

Don't like it, you don't want to be giving your opponents cards.

Quote From ArcyroX

I dont get it. it says discover, not discover a copy. so you gonna steal from his deck but then he also draws... a what?

They probably didn't make it fit into the text, since it's quite long already. When you steal from opponent's deck, it literally says steal, like Death Grip.

Potential in mills if Soul Fragment selected?

Good card for Nice Guy decks if you want to help your opponent pull off a tricky combo. Cards in your opponent's deck are usually worth more to your opponent than they are to you. Unless this is used in combination with a card that shuffles unwanted things into your opponent's deck, I don't think it will make it into very many decks.

Art is great effect is oh boy really bad.

Edited the comment, didn't understand the effect well.
You don't want to give any opponent resources as an aggressive deck (which you plobably are, playing this for +1 attack). So no.

it can be good in some kind of burglar rogue with pirates in wild

Quote From jacob1487

pack filler, you don't really want to give your opponent draw.

No, indeed, but it grant you a card advantage - plus one card generated for you, that isn't subject to too much random, as it was good enough to make it into your opponent's list - and the certitude that the card is in their hand ; that knowledge can be advantageous.

Aside from being the top end tech option for a hyper aggro deck, I don't see much usefulness out of the card which is a shame, the art is amazing.

Could be overly broken in a mill deck.

Decide which card your opponent mills is insane value.

Going to try it if I open it.

I'm sure this is meant to be disruptive in some way, but the only deck I can imagine it working against is a Sunscale Raptor Hunter. Drawing the raptor early would keep them from buffing it with Scavenger's Ingenuity. Obviously also good if you can force them to burn something important, but that's not exactly a consistent game plan.

Maybe there's more, but since I can't think of anything, I'm going to have to say this is bad.

4 mana 5/5. That's very solid in Arena, but I don't think this will ever pass meme status in constructed.

A lot of variance. Hard to tell which way it falls

Too random, even with a discovery keyword.

A 4 Mana 5/5 that gives you some value and gives both you and your opponent information about one card in your respective hands. What a weird one... I don't think it'll be that useful. 

You generate a card while your opponent draws a card. I'd say your opponent is getting the better deal and that is nowhere near worth +1 stat above vanilla stats.

Good stats, but the effect doesn't seem worth it

Awful, unless you use it force them to overdraw and burn a key card.

I can see this on a mill deck.

Very good and even better if your opponent has a full hand

"Yeah, THAT'S what I stole!"

Good Stats and could work to overdraw your opponent. But i think most of the time your opponent will get to use the drawn card before you so not sure if this will be any good. 

Still decent stats that will also get you a card. Overall an ok card.

Stats ok, but you should not help opponent draw a card.

intresting but useless

Not sure what kind of deck would want this. Thief rogue? But even then it is bad

I like the way they get to know what you have copied.

Drawing for your opponent is never a good thing, and there's always an argument to be made that your opponent will always be able to make use of their card better than yourself.

Its only niche is that if your opponent some how has 10 cards in hand then this card is just nuts. Try and guess how many times that will happen, multiply that with zero and that's exactly the number of times you will see this card unironically in a competitive deck.

Interesting, nice flavor here. Good stats and a generated card, with the punishment of your opponent drawing a strong card. Maybe could see play in an aggresssive Pirate deck?

Giving your opponent a good card(they play good synergy cards) and you getting an okay card at best. 5/5 isn't even good to make it worth it no immediate board impact , okay in arena.

Great stats, and you can generate a card from your opponent. However, he draws it as well, so you'd better be able to use it better than him.

First of all, good stats and nice art

Maybe a deck spying tool

One of those cards which are good if you're winning and terrible if you're losing.

So if you want to draw a good card from their deck he draws the good card too? Why do we want that? Dont tell me to know what cards your opponent is playing because after a few weeks we know all the cards the decks are playing

good

This is a very strange value pirate. Maybe it sees play in a metagame where some deck wants to have specific cards in their deck? For example, forcing a Deathrattle Demon Hunter to draw their deathrattles might weaken Death Speaker Blackthorn, or maybe you draw a key beast card to mess with Warsong Wrangler?

4 mana 5/5, no need to say more

The stat are very good but drawing a card for your opponent is terrible, especially if that card is good. So the drawback is to much to play it

Very good anti combo card, even better after Polkelt

Very unreliable, but could still be good.

This is an interesting effect, but I can't see a use for it other than learning about your opponents deck or trying to mill.

Mechanic is interesting but the effect is rather awful. You do not want to give your opponent a free card, that is terrible in most cases

Great stats, discover and a pirate tag. Seems decent.

Cool 

Seems like it'll be used in Mill and nothing else. I doubt the effect is consistent enough to be played just for the disruption capabilities.

It's epic, so it's nothing a want in my collection. And nothing I want to play. Just another epic card in expansion.

This is a very strange card, hard to tell if it'd ever be useful

Super interesting effect being pushed with premium stats, but it feels a bit too weird to be considered over other options/

kinda weird card. good stats though

Im not crazy about giving them their card since theres a better chance they'll benefit more from it then me but maybe in steal Priest or Rogue.

Meh

Very weird card, and probably not very good. Symmetrical effects need to be way more abuseable by the person who plays them in order to be good.

good card

That is an interesting take on steal mechanics. Sure you get something interesting from your opponent. But  they also draw it. I'm trying to decide if there is anything that you would want to force draw.

Slow but fun

I like the design, but I think the symmetrical effect may keep people from using it much. It may be too damaging to give your opponent a card in many situations. 

Good stats, but this is definitely a downside. Won't see play

The opponent drawing their card as well seems too much of a drawback to overcome.  Maybe it can fit in some Wild Mill decks, but I don't see it impacting standard.

Interesting design but helping your opponent draw their powerful cards doesn't seem like a good idea.

The ONLY benefit I see is the extremely niche case where a combo opponent has a full hand and you make them burn a combo piece.

In the pre-Barrens meta, it feels like that might have happened a lot, but I don't think it's going to be a useful strategy in the Year of the Gryphon.

Damn, until know I thought you stole the card and the opponent got the other two cards! Oops.
Anyway, seems clunky. I don't see a reason to use this anywhere, except it would be super cool in Burgle Rogue.

I'm not sure about this one. You maybe discover a good card from your opponent's deck, but they draw their copy too. I struggle to think of scenarios where this would be more advantageous to you than them.

This is the card I never knew I wanted. It's really cool and the stats for the cost make this twice as good.

Good for burning an opponent's card. Doubt will see play in any meta deck.

Better to not give a strong card to your opponent

Not really good to give your opponent cards.  

I guess you could try and pick a card that won't be useful for your opponent right then... but then is it really going to be useful to you, who didn't even put it in their deck?

You give a card to the opponent which is bad, but you gain information too and a copy. Strange but could be fun to get an extra Old God or something big as long as you can remove their copy.

Good stats for the cost, but the battlecry is the definition of a catch 22.  If you choose a good card then you give a good card to your opponent, but if you choose a bad card it might just be bad for you, since your opponent clearly had something in mind when they added it to their deck in the first place.  It's definitely a risk either way.

Great stats. Effect might be good too.