2 Old Murk-Eyes

I was browsing thru my collection and noticed I've got 2 Old Murk-Eyes. I think I must have gotten the second one when I was reaping all the free achievement rewards just after patch 20.0 went live. Unfortunately, no 4 Parrots, not even 2, as I still don't have Captain Greenskin from the Classic set. I'm somewhat hesitant to dust one because I'm not really sure if Blizzard knows about this already and what they'll do when they're aware of their mistake.

Anyone else got extra copies? What did you do with them?

I also got a 2nd Old Murk-Eyes and another Parrots from the new achievements. I dusted the extra legendary.

Same thing here. I have 2 Murkeye and 4 parrots. When the new achievements launched seems they rewarded you again if you met the requirements.

I'm certain their safe to dust but I'm holding them until stuff settles a bit just in case. Expansion+ Core is a big launch. Letting blizzard catch up a bit to clean up some of these bugs. Then dust they will become.

I've dusted mine by now. If Blizzard decides to do anything at all. The most they can do is remove the dust from our accounts we got from dusting. If they decide to remove the other copies of Murk-Eye and Parrot reddit and twitter will blow up again.

Quote From Tumbleweedovski

I've dusted mine by now. If Blizzard decides to do anything at all. The most they can do is remove the dust from our accounts we got from dusting. If they decide to remove the other copies of Murk-Eye and Parrot reddit and twitter will blow up again.

There was no mistake.  Pretty much certain they intended everyone to get it if they met the requirements, even if they already had one.

I'm not sure it was intended to get another copy of you owned them already, but may have been harder to program a check for.

If it was intended, fine, but either way, at this point, the bad publicity of revoking the extra cards and dust will be more trouble than it's worth over a whole one legendary and pair of epics.