Feedback Realm

Feedback

9 Characters

Some small bits of feedback on the Site :-)

Submitted 5 years, 5 months ago by

First off, the site looks really good - I like the Adventure Font (I think it is) for the site name / logo. 
If I see things, I'll add them to this here. But some bits I've come across:

- It would be useful to have a link at the end of a thread page to return to the top of the page and / or a breadcrumb link to get back to the main page again. Having to scroll up to the top of the page (or pressing Ctrl+Home) is doable, but awkward

- There is a random "p" down there under the entry text area for replying to a thread (or creating a new one). Pressing it selects all the text in the Text Area. If that is the intended function, it could probably use a rename in front end code

- (Low priority) - Any chance of customisable (or selective) colour schemes perhaps?

- Notifications for new messages as it's hard to keep trakc of replies.

- Profile & Manage options. The Manage option could probably work better if inside the Profile PAge area. I found that when I wanted to update my profile, I inuitively clicked on the Profile link and was then confused as to how to edit my details. :-)

******
EDIT : From Ironfist15 

- Search box for forums to stop potential spamming

- Notification tab

From "P"

- Search box for cards

On that note, should "P" be a viable username? Lol :-D 
Think you may want to consider a minimum char-length for names and passwords (if there isn't one)

 

*** I will add more as I come across things ***

Cheers all! :-D

  • Scorpyon's Avatar
    120 92 Posts Joined 05/28/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    First off, the site looks really good - I like the Adventure Font (I think it is) for the site name / logo. 
    If I see things, I'll add them to this here. But some bits I've come across:

    - It would be useful to have a link at the end of a thread page to return to the top of the page and / or a breadcrumb link to get back to the main page again. Having to scroll up to the top of the page (or pressing Ctrl+Home) is doable, but awkward

    - There is a random "p" down there under the entry text area for replying to a thread (or creating a new one). Pressing it selects all the text in the Text Area. If that is the intended function, it could probably use a rename in front end code

    - (Low priority) - Any chance of customisable (or selective) colour schemes perhaps?

    - Notifications for new messages as it's hard to keep trakc of replies.

    - Profile & Manage options. The Manage option could probably work better if inside the Profile PAge area. I found that when I wanted to update my profile, I inuitively clicked on the Profile link and was then confused as to how to edit my details. :-)

    ******
    EDIT : From Ironfist15 

    - Search box for forums to stop potential spamming

    - Notification tab

    From "P"

    - Search box for cards

    On that note, should "P" be a viable username? Lol :-D 
    Think you may want to consider a minimum char-length for names and passwords (if there isn't one)

     

    *** I will add more as I come across things ***

    Cheers all! :-D

    0
  • Zelgadis's Avatar
    Wizard 1070 868 Posts Joined 05/29/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    - There is a random "p" down there under the entry text area for replying to a thread (or creating a new one). Pressing it selects all the text in the Text Area. If that is the intended function, it could probably use a rename in front end code

    I was also wondering what that "p" was at first, but it seems to list the HTML tags that contain the text you're currently editing. Try moving your cursor into quoted text or change the style from "paragraph" to "heading 1" and you'll see it change. I agree though that it's not very intuitive and people who are not familiar with how HTML works will be even less likely to figure it out.

    0
  • Scorpyon's Avatar
    120 92 Posts Joined 05/28/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    Ahhh it's markup info. Interesting. It could be a random tag that has been left open, perhaps. 
    Or maybe it's purely a guide to what mode you are in perhaps. 

    0
  • Zelgadis's Avatar
    Wizard 1070 868 Posts Joined 05/29/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    The way it is nicely formatted for nested tags suggests it is deliberate. But I don't know if it's intended as an end-user feature or a leftover debugging feature.

    0
  • p's Avatar
    E.V.I.L. Dragon 615 127 Posts Joined 05/28/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    Biggest missing thing imo is a search box even just for cards with auto complete would be enough

    0
  • IronFist15's Avatar
    45 7 Posts Joined 05/28/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago

    Search box for forums to stop potential spamming

    Notification tab

     

    Otherwise great work so far! Also I can't get the deck in my signature to show. Does it show for other users that I have a deck in my signature? It doesn't show when I view my comments.

    Invalid Deck ID

    0
  • Horus's Avatar
    Detective Pikachu 2575 3348 Posts Joined 05/29/2019
    Posted 5 years, 5 months ago
    Quote From IronFist15

    ''(...) Does it show for other users that I have a deck in my signature? It doesn't show when I view my comments.''

    No, your signature is one line that reads ''Invalid Deck ID'' ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

    Struggle with Heroic Galakrond's Awakening? I got your back : 

    0
  • Leave a Comment

    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Sign in here.