I see a lot of potential for shenanigans here, I just haven't come up with something truly crazy yet. TITANS and Colossals are one obvious alley to go down, there's always Illidari Inquisitor and then you could also try and abuse low Health Deathrattle stuff. The card opens a lot of possibilities and for that alone I'll rate it highly.
Hey look, we got a new Stormhammer! And that's where you can see this isn't the best card unfortunately: It's too expensive and keeping the condition alive is way harder. Might be good with Aranna in play. Mediocre card for now.
This is probably too situational to be considered removal (as in attacking the targeted minion with your hero). Gain 4 Attack for 3 Mana isn't exactly efficient either. Combining the two makes it slightly better, but not crazy good (reducing Attack of the opponent's minion allows for a favorable trade with your stuff). Acceptable way to gain more Attack, but I'm not excited.
Depending on what aggression looks like in the new meta, this could be useful as early game board control (or you can use it to soften up the board for a Baking Soda Volcano clear). I'm thinking it's more likely to be run in Burn Shaman, combining it with Spell Damage (and maybe some cost reduction) for big damage on the opponent's face.
It's a big body that could soak up some hits in an aggressive meta. Besides that, maybe you're running this in a Frost Tourist DK to trigger Freeze payoffs? That's probably too wonky to work.
I'm betting there's a Mana sweet spot where this is really good most of the time, but's there's just too much risk for me - I'm paying 4 for this, so I'd probably like to be summoning a minion that costs 4 at least, but likely I'm going for big payoffs if I went to the trouble of running this. It's unreliable; it could make for some fun games but I don't think you're going to win a lot if you include this in your deck.
As anchorm4n said, Discovery of Magic is waaaaaaaaaaaaaay better than this because you get to Discover the spell in question. I'd rather have one spell that I picked (even from a limited pool) than two spells I didn't. This card will probably never see play (not even in Rainbow spells).
Cost reduction is powerful, but it just feels like Rainbow Spells decks are going to be either too reliant on random spell generation or forced to run the one spell in a school to make it worth their while. Keep an eye on this for future expansions, but it's a pass for now.
If you're playing this, it's probably because you need the Frost spell for Rainbow Shaman and it's not exceptionally bad for its cost - if the meta is extremely fast this would be a good way to potentially stay alive for another turn or two until you can get to your bigger finishers. So, maybe Reno Shaman in a fast meta runs it?
Two random things, both from not small pools of cards, means this is just going to be way too unpredictable. Unless Rainbow Spells DK decides that it desperately needs a Nature spell, I don't think this sees play.
I'm pretty much out on Rainbow Shaman - don't think the cards it got are necessarily going to push the class in that direction. This could be a solid board-builder for that deck (there are 76 5-Cost minions in Standard [plus some unrevealed ones, I assume] and by my count only 10 to 12 of them are trash summons - all the rest are at least a decent body and some of them Rocket Hopper, for instance would be amazing. I'm kind of interested in Rainbow Spells DK, but the class has only two natural spell schools of Frost and Shadow, and Malted Magma is the only Shaman Spell they'd probably want to run. So, this card is likely a dud.
I kinda think this card is going to be pretty good. The Demon Hunter tools that it gives you access to (Patches the Pilot, Dangerous Cliffside, Sigil of Skydiving) go really well with its effect, plus you can run Paraglide, which is pretty strong card draw (especially for Shaman). This is the best Shaman card in the set.
Got some interesting cases, I just don't see Rainbow Shaman or Rainbow Spells DK being so strong that a deck would find a reasonable place for her, not to mention that the best effects for board control are Fel and Shadow, and Shaman has exactly one Standard spell that's Shadow and none that are Fel (unless they go Tourist into Demon Hunter for the one Shadow and one Fel spell in the set) so you'd have to pray that Siren Song gives you something actually playable for those effects to even trigger.
Drinks are nice value and this one is no exception. I'm not yet sold overall yet, as 1 damage doesn't kill a lot of stuff. If Rainbow Shaman comes together though, it would make sense to add some spell damage as well. And then we're talking.
This has huge potential if a Rainbow Shaman deck ever becomes a thing. Cost reduction by (2) probably means that won't happen though. Too bad, that art is so beautiful!
A value location that can be triggered by your Hero Power... feels a bit off as Ramp is just generally better than stalling but I guess it's an okay card overall.
This card is run in almost every deck on ladder right now. While I like it when free stuff is actually useful, I dislike it when they design stuff that gets predictably nerfed. Let's enjoy him while we can, I guess.
While most locations from this expansion look decent or even good, I still would absolutely hate to get this from a pack. RNG just isn't my thing and there's a huge chance to hit something you really don't want to see with this one.
Finally a good Demon Hunter card that doesn't look utterly broken and will get nerfed 4 times within the first 2 weeks after release? Thanks, Blizzard! We'll be happy to draw Patches on turn 1 for a change :D After the changes to the Highlander condition, it's even possible to run it in a Reno deck.
Most of the potions are strong and this will probably see a lot of play. Also curves nicely with most Hero Powers. The sig art looks super cool. I like it!
Cool tech card for greed metas. As a Wild main, I really like this one. Might help Standard a bit, too, as copies from Dorian should be affected by the tax, right?
"Big" decks need stuff that help them survive the early game... this one certainly does that. Good card for a niche archetype that has to come together in the first place.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Cliff Dive
I see a lot of potential for shenanigans here, I just haven't come up with something truly crazy yet. TITANS and Colossals are one obvious alley to go down, there's always Illidari Inquisitor and then you could also try and abuse low Health Deathrattle stuff. The card opens a lot of possibilities and for that alone I'll rate it highly.
New Demon Hunter Weapon - Climbing Hook
Hey look, we got a new Stormhammer! And that's where you can see this isn't the best card unfortunately: It's too expensive and keeping the condition alive is way harder. Might be good with Aranna in play. Mediocre card for now.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Skirting Death
This is probably too situational to be considered removal (as in attacking the targeted minion with your hero). Gain 4 Attack for 3 Mana isn't exactly efficient either. Combining the two makes it slightly better, but not crazy good (reducing Attack of the opponent's minion allows for a favorable trade with your stuff). Acceptable way to gain more Attack, but I'm not excited.
New Shaman Spell - Malted Magma
This is a better Warpath in 95% of cases. Would Warpath see play nowadays? ...probably not, but I think this has some potential.
New Shaman Spell - Malted Magma
Depending on what aggression looks like in the new meta, this could be useful as early game board control (or you can use it to soften up the board for a Baking Soda Volcano clear). I'm thinking it's more likely to be run in Burn Shaman, combining it with Spell Damage (and maybe some cost reduction) for big damage on the opponent's face.
New Shaman Minion - Meltemental
It's a big body that could soak up some hits in an aggressive meta. Besides that, maybe you're running this in a Frost Tourist DK to trigger Freeze payoffs? That's probably too wonky to work.
New Shaman Spell - Matching Outfits
I'm betting there's a Mana sweet spot where this is really good most of the time, but's there's just too much risk for me - I'm paying 4 for this, so I'd probably like to be summoning a minion that costs 4 at least, but likely I'm going for big payoffs if I went to the trouble of running this. It's unreliable; it could make for some fun games but I don't think you're going to win a lot if you include this in your deck.
New Shaman Spell - Siren Song
As anchorm4n said, Discovery of Magic is waaaaaaaaaaaaaay better than this because you get to Discover the spell in question. I'd rather have one spell that I picked (even from a limited pool) than two spells I didn't. This card will probably never see play (not even in Rainbow spells).
New Shaman Minion - Cabaret Headliner
Cost reduction is powerful, but it just feels like Rainbow Spells decks are going to be either too reliant on random spell generation or forced to run the one spell in a school to make it worth their while. Keep an eye on this for future expansions, but it's a pass for now.
New Shaman Spell - Frosty Décor
If you're playing this, it's probably because you need the Frost spell for Rainbow Shaman and it's not exceptionally bad for its cost - if the meta is extremely fast this would be a good way to potentially stay alive for another turn or two until you can get to your bigger finishers. So, maybe Reno Shaman in a fast meta runs it?
New Shaman Spell - Natural Talent
Two random things, both from not small pools of cards, means this is just going to be way too unpredictable. Unless Rainbow Spells DK decides that it desperately needs a Nature spell, I don't think this sees play.
New Shaman Minion - Razzle-Dazzler
I'm pretty much out on Rainbow Shaman - don't think the cards it got are necessarily going to push the class in that direction. This could be a solid board-builder for that deck (there are 76 5-Cost minions in Standard [plus some unrevealed ones, I assume] and by my count only 10 to 12 of them are trash summons - all the rest are at least a decent body and some of them Rocket Hopper, for instance would be amazing. I'm kind of interested in Rainbow Spells DK, but the class has only two natural spell schools of Frost and Shadow, and Malted Magma is the only Shaman Spell they'd probably want to run. So, this card is likely a dud.
New Shaman Minion - Carefree Cookie
I kinda think this card is going to be pretty good. The Demon Hunter tools that it gives you access to (Patches the Pilot, Dangerous Cliffside, Sigil of Skydiving) go really well with its effect, plus you can run Paraglide, which is pretty strong card draw (especially for Shaman). This is the best Shaman card in the set.
New Shaman Minion - Carress, Cabaret Star
Got some interesting cases, I just don't see Rainbow Shaman or Rainbow Spells DK being so strong that a deck would find a reasonable place for her, not to mention that the best effects for board control are Fel and Shadow, and Shaman has exactly one Standard spell that's Shadow and none that are Fel (unless they go Tourist into Demon Hunter for the one Shadow and one Fel spell in the set) so you'd have to pray that Siren Song gives you something actually playable for those effects to even trigger.
New Shaman Spell - Malted Magma
Drinks are nice value and this one is no exception. I'm not yet sold overall yet, as 1 damage doesn't kill a lot of stuff. If Rainbow Shaman comes together though, it would make sense to add some spell damage as well. And then we're talking.
New Shaman Minion - Cabaret Headliner
This has huge potential if a Rainbow Shaman deck ever becomes a thing. Cost reduction by (2) probably means that won't happen though. Too bad, that art is so beautiful!
New Druid Location - Hiking Trail
A value location that can be triggered by your Hero Power... feels a bit off as Ramp is just generally better than stalling but I guess it's an okay card overall.
New Neutral Minion - Marin the Manager
This card is run in almost every deck on ladder right now. While I like it when free stuff is actually useful, I dislike it when they design stuff that gets predictably nerfed. Let's enjoy him while we can, I guess.
New Druid Minion - Cruise Captain Lora
While most locations from this expansion look decent or even good, I still would absolutely hate to get this from a pack. RNG just isn't my thing and there's a huge chance to hit something you really don't want to see with this one.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Patches the Pilot
Finally a good Demon Hunter card that doesn't look utterly broken and will get nerfed 4 times within the first 2 weeks after release? Thanks, Blizzard! We'll be happy to draw Patches on turn 1 for a change :D After the changes to the Highlander condition, it's even possible to run it in a Reno deck.
New Neutral Minion - Mixologist
Most of the potions are strong and this will probably see a lot of play. Also curves nicely with most Hero Powers. The sig art looks super cool. I like it!
New Neutral Minion - Package Dealer
Another pack filler that might make some Ogre-lovers happy. More fun to you! At least I won't regret dusting these.
New Neutral Minion - Octo-masseuse
Fun card that might end up being decent in actual game play and it has the Mech tag! Sign me up, we'll find yourself a home, buddy.
New Neutral Minion - Customs Enforcer
Cool tech card for greed metas. As a Wild main, I really like this one. Might help Standard a bit, too, as copies from Dorian should be affected by the tax, right?
New Neutral Minion - Bumbling Bellhop
"Big" decks need stuff that help them survive the early game... this one certainly does that. Good card for a niche archetype that has to come together in the first place.