Back when it first debuted the community’s Christmas gift was 3 Knights packs. This year we got squat for landing on the naughty list, and complaining about the battle pass...
I swapped out Kooky Chemist and Hoard Pillager for Sea Giant and Mogu Fleshshaper. Those were a bit too slow, and battlefield stuff is super broken. Otherwise, good list.
IDK what was going on that last time this brawl happened, I barely remember it to be honest, but Evolve Shaman makes this about as unfun for your opponent as possible. Don't get me wrong, Druid, Priest and Warlock have some interesting options as well, but shaman legitimately is the king of this Brawl.
So I was just knocked out of battlegrounds, but I was sitting first with 40HP (no hits on me yet) and 6 players left. N the next round I lost and hit for 12 damage and it ‘killed’ me and I was knocked our hit of the match. Glitch? Big? What in the heck?!
DavnanKillder: I prefer the second snowman, the one with the red scarf. Really cool that it has 4 arms.
FieselFitz: Demon explained the reasoning behind my feedback very well. The remaining issue is that I don't get the connection between the Water Elemental and having a Secret in play. If you have a flavorful explanation for this, make sure to add it to your submission (and yes, that issue has cost linkblade a point, too after I had put some more thought to it)!
KANSAS: Still happy with your card, I think you're good to go…. I wanted to say. Then I saw your edit. It's no big issue, but with the Panther having stealth right from the start I think 4 mana would be better.
Hordaki: Very strong card, well done. Not many Christmas Vibes coming over, but then that wasn't asked for in the prompt.
Wailor: The neutral Ghost of Winterveil Past looks cool to me. Much Christmas flavor and quite interesting effect.
BloodMefist: I'm not sure if that much cleveage might not fit current Hearthstone style. Other than that, I'm also not sure if there's a "random" missing before Paladin Secrets. Interesting idea and a good fit for Paladin.
Demon: Now this is what I was hoping to see when I asked for a fresh card. Very flavorful, quite strong and lots of Christmas Vibes. I love it! The only issue that comes to mind is balance. Discovering a Secret and putting it into play right away is quite strong after all. The best comparism is probably made with Arcane Keysmith. Combo isn't that big of an obstacle imho, so I'd at least suggest to make it an epic. Last but not least, Rinling's Rifle says we don't put Secrets into the battlefield anymore but cast them.
FieselFitz: Your idea is decent enough but not very exciting.
DavnanKillder: Your new idea is pretty cool, too. Really hard to decide between the two of them… I probably prefer Sand Shark because it feels more inventive. You're missing those little strikes above the es in protégé, though. That said, I really like the Murloc Mech art. The other two cards are better, but you should make sure to save this piece for future competitions.
Wailor: Much better art. The card is quite strong now, but I think it's okay. Cool idea!
KANSAS: Since you brought up the similarity to SN1P-SN4P yourself, there are several issues I can see here. I would order the keywords like in SN1P-SN4P's text box, so Magnetic first followed by Echo. Those two are separated by a comma, not a period. Finally, the name is already taken by SN1P-SN4P's token and I for one would give you one less star for this. All that said, it feels kinda off to me to adapt a Mech. The adapt flavor translates as something natural to me that happens to Beasts or Elementals. It just doesn't feel right on a Mech. All in all I'm not a fan, I'm sorry. I hope you can work with my reasoning if nothing else.
ChickyChick: It's a solid idea, if not terribly exciting. I think there's missing an "a" before Lackey. Nice of you to think of Spare Parts!
Hordaki: I prefer Pupil of the Moon. It's a cool card and quite strong in the right deck. I don't mind that it has an already existing big brother in the game.
BloodMefist: I'm a sucker for Hunter, Mechs and Deathrattles so this is a very interesting card in my eyes. The one thing that feels a bit off is that the duplicate effect is triggered by Spellburst. Bomb Toss is a thing, but Mechs and magic just don't go together well imho. Sadly I'm not sure how to fix this.
I will stay with Desguised Saboteur. Like some pointes, a Cristhmas Art can be flavorful. Fond this three. The elf one is more flavorful and funny, but I don't think is Hearthstone-ish. What do tou guys think?
Snowflakes
If possible i will spend all my snowflakes on snowballs i don't like the profile headers.
Wacky Waxy Winter's Veil
Back when it first debuted the community’s Christmas gift was 3 Knights packs. This year we got squat for landing on the naughty list, and complaining about the battle pass...
Happy Holidays From Second Dinner, Ben Brode's Game Company Levels Up With More Hearthstone Team Talent
We haven't covered every announcement they've put out. In retrospective, we should have.
Happy Holidays From Second Dinner, Ben Brode's Game Company Levels Up With More Hearthstone Team Talent
Last Second Dinner news was over a YEAR ago?? Dammmn, talk about building hype
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Nope
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Unseen Saboteur?
Evolved Fun
I swapped out Kooky Chemist and Hoard Pillager for Sea Giant and Mogu Fleshshaper. Those were a bit too slow, and battlefield stuff is super broken. Otherwise, good list.
Wacky Waxy Winter's Veil
IDK what was going on that last time this brawl happened, I barely remember it to be honest, but Evolve Shaman makes this about as unfun for your opponent as possible. Don't get me wrong, Druid, Priest and Warlock have some interesting options as well, but shaman legitimately is the king of this Brawl.
very sad iM playin EU :c
Budget Friendly Meta Decks for Runeterra - Hyper Aggro Endure feat. Kalista
Ah!! They Who Endure, we had such a good time together. Then Hush got released...
Killed in battle grounds with 40 hp
So I was just knocked out of battlegrounds, but I was sitting first with 40HP (no hits on me yet) and 6 players left. N the next round I lost and hit for 12 damage and it ‘killed’ me and I was knocked our hit of the match. Glitch? Big? What in the heck?!
Secret Santa Snowdown - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
More feedback.
DavnanKillder: I prefer the second snowman, the one with the red scarf. Really cool that it has 4 arms.
FieselFitz: Demon explained the reasoning behind my feedback very well. The remaining issue is that I don't get the connection between the Water Elemental and having a Secret in play. If you have a flavorful explanation for this, make sure to add it to your submission (and yes, that issue has cost linkblade a point, too after I had put some more thought to it)!
KANSAS: Still happy with your card, I think you're good to go…. I wanted to say. Then I saw your edit. It's no big issue, but with the Panther having stealth right from the start I think 4 mana would be better.
Hordaki: Very strong card, well done. Not many Christmas Vibes coming over, but then that wasn't asked for in the prompt.
Wailor: The neutral Ghost of Winterveil Past looks cool to me. Much Christmas flavor and quite interesting effect.
BloodMefist: I'm not sure if that much cleveage might not fit current Hearthstone style. Other than that, I'm also not sure if there's a "random" missing before Paladin Secrets. Interesting idea and a good fit for Paladin.
Demon: Now this is what I was hoping to see when I asked for a fresh card. Very flavorful, quite strong and lots of Christmas Vibes. I love it! The only issue that comes to mind is balance. Discovering a Secret and putting it into play right away is quite strong after all. The best comparism is probably made with Arcane Keysmith. Combo isn't that big of an obstacle imho, so I'd at least suggest to make it an epic. Last but not least, Rinling's Rifle says we don't put Secrets into the battlefield anymore but cast them.
Wacky Waxy Winter's Veil
Just one pack. The article above just showed when the brawl was used before and what the reward was at that time.
Wacky Waxy Winter's Veil
I did not remember we had this one before.
When Worlds Collide - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
More feedback.
FieselFitz: Your idea is decent enough but not very exciting.
DavnanKillder: Your new idea is pretty cool, too. Really hard to decide between the two of them… I probably prefer Sand Shark because it feels more inventive. You're missing those little strikes above the es in protégé, though. That said, I really like the Murloc Mech art. The other two cards are better, but you should make sure to save this piece for future competitions.
Wailor: Much better art. The card is quite strong now, but I think it's okay. Cool idea!
KANSAS: Since you brought up the similarity to SN1P-SN4P yourself, there are several issues I can see here. I would order the keywords like in SN1P-SN4P's text box, so Magnetic first followed by Echo. Those two are separated by a comma, not a period. Finally, the name is already taken by SN1P-SN4P's token and I for one would give you one less star for this. All that said, it feels kinda off to me to adapt a Mech. The adapt flavor translates as something natural to me that happens to Beasts or Elementals. It just doesn't feel right on a Mech. All in all I'm not a fan, I'm sorry. I hope you can work with my reasoning if nothing else.
ChickyChick: It's a solid idea, if not terribly exciting. I think there's missing an "a" before Lackey. Nice of you to think of Spare Parts!
Hordaki: I prefer Pupil of the Moon. It's a cool card and quite strong in the right deck. I don't mind that it has an already existing big brother in the game.
BloodMefist: I'm a sucker for Hunter, Mechs and Deathrattles so this is a very interesting card in my eyes. The one thing that feels a bit off is that the duplicate effect is triggered by Spellburst. Bomb Toss is a thing, but Mechs and magic just don't go together well imho. Sadly I'm not sure how to fix this.
Wacky Waxy Winter's Veil
3 packs?
Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!
Why do I keep playing this game? 70% of the time it only brings me misery. I suffered a 9-game losing streak today and I just feel terrible.
Honestly, I think I hate this game and the only reason I keep playing it is because I hate myself equally and this is my way of punishing myself. Fml
Titanoth Rex
OMG!!! I want this card so hard.
Secret Santa Snowdown - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks for all the feedback.
I will stay with Desguised Saboteur. Like some pointes, a Cristhmas Art can be flavorful. Fond this three. The elf one is more flavorful and funny, but I don't think is Hearthstone-ish. What do tou guys think?
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
AMEN TO THAT
Secret Santa Snowdown - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Ok good - thx again
When Worlds Collide - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Hello there,
i almost missed this competition - i thought the Santa thing was the next one :)
Heres my first Idea:
I hope i understood which Keywords are allowed to use :)
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
I think that they should make The Cow King a warrior skin also.
Secret Santa Snowdown - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Honestly, I don't think the first new version needs to be nerfed.
Making the comparison to Occult Conjurer again, it seems perfectly fine to me where it is.
Secret Santa Snowdown - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thx for the Feedback. I think i will go with the first new version.
Balance-wise im not sure if i should change the stats or just increase the mana cost.
Stats could be 4/5 or 4/6 - or a mana increase up to 6. I will think a little about that.