All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Shaman Minion - Saxophone Soloist

    Good in murloc or swarm type decks because you'll always mulligan for your 1 drops and this card is technically just Fire Fly in murloc form.

    Unfortunately, at the end its still a 1/2 and in 2023 there's no reason to believe a vanilla 1/2 on 1 is good enough. Hell, bring firefly back to standard and Im not even sure it gets a nod anywhere now.

  • New Hunter Minion - Harmonica Soloist

    If the conditions wasn't so impossible in a class like hunter this card would realistically be powerful enough to see play in most decks. Never underestimate secrets to win you games.

    Unfortunately, I see no reason why hunter would play a deck that doesn't curve so minions would be on board 90% of the time, and if they're not then you've technically lost the game, or 100% all in spitter to do the job because this card can't possibly save you anyway.

  • New Mage Minion - Holotechnician

    Its the kind of card that sounds powerful but in practice is simply tech at best.

    Because what does mage realistically need something like this for? The only existing situation that comes to mind would be against rogue, where they can go completely apeshit and play their entire hand out.

    And then this card needs something like an Arcane Explosion to do well, which it doesn't have. All it has is Shooting Star, which isn't bad but not good enough neither.

    I'd say mage forgets about removal and just stall. If they do need removal, it'll likely not be this card.

  • New Druid Spell - Rhythm and Roots

    Pretty good actually, but definitely one of those cards that tends to get weaker as the game progresses.

    Because in effect, you're playing this for a swing turn in future, or setup a massive board with Drum Circle. Given that druid lost pretty much all their win cons and stabilization, this might be the only thing you have that isn't hp and remotely broken

    Imagine cheating this out with Innervate etc. just get a trio of 5/5s as early as turn 4.

  • New Shaman Spell - Chill Vibes

    This needs overload.  It's too good. 3 for 8 health, pretty ok.  3 for a 3/3 with taunt, pretty ok.  Combined for the same cost with no drawback... stupid

  • New Druid Spell - Rhythm and Roots

    There are enough tactics to get this out fast... and year 4 turns to get the effect seems like a pain... but the fact that you'll have 8/8's on the board that your opponent now has to deal with, is a little tough

  • New Death Knight Minion - Hardcore Cultist

    Play it last and you have a Consecration with legs... what's not to like about that?

  • New Shaman Spell - Melomania

    No idea how good this will be, but I think Shaman has a decent number of good spells.

  • New Shaman Minion - Saxophone Soloist

    This seems a bit useless. You get another 1/2 in your hand that gives you a 1/2 if you play it after your board has been cleared.

  • New Mage Minion - Holotechnician

    This plus Spectral Trainee plus any other spell equals complete one-sided board wipe (barring any divine shield, certain death rattles, or reborn). That'll cost at least 7 mana, but Twisting Nether costs 8 and it kills your dudes as well. Seems like a pretty good deal.

  • All Card Flavor Text for the Festival of Legends Hearthstone Expansion

    I find the text of Jazz Bass very funny.

  • New Hunter Minion - Harmonica Soloist

    It looks like Hunter will have three secrets after rotation, so that will make the discover choices you get rather predictable. For now anyway. Would you want to not play minions for this? It's Hunter, so I doubt it, but perhaps if your board gets wiped. But probably you should be rebuilding.

  • New Druid Spell - Rhythm and Roots

    I would assume in most cases you wouldn't want to wait four turns for something to happen, especially if you can't play this on turn 4, but I wouldn't know.

  • New Mage Weapon - Cosmic Keyboard

    Big Mage cooming

  • Festival of Legends Final Card Reveal Dump - See 22 New Cards Revealed (Launches April 11)

    But it doesn't work like that. When you hover over the Theorycrafting Drops it has a different date and that's 2 different packs. If you missed today's two packs, they are gone. The drops never worked like that in two separate time periods.

  • All Card Flavor Text for the Festival of Legends Hearthstone Expansion

    So many music related flavour texts xD

    Mosh Pit - Let the Corpses hit the floor!

    Love Everlasting - Poison Bloom was accused of plagiarizing the "Ooh, how long can this go on (ooh yeah)" hook from an old-school musical group called The Saronite Chain Gang.

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Before the lifeboats get full, I just wanted to say that this site is unique because:

    The other sites don't have easy 5-star rating systems for each card and when they DO, it's slow as shit.

    Also the site runs smooth in general.

  • All Card Flavor Text for the Festival of Legends Hearthstone Expansion

    "Look at this photograph."

     

    Just that one fucking line gets me every single time.

  • New Shaman Spell - Melomania

    What does From De Other Side do?

  • New Warrior Weapon - Kodohide Drumkit

    It's not even that it's bad (it is), but how hard Warrior has to work for a mediocre payoff compared to everyone else...and that you would rotate Armorsmith while printing this.

    Honestly, it's hard not to think of the devs as spiteful when pretty much every single class except Warrior got some truly powerful buildarounds and they just get reprints of boring cards for failing archetypes.

  • New Warlock Spell - Demonic Dynamics

    Too bad for constructed. 3-mana discover random stuff instead of drawing stuff will always suck. The buffs are irrelevant because you'Re sacrificing too much tempo by playing this in the first place.

     

    Also, where was this when Fel Warlock was supposed to be a thing?

  • New Warlock Spell - Dirge of Despair

    They're really trying to make cubeless Cubelock happen. Well, I'm down for it, it's time Enhanced Dreadlord got her time in the spotlight in Standard after she went for two years without getting a functional archetype

    Shouuld be noted that you can cast this early if you discount it with the Shadow guy from Nathria (that nobody ever played)

  • New Shaman Spell - Chill Vibes

    Absolutely outstanding control card. As long as you can proc the Finale it'S Antique Healbot on steroids, and even without Finale it's still good in a pinch.

  • New Shaman Spell - Melomania

    Absolutely insane with Schooling in any value-oriented Shaman decks. The spell pool is also pretty good right now, so extra points.

    Honestly, this might be the thing to enable slower Shaman decks because it gives them stuff to do early without compromising their lategame plan.

  • New Shaman Minion - Saxophone Soloist

    I get the idea, but this really could have been a 2/2 and it would have been balanced.

    It's basically "here's something to do for your lategame deck on turns 1-3" but it doesn't really contest anything.

    It's basically a worse [Hearthstone Card (Firefly) Not Found] and FIrefly was good in a way less efficient meta than this one.