All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Druid Spell - Spread the Word

    Probably a 2 mana Arcane Intellect in the Hero power druid deck. But if druid gets any more "give hero +x attack" cards kinda like Claw or Bite it's going to be discounted to 0 mana quite quickly.

    Also this seems good with the druid questline, which might matter in wild? Maybe this can help some kinda EVEN druid rise up? Meh probably needs more than this.

  • New Druid Minion - Groovy Cat

    Weaker card than Free Spirit when on curve, but i feel like Attack buffs on your hero power are better than armor buffs. Also this can help discount Spread the Word. Seems good to me.

  • New Druid Minion - Peaceful Piper

    This can tutor Groovy Cat or Free Spirit, and even in decks without those it's a 1 mana draw a card OR discover a card. 5/5 star card.

  • New Druid Minion - Free Spirit

    5/5 star card. Great 1 drop and buffs your hero power, this will see a lot of play.

    This warrior card is amazing!!!!... oh wait.

  • New Druid Spell - Drum Circle

    Good with Timber Tambourine, and probably fits well in a midrange token DH deck as either a finisher, or as a reload. Seems good. Really reminds me of The Forest's Aid.

  • New Druid Weapon - Timber Tambourine

    It's alright. It has a interesting interaction with weapon removal. After all, you want to break the weapon before the deathrattle summons too many 5/5s... But at the same time you might not want to break it yet, because your not ready to deal with the 5/5s yet. And iirc breaking their weapon on your turn with weapon removal makes it so the 5/5s wont have fatigue/summoning sickness or whatever during your opponents turn. (Which means they can go SMOrc immediately.)

    As for 5+ cost spells we got: Flipper Friends, Beetlemancy, Unending Swarm, Life from Death, Drum Circle, Nightshade Bud, Miracle GrowthConvoke the spirits. Oh and from core: Nourish.

    Overall, the spells are mostly midrangey spells. Which is probably the kinda deck where you want to play Timber Tambourine in. Altough, some kinda ramp druid might considering it as well.

  • New Druid Minion - Zok Fogsnout

    This seems pretty good if you can set it up correctly, but that's the problem. How difficult is it to setup a decent fogsnout? Fogsnout + basic hero power (So just +1/+1) = 7 mana Cenarius. (With the summon option) But that either requires 9 mana total, making it just Cenarius... Or you have to spend a total of 8 mana (fogsnout + Tour Guide), so a 1 mana discount in the WORST case scenario. Of course it gets better with all the Hero power upgrades, and discounted spells that give your hero Atk/Armor. 

    Overall, it seems a bit clunky to setup. At worst it's either a 7 mana 6/6 do nothing, or it's Cenarius, which hasn't seen play in quite a long time. At average it will probably summon about 3/3 or 4/4 ish taunts, which doesn't sound that good considering all the setup it needs.

  • New Druid Spell - Rhythm and Roots

    Seems good on 4, but 9/10 times it's just too slow. Seems good with Drum Circle, however this is a LEGENDARY which means it's hard to draw. I'm not convinced about this card, it just seems too meh outside of super aggresive druid decks... Which might prefer something with immediate impact instead.

  • New Demon Hunter Minion - Guitar Soloist

    Hmm this is a interesting card, but i do wonder where this slots into. Most decks already have better options... Maybe some kind of Big DH can use this, considering this has no tribe + tutors a spell and a weapon. (Maybe Aldrachi Warblades tutor?) But even then, it just seems meh because it can mess with Abyssal Depths. 

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Taste of Chaos

    Seems good to me. 1 mana deal 2 damage to a minion has seen quite a bit of play, and it also has an additional upside with the Finale. I think this will see play. 

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Pro

    I have yet to properly wrap my head around what we're supposed to do here / what would make for a cool card text, but I generally love special competitions so thumbs up for hosting this! 

  • There's No Heal Like Overheal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Pro

    I'm sorry I couldn't find the time to provide feedback this week. I'll try to do better in our next competition. Thanks to everybody who gave advice on my idea! 

  • Rewards Track: Current progress 7.0

    It took me a lot of time, but I finally crawled to lvl 200 (again, half from @Neb :D ) and my XP achievement count is back at 50%, spending all my play time completing them, until they disable the XP points from it. Getting closely to the new expansion, looks like this will be my lowest level yet. With Mercs, I have finally collected them all, slowly finishing last remaining tasks, not really bothering with the new Boss mode.

    Anyway, how are you all doing? Where are you at? Will you finish higher/lower than you expected? Looking forward to the next track? Feel free to share :)

    P.S.: Grats Neb, you did it again! :)

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Not sure if the Squire fills the requirement. If not i'll word it more weirdly.

    Art credit:

  • All Card Flavor Text for the Festival of Legends Hearthstone Expansion

    I SPECIFICALLY REQUESTED IT!

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    I have this card I almost used for the Christmas comp some years ago.

    Synergies aside, this card is just a vanilla 4/5/4. And even then, it wouldn't even be the worst Freeze Shaman card from KFT.

  • New Rogue Spell - Mixtape

    Quote From dapperdog

    No more tess, no more chest, so what the hell are we doing playing this card? A card that's so inconsistent in results that even dedicated thief decks in wild wouldn't think of it. Can't even play this shit on turn 1 for god sake.

    Meme at best, though Im 100% sure there's a bs achievement tied onto it.

    Tess won't rotate, but will stay in the core set. I woudln't understimate this card, because it's an 1-mana discover. It's comparable Identity Theft, but you get only one card and not two.

     

    https://bnetcmsus-a.akamaihd.net/cms/content_entry_media/TVM7GYDSD9XB1679527943501.pdf

     
     

     

     

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    With that in mind, it's time to get out there and make some truly unglued cards.

    Another Lightning Bolt does a totally different thing than Lightning Bolt. I don't know what you're talking about.

    As for Guy In A Bear Suit. Is it a Beast? Is it not a Beast? Who knows? Either way, it's a tribal wording inconsistency, so I think it counts.

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    It's time to get crazy. If you've ever wanted to make a really stupid and nonsensical card for any competition, now is the time to do that.

    With that in mind, while a victory in this competition will still be displayed in the Winner's Gallery and will still count towards your leaderboard total, we've decided that this competition will not count towards the tally for the prize at the end of the season. Perhaps some more serious side competitions will count, but given the theme and context of this one, it's most appropriate that it doesn't count.

    This is also a very experimental and risky idea that may not play out and I will also admit that it very narrowly avoided being dropped entirely, so you'll have to let us know if you like it or not.

  • There's No Heal Like Overheal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    You guys have 24 hours left to submit.

  • Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro


    Competition Theme: Inconsistently Consistent

    The wording is getting a little weird around here, and it's time to embrace that.

    • You must make a card that is functional, but is not consistently worded with other similar cards or doesn't follow conventional wording rules.

    In celebration of the first of April, it's time to get a little bit wacky.

    As always, we can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.


    Competition Phases

    Here are the phases of this card design competition

    • Submission Phase: Starts on Fri, Mar 31 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Wed, Apr 5 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Voting Phase: Starts on Wed, Apr 5 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Thu, Apr 6 16:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Finalist Phase: Starts on Thu, Apr 6 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400). Runs until Fri, Apr 7 17:00 EDT (GMT -0400)
    • Winner Selected: After finalist voting concludes and we validate votes.

    Discussion Thread Rules

    Please note: This is a special competition and not in a normal season.

  • Mercenaries fangame (including fanmade Mercenaries)

    Amazing work!

  • New Rogue Spell - Mixtape

    Another card for Thief Rogue. Yay. Perhaps one out of the three choices will be good, though your opponent's cards are likely to be better for their deck than your deck.

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Taste of Chaos

    I guess this might be good if you have the coin and your opponent played a minion the first turn. Otherwise you'll need to make sure to spend all but 1 mana crystal before playing this. Which is often pretty easy.

  • New Mage Spell - Synthesize

    While there are some good elementals of those costs, there's also quite a few of them, so I'm not feeling good about the odds of getting something helpful. And Mage doesn't have any real payoff for playing elementals currently.