Think you are right on this one, it is simply a question of time before the right combo pieces get discovered. This has the potential to be abused ; mana cheat always see play!
I've been waiting a long time for this feature, and it looks like I'll continue waiting. This drippy half-measure is not even close to adequate. I want UI elements where I can enter how many to open, and I absolutely want the post-opening summary. Without those, I'm better off with the old one-at-a-time method.
Unfortunately I will never truly understand or experience what it feels like to actually possess so many packs that automation becomes a necessity.
You've pretty much answered your own question. Opening more than a hundred packs at one time is extremely tedious. There's no excitement or anticipation because you know you'll end up with all the cards anyway. The only question is how much dust you'll have to spend to grab the last few legendaries.
I do like how the scalling effect is ongoing, and not limited to its board state when played (battlecry). Cheap (1) drops that do something tend to see play, I don't see why this one wouldn't ... unless there isn't much Imp/Zoo material to work with.
Im still on the fence about Gigantotem, as in the best case scenario, by turn 6-7, you could get about 8 mana discount on it, which would be enough to set a powerful turn 8, but oh so conditional. The game might have been lost before you get to that point ...
Out of the new champions Kai'sa and the evolve mechanic are my favorites, thematically it fits the void and I do like having control over which keywords I can give my unit's rather than just hoping that I won't get screwed over by RNG.
You know how they say better late than never, well it is exactly the case for Totem Shamy, which suffered from too little support for the first 5-6 years of HS, but is now building up to a decent viable standard, which is good news for meta diversity!
I like the card design and its disruptive nature, but I'm skeptical as to its efficiency. Its good, but maybe not a 5 stars like some ahead of me commented. Should see play, or at least, experiment.
I've updated my card, although now I feeling that it's a bit OP if I compare it to Nightcloak Sanctum. The great thing about this design is that I don't need a new Treant token, and I can just use the one created by Plot of Sin.
Linkblade91
There is the situation of Druid not being good at removal, but the card's flavor and mechanics are on point. It is slightly situational given that it can't remove minions with more Health than Attack. You may want to make it 5 mana to hopefully dodge some comments about Druid removal.
Wailor
Thank you for your kind words.
Draenor is a pretty creative location, although it doesn't really feel like a dual-class card to me.
Your original Walls of Orgrimmar seems to have expired, so I unfortunately can't leave a comment about that one.
Shadowmoon Valley is cool. It's certainly not as problematic in Warlock as it would be in either Paladin or Shaman, but Warlock is still a class that's pretty good at swarming useless tokens onto the board. Potentially locking out an enemy board like this is a bit on the scary side, though it does limit your board building potential, and you may have to dump quite a few cards out of your hand to use it, so it might be fine.
Orgrimmar should probably specify "Give this Taunt" or something like that. I read it, and my first thought was that your hero gained Taunt and then figured out that it was the location after I kept reading.
AeroJulwin
This feels like it might be too slow and impractical to work as good removal since you need to silence the minion you want to kill first, wait 2 turns (meaning your opponent will be able to attack twice with it before you can use the location again), and then use another point of Durability to kill it. I think it ends up working better as just a way to silence 3 minions rather than being used as a removal since you can just use removal spells to do that same thing.
Flavor though is absolutely great.
R
A Neutral location is going to hard to win over with the voters, but if you want to try, then go ahead.
The card seems fairly okay.
Amansleungcn
Hermetist's Room is a bit awkward to use. Specifically the second part, since if you only care about a single spell school for synergy, then most spells in your deck are going to be of that school anyway. And on the other hand, if you're running multiple spell school synergies, then the second effect has anti-synergy as it actively turns them off. Judging by the way it's phrased, it appears to be permanent too.
The Highest is okay, although the flavor is not too obvious.
Sunwell feels like it could be quite broken.
Moonwell seems to be awkwardly phrased, and I do agree that the art could be better. As a card though, it's alright.
I personally prefer the first Altar of Evil over the second.
I think Darius looks good enough to mess around with so glad to see it added. Volatile skeletons could be nuts in standard and a mage picking up that tier 2 could be an easy 12-win run. Honestly I’m not worried about the Ring of Haste. If you were drafting the kind of deck to really scam that treasure, you are probably getting rocked in those early games. I get that it could be super unfun to play against but ultra-rare from the start means there is very little chance of it meeting the right draft
I dont play Azir Irelia but it's a cool deck people should feel like they have the ability to play.
Same with sundisc, Yassao, deep, thralls, Lurk etc.
Yeah I know the stats haven't changed, we already talked about how without nerfs Annie and Bard would remain dominate.
The only thing that has changed is the number of options, and solutions at your disposal to play around or counter these established archetypes as a clever brewer.
But no if you played Annie Tf all last season, you can play Annie TF all this season if you want, nothing new there.
For the most part, I feel that this meta is stale but refreshing? I don't play ranked but I do look at the meta stats out of curiosity from time to time. It feels like the top decks have not changed except for the inclusion of Kai'Sa which understandably is quite a pain in the ass. Bard, Illaoi, Annie are still pretty strong and just as tier 1.
That said, I play normals a lot and this time around I'm surprised at how much more random pairings of champions appeared with the new champs despite last expansion having quite a bit of variety for each champion introduced. Not very many of them are any good though.
Other than that, I don't think the meta is solved just yet. I do feel like this time around it's relatively quicker. I'm awaiting for people to realize the power of Lulu Shen midrange-aggro but I'm not sure that's ever going to come true.
Also, I will say Nifty I do notice one pattern of when you say a meta is good. That's literally whenever Azirelia is meta.
I would strongly argue against your statement as all the new archetypes are very bland in their execution and do not create much of a unique play patterns okay maybe Evelynn is a new summon/die/1cost unit engine is a bit interesting despite it mostly being a keyword soup archetype... Kaisa isn't at all interesting or fun unless giving valor spellshield and overwhelm to copy that keyword soup is original/bigbrain to you and Gwen really is just ramping up attack bound to otherwise very weak units as we have seen it in lurk before.
To me none of the new archetypes stand out or are something I would like to build around and I proably will just pass on ranked unless Yasuo decks actually should prove viable which they still struggle to do
Could not agree more. I'm opening 2-300 packs every expansion launch, which easily takes an hour or more and is just delaying actual gameplay. I ended up using a macro recorder to press the spacebar for me while I'm taking care of other business.
Pretty cool card, whose effect fits the flavor well enough. My only gripe is that Druid isn't supposed to be good with removal, but since many minions are Health-heavy, that's probably not too big a deal.
Demonxz95
First of all, I hope covid isn't too hard on you and you recover soon!
About your cards, both introduce interesting ideas to locations, which I really appreciate.
I think I prefer Haunted Grove, but I'd make the baseline token a 2/2 Treant. Maybe I'd nerf the Shadowbark Golem to a 4/4 or a 3/4 to compensate.
About Scorchland Spires, it's not bad, but its similarity to Mage's HP makes it feel less interesting, especially considering that the HP Mage archetype tends to run a lot of refresh and cost reductions already.
AeroJulwin
I think locations need to be a bit weaker than if they were a spell, since they can be used several times. That said, your card seems pretty balanced, and its flexibility makes it very interesting. Flavor is on-point, too.
R
I like it, but I think it's a bit weak right now. Since you can only activate locations every other turn, this would take 5 whole turns to generate Mana advantage. Thus, I'd probably drop its cost to 1 Mana or give it an extra Durability (which would make it even slower, but in turn would generate more value).
Also, the effect feels like a Druid or Rogue card more than Neutral, but I guess it can stay that way because of its Coin flavor (this card references throwing coins to a wish fountain, right?)
adamsleungcn
Pretty interesting bunch of cards! As a general criticism for them, you shouldn't use WoW screenshots, since it doesn't look very well. For each card individually:
I like Hermetist's Room, but I don't get the second part. Does it transform all your spells into random ones from the chosen school? Or does it simply change their school tag? I don't like any of this options very much, but the base concept of doing something with the chosen spell school is very cool. Perhaps drawing a card from your deck that has that very same school? Dunno.
The Highest is probably my favorite of your cards, but the name is a bit strange. I'm not an English native speaker, but I think The Highest Point or The City's Pinnacle would make more sense. Besides that, I think it could cost 1 Mana instead of 2, and even have 3 Durability.
Sunwell is quite interesting, but lorewise should probably be a Mage card. I also think it should be a legendary card, both for lore and balance reasons. Finally, I'd word it as "Add a copy of the next spell you cast to your hand. It costs (0)."
Moonwell is cool and a very good translation of its Warcraft 3 effect. I'd just change the artwork, but it's otherwise very cool.
Finally, both versions of Altar of Evil are cool, but I'm not specially fond of their base concept. Not that they're bad, I just enjoy your other cards more.
All in all, you have very interesting concepts here. They just need some polish, but the idea themselves are very good, especially for someone new at card design.
I said it before when people speculated what the 3. expansion could be, because it has been confirmed that it's going to be bigger than usual, but I always wanted a "What if" type of Expansion with a bunch of old characters of another timeline. Rafaam as Explorer Member, Hagatha as a Scholomance teacher, Dr. Boom the plaque lord, Reno the old god etc.
The fact that this is a rare card makes it very powerful to disrupt a lot of deck building strategies and marks the start of the end of sunken city add to bottom mechanic
I would like to see their take on the novel/movie 'Journey to the center of the Earth'. The mechanic would be alternating tribal tags. For example, a card could be an elemental while in you hand, but a beast when it hits the board. Locations could also be appropriate here.
New Hunter Minion - Batty Guest
Sticky 1-drops are great, and it's a good 2-for-1 if you are trying to infuse. I give it 4 stars.
New Warlock Minion - Shadowborn
Think you are right on this one, it is simply a question of time before the right combo pieces get discovered.
This has the potential to be abused ; mana cheat always see play!
[Updated] Hearthstone’s Castle Nathria Patch 24.0 Is Now Live - Duels Refreshed, Battlegrounds and Mercenaries Updates, More Features, & Dev Insights
Click "Uncraftable Cards" after selecting crafting in the Collection Manager and it will show you all the cards (filter by MCN).
Continuous Pack Opening Functionality Arrives for Hearthstone’s Desktop Clients With the New Patch - Keep Your Spacebars Ready!
I've been waiting a long time for this feature, and it looks like I'll continue waiting. This drippy half-measure is not even close to adequate. I want UI elements where I can enter how many to open, and I absolutely want the post-opening summary. Without those, I'm better off with the old one-at-a-time method.
Continuous Pack Opening Functionality Arrives for Hearthstone’s Desktop Clients With the New Patch - Keep Your Spacebars Ready!
You've pretty much answered your own question. Opening more than a hundred packs at one time is extremely tedious. There's no excitement or anticipation because you know you'll end up with all the cards anyway. The only question is how much dust you'll have to spend to grab the last few legendaries.
New Warlock Minion - Flustered Librarian
I do like how the scalling effect is ongoing, and not limited to its board state when played (battlecry). Cheap (1) drops that do something tend to see play, I don't see why this one wouldn't ... unless there isn't much Imp/Zoo material to work with.
New Shaman Spell - Criminal Lineup
Im still on the fence about Gigantotem, as in the best case scenario, by turn 6-7, you could get about 8 mana discount on it, which would be enough to set a powerful turn 8, but oh so conditional. The game might have been lost before you get to that point ...
New Shaman Minion - Gigantotem
Totem support - Neat!
Totem Golem's uncle, gone too soon.
[Updated] Hearthstone’s Castle Nathria Patch 24.0 Is Now Live - Duels Refreshed, Battlegrounds and Mercenaries Updates, More Features, & Dev Insights
Don't visit the reward track after you update. Or maybe go ahead. A little bit of you know what.
And probably craft the Murloc Holmes on 1st day to finish the achievement. Everyone got 3 days refund time to complete 3 right guesses in 1 shot.
Although, I can't see any MCN cards yet (in crafting). I thought I could in the past.
Riot Shares Insights on the Designs of Kai'Sa, Gwen, and Evelynn in Legends of Runeterra
Out of the new champions Kai'sa and the evolve mechanic are my favorites, thematically it fits the void and I do like having control over which keywords I can give my unit's rather than just hoping that I won't get screwed over by RNG.
New Shaman Weapon - Carving Chisel
You know how they say better late than never, well it is exactly the case for Totem Shamy, which suffered from too little support for the first 5-6 years of HS, but is now building up to a decent viable standard, which is good news for meta diversity!
New Neutral Minion - Ashen Elemental
I like the card design and its disruptive nature, but I'm skeptical as to its efficiency. Its good, but maybe not a 5 stars like some ahead of me commented. Should see play, or at least, experiment.
Location, Location, Location - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Alright, let's push through this!
I've updated my card, although now I feeling that it's a bit OP if I compare it to Nightcloak Sanctum. The great thing about this design is that I don't need a new Treant token, and I can just use the one created by Plot of Sin.
Thank you for your kind words.
Draenor is a pretty creative location, although it doesn't really feel like a dual-class card to me.
Your original Walls of Orgrimmar seems to have expired, so I unfortunately can't leave a comment about that one.
Shadowmoon Valley is cool. It's certainly not as problematic in Warlock as it would be in either Paladin or Shaman, but Warlock is still a class that's pretty good at swarming useless tokens onto the board. Potentially locking out an enemy board like this is a bit on the scary side, though it does limit your board building potential, and you may have to dump quite a few cards out of your hand to use it, so it might be fine.
Orgrimmar should probably specify "Give this Taunt" or something like that. I read it, and my first thought was that your hero gained Taunt and then figured out that it was the location after I kept reading.
This feels like it might be too slow and impractical to work as good removal since you need to silence the minion you want to kill first, wait 2 turns (meaning your opponent will be able to attack twice with it before you can use the location again), and then use another point of Durability to kill it. I think it ends up working better as just a way to silence 3 minions rather than being used as a removal since you can just use removal spells to do that same thing.
Flavor though is absolutely great.
A Neutral location is going to hard to win over with the voters, but if you want to try, then go ahead.
The card seems fairly okay.
Hermetist's Room is a bit awkward to use. Specifically the second part, since if you only care about a single spell school for synergy, then most spells in your deck are going to be of that school anyway. And on the other hand, if you're running multiple spell school synergies, then the second effect has anti-synergy as it actively turns them off. Judging by the way it's phrased, it appears to be permanent too.
The Highest is okay, although the flavor is not too obvious.
Sunwell feels like it could be quite broken.
Moonwell seems to be awkwardly phrased, and I do agree that the art could be better. As a card though, it's alright.
I personally prefer the first Altar of Evil over the second.
Darius Crowley Joins Hearthstone Duels - Our Opinion on the New Playable Hero and the New Passive Treasures
I think Darius looks good enough to mess around with so glad to see it added.
Volatile skeletons could be nuts in standard and a mage picking up that tier 2 could be an easy 12-win run.
Honestly I’m not worried about the Ring of Haste. If you were drafting the kind of deck to really scam that treasure, you are probably getting rocked in those early games. I get that it could be super unfun to play against but ultra-rare from the start means there is very little chance of it meeting the right draft
Had The Meta Been Solved?
I dont play Azir Irelia but it's a cool deck people should feel like they have the ability to play.
Same with sundisc, Yassao, deep, thralls, Lurk etc.
Yeah I know the stats haven't changed, we already talked about how without nerfs Annie and Bard would remain dominate.
The only thing that has changed is the number of options, and solutions at your disposal to play around or counter these established archetypes as a clever brewer.
But no if you played Annie Tf all last season, you can play Annie TF all this season if you want, nothing new there.
New Neutral Minion - Ashen Elemental
Very powerful disruption tool, it's a soft taunt if you dont want to it make snowball damage
New Warrior Minion - Anima Extractor
A very powerful combo if you manage to do it with Spammy Arcanist for a handbuff turn
Had The Meta Been Solved?
For the most part, I feel that this meta is stale but refreshing? I don't play ranked but I do look at the meta stats out of curiosity from time to time. It feels like the top decks have not changed except for the inclusion of Kai'Sa which understandably is quite a pain in the ass. Bard, Illaoi, Annie are still pretty strong and just as tier 1.
That said, I play normals a lot and this time around I'm surprised at how much more random pairings of champions appeared with the new champs despite last expansion having quite a bit of variety for each champion introduced. Not very many of them are any good though.
Other than that, I don't think the meta is solved just yet. I do feel like this time around it's relatively quicker. I'm awaiting for people to realize the power of Lulu Shen midrange-aggro but I'm not sure that's ever going to come true.
Also, I will say Nifty I do notice one pattern of when you say a meta is good. That's literally whenever Azirelia is meta.
Had The Meta Been Solved?
I would strongly argue against your statement as all the new archetypes are very bland in their execution and do not create much of a unique play patterns okay maybe Evelynn is a new summon/die/1cost unit engine is a bit interesting despite it mostly being a keyword soup archetype... Kaisa isn't at all interesting or fun unless giving valor spellshield and overwhelm to copy that keyword soup is original/bigbrain to you and Gwen really is just ramping up attack bound to otherwise very weak units as we have seen it in lurk before.
To me none of the new archetypes stand out or are something I would like to build around and I proably will just pass on ranked unless Yasuo decks actually should prove viable which they still struggle to do
Continuous Pack Opening Functionality Arrives for Hearthstone’s Desktop Clients With the New Patch - Keep Your Spacebars Ready!
Could not agree more. I'm opening 2-300 packs every expansion launch, which easily takes an hour or more and is just delaying actual gameplay. I ended up using a macro recorder to press the spacebar for me while I'm taking care of other business.
Just My Card Type - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks guys! I doubt this card will ever be made, though, as it would definetly be a pain to code (and to balance, as well)
Location, Location, Location - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
More streamlined versions of my previous cards:
Let me know which version you prefer.
Feedback:
About your cards, both introduce interesting ideas to locations, which I really appreciate.
Also, the effect feels like a Druid or Rogue card more than Neutral, but I guess it can stay that way because of its Coin flavor (this card references throwing coins to a wish fountain, right?)
All in all, you have very interesting concepts here. They just need some polish, but the idea themselves are very good, especially for someone new at card design.
What's your dream theme for an expansion? (That's not WOW related)
I said it before when people speculated what the 3. expansion could be, because it has been confirmed that it's going to be bigger than usual, but I always wanted a "What if" type of Expansion with a bunch of old characters of another timeline. Rafaam as Explorer Member, Hagatha as a Scholomance teacher, Dr. Boom the plaque lord, Reno the old god etc.
New Neutral Minion - Steamcleaner
The fact that this is a rare card makes it very powerful to disrupt a lot of deck building strategies and marks the start of the end of sunken city add to bottom mechanic
What's your dream theme for an expansion? (That's not WOW related)
I would like to see their take on the novel/movie 'Journey to the center of the Earth'. The mechanic would be alternating tribal tags. For example, a card could be an elemental while in you hand, but a beast when it hits the board. Locations could also be appropriate here.