My sense, based on dev comments from around the time of the first rewards track, is that it's decided from the outset how much gold in total would be given out on the rewards track. Thereafter, it's a question of distributing the gold across the many levels. From that perspective, we're not getting golden cards in lieu of gold; without such 'filler' rewards, the alternative would have been to reduce the amount of gold awarded on some levels.
I'd love to see them double up on those slots for rewards. I know so many people just don't care about golden cards that it would be a really nice square to give them something.
Mass nerfing is an interesting concept to explore. Keeping a weaker core set makes the expansions more playable, but does come at a cost of diversity. I wouldn't dismiss it altogether, though I'm also interested whether it makes hearthstone a little more dependent on its expansions (and therefore a more costly product to have fun in).
Glad to also know that the team will be discussing nerfs and confirmation of at least one card that will be changed cough* cough*Incanter's Flow. This may be the hardest to balance, because some stuff in stormwind seems to anticipate a combo heavy meta so we have absolutely insane aggro cards like Battleground Battlemaster. Will be surprised if this wasn't hit (maybe to the stats) in some way after combo decks get nerfed.
Incanter's flow is useful even in the late game because that's usually how they kill you after completing the quest. Just draw their whole deck with cram sessions and refreshing spring water, and then ignite all the way. So its not necessarily needed early actually.
Yes, that's correct. And then some guy I faced had a big brain idea to start teching in devolving missiles so even divine shield doesn't save it. Its kinda harsh but robes can absolutely be countered by mage. They can even chance a discover at it. Back to the drawing board.
Hadbuff seems to really take off around D7 and up. On my grind up (as quest mage) I basically faced none that were a problem until then, at which point it was all Cult Neophyte, Robes of Protection, and Battleground Battlemaster combo wombos
If you're running into a lot of problems with mage, run Robes of Protection. Hard mulligan for it, if necessary. I've had a dozen games as mage get completely shut out by a single one of those, as quest mage (at least the no spell version) has exactly zero counters for it.
The stats might be an interesting showcase of what happens yet again when you live within a polarising rock-paper-scissors meta. Quest mage might not be the 'best' deck statistically as shown by the pic, but it sure doesn't feel that way whenever you're facing it. And while handbuff pally is shown to have a higher win rate, it really does fold rather quickly to the combo decks.
Far as Im concerned its likely because everyone is teching against combo (Cult Neophyte, Far Watch Post, cheaper and smaller decklist etc.) that whenever you meet a handbuff pally youre just in such a poor condition to face it.
DS + IF is probably the easiest combo to assemble in the whole game. When they announced the new core set for Priest and i saw that Inner Fire was gone, i became hopeful that Priest would be able to play a genuine buff based deck without resorting to a combo finisher. However, they also removed Power Word: Shield and Northshire Cleric which were the main cycle/reloading tool for the class. After that, they kept printing good tempo minions and buffs but all of these cards ended up as a complete failure. Priest doesn't have a hero power that creates minions like Paladin. Paladin can always throw their buffs into their 1/1s whenever they are out of minions. Priest, however, needs actual minions to buff and if their stuff gets removed there's a pretty high chance that they will become stuck with buff spells in hand that simply can't be used.
I'm not desperate for the birth of a super good aggro/tempo priest because i'm sure it will be infuriating to deal with. What annoys me is the fact that they keep printing these tempo cards and buffs that serve no purpose outside of discover/generation. Precious slots in card sets are wasted with cards that are simply hopeless. The strongest example is Scholomance Academy. This set brought a few cards that see play all the time (mainly Draconic Studies and Raise Dead) but both dual class legendary slots failed completely within the class because they were supporting buff/tempo playstyles. High Abbess Alura was a huge success in Paladin and even took a nerf because of that but the card simply doesn't work with any reliable Priest strategies. And Disciplinarian Gandling was simply insanely overrated and failed even within Warlock. There's also Frazzled Freshman (people were worried because it was a 1/4) and Power Word: Feast. If they just gave Priest a basic Arcane Intellect, these cards would probably be playable, at least. If they have no intention of doing this then i would wish for them to stop printing useless stuff and give the class cards that actually support its slower nature.
I think we'll see Mage played less as folks begin to play counter decks, aka RUSH EM GOOD.
Definitely frustrating to play against though. Incanter's Flow is such a stupid card - and I say that as someone that loves to abuse it as Mage. The mana cheating in Hearthstone is just so insane and really, its my only major complaint about the way the game has been designed in recent times.
Quest Mage is still good without it. I've been beat by players who didn't play an IF til much, much later in the game. Its just insane when they Turn 1 Coin+IF followed by IF. Yeah, no point in playing then!
I do think if a nerf does end up needing to happen, they should target IF with a +1 to mana cost. The spell is clearly problematic and I'd hate to go into the Alterac Valley (pls blizz) expansion later this year with it still being the bread and butter of the class. Then when it rotates in March/April of next year, do not unnerf it. Wild players don't deserve to fight against that forever.
My biggest concern is that even with potential quest/card nerfs for this expansion, we won't see any visceral change until the core set rotation of next year. 5-7 months is a long time to wait for the core set to rotate out all the changes/inherent neutral draw options available.
Also, a comment I meant to make earlier was that my feeling is that Demon Hunter is the problem/crux of all this. Demon Hunter set a "standard" for card draw with their initial release, and since then they've been a powerhouse class becuase of it. Even after multiple nerfs I'd argue that the class is still inherently strong from a combo/aggro standpoint. (Which as an aside, I didn't think we needed another aggro/combo class.)
It's funny to think that the Nzoth/Inquisitor build from last meta, is being completely shut out because the power level of the decks in this expansion is so high it's completely shut down any decks that require turn 8+ win conditions.
Edit: looks like I ended up typing out a long reply anyways oh well.
Lol. I know that feeling. I often think it'll just be a couple of paragraphs, then 17 paragraphs later I can't imagine how it could be made shorter.
Anyway, yes, "word creep" is definitely how HS has handled power creep. We should be glad of that really, because if vanilla stats don't change then there's hope that Standard can undo power creep. At least in principle. It happened before with the Year of the Raven, which was a huge benefit to the game in the Year of the Dragon, but I'm not optimistic that they'll do it again since it requires a year of cards that don't impact the meta much immediately.
I was in serial disconnect/re-connect land too for the first 2 days. Very frustrating, but it seems like performance has improved a bit in the last 24 hours. Here's hoping.
I am farming achievements at the Diamond 5 floor. Painful to lose so much, but the at least I am getting XP for now.
I don't feel like typing out a super long reply, but in reply to your Primary post Shuckle, I 100% agree. Right now it feels like card draw is overtuned, and the usual format of Combo>Control>Aggro>Combo doesn't exist. Instead Combo and Aggro vie against one another for meta supremacy between expansions/mini-set releases/balance patches...while Control huddles in the corner in a fetal position.
For the last year-ish, playing control has felt like "did I draw the perfect nuts draw and counter my combo or aggro opponent perfectly with an extremely refined and teched deck" Yes? Congrats. No. You lose.
My biggest issue with the current Stormwind meta is that back and forth interactions are no longer a thing. Standard feels like wild now. The reason I liked standard and play standard is for the back and forth decision making and interactions between two players playing decks. Wild doesn't really care about the opponents deck. It has it's own gameplan, and if it fufills it's gameplan before you fufill yours, you generally just lose....
....which is exactly what is occurring in standard now. I'm honestly fed up with a lot of the design decisions the devs have made. Vanilla statlines haven't moved that much, but extra effects sure have. A 3 mana 3/4 with no special effects (aka spider tank) used to be the gold standard for 3 drops. Now, unless your 3 mana minion has a special passive, deathrattle, battlecry, etc it's usually not worth running (see LuckySoul Hoarder or Razorfen Beastmaster, Dreaming Drake, Pack Kodo, Alliance Bannerman, etc).
Now some of those are 3/3's or even 2/2's but the 3 cost is tied to a super strong effect. I know those are all class cards, but even cards like Archdruid Naralex, or Devouring Ectoplasm exist). Put simply, we don't need to go back to "vanilla" hearthstone like PrivateNightmare was suggesting, but I think we are starting to see too many compounded effects being tacked onto cards.
In short: Too much "word creep" (special effects attached to vanilla or normal statlines). Too much available card draw with little-to-no downsides attached. And control has been pushed out entirely at this point. (the last surviving bastion of control was priest, but after the nerfs to Apotheosis and Renew, the deck has struggled to say the least.)
Edit: looks like I ended up typing out a long reply anyways oh well.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
My sense, based on dev comments from around the time of the first rewards track, is that it's decided from the outset how much gold in total would be given out on the rewards track. Thereafter, it's a question of distributing the gold across the many levels. From that perspective, we're not getting golden cards in lieu of gold; without such 'filler' rewards, the alternative would have been to reduce the amount of gold awarded on some levels.
Hearthstone Access - A New Mod Improves Accessibility for Blind and Visually Impaired Players
Finally, something to smile widely for. Nothing but absolute respect for Guide Dev.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
I'd love to see them double up on those slots for rewards. I know so many people just don't care about golden cards that it would be a really nice square to give them something.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
I might be alone in thinking this, but I would rather have the 50 gold from the rewards track than agolden cards that you can’t disenchant.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
Mass nerfing is an interesting concept to explore. Keeping a weaker core set makes the expansions more playable, but does come at a cost of diversity. I wouldn't dismiss it altogether, though I'm also interested whether it makes hearthstone a little more dependent on its expansions (and therefore a more costly product to have fun in).
Glad to also know that the team will be discussing nerfs and confirmation of at least one card that will be changed cough* cough* Incanter's Flow. This may be the hardest to balance, because some stuff in stormwind seems to anticipate a combo heavy meta so we have absolutely insane aggro cards like Battleground Battlemaster. Will be surprised if this wasn't hit (maybe to the stats) in some way after combo decks get nerfed.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
Incanter's flow is useful even in the late game because that's usually how they kill you after completing the quest. Just draw their whole deck with cram sessions and refreshing spring water, and then ignite all the way. So its not necessarily needed early actually.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
Yes, that's correct. And then some guy I faced had a big brain idea to start teching in devolving missiles so even divine shield doesn't save it. Its kinda harsh but robes can absolutely be countered by mage. They can even chance a discover at it. Back to the drawing board.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
Hadbuff seems to really take off around D7 and up. On my grind up (as quest mage) I basically faced none that were a problem until then, at which point it was all Cult Neophyte, Robes of Protection, and Battleground Battlemaster combo wombos
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
If you're running into a lot of problems with mage, run Robes of Protection. Hard mulligan for it, if necessary. I've had a dozen games as mage get completely shut out by a single one of those, as quest mage (at least the no spell version) has exactly zero counters for it.
9 More Top Legend Standard Hearthstone Decks to Complete Your Early United in Stormwind Experience
No Garrote Rogue is ridiculous they get their combo turn 6 and just win. Who would of thought 4 mana deal 16 is broken....
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
The stats might be an interesting showcase of what happens yet again when you live within a polarising rock-paper-scissors meta. Quest mage might not be the 'best' deck statistically as shown by the pic, but it sure doesn't feel that way whenever you're facing it. And while handbuff pally is shown to have a higher win rate, it really does fold rather quickly to the combo decks.
Far as Im concerned its likely because everyone is teching against combo (Cult Neophyte, Far Watch Post, cheaper and smaller decklist etc.) that whenever you meet a handbuff pally youre just in such a poor condition to face it.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
Face hunter wont be a thing when people don't want to win anymore.
Card draw power creep is a major issue
DS + IF is probably the easiest combo to assemble in the whole game. When they announced the new core set for Priest and i saw that Inner Fire was gone, i became hopeful that Priest would be able to play a genuine buff based deck without resorting to a combo finisher. However, they also removed Power Word: Shield and Northshire Cleric which were the main cycle/reloading tool for the class. After that, they kept printing good tempo minions and buffs but all of these cards ended up as a complete failure. Priest doesn't have a hero power that creates minions like Paladin. Paladin can always throw their buffs into their 1/1s whenever they are out of minions. Priest, however, needs actual minions to buff and if their stuff gets removed there's a pretty high chance that they will become stuck with buff spells in hand that simply can't be used.
I'm not desperate for the birth of a super good aggro/tempo priest because i'm sure it will be infuriating to deal with. What annoys me is the fact that they keep printing these tempo cards and buffs that serve no purpose outside of discover/generation. Precious slots in card sets are wasted with cards that are simply hopeless. The strongest example is Scholomance Academy. This set brought a few cards that see play all the time (mainly Draconic Studies and Raise Dead) but both dual class legendary slots failed completely within the class because they were supporting buff/tempo playstyles. High Abbess Alura was a huge success in Paladin and even took a nerf because of that but the card simply doesn't work with any reliable Priest strategies. And Disciplinarian Gandling was simply insanely overrated and failed even within Warlock. There's also Frazzled Freshman (people were worried because it was a 1/4) and Power Word: Feast. If they just gave Priest a basic Arcane Intellect, these cards would probably be playable, at least. If they have no intention of doing this then i would wish for them to stop printing useless stuff and give the class cards that actually support its slower nature.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
When will Face Hunter no longer be a thing?
When will the deck archetypes they push and get us excited about actually work better than aggro decks?
Bleh. It's the usual week-into-an-expansion sadness when all my experiments aren't working out.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
I think we'll see Mage played less as folks begin to play counter decks, aka RUSH EM GOOD.
Definitely frustrating to play against though. Incanter's Flow is such a stupid card - and I say that as someone that loves to abuse it as Mage. The mana cheating in Hearthstone is just so insane and really, its my only major complaint about the way the game has been designed in recent times.
Quest Mage is still good without it. I've been beat by players who didn't play an IF til much, much later in the game. Its just insane when they Turn 1 Coin+IF followed by IF. Yeah, no point in playing then!
I do think if a nerf does end up needing to happen, they should target IF with a +1 to mana cost. The spell is clearly problematic and I'd hate to go into the Alterac Valley (pls blizz) expansion later this year with it still being the bread and butter of the class. Then when it rotates in March/April of next year, do not unnerf it. Wild players don't deserve to fight against that forever.
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
It's because quest mage is frustating to play against if you aren't a face deck.
Darkseeker's channel - 13th November update: KOtsosKOtsos' Reno Evolve Shudderwock Shaman - ft. Archivist Elysiana
6th August update: LaboreSangre's WILD Giants Shaman - United in Stormwind!
All hail Laboresangre for this awesome Giants Shaman deck. Draw through your deck, find your giants, win the game.
https://twitter.com/laboresangre/status/1422845244350124037
Deck code: AAEBAaoIBpUBlAOr0ALz5wLcuAOLnwQM0hOCtAKNzgL28AKe/QKMhQPw1AP67APk9gOF+gPwhQT5nwQA
https://youtu.be/-xM-wrheD30
New Priest Minion - Voidtouched Attendant
this card in wild aggro shadow priest just reads :
1 mana 1/3 effect : raid leader + spell damage + hero power damage
it's busted :D, got to legend with 70% win shadow priest
What Standard Decks to Play in Hearthstone's New Expansion? The Top 10 Stormwind Deck Archetypes of Week 1
Nerf mage >:(
Its interesting to see how these always differ from the general perception, I myself also fully expected to see Mage on top
Card draw power creep is a major issue
My biggest concern is that even with potential quest/card nerfs for this expansion, we won't see any visceral change until the core set rotation of next year. 5-7 months is a long time to wait for the core set to rotate out all the changes/inherent neutral draw options available.
Also, a comment I meant to make earlier was that my feeling is that Demon Hunter is the problem/crux of all this. Demon Hunter set a "standard" for card draw with their initial release, and since then they've been a powerhouse class becuase of it. Even after multiple nerfs I'd argue that the class is still inherently strong from a combo/aggro standpoint. (Which as an aside, I didn't think we needed another aggro/combo class.)
It's funny to think that the Nzoth/Inquisitor build from last meta, is being completely shut out because the power level of the decks in this expansion is so high it's completely shut down any decks that require turn 8+ win conditions.
Card draw power creep is a major issue
Lol. I know that feeling. I often think it'll just be a couple of paragraphs, then 17 paragraphs later I can't imagine how it could be made shorter.
Anyway, yes, "word creep" is definitely how HS has handled power creep. We should be glad of that really, because if vanilla stats don't change then there's hope that Standard can undo power creep. At least in principle. It happened before with the Year of the Raven, which was a huge benefit to the game in the Year of the Dragon, but I'm not optimistic that they'll do it again since it requires a year of cards that don't impact the meta much immediately.
9 More Top Legend Standard Hearthstone Decks to Complete Your Early United in Stormwind Experience
I was in serial disconnect/re-connect land too for the first 2 days. Very frustrating, but it seems like performance has improved a bit in the last 24 hours. Here's hoping.
I am farming achievements at the Diamond 5 floor. Painful to lose so much, but the at least I am getting XP for now.
10 subscriber thank you video
9 More Top Legend Standard Hearthstone Decks to Complete Your Early United in Stormwind Experience
I forgot to use my aren-uh... tavern tickets last expansion, so this is good news to me.
Card draw power creep is a major issue
I don't feel like typing out a super long reply, but in reply to your Primary post Shuckle, I 100% agree. Right now it feels like card draw is overtuned, and the usual format of Combo>Control>Aggro>Combo doesn't exist. Instead Combo and Aggro vie against one another for meta supremacy between expansions/mini-set releases/balance patches...while Control huddles in the corner in a fetal position.
For the last year-ish, playing control has felt like "did I draw the perfect nuts draw and counter my combo or aggro opponent perfectly with an extremely refined and teched deck" Yes? Congrats. No. You lose.
My biggest issue with the current Stormwind meta is that back and forth interactions are no longer a thing. Standard feels like wild now. The reason I liked standard and play standard is for the back and forth decision making and interactions between two players playing decks. Wild doesn't really care about the opponents deck. It has it's own gameplan, and if it fufills it's gameplan before you fufill yours, you generally just lose....
....which is exactly what is occurring in standard now. I'm honestly fed up with a lot of the design decisions the devs have made. Vanilla statlines haven't moved that much, but extra effects sure have. A 3 mana 3/4 with no special effects (aka spider tank) used to be the gold standard for 3 drops. Now, unless your 3 mana minion has a special passive, deathrattle, battlecry, etc it's usually not worth running (see LuckySoul Hoarder or Razorfen Beastmaster, Dreaming Drake, Pack Kodo, Alliance Bannerman, etc).
Now some of those are 3/3's or even 2/2's but the 3 cost is tied to a super strong effect. I know those are all class cards, but even cards like Archdruid Naralex, or Devouring Ectoplasm exist). Put simply, we don't need to go back to "vanilla" hearthstone like PrivateNightmare was suggesting, but I think we are starting to see too many compounded effects being tacked onto cards.
In short: Too much "word creep" (special effects attached to vanilla or normal statlines). Too much available card draw with little-to-no downsides attached. And control has been pushed out entirely at this point. (the last surviving bastion of control was priest, but after the nerfs to Apotheosis and Renew, the deck has struggled to say the least.)
Edit: looks like I ended up typing out a long reply anyways oh well.