While I agree that there is exactly zero reason why Flesh Giant, of all giants, should be the cheapest, considering how easily it can be (permanenty) discounted in contrast to Mountain Giant, Molten Giant etc. it don't think destroying that card alone fixes the problem. There is still an underlying groundwork of brokenness that allows Warlock to even discount the Giant as quickly as they do (note how utterly useless the card is in Priest). Nerf the giant, definitely, but Darkglare HAS to go too. It's Darkglare that enables all of this shit in the first place and it's absurd to me that it has been allowed to exist in its current state after the first nerf. I mean they nefed it and it became the centrepiece of one of the most dominant decks in Wild's history.
There's no way I should be able to play Quest on turn 1 and then immediately seize the board on turn 2 with coin by playing 6 mana worth of stuff on turn 2 and still have mana left over. Darkglare + Tour Guide + Flame Imp + 2x Kobold Librarian and good luck to the opponent in controlling the board despite the fact I skipped my turn 1. My hand is refilled, I have tons of bodies on the board and the opponent likely has to spend their entire turn just killing the Darkglare.
They should definitely up the giant's cost to at least 10 if not 12, but it's only a matter of time until another card is printed that abuses Darkglare, giant or no, since self damage is such an integral part of Warlock identity. Tying mana cheating to the basic thing Warlocks do is just not on. Make that thing trigger only once a turn, maaaybe refresh 2 crystals instead of one to compensate, though that might still be way too generous of a mana cheat. At best you'd have a free 2/3 that requires an answer, but you can't just run away with the game within the span of a one turn from hand.
For glare, just make it a 3/4 for 3again like used to but keep refresh 1mana instead of old refresh 2 and make raise dead 1.
That would weaken/slow it down quite abit, (glare into raise into 1drops would be turn 4 vs turn 2)
While I agree that there is exactly zero reason why Flesh Giant, of all giants, should be the cheapest, considering how easily it can be (permanenty) discounted in contrast to Mountain Giant, Molten Giant etc. it don't think destroying that card alone fixes the problem. There is still an underlying groundwork of brokenness that allows Warlock to even discount the Giant as quickly as they do (note how utterly useless the card is in Priest). Nerf the giant, definitely, but Darkglare HAS to go too. It's Darkglare that enables all of this shit in the first place and it's absurd to me that it has been allowed to exist in its current state after the first nerf. I mean they nefed it and it became the centrepiece of one of the most dominant decks in Wild's history.
There's no way I should be able to play Quest on turn 1 and then immediately seize the board on turn 2 with coin by playing 6 mana worth of stuff on turn 2 and still have mana left over. Darkglare + Tour Guide + Flame Imp + 2x Kobold Librarian and good luck to the opponent in controlling the board despite the fact I skipped my turn 1. My hand is refilled, I have tons of bodies on the board and the opponent likely has to spend their entire turn just killing the Darkglare.
They should definitely up the giant's cost to at least 10 if not 12, but it's only a matter of time until another card is printed that abuses Darkglare, giant or no, since self damage is such an integral part of Warlock identity. Tying mana cheating to the basic thing Warlocks do is just not on. Make that thing trigger only once a turn, maaaybe refresh 2 crystals instead of one to compensate, though that might still be way too generous of a mana cheat. At best you'd have a free 2/3 that requires an answer, but you can't just run away with the game within the span of a one turn from hand.
I'm afraid I have to insist: this would change everything.
Smart bots were banned by Blizzard many years ago, and thousands of accounts were banned. Blizzard's "excuse" for banning them was precisely that they injected code into the executable (which is precisely what this "mod" does), which violates Blizzard's rules. This type of bots no longer exist nowadays, as it's very easy to detect them (a checksum of the executable would suffice) and the ban of the account would be immediate.
The bots that still exist today are repetition bots, that is, they do not think for themselves, they only limit themselves to following a series of serial orders, since they only interact with the graphical interface blindly.
As a programmer, I could create an intelligent bot thanks to this "mod" in 10 minutes, since this mod would allow me to bypass the graphical interface and directly collect the information I need to know everything: what cards are in my hand, how much mana I have, what are the minions in play and where are they, etc ...
What's more, this "mod" would allow my bot to interact with the game without using the mouse, just sending keyboard commands, and therefore I could be doing anything while my bot makes me reach legend in a couple of days and level 400 in no more than a month.
In short, Blizzard will NEVER allow this project to continue as a "mod", unless they do it themselves and integrate it into the game, but I think it's pretty obvious that won't happen.
I can't really imagine what it would be like to be blind or deaf but I am sure if I were, I would love this CCG. This is a very cool modification. Cudos to the coders and thanks for the article!
I want to see a nerf to Occult Conjurer. Their burst can be healed through, but that card alone patches one of few abusable weaknesses it had, which was a weak turn 4.
Thanks for highlighting my deck! It's what I made for the give-away. I still have to try it myself, but now that I've had a peak of the new Wild ladder I don't think it's very strong. Luckily, that doesn't mean it can't be fun!
I'm almost exclusively playing Wild and it looks like the meta is healing there. Shortly after release everybody was playing QL Warlock, now the ladder is full of hyper Aggro decks, we're even having our own version of Shadowpriest. The logical next step would be the return of Control lists that counter the aggro fiesta and voilà: we're back at rock-paper-scissors with Secret Mages laughing their asses off because they just don't care.
Weird though, I never face Flesh Giant in D10 rank and below. All I faced was Dark Glare, and Stealer of Souls discounted by Free Admission. (just like @dapperdog mentioned). And it still pretty much ruined my games on turn 6 or 7.
It seems Face Hunter and sometime Tempo Shaman is the only one fast enough to beat them since Warlock usually at their low health.
Been trying to complete the Rogue Masquerade achievement, and finally got it after many many attempts using a Masquerage Questline Rogue. Garrosh couldn't avoid me forever!
Anyway, that isn't important! What is important is that the final game was against a Questline Spell Mage, and my Wandmaker just happened to give me a Savory Deviate Delight right after this Mage completed their quest! So of course I played it, and of course Arcanist Dawngrasp was the only minion in their hand so it became a Prize Plunderer!
On the flip side, my Prize Plunderer transformed into a Southsea Scoundrel, which I used to gain a copy of Ignite from their deck, and add to the other copy I got off Wand Thief... It was a bit of an RNG Fiesta, but it sure was fun!
Combo with Stealer of Souls, Darkglare, and Free Admission would have been the best deck had it not been for the goddamned slow as hell animations of the quest itself. The number of times I've lost my games because the bs quest takes forever to flip between tiers. Otherwise, it's death by turn 5-6 one way or another. Turn off the animations and I can finish all 3 tiers and kill my opponent on turn 5-6 more consistently than it would otherwise.
Of course, another problem that's currently creeping up the corners is as pointed out, Battleground Battlemaster. I can see why you hate that card so much in this post: you're playing warlock, and you're zooming past all corners to get the giants out. Coincidentally, any deck that's not playing combo now has this one card in it that reads: deal double damage on turn 5 if your opponent ignores your minions on board.
The madness of how fast the combos tend to come out is countered by how fast minion based decks can scam wins with this one card. Its a near mandatory inclusion into any minion based deck right now, and unless nerfs happen, will continue for time to come.
I do think the giants are strong, but I don't think its going to get nerfed. Zoolock in the past has dropped giants on 3 before and no one batted an eye. The reason being that you're basically trading health away to do it so you're playing on a clock as well as they are. With turn 5 battleground battlemaster, and the notable lack of taunts, the only way zoolock steal wins is by double giants on 3-4, with a good existing board like Bloodbound Imp and Darkglare support. That's the equivalent of token druid turn 1 bs, and just about as consistent.
If team5 decides to slow combo down in the next change (maybe switch the quest reward mana cost from 5 to 7, or just straightup nuke Incanter's Flow) zoolock may well be killing themselves faster than they can scam that win out because no one needs to tech against mage anymore. Nerfing battleground battlemaster would be the correct choice, not flesh giant.
I accidently forgot to mention I was speaking of wild, lol. Anyways, yes, I do not think Mutanus itself was what lead to the meta we had pre-Stormwind. A combination of Brann, Dirty Rats, and Mutanus had seen a surge of play this month. If your combo required more than 3 cards, you could never get it off because of those cards which lead to more value oriented games. There is also the fact that every top tier deck has 1-2 neutral counters. As for standard? Yeah, there really isn't a lot of interaction.
I feel as though we have had the most counter play against swing turns than we have ever had. The Introduction of Mutanus has given a rise to hand disruption and Tealen and Polket has made it easier than ever to predict when the best time to disrupt your opponent is. I have faced at least 5 different unique (and seemingly viable?) ways to disrupt popular strategies this past month.
A single card is not, "rise to hand disruption". Dirty rat was more of a disruptive meta than Mutanus. And I can't even recall the last time I saw Polket played. Taelen sure, but Polket? Was Scholo.
And unique ways to disrupt doesn't always equate to viable. (you even questioned the viability yourself in the statement above!)
Jeez man you're really looking too deep into this and heavily exaggerating what I'm saying.
This is why I didn't reply to him earlier. I honestly just felt like I was talking to a hyperbolic brick wall. He's taking every comment to the extreme.
Yeah, seeing as you Discover cards of the class you are disguised as before turning back into a Rogue, you are actually that other class unless you play a Rogue card during the game. At least in terms of how the game views you until you turn into a Rogue, you are that class. So it makes sense that you'd gain XP to level that class instead of Rogue.
Doesn't mean it's intentional though, but maybe it is? I doubt it's something that they will address though even if it is unintentional.
Yeah, the giant seems to be the issue in standard, and is an issue in wild as well. After a week or two when balance changes are made, if mage is nerfed and the giant isn't I could see the meta shifting to an aggro/tempo meta because I cannot see a meta where control can exist where warlock can complete their quest while dropping threats that need to be killed.
I feel as though we have had the most counter play against swing turns than we have ever had. The Introduction of Mutanus has given a rise to hand disruption and Tealen and Polket has made it easier than ever to predict when the best time to disrupt your opponent is. I have faced at least 5 different unique (and seemingly viable?) ways to disrupt popular strategies this past month.
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
For glare, just make it a 3/4 for 3again like used to but keep refresh 1mana instead of old refresh 2 and make raise dead 1.
That would weaken/slow it down quite abit, (glare into raise into 1drops would be turn 4 vs turn 2)
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
While I agree that there is exactly zero reason why Flesh Giant, of all giants, should be the cheapest, considering how easily it can be (permanenty) discounted in contrast to Mountain Giant, Molten Giant etc. it don't think destroying that card alone fixes the problem. There is still an underlying groundwork of brokenness that allows Warlock to even discount the Giant as quickly as they do (note how utterly useless the card is in Priest). Nerf the giant, definitely, but Darkglare HAS to go too. It's Darkglare that enables all of this shit in the first place and it's absurd to me that it has been allowed to exist in its current state after the first nerf. I mean they nefed it and it became the centrepiece of one of the most dominant decks in Wild's history.
There's no way I should be able to play Quest on turn 1 and then immediately seize the board on turn 2 with coin by playing 6 mana worth of stuff on turn 2 and still have mana left over. Darkglare + Tour Guide + Flame Imp + 2x Kobold Librarian and good luck to the opponent in controlling the board despite the fact I skipped my turn 1. My hand is refilled, I have tons of bodies on the board and the opponent likely has to spend their entire turn just killing the Darkglare.
They should definitely up the giant's cost to at least 10 if not 12, but it's only a matter of time until another card is printed that abuses Darkglare, giant or no, since self damage is such an integral part of Warlock identity. Tying mana cheating to the basic thing Warlocks do is just not on. Make that thing trigger only once a turn, maaaybe refresh 2 crystals instead of one to compensate, though that might still be way too generous of a mana cheat. At best you'd have a free 2/3 that requires an answer, but you can't just run away with the game within the span of a one turn from hand.
Hearthstone Access - A New Mod Improves Accessibility for Blind and Visually Impaired Players
I'm afraid I have to insist: this would change everything.
Smart bots were banned by Blizzard many years ago, and thousands of accounts were banned. Blizzard's "excuse" for banning them was precisely that they injected code into the executable (which is precisely what this "mod" does), which violates Blizzard's rules. This type of bots no longer exist nowadays, as it's very easy to detect them (a checksum of the executable would suffice) and the ban of the account would be immediate.
The bots that still exist today are repetition bots, that is, they do not think for themselves, they only limit themselves to following a series of serial orders, since they only interact with the graphical interface blindly.
As a programmer, I could create an intelligent bot thanks to this "mod" in 10 minutes, since this mod would allow me to bypass the graphical interface and directly collect the information I need to know everything: what cards are in my hand, how much mana I have, what are the minions in play and where are they, etc ...
What's more, this "mod" would allow my bot to interact with the game without using the mouse, just sending keyboard commands, and therefore I could be doing anything while my bot makes me reach legend in a couple of days and level 400 in no more than a month.
In short, Blizzard will NEVER allow this project to continue as a "mod", unless they do it themselves and integrate it into the game, but I think it's pretty obvious that won't happen.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
Millhouse Manastorm
Hearthstone Access - A New Mod Improves Accessibility for Blind and Visually Impaired Players
I can't really imagine what it would be like to be blind or deaf but I am sure if I were, I would love this CCG. This is a very cool modification. Cudos to the coders and thanks for the article!
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
I want to see a nerf to Occult Conjurer. Their burst can be healed through, but that card alone patches one of few abusable weaknesses it had, which was a weak turn 4.
Hearthstone Dueling in Stormwind - 12-Win Duel Decks to Take to Battle
That warlock deck is amazing! I got 12 wins the first time ever!!! I swapped loatheb and mutanus for the Shady Bartender and Travelling Merchant.
.
Meek mastery just killed everyone haha. 400 gold and 2 packs!
Here is my list
Here is the second half of my list
Stormwind's First Wild Deck Weekend Spotlight - Burgle Rogue, Highlander Demon Hunter, Divine Shield Paladin, & More
Thanks for highlighting my deck! It's what I made for the give-away. I still have to try it myself, but now that I've had a peak of the new Wild ladder I don't think it's very strong. Luckily, that doesn't mean it can't be fun!
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
Evasive Wyrm
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
I'm almost exclusively playing Wild and it looks like the meta is healing there. Shortly after release everybody was playing QL Warlock, now the ladder is full of hyper Aggro decks, we're even having our own version of Shadowpriest. The logical next step would be the return of Control lists that counter the aggro fiesta and voilà: we're back at rock-paper-scissors with Secret Mages laughing their asses off because they just don't care.
Hearthstone Access - A New Mod Improves Accessibility for Blind and Visually Impaired Players
Bots have already existed in Hearthstone for a very long time using similar methods. This doesn't change anything =)
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
Weird though, I never face Flesh Giant in D10 rank and below. All I faced was Dark Glare, and Stealer of Souls discounted by Free Admission. (just like @dapperdog mentioned). And it still pretty much ruined my games on turn 6 or 7.
It seems Face Hunter and sometime Tempo Shaman is the only one fast enough to beat them since Warlock usually at their low health.
Stormwind's First Wild Deck Weekend Spotlight - Burgle Rogue, Highlander Demon Hunter, Divine Shield Paladin, & More
If you write text="Your Text" within the first card tag parentheses, you can change card names into whatever you wish.
If you're interested of all possible magic tricks we have, Sinti has made a great thread about them.
The Pepper Thread - Share Some Good Vibes!
Been trying to complete the Rogue Masquerade achievement, and finally got it after many many attempts using a Masquerage Questline Rogue. Garrosh couldn't avoid me forever!
Anyway, that isn't important! What is important is that the final game was against a Questline Spell Mage, and my Wandmaker just happened to give me a Savory Deviate Delight right after this Mage completed their quest! So of course I played it, and of course Arcanist Dawngrasp was the only minion in their hand so it became a Prize Plunderer!
On the flip side, my Prize Plunderer transformed into a Southsea Scoundrel, which I used to gain a copy of Ignite from their deck, and add to the other copy I got off Wand Thief... It was a bit of an RNG Fiesta, but it sure was fun!
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
Combo with Stealer of Souls, Darkglare, and Free Admission would have been the best deck had it not been for the goddamned slow as hell animations of the quest itself. The number of times I've lost my games because the bs quest takes forever to flip between tiers. Otherwise, it's death by turn 5-6 one way or another. Turn off the animations and I can finish all 3 tiers and kill my opponent on turn 5-6 more consistently than it would otherwise.
Of course, another problem that's currently creeping up the corners is as pointed out, Battleground Battlemaster. I can see why you hate that card so much in this post: you're playing warlock, and you're zooming past all corners to get the giants out. Coincidentally, any deck that's not playing combo now has this one card in it that reads: deal double damage on turn 5 if your opponent ignores your minions on board.
The madness of how fast the combos tend to come out is countered by how fast minion based decks can scam wins with this one card. Its a near mandatory inclusion into any minion based deck right now, and unless nerfs happen, will continue for time to come.
I do think the giants are strong, but I don't think its going to get nerfed. Zoolock in the past has dropped giants on 3 before and no one batted an eye. The reason being that you're basically trading health away to do it so you're playing on a clock as well as they are. With turn 5 battleground battlemaster, and the notable lack of taunts, the only way zoolock steal wins is by double giants on 3-4, with a good existing board like Bloodbound Imp and Darkglare support. That's the equivalent of token druid turn 1 bs, and just about as consistent.
If team5 decides to slow combo down in the next change (maybe switch the quest reward mana cost from 5 to 7, or just straightup nuke Incanter's Flow) zoolock may well be killing themselves faster than they can scam that win out because no one needs to tech against mage anymore. Nerfing battleground battlemaster would be the correct choice, not flesh giant.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
I accidently forgot to mention I was speaking of wild, lol. Anyways, yes, I do not think Mutanus itself was what lead to the meta we had pre-Stormwind. A combination of Brann, Dirty Rats, and Mutanus had seen a surge of play this month. If your combo required more than 3 cards, you could never get it off because of those cards which lead to more value oriented games. There is also the fact that every top tier deck has 1-2 neutral counters. As for standard? Yeah, there really isn't a lot of interaction.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
So, um, if you want to solve this riddle and many others simply run a word or two through an online thesaurus....
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
A single card is not, "rise to hand disruption". Dirty rat was more of a disruptive meta than Mutanus. And I can't even recall the last time I saw Polket played. Taelen sure, but Polket? Was Scholo.
And unique ways to disrupt doesn't always equate to viable. (you even questioned the viability yourself in the statement above!)
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
This is why I didn't reply to him earlier. I honestly just felt like I was talking to a hyperbolic brick wall. He's taking every comment to the extreme.
Maestra of the Masquerade levels other classes up
Yeah, seeing as you Discover cards of the class you are disguised as before turning back into a Rogue, you are actually that other class unless you play a Rogue card during the game. At least in terms of how the game views you until you turn into a Rogue, you are that class. So it makes sense that you'd gain XP to level that class instead of Rogue.
Doesn't mean it's intentional though, but maybe it is? I doubt it's something that they will address though even if it is unintentional.
Masquerade Ball
Dane played an Even Reno deck just like this, and one of the clips on his YouTube video of the deck he's Demon Hunter. EVEN Demon Hunter... LOL
Scalding Hot Take: The Demon Seed is not the problem
Yeah, the giant seems to be the issue in standard, and is an issue in wild as well. After a week or two when balance changes are made, if mage is nerfed and the giant isn't I could see the meta shifting to an aggro/tempo meta because I cannot see a meta where control can exist where warlock can complete their quest while dropping threats that need to be killed.
Stormwind's First Wild Deck Weekend Spotlight - Burgle Rogue, Highlander Demon Hunter, Divine Shield Paladin, & More
How do you write Bolvar Fordragon while referencing Highlord Fordragon? What kind of trickery is this?
An Odd Feral Druid, Lost in the Park
I replaced 2x Starfall by 1x Naturalize and 1x Guidance. I'm not sure yet about Guidance, but Naturalize has been useful.
Dean Ayala's Hearthstone Community Q&A #24 - Revisiting Balance Next Week, Emote Wheel, Bring Back a Friend, Mass Nerf
I feel as though we have had the most counter play against swing turns than we have ever had. The Introduction of Mutanus has given a rise to hand disruption and Tealen and Polket has made it easier than ever to predict when the best time to disrupt your opponent is. I have faced at least 5 different unique (and seemingly viable?) ways to disrupt popular strategies this past month.