It's not giga strong but since we're now able to stack auras and extend their durability it might become scary at some point. Removing 6 drops on 3 or 4 consecutive turns in addition to what the Paladin is doing anyway is no small task.
A neat little card draw minion for Elemental Mage, and I like the cost reduction making an expensive Frost spell a lot easier to cast the longer you hold on to it. However, I don't agree with the flavor: Usually paintings get more expensive the longer they've been around.
This is interesting: The first half of Tarim is obviously going to be used as a buff for a smaller friendly minion, and the second half as a debuff for an enemy minion. A neat little two-for-one for aggro pally; I think there's a ton of gas for that archetype so I'm fairly certain we'll be seeing this guy around. (sidenote: one of the great tragedies of Baku-era standard was that Odd Paladin was so good that the obviously busted 6-Cost Tarim was close to an afterthought).
Augmented Porcupine for DK! At least kind of. It actually is even stronger I guess because it can go off multiple times. Maybe I'll have to craft Drakkari Enchanter after all...
Yeah I don't like it. It's obviously strong but I've never been a fan of Zephrys either and this just elevates it to the next level. Viper in all of my decks I guess.
This is a decent weapon. I can imagine that Pirate Rogue wants to play with it, especially with cards like Toy Boat giving benefits for summoning Pirates. Won't see play outside of Pirates, but that seems perfectly acceptable.
I expect this to be one of the most annoying cards of the set. Even Paladin will love it and even in Standard there are a few noteworthy ways to abuse it... Bucket of Soldiers would be a nice example from this set.
This is really good. Technically, the first half only "costs" 2, then the mini version is like a minion Prep that helps you cheat out basically anything you want. For Pirate Rogue this is an auto-include, I think there will be other kinds of Rogue that give this a run, as well.
So they're basically saying we can choose the Animal Companion if we pay one more Mana? Sounds pretty strong and incredibly versatile! This will round out a lot of decks...
This card reminds me of Arbor Up: It's a buff spell that brings along a decent body and can be back-breaking if you've already got a decent board presence. I like this better at the 4 spot than something like Crusader's Aura specifically because it brings with it an Annoy-o-Tron so you can protect whatever minions are already on the board (and the Aura only buffs if the minions are ready to attack).
Very strong 1 drop, this set has a lot of those for different tribes! This will instantly slip into Elemental decks and do a great job of keeping the early under control or enabling follow up effects without being a total waste of Mana later in the game.
I'm of a completely different opinion here - for me, this is one of the candidates for the Magma Rager award. It's way too expensive and 5 Mana do nothing has a nasty habit of exploding in your face if your not ahead anyway. Maaaaaaybe Spell Druid can use this because their location is super cheap and they might need the draw.
This is the big payoff for Undead Buff strategies; I want to make this so big that it can machine gun down the entire board with a little left over for the opponent's face. I'm pretty high on this specifically for buff decks, I don't think any other decks will bother.
This definitely looks strong and will probably be a favorite card of the set for many players. It's a dragon, it promotes board based strategies and it helps enable one of the funny broken (?) stars of the expansion. Nice one!
This is the Aura that would most benefit from some variety of cost reduction, like from Holy Cowboy, because otherwise that's a lot of random for a bit too much Mana and most 6-Drops in Standard aren't the kind of minions that you want to summon randomly (or at the end of your turn).
In a vacuum, this looks bonkers. Draw a Pirate for free sounds amazing! The biggest problem of this card is the power level of other 1 cost cards that Rogue already has access to... first and foremost Secret Passage and Gear Shift. So just like toy boat, I wouldn't bet on this making the cut in Wild Pirate Rogue.
Hand Buff Paladin is one of my weak spots, but for the most part the archetype has never been that powerful. A 2 Attack weapon that costs 4 is not going to bring handbuffs back.
Powerful location for Battlecry Shaman. I'd be interested in trying to use this to tutor specifically Shudder or Hagatha, and run otherwise only spells or minions that don't have Battlecries but that probably is getting a little too cute with a card that's just good.
Rarity and gold seem to matter, with gold mattering a whole lot more, even more than in actual Hearthstone's dust value. The total pack value might be some kind of multiplication rather than addition, because a lone golden legendary isn't enough to get a really high score, but in the company of some golden cards of lower rarities the point value skyrockets.
These callback cards that refuse to use their keywords are confusing af. This might end up being one of the best of them actually, the damage potential is nothing to ignore. Combo with Brann or Highlander Brann or Spirit of the Shark and you're good to go.
I'm a lot lower on this card than those above me. If it's going to see play it'd be in a deck that has plenty of targets, and I don't think Warrior has enough to make that happen.
Nice reference here but probably not good enough to make the cut. I don't even know what would be the best outcome here. And what's the synergy with the rest of the set? I don't want this to be hit by Magatha either.
Rogue always has to have at least two cards that Cost 1 and draw cards in Standard, it's the law. I mean, even if you didn't have the second half of the card, drawing a minion for 1 Mana is still pretty good. I like Pirate Rogue, so I'll definitely try to see how powerful this card can get.
New Paladin Spell - Crafter's Aura
It's not giga strong but since we're now able to stack auras and extend their durability it might become scary at some point. Removing 6 drops on 3 or 4 consecutive turns in addition to what the Paladin is doing anyway is no small task.
New Mage Minion - Watercolor Artist
A neat little card draw minion for Elemental Mage, and I like the cost reduction making an expensive Frost spell a lot easier to cast the longer you hold on to it. However, I don't agree with the flavor: Usually paintings get more expensive the longer they've been around.
New Paladin Minion - Toy Captain Tarim
This is interesting: The first half of Tarim is obviously going to be used as a buff for a smaller friendly minion, and the second half as a debuff for an enemy minion. A neat little two-for-one for aggro pally; I think there's a ton of gas for that archetype so I'm fairly certain we'll be seeing this guy around. (sidenote: one of the great tragedies of Baku-era standard was that Odd Paladin was so good that the obviously busted 6-Cost Tarim was close to an afterthought).
New Death Knight Minion - Darkthorn Quilter
Augmented Porcupine for DK! At least kind of. It actually is even stronger I guess because it can go off multiple times. Maybe I'll have to craft Drakkari Enchanter after all...
New Hunter Spell - Patchwork Pals
Always Huffer
New Mage Minion - Puzzlemaster Khadgar
Yeah I don't like it. It's obviously strong but I've never been a fan of Zephrys either and this just elevates it to the next level. Viper in all of my decks I guess.
New Rogue Weapon - Watercannon
This is a decent weapon. I can imagine that Pirate Rogue wants to play with it, especially with cards like Toy Boat giving benefits for summoning Pirates. Won't see play outside of Pirates, but that seems perfectly acceptable.
New Paladin Spell - Flash Sale
I expect this to be one of the most annoying cards of the set. Even Paladin will love it and even in Standard there are a few noteworthy ways to abuse it... Bucket of Soldiers would be a nice example from this set.
New Rogue Minion - Sandbox Scoundrel
This is really good. Technically, the first half only "costs" 2, then the mini version is like a minion Prep that helps you cheat out basically anything you want. For Pirate Rogue this is an auto-include, I think there will be other kinds of Rogue that give this a run, as well.
New Hunter Spell - Patchwork Pals
So they're basically saying we can choose the Animal Companion if we pay one more Mana? Sounds pretty strong and incredibly versatile! This will round out a lot of decks...
New Paladin Spell - Flash Sale
This card reminds me of Arbor Up: It's a buff spell that brings along a decent body and can be back-breaking if you've already got a decent board presence. I like this better at the 4 spot than something like Crusader's Aura specifically because it brings with it an Annoy-o-Tron so you can protect whatever minions are already on the board (and the Aura only buffs if the minions are ready to attack).
New Neutral Minion - Tar Slime
Very strong 1 drop, this set has a lot of those for different tribes! This will instantly slip into Elemental decks and do a great job of keeping the early under control or enabling follow up effects without being a total waste of Mana later in the game.
New Mage Minion - Puzzlemaster Khadgar
This is exciting: Usually when I play against Mage my weapon removal is just a dead card. Now it has a use! 10/10! Can't wait to Oooze!
New Neutral Minion - Workshop Janitor
I'm of a completely different opinion here - for me, this is one of the candidates for the Magma Rager award. It's way too expensive and 5 Mana do nothing has a nasty habit of exploding in your face if your not ahead anyway. Maaaaaaybe Spell Druid can use this because their location is super cheap and they might need the draw.
New Death Knight Minion - Darkthorn Quilter
This is the big payoff for Undead Buff strategies; I want to make this so big that it can machine gun down the entire board with a little left over for the opponent's face. I'm pretty high on this specifically for buff decks, I don't think any other decks will bother.
New Priest Minion - Clay Matriarch
This definitely looks strong and will probably be a favorite card of the set for many players. It's a dragon, it promotes board based strategies and it helps enable one of the funny broken (?) stars of the expansion. Nice one!
New Paladin Spell - Crafter's Aura
This is the Aura that would most benefit from some variety of cost reduction, like from Holy Cowboy, because otherwise that's a lot of random for a bit too much Mana and most 6-Drops in Standard aren't the kind of minions that you want to summon randomly (or at the end of your turn).
New Rogue Spell - Dig for Treasure
In a vacuum, this looks bonkers. Draw a Pirate for free sounds amazing! The biggest problem of this card is the power level of other 1 cost cards that Rogue already has access to... first and foremost Secret Passage and Gear Shift. So just like toy boat, I wouldn't bet on this making the cut in Wild Pirate Rogue.
New Paladin Weapon - Painter's Virtue
Hand Buff Paladin is one of my weak spots, but for the most part the archetype has never been that powerful. A 2 Attack weapon that costs 4 is not going to bring handbuffs back.
New Shaman Location - Fairy Tale Forest
Powerful location for Battlecry Shaman. I'd be interested in trying to use this to tutor specifically Shudder or Hagatha, and run otherwise only spells or minions that don't have Battlecries but that probably is getting a little too cute with a card that's just good.
Win a Whizbang's Workshop Pre-order Bundle With Out of Games
Rarity and gold seem to matter, with gold mattering a whole lot more, even more than in actual Hearthstone's dust value. The total pack value might be some kind of multiplication rather than addition, because a lone golden legendary isn't enough to get a really high score, but in the company of some golden cards of lower rarities the point value skyrockets.
New Neutral Minion - Nostalgic Clown
These callback cards that refuse to use their keywords are confusing af. This might end up being one of the best of them actually, the damage potential is nothing to ignore. Combo with Brann or Highlander Brann or Spirit of the Shark and you're good to go.
New Warrior Spell - Chemical Spill
I'm a lot lower on this card than those above me. If it's going to see play it'd be in a deck that has plenty of targets, and I don't think Warrior has enough to make that happen.
New Shaman Spell - Incredible Value
Nice reference here but probably not good enough to make the cut. I don't even know what would be the best outcome here. And what's the synergy with the rest of the set? I don't want this to be hit by Magatha either.
New Rogue Spell - Dig for Treasure
Rogue always has to have at least two cards that Cost 1 and draw cards in Standard, it's the law. I mean, even if you didn't have the second half of the card, drawing a minion for 1 Mana is still pretty good. I like Pirate Rogue, so I'll definitely try to see how powerful this card can get.