A very strong removal effect, but a little less so than the All-Star Psychic Scream because it only puts one card into the opponent's deck - they pay two and get all their minions back (assuming they have the room in hand) after drawing it, which could be immediately. I think this will see play; it's very annoying and annoying Priest cards see play.
I want Undead Buff DK to be good so very, very bad. I'm not in love with this card but I think it could be a decent mid-game buff for your hand full of Undead and I'm obviously willing to give it a go.
It probably only sees play in Mech decks. We've evolved past the point where smaller Dr. Booms are not much of a problem anymore. At some point, the Mech tag might be its savior though.
This is OK, this is one of the few Miniaturize minions where the Mini might actually be worse than the first half, which makes me think that this probably isn't going to see a lot of play.
Minis are really good, but random Minis aren't a reliable way to win the game - add to that the fact that this costs 9 and you're really struggling to make things work. Chemical spill or nothing for this minion, unfortunately.
It's probably not as strong as some people think it is just because it needs other cards to really get going, but it works really with Holli'dae and Shudderblock.
If Taunt Warrior sees play, then this will see play. If it doesn't, then it won't. I don't think Taunt Warrior is happening in Standard in this set, but there's always the next 2 sets.
This is really strong for a variety of Shaman decks. Obviously Elemental Shaman but just imagine landing this in Reno Shaman with Staff of Frogs equipped for a couple extra swings to get a few more frogs out of your turn.
In Wild, you can now play "random spells" cards on 8, 9, and 10 so that's pretty cool. Maybe this is the card that forces you into no minion decks, but I'm still not seeing it. The spells are still random (Wish Upon a Star would be a terrible hit considering that, like, you got no minions).
Yeah, good draw. Pay two, draw two decent minions. Gets them into hand for buffs, gets them into hand so you can play them. Good stuff for Taunt Warrior and I'm not interested in thinking about what other Warrior archetypes can do with this, but I'm sure it's good.
This is for Wish Upon a Star Shaman, for sure. Basically, if you've played a Wish or two, then you can use Shudder to fill the board with five buff taunt bodies and that sounds like something I'm definitely into.
This is an okay card. By itself it's not really enough to encourage no-minion Mage and even with the second 3-drop, you still sometimes might get screwed by the RNG and not get a good board for what you paid for.
At the very least I do appreciate the fact that the two pictures in the artwork do have some actual differences in them.
I'm not a fan of this location. Maybe it's a lot easier to get a lot of Beasts on board, but you're basically capped at 7 damage thanks to board space and I'm not really interested in trying to make this work.
Combustion for Demon Hunter. Combustion was pretty darn good for Mage to clean up early game aggression, and the lifesteal attached to outcast makes it very useful as stabilization for Demon Hunter. Going to see play.
So you have to be No Minions to even consider running this card. Feels a lot like Refreshing Spring Water - costs a little more and doesn't refresh the Mana so you can just play anything, and RSW was mostly busted thanks to Incanter's Flow and thankfully we're not seeing that kind of card show up in these reveals.
Weird stats on this one. Obviously a hand wide buff can't be too cheap, but why not skip the Lifesteal and give it Windfury instead? Or just reduce the cost a bit... I'm not sold on this one.
This is a decent little spell; it feels a bit too fair so what you really want to do with this is draw it with Watercolor Artist. I like it for Elemental Mage, but I'm a weirdo.
Regardless of how strong or weak the card is, I do hope that doesn't set a precedence for more cards being timed exclusives for pre-ordering. I don't want them to try this again.
No Minion Mage is certainly an intriguing option for deck-building. This card is fine in specifically a No Minion build - it's not a card that's going to force you into no minions, it's just a nice tool to have if you've already decided to be no minions. Considering that Khadgar is a minion, I don't think people are going to be very interested in no minion mage during this expansion.
New Priest Spell - Repackage
A very strong removal effect, but a little less so than the All-Star Psychic Scream because it only puts one card into the opponent's deck - they pay two and get all their minions back (assuming they have the room in hand) after drawing it, which could be immediately. I think this will see play; it's very annoying and annoying Priest cards see play.
New Death Knight Minion - Amateur Puppeteer
I want Undead Buff DK to be good so very, very bad. I'm not in love with this card but I think it could be a decent mid-game buff for your hand full of Undead and I'm obviously willing to give it a go.
New Warrior Minion - Fireworker
It probably only sees play in Mech decks. We've evolved past the point where smaller Dr. Booms are not much of a problem anymore. At some point, the Mech tag might be its savior though.
New Neutral Minion - Nostalgic Gnome
This is OK, this is one of the few Miniaturize minions where the Mini might actually be worse than the first half, which makes me think that this probably isn't going to see a lot of play.
New Warrior Minion - Botface
Minis are really good, but random Minis aren't a reliable way to win the game - add to that the fact that this costs 9 and you're really struggling to make things work. Chemical spill or nothing for this minion, unfortunately.
New Shaman Minion - Sand Art Elemental
It's probably not as strong as some people think it is just because it needs other cards to really get going, but it works really with Holli'dae and Shudderblock.
New Warrior Minion - Fireworker
A fun little 5-Drop, probably going to see the most play in Dr. Boom decks or deathrattle Mech decks which may or may not be a thing.
New Warrior Spell - Quality Assurance
It lives and dies by Taunt Warrior.
If Taunt Warrior sees play, then this will see play. If it doesn't, then it won't. I don't think Taunt Warrior is happening in Standard in this set, but there's always the next 2 sets.
New Shaman Minion - Sand Art Elemental
This is really strong for a variety of Shaman decks. Obviously Elemental Shaman but just imagine landing this in Reno Shaman with Staff of Frogs equipped for a couple extra swings to get a few more frogs out of your turn.
New Mage Spell - Yogg in the Box
In Wild, you can now play "random spells" cards on 8, 9, and 10 so that's pretty cool. Maybe this is the card that forces you into no minion decks, but I'm still not seeing it. The spells are still random (Wish Upon a Star would be a terrible hit considering that, like, you got no minions).
New Demon Hunter Spell - Workshop Mishap
It is probably going to tried out at the very least because it is a Combustion.
But it is a bit awkward to trigger Outcast and get good value of the excess damage effect at the same time.
New Warrior Spell - Quality Assurance
Yeah, good draw. Pay two, draw two decent minions. Gets them into hand for buffs, gets them into hand so you can play them. Good stuff for Taunt Warrior and I'm not interested in thinking about what other Warrior archetypes can do with this, but I'm sure it's good.
New Shaman Minion - Shining Sentinel
I'm already not looking forward to how annoying this is going to be to remove.
Which means that the card is really good.
New Hunter Location - Jungle Gym
This card seems to be being undervalued. Hunter definitely has the ability to swarm Beasts to rack up the damage with it.
New Shaman Minion - Shining Sentinel
This is for Wish Upon a Star Shaman, for sure. Basically, if you've played a Wish or two, then you can use Shudder to fill the board with five buff taunt bodies and that sounds like something I'm definitely into.
New Mage Spell - Spot the Difference
This is an okay card. By itself it's not really enough to encourage no-minion Mage and even with the second 3-drop, you still sometimes might get screwed by the RNG and not get a good board for what you paid for.
At the very least I do appreciate the fact that the two pictures in the artwork do have some actual differences in them.
New Hunter Location - Jungle Gym
I'm not a fan of this location. Maybe it's a lot easier to get a lot of Beasts on board, but you're basically capped at 7 damage thanks to board space and I'm not really interested in trying to make this work.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Workshop Mishap
Combustion for Demon Hunter. Combustion was pretty darn good for Mage to clean up early game aggression, and the lifesteal attached to outcast makes it very useful as stabilization for Demon Hunter. Going to see play.
New Mage Spell - Manufacturing Error
So you have to be No Minions to even consider running this card. Feels a lot like Refreshing Spring Water - costs a little more and doesn't refresh the Mana so you can just play anything, and RSW was mostly busted thanks to Incanter's Flow and thankfully we're not seeing that kind of card show up in these reveals.
New Paladin Weapon - Painter's Virtue
Remember Brass Knuckles?
This is that except a hell of a lot better. It's still a bit slow, but it might work out?
New Mage Spell - Frost Lich Cross-Stitch
This is a cool spell that doesn't seem too broken. Could be pretty good with Frost synergy.
New Paladin Weapon - Painter's Virtue
Weird stats on this one. Obviously a hand wide buff can't be too cheap, but why not skip the Lifesteal and give it Windfury instead? Or just reduce the cost a bit... I'm not sold on this one.
New Mage Spell - Frost Lich Cross-Stitch
This is a decent little spell; it feels a bit too fair so what you really want to do with this is draw it with Watercolor Artist. I like it for Elemental Mage, but I'm a weirdo.
New Neutral Minion - Corridor Sleeper
Regardless of how strong or weak the card is, I do hope that doesn't set a precedence for more cards being timed exclusives for pre-ordering. I don't want them to try this again.
New Mage Spell - Spot the Difference
No Minion Mage is certainly an intriguing option for deck-building. This card is fine in specifically a No Minion build - it's not a card that's going to force you into no minions, it's just a nice tool to have if you've already decided to be no minions. Considering that Khadgar is a minion, I don't think people are going to be very interested in no minion mage during this expansion.