All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Hunter Minion - Spurfang

    So a card that wants both handbuffs and board buffs, eh? This could be good, but it really depends on the support it gets.

  • New Warlock Minion - Disposal Assistant

    This, team5, is the problem with your idea of a sludgelock deck.

    You print several cards that get better when this card is played but this is only 2 out of 30 cards in your deck. So you build your entire deck around two of a piece and call it synergy?

    I would have preferred if all these sludge related cards simply discarded from the hand instead of bottom of the deck. At very least that way we know there's discard synergy already existing that can support this archetype. At present moment, this is the most important card in sludgelock and its not even that great. So why are we arsed to play sludgelock at all?

  • New Warlock Minion - Waste Remover

    This is the kind of "lol, 4 mana 7/7" moments that we all know and love.

    Unfortunately, this is 2023 and in this era even a 4 mana 8/8 is no longer considered good enough to suffer through its conditions, and this card comes with one major problem indeed. Fair enough its only destroying cards from the bottom of your deck, but imagine playing this against mage or DK and you can already see the problem.

    Aggro decks nowadays tend to have plenty of reload options so there's just no reason to believe that burning 10 cards, for example, from your deck is inconsequential. Making things worse is that this card practically puts you on a timer, and its very nearly impossible to play two of these at the same time unless you really, really feel lucky that day.

  • New Warlock Spell - Furnace Fuel

    Its not very good but the whole idea is for this card to be discarded/destroyed and never played on its own.

    So the question is whether it is possible for this card to be discarded/destroyed with any consistency? My guess is no. There's at present no many discard cards and none of them presents a consistent method of discarding this specific card. Even if you play this in a sludgelock deck, there's just no way to guarantee it destruction. Imagine drawing this card, what then? Just do a hail mary? Making things worse is the fact that sludgelock presents more targets to be discarded so this card gets even less consistent.

    Hand of Gul'dan it is not.

  • New Warlock Spell - Fracking

    Personally I think the card is shit. Its the kind of thing that can only ever be good if you do some convoluted mexican hat dance so the card wont screw you.

    The whole idea is of course to discard the sludges but what if you dont have any sludge at the bottom, will you risk it all and play this card regardless? Or more likely it'll just stay stuck in your hand until you can properly set it up.

    There is only one silver lining, and is presently the only thing keeping me from downgrading this to 1 star, is that you can build an aggro deck and just pretend that you're playing Gone Fishing. But in 2023 nowadays, its increasingly difficult to justify building a deck filled with garbage even for aggro decks.

  • New Warlock Minion - Sludge on Wheels

    Its really not good. But if youre gonna play this is entirely because it puts a barrel into your deck's bottom.

    Personally I think this card is bait. Unless youre playing aggro your opponent would likely manipulate this card to either overdraw you or to fill your deck with so much trash that when shuffled instantly makes your deck weaker on the draw.

    And with options like Snake Oil Seller being very likely to see play throughout, forcing a shuffle will likely not be too difficult. Id avoid this card, but then you'll likely play it just for the synergy and pray.

  • New Warlock Minion - Mo'arg Drillfist

    The only good thing about it is that excavates, so you'll play this entirely for that reason alone. The nice stat and taunt is a bonus, though a good one at that.

    It'll see play in excavatelock, because there's really no other reason to play this vanilla minion in your deck otherwise.

  • New Warlock Spell - Smokestack

    Its an excavate card so it'll see play if excavate warlock is playable.

    That's about it really. The main factor is indeed just to trigger more excavate, because you're probably aiming to get to The Azerite Snake as soon as possible. Screw the card, its main function is for a higher purpose, and thus even if its effect is simply just to excavate it'll see play.

  • New Warlock Minion - Pop'gar the Putrid

    Personally I think this card is a miss because at current moment of writing there's just no good fel spells. Ironically had this card came out during alterac it would at very least be an impactful card, over the many fel spells that were introduced then.

    But will this card see play? Probably yes, because lifesteal is a keyword you can never ignore and always must be respected. Even if I personally dont think its as good as it seem, you'll play this because of deck synergy. At very least the card grants you two 1 mana deal 3 damage fel spells so you can do something with it.

  • New Warlock Minion - Tram Conductor Gerry

    Its practically Soulciologist Malicia in all but name. Bizarrely this card has less stats by 1. Is that extra health and attack really that OP team5?

    So, there's no real reason to review cards like these. Its gonna see play if excavate sees play. No reason not to play it, especially since you'll likely need that board swing option for playing so many excavate cards that probably dont do more than putting stats on board.

    Its unlikely to ever win you games on its own, but then again neither did malicia and yet that card functioned pretty well with good win rates.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Playing 3 modes with less than 18 deck slots would not be fun either. I think the solution would be to filter decks by mode, not less deck slots.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    I liked the meta when Prince Renathal gave you 40 health, so experimentally I'd say that for me the game is better with more health.

    Maybe you only included it for humorous purposes, but going from Magma Rager to Ice Rager is not power creep, as neither card ever played a role in any past meta. A real example of power creep is Azure Drake, which used to be considered a good card included in many decks and now barely sees play despite being buffed. Or going from Sen'jin Shieldmasta to Saronite Tol'vir.

    What happened in Wild is a particular kind of power creep: the main factor driving up the power level is not that people select the best cards from all past sets, but that synergies work much better if you have a larger pool of synergistic cards to pick from.

    Old Hearthstone had a few OTKs and that sort of thing, but also three things you seldom find in modern Hearthstone:

    • Less swings. No healing to full health 5 times a game. No 20 face damage a turn as a baseline for most decks.
    • Stickier minions. When you placed a strong, expensive minion on the board, you didn't expect your opponent to have an answer for it 80% of the time.
    • Games that would consistently last past round 10. This has become shorter over time.

    I agree with your first two observations, but old Hearthstone games did not consistently last past round 10. Maybe if you go back to before Naxxramas or played a very control-heavy deck, but most games I played with mid-range decks took between 8 and 12 turns (I remember because I logged my attempts to play decks like Beast Druid). Going past turn 10 wasn't rare, but it wasn't a majority of games either. Dr. Boom was such a good card because he came down on turn 7, which was often just before games were decided.

    Less swings has both upsides and downsides. It feels more fair when your efforts aren't easily erased, but it also means that if a deck snowballs, there is no hope of recovering. While I think Modern Hearthstone has a bit too much swing potential, I wouldn't want to go back to the old days either.

    I fully agree with stickier minions. Minions are now so easily removed that you summon them to force your opponent spend resources on removing them, not because you expect them to still be there the next round. Again, I wouldn't want to go all the way back to the old days (games being decided by a turn 1 Mana Wyrm was no fun), but having stickier minions would be nice.

    Giving a hero more health has two main effects:

    • it gives you more time to stabilize versus aggro
    • it raises the bar for OTKs

    I think having more time to stabilize versus aggro is a good thing, because it makes games more interactive. It will force aggro decks to have a game plan that goes beyond just dumping the initial hand on the board and going face.

    Raising the bar for OTKs is good up to a certain point: metas in which OTK decks are dominant aren't fun, as the first player to draw their combo wins. But metas in which control decks without win conditions are dominant become a slog. I think it's good that in modern Hearthstone control decks do have win conditions, although when a single card is a win condition, like Odyn, Prime Designate, it becomes too repetitive.

    Tying health, archetypes and classes together sounds like a risky proposition:

    • even though cards were designed with a particular archetype in mind, that is no guarantee they'll be played only in that archetype; cheap taunts have been used successfully in aggro decks as well, for example
    • what about decks from previous expansions? do you tie a class and archetype together for an entire year? do you power creep so much from expansion to expansion that old decks become unplayable? if not, then some classes will have multiple archetypes
    • for aggro decks, how much health the most common opposing decks have is more important than the amount of health the own hero has

    In particular, if there is a viable aggro deck in a class that was predicted to not play aggro, that deck could beat all the aggro decks in the lower-health classes, because it wins damage races.

    In Hearthstone a card has a significant intrinsic mana value. For example, we have 0-mana cards that do useful things. The Warlock hero power costs 2 mana and 2 health for a single card and still it's considered one of the better hero powers. Arcane Intellect gives you net +1 card for 3 mana, yet lots of decks include it. Faeria had a neutral card with the same cost and effect, but it saw almost no play, because in Faeria drawing cards just gives you more options, but the mana cost determines the power level of the card.

    It is because of the intrinsic mana value of cards that we have aggro decks that dump their initial hand on the board and win or lose based on that momentum. It is the reason card draw and card generation are so good and that in turn is one of the main contributing factors to today's power creep: it is easier than ever to draw and generate cards and every card represents a mana discount.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff

    Honestly I'm starting to wonder if we don't have too many deck slots lmao. Hearthstone's interface is not exactly great when you've got 18 decks lying around, spread across a bajillion different modes.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff

    I agree messing with health isn't a perfect solution, but it seems Team 5 is already designing around the - for these times - small-ish health pool heroes have. The stronger cards' effects and stats get, the stronger healing & armor effects you get. If Grace of the Highfather restores 8 health today, I worry the future's 3-cost healing card will have to restore 10 to be competitive, and so on. Card numbers keep going up, health stays the same, and the game gets swingier and faster.

    What could be a solution that isn't a bandaid which results in the team still designing around it?

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff

    I, too, am a slugfest enjoyer. I'm not looking for all games to last at least 15 minutes, but just enough to feel like I've used most of the cards in my deck and they all had a bit of weight to them (so, not drawing half my deck by turn 7). It's the same jarring feeling you get in Warcraft III when you move from the campaign to some 1v1 multiplayer: Instead of having a bit of time to get your base set up, 2 minutes in you've already got some damn enemy Ghoul hounding on your peasants!

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff Pro

    Do you want a tooltip, or deck slots? There's only so much space in the files to go around!

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff

    A simple tooltip simply makes the game too complicated!

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Even now, the game could use a way of showing your opponent's max health. 

    Sure, it says 28 now, but is that 28/30, 28/35, or more? 

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Boost the health and then team5 has to now design cards around it and inevitably the same result will come off.

    Renathal was the first true exception whereby additional health are granted on an optional basis and we already seen the effects of renathal in the game. Suddenly aggro decks can sustain entire matches without ever running out of stuff, burn damage got increasingly more insane and in some cases near infinite, and certain classes go far into greeding their entire deck. Burn mage can virtually destroy any 30 health deck without a whimper, but struggle against a 40 health control deck.

    To me, there's just no reason to ever buff the starting health of any class because inevitably team5 would design around it. If they needed a class to last longer in the game, all they got to do is to print better sustain cards for them. We've seen it with priest already. The class went from being a laughing stock for having less than healing than paladin, to the point that you sometimes genuinely needed 60 damage in total to kill them.

     

    Also, the additional health means certain classes pretty much gets pigeonholed into one archetype or another. How is it fair for shaman to play aggro with 40 health against the same archetype in hunter who has 10 less health? If we print more powerful aggro tools for hunter to compensate, then what happens when they face a more controlling or greedy dhunter? Its just not ideal whichever way we do it.

    In my opinion, the hero health in hearthstone hearthstone is perfect. No need to tweak what isnt broken.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    Staff Pro

    "Renathal is an experiment, to see if they should raise everyone to 40!" - Some people when Nathria dropped. Then it was nerfed, and we never heard from them again lol.

    For what it's worth, my absolute favorite Hearthstone games are slugfests. I want to play the ultimate duel, where both players are going back-and-forth on the board and their life totals are rubber-banding as they give everything they got. Fatigue, value wars, lethals out of nowhere; whatever it takes to get the win.

    If I have the time to play one, obviously...which is the crux of the issue. People need to be able to get through a match on the bus or whatever, and thus Blizzard tends to cater to the "I won before we ever got close to 10 Mana" crowd. I get it (though if you truly want fast games, go play Marvel Snap lol).

  • spam deck

  • spam deck

  • All Showdown in the Badlands Day 9 Hearthstone Card Reveals - October 27

    Doesn't matter if it's good or not, if you're playing Excavate you're playing as much Excavate as you can. I mean, look at Praise Galakrond!. That actually saw play.

  • Should Hearthstone's Heroes Have More Than 30 Health?

    If heroes start getting more health then aggro and midrange decks will need more powercreep to stay relevant. It's either that or this game becomes combostone or a slugfest. None of those options seem healthy. 

  • Inventory Systems in Games - The Platform Nightmare

    Staff

    That... actually looks great! As long as the 'Enter' key functionality, to use items remains working, it looks like a net positive improvement over's the game's extremely clunky wheels.