Not a fan of this card design - the only silver lining is that it slims your deck and summons directly - but without the finale effect, I doubt it is really worth (3) mana ...
The core of Thief Rogue's deck may be rotating, but I see this card as an absolute blessing, as instead of getting any generic cards from random class, you get a card your opponent deemed good enough for their deck, and it is a discover mechanic, so it allows for some choice.
That tape has got poetry and clarinet on it, Garona. POETRY. AND CLARINET.
And the flavor text just hit a little too close from real life : He used to play to crowds of adoring Murlocs, but 20 years later all that's left is gigs at secluded clubs and regrets. Where did all the time go? His dreams of fame and fortune, snuffed out like the flame of a small candle in a dimly lit bar. Nothing but smoke in the wind.
They really didn't wanted Warrior to have a clear directly, or viable archetype, so instead, we are going back in time, revisiting archetypes that didn't worked back then and hoping for new results ... maddening
Stolen from a druidic drum circle, now destined to make music that is actually good.
But for Yogg's sake check the timeline in the initial post, you can only submit until Wednesday!
For some weird reason I thought it was Monday when I posted that comment, oh well, anyway, here's the feedback, sooner than promissed, and given the nature of the comp, I've decided to be more straight forward on my comments as well:
Show Spoiler
CursedParot - That is very cute, i like it, and I think the second version is the beast.
Dolphinslayer - Personally I think the "guy" meme is more than saturated right know, but that is just me, sure it still has its fans out there.
hammer12win - Honesestly this one is my favorite so far, very creative and cute, I love it.
Gear5PhoenixMan - I'll have to agree with the others, usually i would give suggestion on how to improve the card, but I'm really sure what to suggest, sorry.
GoodEgor - The art is bad, kinda hard to see what's going on, but otherwise, loved your card.
BasilAnguis - Fetch is the best for sure, the others are kinda meh.
Wailor - I mean, it is dumb (in a good way) but think it could be dumber if you messed with the flavour a bit more. Not sure what to suggest, but i smell a 5/5 with the right tweaks.
Demonxz95 - I think i'm only one here that actually preffer the Guy in a Bear Suit, I find it way more creative and unic, but once again I'm sure what to suggest to improve it.
I have this idea for a Resurrect/Evolve dual-class card but I'm not sure which version is best:
Both versions of this card function as a more fun type of resurrect Priest, since instead of dealing with the same minion over and over you face off against other random minions that they transform into. This card also breaks the rules by being a dual-class and dual-spell school card but given the spirit of the competition, I think some leniency on that front makes sense.
Adorable! And a nice play of words as well. Great work! Maybe move the artwork a tiny bit to the left so the bug can be seen better and I'd also change the watermark to a custom expansion. Probably 4 stars from me.
MrRhapsody
I've already expressed my love for this card. Favorite design this week! 5 stars from me!
Gear5PhoenixMan
I fear I have to agree with Wailor, I'm not a big fan either. If you choose to go with it nevertheless, I'd recommend to change the watermark to a custom expansion and move the text between brackets to the second line as well as the period behind the closing bracket. Probably 2 or 3 stars from me.
BasilAnguis
I also like Fetch! the most and I also agree it would be a better fit for Demon Hunter. Cool card! Probably 4 stars from me.
Wailor
Nice card, flawless execution as usual. My one worry is it might not be crazy enough to win. Probably 4 stars from me.
Demonxz95
Thanks for hosting this competition, it's always cool to mess around with goofy themes. Easily my facorite competition this season already! Regarding your cards, I agree with Wailor that Guy In A Bear Suit isn't the most creative way to interpret the prompt. Another Lightning Bolt is definitely funnier but not my favorite card in the thread either. Probably 3 or 4 stars from me.
Golden Touch Star provide a wide range of nutritious treatments to our spotless clientele in Dubai. Our therapists are skilled in a variety of soothing procedures that will help you relax and feel beautiful. Our massage and spa menu includes a variety of holistic treatments and therapies from across the world, all of which are intended to help you achieve mental and physical equilibrium. With our expert facial services, you may moisturize, exfoliate, and nourish your skin. We also provide a range of massages that can help you ease chronic discomfort in your body.
First round of feedback. It's gonna be very subjective, given the nature of this comp, so keep that in mind.
Demonxz95
I prefer Another Lightning Bolt, as I find it funnier. Also, I'm not a fan of the way Guy in a Bear Suit circumvents the rules.
BasilAnguis
Fetch is unironically my favorite card. The quirky wording and its playful flavor makes it appropriate for the comp, but it wouldn't feel out of place in a regular comp (you'd have to remove the Good boy in that case, but that's pretty minor).
My only suggestion is making it a Demon Hunter card. The flavor of treating your Demon like pets feels appropriate for a class named Demon HUNTER.
I'm not a fan of your other cards, though.
GoodEgor
Funny card, but it should probably be a legendary.
PhoenixMan
I don't find this card particularly funny or interesting, sorry.
MrRhapsody
I think this card is the funniest of the thread. The watermark is very dumb in a good way, too.
Audio Amplifier
TURN IT UP TO ELEVEN
Metrognome
Said to have over ONE MILLION Lugnutz on the hottest app, Clink-Clank!
Amplified Elekk
Prince ALI
Fabulous HE,
ALI Ababwa!
New Paladin Spell - Boogie Down
Not a fan of this card design - the only silver lining is that it slims your deck and summons directly - but without the finale effect, I doubt it is really worth (3) mana ...
Whatever you do, do NOT sashay to the right.
New Paladin Weapon - Disco Maul
Is every class receiving a new weapon sufficient sign that most decks will roll weapon removal?
I think they should.
Disco-ball ? Nah, dis go face.
New Rogue Spell - Mixtape
The core of Thief Rogue's deck may be rotating, but I see this card as an absolute blessing, as instead of getting any generic cards from random class, you get a card your opponent deemed good enough for their deck, and it is a discover mechanic, so it allows for some choice.
That tape has got poetry and clarinet on it, Garona. POETRY. AND CLARINET.
New Shaman Spell - Melomania
From De Other Side - hope this helps
I once saw a horse that had watermelons for hair. It was a melon mane, ya?!
New Shaman Minion - Saxophone Soloist
But Fire Fly was consistent, this Saxophone Soloist is pretty conditional.
And the flavor text just hit a little too close from real life :
He used to play to crowds of adoring Murlocs, but 20 years later all that's left is gigs at secluded clubs and regrets. Where did all the time go? His dreams of fame and fortune, snuffed out like the flame of a small candle in a dimly lit bar. Nothing but smoke in the wind.
New Warrior Weapon - Kodohide Drumkit
They really didn't wanted Warrior to have a clear directly, or viable archetype, so instead, we are going back in time, revisiting archetypes that didn't worked back then and hoping for new results ... maddening
Stolen from a druidic drum circle, now destined to make music that is actually good.
New Shaman Spell - Chill Vibes
Its the return of Antique Healbot with a powercreep-spell twist!
"You're listening to 47.7 Shaman FM radio. It's time to kick back, relax, and take in the music."
Pozzik, Audio Engineer
Was wondering who was weaseling all those bots onto the social web space.
Glad to see him starting the Rewards Track.
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
And that's the beauty of it. I love the chaos you've created here!
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
For some weird reason I thought it was Monday when I posted that comment, oh well, anyway, here's the feedback, sooner than promissed, and given the nature of the comp, I've decided to be more straight forward on my comments as well:
CursedParot - That is very cute, i like it, and I think the second version is the beast.
Dolphinslayer - Personally I think the "guy" meme is more than saturated right know, but that is just me, sure it still has its fans out there.
hammer12win - Honesestly this one is my favorite so far, very creative and cute, I love it.
Gear5PhoenixMan - I'll have to agree with the others, usually i would give suggestion on how to improve the card, but I'm really sure what to suggest, sorry.
GoodEgor - The art is bad, kinda hard to see what's going on, but otherwise, loved your card.
BasilAnguis - Fetch is the best for sure, the others are kinda meh.
Wailor - I mean, it is dumb (in a good way) but think it could be dumber if you messed with the flavour a bit more. Not sure what to suggest, but i smell a 5/5 with the right tweaks.
Demonxz95 - I think i'm only one here that actually preffer the Guy in a Bear Suit, I find it way more creative and unic, but once again I'm sure what to suggest to improve it.
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Not gonna lie, I'm really not even sure how to give feedback how unconventional the theme is.
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I have this idea for a Resurrect/Evolve dual-class card but I'm not sure which version is best:
Both versions of this card function as a more fun type of resurrect Priest, since instead of dealing with the same minion over and over you face off against other random minions that they transform into. This card also breaks the rules by being a dual-class and dual-spell school card but given the spirit of the competition, I think some leniency on that front makes sense.
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I could not pass up this opportunity for one of my favorite hearthstone memes.
All Card Flavor Text for the Festival of Legends Hearthstone Expansion
Chill Vibes - "You're listening to 47.7 Shaman FM radio. It's time to kick back, relax, and take in the music."
Love this reference. You better know the reference!
Baritone Imp - He used to be an epic sax guy, but now he's just a common.
Fixed the above flavor text with the appropriate hyperlink 🙃
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback!
New Shaman Spell - Chill Vibes
Duuuuude, we've been asking for a sweet control spell for like....ever man... so rad we get one now... wanna go for a smoke?
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
"Silence is sometimes better than speech."
btw This card cannot be cast or revealed.
New Neutral Minion - Cowbell Soloist
Makes me sad this is so trash cause... well, i'll just say it. Cow has some milkers.
beautifymemedicalcenterdubai
Golden Touch Star provide a wide range of nutritious treatments to our spotless clientele in Dubai. Our therapists are skilled in a variety of soothing procedures that will help you relax and feel beautiful. Our massage and spa menu includes a variety of holistic treatments and therapies from across the world, all of which are intended to help you achieve mental and physical equilibrium. With our expert facial services, you may moisturize, exfoliate, and nourish your skin. We also provide a range of massages that can help you ease chronic discomfort in your body.
There's No Heal Like Overheal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Good luck to the finalists!...in an hour, of course.
There's No Heal Like Overheal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Lots of great ideas were submitted, nice work everyone!
Inconsistently Consistent - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
First round of feedback. It's gonna be very subjective, given the nature of this comp, so keep that in mind.
My only suggestion is making it a Demon Hunter card. The flavor of treating your Demon like pets feels appropriate for a class named Demon HUNTER.
I'm not a fan of your other cards, though.