DestroyerR

Controversial Comment 

How about this one?

so you either get a slightly worse [card]Darkbomb[/card], or a free 3 damage attack which your opponent can play around. Do you prefer this or Xal’atath?

To clarify on how Xal’atath works: it’s NOT random. It’ll have the targetable spells glow in a purple aura, and you don’t get to drag the spell to …

Feedback (feel free to contest if you think it’s wrong):

[spoiler]

Nirast

[spoiler]

TH — -1 star for aesthetics (losing, not loosing. Also, the whole effect really should be written as something like “after you attack, destroy a friendly Treant to not lose Durability”), so 4/5

SotL — -1(?) star for idea (feels a little …

First idea: something that has nothing to do with the Durability, just to be quirky

(Xal’atath chooses = HS A.I.)

Feedback later hopefully 

Yay, finalist at last! Good luck everyone

BTW, since I don’t think anyone answered when I last asked, are people still doing the “rate 5 for one”/“rate 1 for rest” thing?

[card]Transfer Student[/card]?  

@ChickyChick Probably the theme... it’s too general 

Doing a Rager because that’s what this comp is really about (probably too cheap). Yes, the effect counts Mytim'orfn itself. Yes, it’s pronounced how you think it is.

EDIT: Actually, never mind, it doesn’t count itself. I’ll write “all other Elementals” in the final version 

Feedback later 

So are people still doing that thing where they vote 1 star on all non-favorites and 5 stars on the favorite?

Because I received a small amount of negative feedback and I’m a perfectionist, I did this. Which one should I submit?

@Wailor I meant it should be capitalized because every second clause in Choose One cards starts with a capitalized word (see [card]Rising Winds[/card])

Doing only spells since I feel like that’s the focus with both the old gods

Feedback (feel free to contest it if you think it’s wrong):

Wailor

[spoiler]

ES — -1 star for aesthetics (not really related to MDF), so 4/5

MW — -1 star for aesthetics (the “discard” on the second clause should …

Hmmmm... [card]Darkest Hour[/card]?

[card]Prince Malchezaar[/card]? 

EDIT: actually, no legendaries. Is it the felhunter token? 

N'Zoth, God of the Deep?

Awesome, thanks to sinti and anchorm4n!

Do the first two lines actually give a hint or are they just filler?

And uhh, [card]Doctor Morrigan[/card]?

@anchorm4n don’t actually stop lol, I want to earn my way back rightfully (also, someone actually read my bio FeelsGoodMan)

about the leaderboard, it looks fine on my end, but I’m on mobile so it might be different. Can you guys tell the mods what’s actually wrong so they can fix it? Thanks

@Live4vrRdieTryin you are in the …

[card]Zola the Gorgon[/card] then? And the leaderboard is in this thread’s OP