CC — 5/5. Creative effect and flavor and balanced pretty well, just an all around good entry

SV — 5/5. Solid card, creative effect, pretty neat

GP — 5/5. Flavor is on point with the rest of Rogue in DMF, I would personally change the name to something even more flavorful like “XXXL Plushie” or something (lul) but that’s about it

TPS — -1 star for balance (3 damage per card is a lot, I’d make it 2 damage and maybe up the cost to 3 if that’s too good), -1 star for aesthetics (cost, not costs), so 3/5

TCH — -1 star for aesthetics (art isn’t really hearthstoney, also I think a better wording would be replacing the “until end of turn” with “this turn”), so 4/5

welcome to the card-creating clown fiesta!

ST — -1 star for idea (just a slightly modified Kabal Crystal Runner, which isn’t too bad I guess but not really comp-winning), -1 star for aesthetics (pretty sure it’s supposed so be “each” instead of “every”), so 3/5.

Also, a few tips:

1) you can avoid the whole watermark thing by just putting a custom watermark, works wonders

2) cards normally look better when they don’t have “orphan” words (words that are alone in their line of text, like the “game” in your card). Generally speaking, the more uniform in size the lines are the better they look, so I’d do “Rush[enter]Costs (1) less for[enter]each Secret you've[enter]played this game.”

LS — -1 star for balance (a card with only one of those effects could be reasonably balanced, so both is a little overkill), so 4/

EF — -1 star for balance (not strong enough to justify no minions…), so 4/5

LF — -2 stars for idea (I dislike cards with too many things going on at once. Most cards should have one main focus on their effect, and “no cards in your deck” is already complex enough without the complexity of the actual reward), so 3/5

NC — -1 star for aesthetics (needs a token for the combined reward. BTW, what DOES happen when this is combined? Does it just summon two 5/5s with Rush and Taunt?), so 4/5

RA — 5/5. Pretty OP card, but you gotta be OP when there’s no other support for the archetype. Also, the wording is fine, or at the very least acceptable (see Death Coil)

LtF — -1 star for balance (sort of, because you could conceivably run this in a deck WITH minion, but… the whole point is to design something for NO minions, and I think it’s too weak then. Warrior is indeed very hard this comp), so 4/5

SoS — -1 star for aesthetics (I think the wording should be “Whenever you cast a spell with no minions in your deck, summon a random Demon” or something like that. Separate condition from effect. Also, minor nitpick, but for some reason the art having just no background bothers me), so 4/5

NML — 5/5. Maybe a tad weak on the no-minions part, but not really drastic

HtW — the card’s wording doesn’t work (restore 3 Health to who?), 1/5

LS — -1 star for balance (too weak RN, but I like the idea of designing a card for when you run out of minions instead of building around it. I think it should be 8 Mana “Destroy all minions. If you have no minions in your deck, destroy all enemy minions instead”), so 4/5

Mediate — (think you meant Meditate?) -1 star for balance (just too weak for the condition), -1 star for aesthetics (the text is barging to the card borders), so 3/5