StormKnightMelody

I don't like the art for Claws of the Dragon. It's perfectly fine in full view, but it shouldn't be spaced out such that you lose so much of the details in the splash image - like, you know, the …

Quote From grumpymonk

I made a secret for each class. I didn't look at any cards before I made these, except for the paladin one which I had to change from its original design.

…

Quote From grayghost39

Flavor text: "We're talking about practice. Not a game, practice" 

Are we talking about the minion that is being attacked, or the one doing the attacking? Because it currently reads as …

I spent more time deliberating on what to put in my deck than I did playing the game: I played a [card]Kobold Librarian[/card], got [card]Forked Lightning[/card], used it next turn, and the Rogue quit on me.

Quote From Lemushki

Always wanted to make a murloc based secret. Also first submission

Unfortunately, there is a lot going on here that's problematic. Grammatical errors, to start, namely the lack of a comma …

Quote From Conduit

New idea! Yes, I know there was an Arena card called Smoke Bomb, but this was the best name I had at the time lmao.

[card]Evasion[/card] already exists, and does basically …

I pulled [card]Waxadred[/card] from within the first ten packs of the YoD set, so hopefully that means yes.

Quote From NekroDan

This is also my first submission ever on here. Thanks for looking!

Welcome to our little side of things :D We'd love to see more new faces in the Discussion thread <3

Thank you to everyone who provided me some feedback; I know I didn't leave it open for long before I submitted. Anyway, here's some feedback for those who have not submitted (at time of writing):

[spoiler]

Xarkkal - …

Quote From KANSAS

Here are two secrets, and one more I made for this competition. Let me know what you think.

Retaliating Flame is scary, but at the same time it might be okay. …

Quote From Devizz

Can I somehow remove my submission? 

Unfortunately no, we do not allow people to edit or remove their cards after submitting :( We always suggest people come here first if they want …

Quote From Devizz

Your card breaks an unspoken rule of Hearthstone in-that no card should have text longer than four lines. Any such card would be considered too complicated for the game, and this is …

Quote From Devizz

Wow, thanks. Can I post my suggestions for a theme in this thread or should I PM them?

If you could PM ShadowsOfSense or myself, that would be preferable :)

Quote From Pokeniner

Review to your cards @linkblade91

Thanks for giving them a look :) I think Counter Strike translates the best out of the three, in terms of being able to pull it out …

I created various Secrets for my custom expansion; maybe I can get away with one here:

• Counter Strike helps a minion "punch up" against a stronger enemy, or to seriously punish the opposing hero for attacking with …

Congratulations Devizz! You swooped in late for the victory haha :D

Good luck to the finalists!

Veteran Investigator says "ALL players", not "BOTH players". Could this mean we'll be seeing a game-mode with more than two players? ;D

You are changing the Silver Hand Recruit from being summoned to being played, meaning he would now trigger things like [card]Mirror Entity[/card], [card]Snipe[/card], and [card]Swamp King Dred[/card]. These aren't exactly popular cards, but it does matter. Not sure I like …

Some additional feedback:

[spoiler]

Menacing Bagel - I'm not a fan of this card; although the idea is interesting, I don't think it would be playable in practice. A super high-Health Taunt is still susceptible to things like …