Feedback

So i am new here. I got an idea for this site. I like the site. I really like the art of the cards. I could not find a site with every art of all the cards in hearhstone. Imagine having a page in the site, with every artwork of every card. I don't think this is a must, but i think it would be really cool, when you have time, just to enjoy the art of the cards, Blizzard put so much effort in. This is just a suggestion. I want to hear some opinions on the idea. Sorry for my grammar and etc.

Okay, I'm just gonna come out and say this again, even if it didn't go over well the last time.

The mascot is a bad idea.

I personally don't like it because it doesn't seem to have any relation to Hearthstone, and it harkens back to an era of poorly executed memes, 12-year-olds obsessing over nyan cat, the fact that newgrounds existed, and numa numa (had to pause to remember that). When I see it, I think that this must be a My Little Pony fan forum, not one for a World of Warcraft based Blizzard card game. Not only that, it is white on a black background and isn't used apart from in the front page and on default profiles (as far as I can see). Honestly it would be much better to not have a mascot but to have a more identifiable logo or brand identity with a singular image or letter.

I know whoever put effort into the mascot put a lot of time and love into it, but I'm giving my feedback as I see it so it's up to you to listen or dismiss it. I don't think I can stand it however if it gets used any more than it already is being used.

Hi again,

Please make it so that the title of a forum thread is grayed out after one has read it. makes it easier to navigate to new threads etc. 

Hi,

First to say that the site looks great. Quite excited to see it with all the features once you are done with them.

Now, in the New Expansion page, it would be great to see the rarity of the not yet revealed cards. Maybe add a tint of the rarity colour to the gray unrevealed cards or something?

As a Main-Wild player it is fairly annoying to go through 100 decks before a new wild deck is listed.. 

This basic filter was mainly the reason for me to use Hearthpwn over other similar pages.

Other than that i would like to emphasize that I think this site looks good and has great potential :) 

When trying to upload a picture from your computer (eg your Desktop), it feels hard. The "insert image" has no Browse button, but a source. Think that is used for URLS?

everyone on this site looks like a unicorn with pink hair. dont get me wrong, I have nothing against unicorns, but I would like to change my avatar, and I think some other people would too. but as far as I know, there is no way to do that. anyone know anything about that?

I would like the ability to upload an Avatar like I had on Hearthpwn.

Sure, it's not the biggest deal, but if this site is bringing people from HeartPwn, can we get our accounts copied or transfered? Would be really cool. 

Are there any plans to implement "Latest thread" next to a subforum heading? Or is that something that's just not being done?

I think a search function would greatly improve the Deckbuilder. For instance, if I were to make a dragon deck, I would search for 'Dragon' to quickly filter what cards synergize with dragons, and not only get cards of the dragon tribe, but also cards with 'Dragon' in their text, e.g. Firetree Witchdoctor.

I realised that there is no mana costs while I'm trying to build a deck and also it doesn't sort cards in mana cost order. It could be good if builder automatically sorts the cards in mana cost order.

and while I am searching my own deck in all the decks I have also realised that I can't click updated tab which could lead me most updated decks. I can't also sort them for names / archetypes / types / costs / scores .

I know you are hardworking on the site and already doing well. I just wanted to point what is missing so don't take this wrong. :)

It could be nice to redirect on the home page or somewhere when we log in, because sometimes I got confused like "did i wrote a bad password? Ho no, i'm logged but it do not redirect me so i'm still on the loggin page" 

Hi HearthStation team,

I like the site so far...congrats.  Are there any plans to have a personal collection manager?  For me, I don't care so much about the manager itself (scrolling through cards, filtering, etc...I use Hearthstone itself for that), but I love being able to see which cards I'm missing when viewing decks.  Hearthpwn of course has this via Innkeeper, and HSReplay via the decktracker.  I only used Innkeeper for the syncing feature, not in-game.  So, having some sort of syncing feature would be great (I realize that is not trivial).

Cheers...

Just wanted to add a note about the new cards released articles.  It would be a nice feature to have the rarity colors on the new cards being released article.  

Also to have the Legendary cards at the start of each section and not the end.  

Just minor things to point out.  :) 

Cheers!

I was just noticing that flipping pages of comments takes you all the way to the top of the Article.  This is a little frustrating in articles as big as Rise of Shadows where you have to scroll all the way back down again through about 5 pages of cards and news just to read the next page of comments.  

I'm a comment reader :) 

I'd like it to put you at the top of the comment section when you flip pages.  (Hearthpwn does this).  

Cheers!

Hello fellow moderators.

Firstly I have loved the concept of the site. Darker theme feels better than brighter one for me. Thanks for deciding to make it like that.

I would ask a question about deckbuilder.

I have no clue about web coding so I would ask is that possible to copy a deck from hearthstone and paste it to the deckbuilder for building the deck quicker.

I mean, i am asking the vice-versa of the Hearthstone deck string content.

If it is possible, it may be a good addition to deckbuilder.

Thanks for your adorable work !

Two things:

1) I think replies are not enough obvious, when I see comments and replies, I didn't even notices there were replies. The space is maybe not big enough or maybe we need some color change I don't know, but it's not obvious enough I thing.

2) This black color background. I'm light sensitive (headache, retinal migraine, etc) I have trouble to read since the combinaison of this dark black and flashy white are "hurting me". I don't have big health trouble, just it's unconfortable and I can't read too long withtout having the text "printed" on my eyes (need some secondes to desapear). I think you may take example on discord black theme, it doesnt hurt me at all and it's grey and white like here ! As a big company I guess they studied that case :P (sorry for beeing weak and having trouble with that^^)

I've been going to the Fan Creation forum on HearthPwn just about daily for years now. It's easily the best part of the website in my opinion, and pretty much the only reason I stay on, as well as card reveal season.

One of the most disappointing things about HearthPwn was that there wasn't very much emphasis put on the fan creation community. News articles regarding the fan community or their competitions never received much attention. Not everyone is interested in creating cards, I get it, but I think it's still possible to do something about it. I have some proposals.

Over here, Sylicas made his/her own column called "Archivist's Lore", where he/she brings up some cards and talks about how they relate (or don't) to WoW lore. It's a really nice read. One proposal I had was to have something like this called "Fan Community Spotlight" or something like that, name is subject to change. In this column, we look at a custom class or card set that someone has made, interview that person and talk about the process of creating the set. Anybody could choose to run it if they want to, doesn't have to be me. Doesn't have to be run on any sort of basis either.

Over here, I also made a guide on creating a Basic set for a custom class, which I copied over from HearthPwn where I also posted it there.

The card search should run the option "neutral" in the class filter imho.