Feedback

Don't know where or how, but title says it all. This game is really good, it would attract more community members, should this topic/game be sticked. Maybe a trivial request, but a nice one nonetheless.

While using the mobile version of the site - the side menu is of course a necessity. Problem is, at least for my Android phone, that when you expand one of the menus into its sub-menus, causing the menu to collapse back requires you to hit the main "side menu" button. This may seem like a personal inconvenience but it was very unintuitive for me, and I'm sure to many others as well.

Personally, I think adding the option of closing the sub-menus back by clicking the little arrow thing (or just adding a small button next to the text instead) would be great.

P.S. Love what you are doing with the site! keep up the amazing work!!!  

I've noticed that Replies are indented a bit, but between the small indent and the site's color scheme, it's very difficult to tell at a glance that a given post is a reply. I think it would scan better if the indent were increased on Replies, or possibly give them a slightly different background color/border -- just something, so that it's easier to tell just by looking at a post that it's a Reply rather than an independent post.

Hey there! First post here, dragged here from hearthpwn.

Love to see the idea, the progress and the milestone you guys set ahead.

But among the things that you plan to do, i did not see the Legendary crafitng tier list sticky post, and that's a bummer for me.

I think would be useful, and should be improved as a single page on the main  menu with a lot of content more (statistic, grading, main interaction in standard or wild...)

How many decks -among each tier- use that legendary?

How the users scored it? Will it be useful in the future?

What you guys think about?

Is this something you will implement? I usually like to have my decks private because they are shitty, and more functions as a tool for keeping track of my decks.

Presently in the card search function, the "expansion" filter works differently from the others: it's not a drop-down list with a scroll bar, rather, it's just a teeny tiny scroll bar that can only display three options at a time. Furthermore, there doesn't seem to be a "null" option, so once you've selected an expansion, and you want to search for cards from multiple expansions, or you're not sure of the expansion, you have to reload the search tool.

I don't really see a reason for that filter to work differently from the others, which are much more convenient.

Hey, OutOfCards!

Post previews in all modes (thread creation and post creation/editing) would be highly appreciated.

Great Job on the site, and thanks in advance!

Writing to suggest that the Decks and Card pages have a more robust filtering process, I'm guessing it's "on the list" but wanted to offer suggestions.

Having filter values of "unknown" as default values is bad design, IMO.  Don't think you should have "unknown" as a choice at all.

Same with the Archetypes, none or blank instead of "unknown".  Also who defines the archetypes? Is it a self assigned thing? Do people pick from a list or do they just make it up on the fly?

It would be nice if it was possible to sort decks like "the site that will not be named" does by "Hot", "New", "Top-Week", "Top-month", "Top-all-time".

Cards don't have the ability to search by minion effects (deathrattle, battlecry, etc).

Will we have the ability to view the cards in a list (as it currently is) or as images?

Do you have a list or schedule of all of the up and coming changes on the radar?

Thanks for all of the work you do on this site!

Hello!

I tried to look around in this feedback forum section for similar requests, but couldn't really find one.

Under the "Cards" section, I was wondering if it's possible to implement (in the near future) a thumbnail image view for all cards at a glance (for all classes, all cards, etc.), rather than full texts. Similar to the Deckbuilder layout, but we could filter and refine based on what we want to see in order to brainstorm and build new decks.

Perhaps we can limit the number of cards loaded per page on the search results, to prevent from loading too slow. And perhaps could set like 20, 50, 100 cards view options.

Thanks!

I noticed a table on the forums that was completely unreadable on mobile. It was 6 columns wide, and for some reason it would set the width of the table to 100% and put all the words vertically.

https://imgur.com/a/uxE1N4e

Title says it all, but I will explain it for better understanding: Wild players create Odd/Even decks. On Hearthpwn, we can filter cost of cards as Odd/Even. So, why not here?

Now this one really needs attention because it helps people to build their deck conveniently. On Hearthpwn, we can preview a card when we hover over a card, as seen in the picture (Yellow: Mouse cursor, screenshot didn't bring it out):

Whereas, on OutofCards, it's not possible, seen here (Yellow: Mouse cursor):

Hope it's possible to bring both features here, especially Thumbnail one, because it can be quite annoying when you forgot a card's ability and you need to search from pictures to find it. With thumbnail, all we need to do is hover over a card's name and that's it.

P.S: I want this thread deleted, if possible. It was the same thread opened about a week ago.

I was wondering if anyone knows how to download a cards artwork with the golden animation and make it into a profile picture here on OOC, preferably without/or cropped from the cards surrounding frame.

Thanks!

- Paragon

Hi, just a simple question, will we be able to merge our old hearthpwn accounts with the new ones in this forum? I am mainly thinking about the achievements and titles I got there :D

Is there any problem advertising a stream and/or youtube channel in signatures?

Assuming the answer to the above question is no, is there a specific problem with advertising an addiction recovery channel?  Subject matter would be solidly in the PG to PG-13 area, but I realize some see it as a touchy subject.

Couldn't think of a better spot to ask this question.  Thanks for your time.

Hello there!

As you know, the specialist format allows players to have similar decks with only 5 different cards. I was wondering if it would be possible (or even a good idea?) to have the possibility to create "versions" of a deck.

The idea is simple : on a deck page, you have the main list, with explanation on the left side, and maybe it would be a good idea to have "delta lists" (probably under the main deck, on the right side), where you just have the few cards that can be changed (with -1/-2 and +1/+2 next to them) plus a title above them, "Against Warrior", "More aggressive", "lowcost", you get the idea.

The cherry on the cake would be to be able to copy the deck code of alternative decklists.

Love the site so far!

Hi team, I don't know how to call this exactly, but what I mean is when you are clicking vote buttons (green/up or red/down), the button to somehow change color or shading or whatever, in order for you to know you have already clicked it. Right now there's no visible way to tell if you've already voted a deck or a comment. 

It's not a critical thing, but it'd be great for my OCD :D 

I hope this isn't just me - but the biggest reason I kept coming back to Hearthpwn was definitely the Card Creation Competitions. Are you guys planning to have those again? I could even help out, if you need. I loved those!

Hey you clever bunch, great work on the site so far and also thank you, i am one of many who very much appreciate your hard work.

I wondered wether or not it might be a neat idea to include a search button under the forum section of the drop down menu tab? This might encourage users to actually search the Forums for pre existing threads rather than create duplicate discussions.

Much love,

Jody

Hello!

I see there isn't one available currently, but I believe it'd be great to have forum specific search features, a good example would be in this forum area to be able to search for specific ideas already mentioned so we don't suggest the same ones over and over :)

Thank you!

tl;dr: 1. Omit needless words from the top of all pages keeping username and add our avatars. 2. Take the information from number one and add that to member page along with a button that shows a list of our posts. 3. Add filter to find decks that use a given card (Hearthpwn's "Contains". 4. Celebrate artists of card art. 5. Is Gamepedia's website going to stop? (sister website of Hearthpwn).

• Tell us what you love about the site.
• I recently visited the card page for Deathwing, Dragonlord and I noticed that on the top of the page there was a banner for Whispers of the Old Gods. It was so well done that I kind of overlooked it. So I started looking at other cards and even Wilfred Fizzlebang has a banner celebrating the card set where this card came from. I wanted to say that design choice looks really nice.
• I love that you provide the font choice Helvetica.
• I love how the moderators respawn super quickly. It feels like a small community even though I am pretty sure this site is growing in popularity.

• Give us details on the things you hate.
• I can't change the text color back to the original/default color using the text color options
  • This is the original color. This is white. This is gray. This is medium gray. I can't customize the color nor do I really care.
  • I hate that I can't really keep track of my posts. I think there should be a link to my posts on my member's page just like there is a threads box.
  • The very top heading looks awkward: Hey, ArcticFox! [Profile] [Manage] Sign Out]
    • I like where it says my name but that's it. If you want to keep the "Hey," so be it but the rest is awkward and probably should be revisited in the future. "Profile" is [bad] redundancy.  "Profile" and "Manage" should not be the third word on every page on this website. It simply is not that important. So if you hid those two options the top of the page would read "Hey, ArcticFox Sign Out" and perhaps some people might feel that I should sign out (Kappa) but that probably is not the best heading for this website which is why "Sign Out" should be hidden as well. It is nice to see my avatar which I selected and I think it should appear to the left or above my username.
• Think you have an idea to make something better? Tell us!
  • Box up the headings "Out of Cards Beta," "Decks," "Cards," "Deckbuilder," "Expansions," "Guides," "Forums" and use some kind of image or icon. It would reinforce the idea that the user can click directly on them.
• Provide us with new ideas that you'd like to see us implement to make HearthStation even better.
  • I would like to Filter your list of decks by cards or "Contains." When I get a new legendary card I will want to search up the best decks that include that card and a search option similar to Hearthpwn would be appreciated. I only know that there is not a single deck that uses Wilfred Fizzlebang because I visited the card page and the "Top Decks" section was completely missing. 
  • Celebrate Artists of Cards:
    • Provide the name of the artist of each card in their respected card home page. This might be easier while Hearthpwn is still up. I wouldn't have known that Alex Horley did the art for Deathwing, Dragonlord had hearthpwn not included that information.
    • Have an artist area similiar to https://hearthstone.gamepedia.com/Alex_Horley#Credits_and_debug_cards
      • On a side note is Gamepedia stopping their services too as their Hearthstone section is called Hearthpwn? If they are closing shop there might be a lot of useful information that will be leaving the internet. Information like when certain expansions were released to help with my own personal predictions of future expansions.