Terrible in a vacuum, but they are pushing the self-damage deck pretty hard. I give it an eventual 4 stars because I'm guessing they will buff the archetype if it doesn't do well at first.
Meh .... even tough this could draw you 3 cards and gives you a little insight on your opponents deck i still think this is to weak. There are better tools to draw.
This is the most important Hearthstone card ever printed. From this point on, it's all mind games and chicanery. It's an undeniable 5 stars because it will drastically redefine the meta until it rotates out.
After playing a few games, I found that the second copy of Sigil of Silence wasn't very useful: on the combo turn, you can play only one of them and their most useful property is that they cost 0 mana when top-decked late. Maybe it's useful during the game if you run into a lot of Mine Rogue, but I only played a Thief Rogue and a Pirate Rogue.
The second copy of Tuskpiercer wasn't very useful either, since you typically have already drawn both Mailbox Dancers by the time you have used up both weapons and there are no other Deathrattles in the deck. I considered putting in Persistent Peddler, but as this deck cares more about the stage 1 and 2 discounts of the questline than about actually completing it, I don't think trading Peddler is as useful here as in the typical DH questline deck. Also it would weaken the tutor effect.
I replaced one duplicate with Sigil of Summoning, as the extra minions fuel card draw via Feast of Souls, can slow the opponent or can be playable on the combo turn if discounted to 1 or even 0 mana. The other duplicate I replaced with Eye Beam, as you can easily maneuver that into outcast position on the combo turn and you can use it to reduce the number of S'theno strikes that go into minions. I'm not certain these are the best replacements, but they were more useful than the second copies of the cards they replaced.
Love this for my Deathrattle Druid. Also could be cheated out cheap with Sesselie of the Fae Court. Or if you have the Druid Location in play you can activate this instantly after playing it.
Meh .... seems to weak for me. You can play it - hope it survives - play another card to get a class card - hope the card you get is good or you have a copy of a garbage card in hand ....
Meh .... first i thought it is a decent support for my Deathrattle Druid but it still seems to weak .... i mean if you run only a few deathrattles and all of them are at least decent then the payoff is ok but not sure. I will sureley try this to see how it performs but im also pretty sure i will remove the card pretty early from my list :)
10/10 card, go fuck yourself Kazakusan and Prestor, go be degenerates somewhere else.
100% putting this into every deck just out of spite (also kills Quest Priest lmao)
Enjoy tanking your win rates across the board. It's a terrible card against any opponent not using those strategies. The current strongest decks will NOT continue to be on top or even popular, and it's got nothing to do with this 2-star card.
New Warrior Minion - Anima Extractor
It's an OK addition to the self-damage package. You can set up some pretty swingy trade-in scenarios, but not reliably, so I give it 3 stars.
New Shaman Minion - Gigantotem
I love it! Always loved Totem Shaman and even if the archetype isn't gonna be that strong im still gonna have fun with it :)
Also this could be cheated out pretty early.
New Warrior Weapon - Imbued Axe
Terrible in a vacuum, but they are pushing the self-damage deck pretty hard. I give it an eventual 4 stars because I'm guessing they will buff the archetype if it doesn't do well at first.
New Shaman Minion - Crud Caretaker
Ok card for evolve - nothing else!
New Warrior Spell - Riot!
For 2 Mana this seems pretty crazy! Also is gonna be decent for the "Damaged Minion" Warrior - but overall seems pretty good!
New Warrior Spell - Conqueror's Banner
"Big" enabler, but too reliant on luck, so 1 star. Any Warrior deck can find much better draw tools.
New Warrior Spell - Conqueror's Banner
Meh .... even tough this could draw you 3 cards and gives you a little insight on your opponents deck i still think this is to weak. There are better tools to draw.
New Warrior Minion - Anima Extractor
Interesting card - some on is gonna make an OTK with this and the other minion that gets charge when damaged :)
New Neutral Minion - Theotar, the Mad Duke
This is the most important Hearthstone card ever printed. From this point on, it's all mind games and chicanery. It's an undeniable 5 stars because it will drastically redefine the meta until it rotates out.
New Warrior Minion - Crazed Wretch
Good card even tough im not feeling this "Damaged Minion" Theme for Warrior ...
S'theno OTK - Temporus Shift
I really like the idea of this deck.
After playing a few games, I found that the second copy of Sigil of Silence wasn't very useful: on the combo turn, you can play only one of them and their most useful property is that they cost 0 mana when top-decked late. Maybe it's useful during the game if you run into a lot of Mine Rogue, but I only played a Thief Rogue and a Pirate Rogue.
The second copy of Tuskpiercer wasn't very useful either, since you typically have already drawn both Mailbox Dancers by the time you have used up both weapons and there are no other Deathrattles in the deck. I considered putting in Persistent Peddler, but as this deck cares more about the stage 1 and 2 discounts of the questline than about actually completing it, I don't think trading Peddler is as useful here as in the typical DH questline deck. Also it would weaken the tutor effect.
I replaced one duplicate with Sigil of Summoning, as the extra minions fuel card draw via Feast of Souls, can slow the opponent or can be playable on the combo turn if discounted to 1 or even 0 mana. The other duplicate I replaced with Eye Beam, as you can easily maneuver that into outcast position on the combo turn and you can use it to reduce the number of S'theno strikes that go into minions. I'm not certain these are the best replacements, but they were more useful than the second copies of the cards they replaced.
New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn General
Love this for my Deathrattle Druid. Also could be cheated out cheap with Sesselie of the Fae Court. Or if you have the Druid Location in play you can activate this instantly after playing it.
Pretty good!
New Neutral Minion - Ashen Elemental
Possibly amazing in Wild, but possibly the worst card in the set in Standard. Will not see play -- 1 star.
New Neutral Minion - Invitation Courier
Meh .... seems to weak for me. You can play it - hope it survives - play another card to get a class card - hope the card you get is good or you have a copy of a garbage card in hand ....
New Neutral Minion - Crooked Cook
Aggro / Zoo-ish decks will love this because they usualy run out of steam pretty fast and this helps to keep up.
New Neutral Minion - Steamcleaner
Oh i didn't even think about those two ..... so i guess a 5 Mana Mech completely destroys Kazakusan and Prestor :)
But on it's own the card itself seems pretty weak ....
New Neutral Minion - Crooked Cook
Aggro's dream come true. I give it 5 stars as one of the strongest neutral aggro tools we've seen in some time.
New Neutral Minion - Invitation Courier
Limited application in a very niche deck -- 1 star.
New Neutral Minion - Masked Reveler
Meh .... first i thought it is a decent support for my Deathrattle Druid but it still seems to weak .... i mean if you run only a few deathrattles and all of them are at least decent then the payoff is ok but not sure. I will sureley try this to see how it performs but im also pretty sure i will remove the card pretty early from my list :)
New Neutral Minion - Steamcleaner
Enjoy tanking your win rates across the board. It's a terrible card against any opponent not using those strategies. The current strongest decks will NOT continue to be on top or even popular, and it's got nothing to do with this 2-star card.
New Neutral Minion - Muck Plumber
I like the idea behind this card but because it is 5 Mana i guess it is to slow???
Well, Mojomaster Zihi was 6 Mana and saw play because it was disruptive so i guess this isn't that bad ? .... not sure tough :)
New Neutral Minion - Scuttlebutt Ghoul
Nice defensive tool for Secret Decks. 4 Mana for 4/10 stats in total seems pretty good.
New Neutral Minion - Dinner Performer
Could be decent for evolve decks or maybe aggro.
New Neutral Minion - Creepy Painting
Seems pretty meh but could work for Deathrattle .... maybe some other Big Minion shenanigans ? not sure tough ...
New Neutral Minion - Roosting Gargoyle
If a good Beast Deck will emerge this expansion this could see play but on it's own it seems pretty useless / bad.