All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Hearthstone Designers Cora Georgiou and Leo Robles Clarify How Rogue's Kidnap Secret Works

    Quote From davidwizard

    Their job isn't to communicate clearly - their job is to create a fun experience.

     

    That's an utterly bizarre formulation. Clear communication  makes for a fun experience.  Board games have been made sources of acrimony because of ambiguity. There are several decades of imperfect experiences due to poor writing in games -- you can check a D&D forum or M:tG forum right now and find that out, instantly. Clarity in language is like clear pricing or good art -- just another element of making a good experience. Declaring them opposites is like saying good health is the opposite of a fun vacation.

    It doesn't for you, because I guess you dislike doing research or testing something to see how it works?

    What? I have no idea where you're coming from, like, at all, or how you got there from what I wrote. First of, experimentation doesn't solve all information problems and sometimes cannot solve them and isn't truly possible. Second, poor communication can interfere with otherwise really good games where both players are having fun engaging with known rules. By your logic, bugs are good because they're unexpected and can be experimented with. I literally pointed out that many people were concerned about communication since beta, including concerned about even cards like Ysera, and impressed with cards like the modern hero cards. How would your anti-experimentation thesis apply to the multitudes who were thereby concerned? I'm just really confused by that.

    The fact that other people are pedantic about Ysera doesn't mean they're RIGHT about it…

    What are you on about? No one's being pedantic about Ysera. This is a communication issue that even Ben Brode admitted was a problem! Y'know, the original lead designer? They were toying with solutions for years on this. The term "pedantry" doesn't even make sense in this context. No one is fighting over mere word choice here, but discussing forseeable behaviors in complex game states. Pedantry just seems like an inflammatory thowaway term.

    just that they want the game to be as boring as you do.

    Oh. It was inflammatory because you were doing your best to be mean-spirited and uncivil.

    You're entitled to your opinion

    You don't believe that, otherwise you wouldn't have lashed out because we had a difference of opinion. It's clear you didn't want to read what I wrote and became upset. Just keep in mind that just because people have a different experience from you doesn't mean they're attacking you. Hopefully you have a better day.

  • What Is Marvel Snap's Nexus Event and Why Do Players Hate It?

    And my interest for this game has completely gone away. I already thought it looked bad but the overpriced microtransactions in a beta has sealed the deal for me.

  • What Is Marvel Snap's Nexus Event and Why Do Players Hate It?

    Brode is getting a lot of flak for being greedy, but I think he might just be clueless. Or more specifically, he doesn't have a good handle on what players want from progression. He seems to have this idea that a lot of players will be happy just playing the game, progressing slowly, and having no way to get specific cards. That might have been true for a casual Magic player in the 90s, but today players NEED to have a way to get the specific card they want. It seems like if he wanted to shake everyone down for money, he could charge a lot more to let people open packs and get other cards specifically.

    When you can pay to get certain cards early (through the monthly pass and these Nexus Events), his belief seems to be that since it's just a couple cards, it's no big deal. If you want to pay for it, that's great, but if you don't, it will be available through the normal progression system in a couple months. That's not at all how other people see it, though.

    So what the game needs is a way to pay a moderate amount of money to get specific cards you want. Right now, the F2P system misses the mark in one way (no control), and the paid system misses the mark in another way (way too expensive, while still not having much control). Again, I don't think it's just greed, because it seems like they left a lot of money on the table by not giving you ways to get more control over your collection. The question is whether they can course correct. At least it's still in beta, but on the other hand, this requires a pretty big change.

  • Hearthstone Designers Cora Georgiou and Leo Robles Clarify How Rogue's Kidnap Secret Works

    Their job isn't to communicate clearly - their job is to create a fun experience. This card does that for me, so it's a huge success. It doesn't for you, because I guess you dislike doing research or testing something to see how it works? Good for you, I guess? But I'd find Hearthstone a lot more boring if they had to spell out every single detail of every card. The fact that other people are pedantic about Ysera doesn't mean they're RIGHT about it... just that they want the game to be as boring as you do.

    You're entitled to your opinion, but you certainly haven't convinced me that there's a single benefit to what you're asking for.

  • Out of Cards Changelog - 2022-07-04

    For anybody like me that didn't notice their RSS feed had broken two weeks ago.

    The old feeds (now returns 500) were at:

    https://outof.cards/hearthstone/hearthstone.rss

    The new feeds are available at:

    https://outof.cards/hearthstone.rss

    Not sure if it was intentional to not leave a redirect here (maybe that was the "Removed references to RSS feeds in places where we don't support RSS feeds"). I am not sure how well RSS readers follow 301/302. Thanks anyway for continuing to support RSS!

     

  • Just My Card Type - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    More Feedback

    adamsleungcn
    I think the Boom Sugars are really cool and the minion and hero versions of the Boomship would be good cards on their own, but I think the three versions together become a little too complex.

    The location version feels a little forced because it suddenly uses the Boom Bots' effect instead of the Boom Sugars' and its requirement seems pretty difficult to achieve because it's very reliant on RNG.

    There's also some technical issues: The Boomship already exists. There shouldn't be two cards with the same name/art. So you should probably find some new art. You're also misunderstanding the Colossal keyword. The limbs should be attached to the main body. The Boom Sugars aren't: they are separate minions.

    Overal I think the minion and hero are quite strong, since you only have to pay once. And I know I'm being quite harsh here, but I don't really see why this specific card is an infinite loop. It has so much going on already.

    DoctorDoom
    I do think the cards should transform for this comp. I also don't really see the point in the location. It's just an extra requirement to get the spell, but the location doesn't do anything else and is very inconsistent with the rest. I also don't understand why the location and weapon have more than 1 Durability. 1 Durability would give the exact same result and would make the text simpler.

    I know it's cool to use as many card types as possible, but it's incredibly difficult to make that work. The growth effect you're going for is pretty interesting, but I recommend to keep the Health/Durability at 1 and use the phrasing "Transform into a Particle (insert next stage here) with permanent +1 Attack." (or +1 damage). That way the growth aspect is far clearer and it changes the text so it transforms like you suggested. Of course, the location wouldn't fit in with this, so you'd either need to remove it or give it a damaging effect.

    I still think it's a little complex, mainly because not everything is consistent, but this could be a pretty cool card with the right changes.

    EDIT: Something I missed earlier is that all the cards should probably return to your hand after transforming. First of all because infinite card generation is quite valuable and the powerful spell would be worth it. But also because the fact that only the spell does so is again inconsistent with the rest of the chain. These inconsistencies make this card a bit confusing for someone who briefly reads over it.

    Daowen
    I'm afraid this doesn't count. You're transforming a minion card into another minion card. I think you're confusing card types with minion types. We're looking for minions, spells, weapons, locations and hero cards.

    Now for the card itself (because feedback is always valuable for learning card creation): Flavorwise, I don't really get why a butterfly would transform into a totem that depicts a bird-dragon-ish creature.

    Also, as far as balance goes, the Totem probably shouldn't have any attack. First of all because most Totems don't and also because your card is very strong. Even at 0 Attack I still think this would be a pretty impactful card.

  • New Neutral Minion - Anonymous Informant

    Auto-include for all secret decks. Any card that allows you to cheat something for 0-mana is already good, and this comes with solid 2/3 stats for a 2-drop on top of it. Great for tempo on turn 2. 

  • All Card Flavor Text for the Murder at Castle Nathria Hearthstone Expansion

    I like Riot! and Wild Standard Spirits

    Edit: and Vengeful Visage.

  • Just My Card Type - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    edit: deleted after feedback. Indeed misinterpretated...let's keep it to it was still early....yawn..

    Hmm, 2nd try in this whole card creation. Hopefully I understood the conditions right. If not please let me know.

  • Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks to Play This Week - Miracle Elise, Burn Shaman & More

    Hello there! Yeah, looking forward to Zeddy's announcement.

  • Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks to Play This Week - Miracle Elise, Burn Shaman & More

    Great to see these back! Hoping for an exciting new meta with the new expansion and coming update, whatever that ends up being!

  • Crud Caretaker

    Does someone know how much the totem costs? Might be good for evolving, I guess?

  • Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks to Play This Week - Miracle Elise, Burn Shaman & More

    I know you like these - sorry for the long waiting, Goliath.

  • Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks to Play This Week - Miracle Elise, Burn Shaman & More

    You're welcome ;)

  • New Neutral Minion - Stoneborn Accuser

    I'm a sucker for consistency, so 5 stars...

    Show Spoiler
    But actually the minion is pretty weak and probably won't see play but might pop up in some high aggro deck like DH.

  • Just My Card Type - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    My idea is 4 different card types that go up in stats as they switch. Minion dies switches to weapon gains +1/1 of every stat including mana. Though the only one you have to pay mana for after the 1/1 is the Particle Blast. It keeps going until it hits 10.

     

    I guess this isn't really within the rules I will have to change the text to transform instead. 

  • What Is Marvel Snap's Nexus Event and Why Do Players Hate It?

    seems ben brode leaving blizzard and hearthstone has been very good for the game and its economy, bye bye ben stay with your mobile game we won't miss you

  • What Is Marvel Snap's Nexus Event and Why Do Players Hate It?

    I haven’t gotten access yet but that’s a big red flag right here. 
    At this point, the HS economy looks amazing even though it’s still the cost of 2-3 AAA titles a year. 

    A nexus event could have been a cool, story driven event that rewards you with one of two cards. If they charge the second one, so be it. But that’s just a limited time “promo”.

    Also, did anyone realize that the pity timer kicks in before you actually hit the drop rate of the card? So you can’t reasonably expect anything else than 50 opens for a card

  • New Neutral Minion - Sinstone Totem

    Utterly useless even to totem shaman.

    That 0 attack hiders this so badly its not even a joke. Without something like Totemic Reflections, what is this card aiming to accomplish even if its a 0/10?

    The only good thing here is that its a totem, and the fact that in totem shaman your opponent will instinctively kill it with everything they've got regardless of its actual nonexistent threat level.

    Of course, you can play it in other classes, and paladin has plenty of buffs. But will you play a minion that will only do something useful after a buff? Unless youre shaman, the answer will likely always be no.

     

    Makes me think that its printed solely to gum up Amalgam of the Deep's totem discovers, so youre not playing 4x Gigantotem by default.

  • New Neutral Minion - Dredger Staff

    Maybe good enough because aggro decks would play any vanilla 1 drop that boost survivability.

    Not much else to say really. Its competing with Beaming Sidekick, but nevertheless possess a niche on its own.

  • New Neutral Minion - Roosting Gargoyle

    The kind of card you design when youre running on a deadline.

    There's no reason to ever expect this to see any play outside of arena. I dont understand why they didn't just make it a bigger Abusive Sergeant. Would have at least been viable instead of being completely crap.

  • New Neutral Minion - Anonymous Informant

    The card that needed to be printed for any form of secret decks to see play. Particularly to mage, because the loss of Kirin Tor Mage practically doomed any secret related deck from existing. Even the mighty explosive runes is tamed by its absence.

    And now we have something potentially better, because the effect stays on until a secret is played.

    Will see play because why not?

  • Get a Free Legendary Hearthstone Card From Prime Gaming for July 2022

    You're correct - this is the 4th. There's a scroll bar on the Prime Gaming > Hearthstone page which is hard to see but it shows the 3rd legendary they gave us which is to the right of the Beach bundle.

  • New Neutral Minion - Creepy Painting

    The description reads 'a copy' which implies that it wont be a 0/6 minion when it transforms.

    In other words, its 3 mana faceless as long as you can kill the target. Imagine getting a colossal minion out of this, its just nuts.

  • New Neutral Minion - Dinner Performer

    Its basically Skydiving Instructor most of the time, with the potential to be better but in reality would never reach that high bar.

    Most good minions tend to be battlecry minions, and this invalidates it. Plus, its 3 mana. Which means, its pulling something that's minus 3 to your current total mana cost. Not even druid needs shit like this.