Seems like to me you're only thinking in the worst-case scenario.
Since my opening was about the worst-case draw scenario, one likely to come up slightly less than 50% of the time, that's correct, but I don't think that means what you think it means.
To reiterate, the point is that the draw-plus-body engine alone doesn't do anything and it can't be slotted into any presently-known DH deck in standard to improve or keep it at parity. It almost-but-not-quite could fit into a DH weenie deck, but that deck is bad right now and its lategame isn't really strong enough to get anything done.
Which was my overall point. If you're not winning the game, drawing cards and making many small minions is meaningless. If the DH card pool had different cards in it than it does at present, there'd be, for example, possible OTKs available as lategame finishers. And if even one of those is revealed, the value of these cards skyrockets. Which is what I said.
Priest has incredible card draw with Handmaiden. Priest is having an extremely hard time winning games because card draw without a solid win condition is meaningless. Pretending that having a strong draw option is the same thing as a game-winning effect won't somehow transform the former into the latter.
There are still plenty of reveals available. If we get a mid-late DH finisher, the Relics will be powerhouses. Alternatively, if a card can justify fitting Relics into the existing Fel archetype -- by making them Fel or by providing Fel generation or something -- then these slot in. Still plenty of time for either to show up.
A card like this is undoubtedly necessary to have available. So it's a bit of a shame that it's an epic. Seems like something that should've been a Common.
And if they insist on making it an Epic, it could at least have had a slightly more interesting design.
Extremely weak as a tech card, especially since most locations so far are very low-cost, so chances are the opponent already got one proc or even two before you're even able to get this into play. And it doesn't even have yeti stats!
I'm pretty sure I'll go with some variation of this, but I'm wondering if I should hive it an optimal statline. I mean, you need your opponent to have two minions AND have some means to damage one of them for this to be effective...
Also, maybe the class should be Warlock, as the effect is a curse. But man, I like this artwork so much for this effect.
My previous ideas are inside the spoiler.
Show Spoiler
I was very satisfied with Faceless Trickster… Until I realized it's almost identical to a previous winner this season. I don't think I'll go with it, but I wanted to post it anyways.
About Darksong Deranger, she's based on the myths of sirens luring sailors with their songs. Not sure if this flavor is conveyed clearly enough, though.
Could have been more interesting if it didn't specify the Location had to be an enemy. Then we could have seen Location self-destruction effects/archetypes, like with Runeterra and Countdown. Perhaps we'll see that in the future?
Red Herring - Even if this stealths your entire board forever in quest rogue I would still rate it as trash. Basically if you're playing a turn 7 minion that has no rush or taunt you're asking for trouble. This card goes one further by actively removing your taunts on board.
If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.
I really like the 'play on words' type cards like Dew Process. I wish they would make more of those. Also there better be a strong Scooby Doo reference on one of the cards not just a voiceline.
Qorval doesn't start with multi-targeting, but after you Infuse him he can kill + summon two minions. The token is an example, such as if you had destroyed a Kalecgos or Ysera the Dreamer.
Recasting them would be too similar to Jace. I said shuffle into the deck because I think the devs want the Questline to be the engine of the deck where given enough turns everything you draw will basically be free.
Idea is that you can either buff up your stuff or destroy 1 minion. if the minion has 1 gift from a previous cast of this spell, receiving another will kill them. issue is finding a mana cost/gift number balance. 3 mana destroy a minion felt ok since priest can do it for 2 but what do you guys think?
Infused only activates if a friendly minion dies right? It's going to be pretty hard to maximize the effect but it is just straight up Call of the Wild.
Blizzard Reveals The Mysterious Demon Hunter 'Relics' in Murder at Castle Nathria
Since my opening was about the worst-case draw scenario, one likely to come up slightly less than 50% of the time, that's correct, but I don't think that means what you think it means.
To reiterate, the point is that the draw-plus-body engine alone doesn't do anything and it can't be slotted into any presently-known DH deck in standard to improve or keep it at parity. It almost-but-not-quite could fit into a DH weenie deck, but that deck is bad right now and its lategame isn't really strong enough to get anything done.
Which was my overall point. If you're not winning the game, drawing cards and making many small minions is meaningless. If the DH card pool had different cards in it than it does at present, there'd be, for example, possible OTKs available as lategame finishers. And if even one of those is revealed, the value of these cards skyrockets. Which is what I said.
Priest has incredible card draw with Handmaiden. Priest is having an extremely hard time winning games because card draw without a solid win condition is meaningless. Pretending that having a strong draw option is the same thing as a game-winning effect won't somehow transform the former into the latter.
There are still plenty of reveals available. If we get a mid-late DH finisher, the Relics will be powerhouses. Alternatively, if a card can justify fitting Relics into the existing Fel archetype -- by making them Fel or by providing Fel generation or something -- then these slot in. Still plenty of time for either to show up.
Demolition Renovator is a New Castle Nathria Hearthstone Card Revealed by MarkMcKz
A card like this is undoubtedly necessary to have available. So it's a bit of a shame that it's an epic. Seems like something that should've been a Common.
And if they insist on making it an Epic, it could at least have had a slightly more interesting design.
New Neutral Minion - Demolition Renovator
Extremely weak as a tech card, especially since most locations so far are very low-cost, so chances are the opponent already got one proc or even two before you're even able to get this into play. And it doesn't even have yeti stats!
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I'm pretty sure I'll go with some variation of this, but I'm wondering if I should hive it an optimal statline. I mean, you need your opponent to have two minions AND have some means to damage one of them for this to be effective...
Also, maybe the class should be Warlock, as the effect is a curse. But man, I like this artwork so much for this effect.
My previous ideas are inside the spoiler.
I was very satisfied with Faceless Trickster… Until I realized it's almost identical to a previous winner this season. I don't think I'll go with it, but I wanted to post it anyways.
About Darksong Deranger, she's based on the myths of sirens luring sailors with their songs. Not sure if this flavor is conveyed clearly enough, though.
New Hunter Minion - Huntsman Altimor
Seems pretty interesting, at least if it is properly infused.
He loves all his Gargons equally. (Hecutis is his favorite and it's not close.)
Blizzard Reveals The Mysterious Demon Hunter 'Relics' in Murder at Castle Nathria
I didn't mean it too literally, just frustrated they're only showing the un-upgraded versions.
Demolition Renovator is a New Castle Nathria Hearthstone Card Revealed by MarkMcKz
Could have been more interesting if it didn't specify the Location had to be an enemy. Then we could have seen Location self-destruction effects/archetypes, like with Runeterra and Countdown. Perhaps we'll see that in the future?
A New Castle Nathria Neutral Infuse Card Revealed On Huya - Insatiable Devourer
My guy have you played in the last two weeks? Renathal makes half the games 15 minutes long and go to fatigue
Blizzard Reveals 9 More Murder at Castle Nathria Cards in a Hearthside Chat, Including Warlock Legendary
It does have taunt though
Demolition Renovator is a New Castle Nathria Hearthstone Card Revealed by MarkMcKz
Finally my boy mark got an actual card reveal.
As for the card itself, it ain't a Rustrot Viper but it's definitely necessary considering that there will be more locations in the future.
Demolition Renovator is a New Castle Nathria Hearthstone Card Revealed by MarkMcKz
A card that needed to exist.
If you need an answer to locations, this would be it. A tech card with subpar but nevertheless good enough stats, nothing more nothing less.
Demolition Renovator is a New Castle Nathria Hearthstone Card Revealed by MarkMcKz
No one saw the Voyage to the Sunken City background art for 30 seconds. I definitely did not make that mistake. Nope.
It's still on Twitter if you care.
New Neutral Minion - Demolition Renovator
A new Epic Neutral Minion, Demolition Renovator, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Murder at Castle Nathria
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Murder at Castle Nathria!
Get Cheaper Card Packs
This section contains affiliate links.
If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.
Spoiler Alert! Leaked Names and Art for Upcoming Murder at Castle Nathria Cards
I really like the 'play on words' type cards like Dew Process. I wish they would make more of those. Also there better be a strong Scooby Doo reference on one of the cards not just a voiceline.
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Swapping stuff is gonna be very common this week i guess...not sure if this is special enough^^
Spoiler Alert! Leaked Names and Art for Upcoming Murder at Castle Nathria Cards
"Death Blossom Whomper" looks/sounds like Treant support to me. Please?
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Qorval doesn't start with multi-targeting, but after you Infuse him he can kill + summon two minions. The token is an example, such as if you had destroyed a Kalecgos or Ysera the Dreamer.
Blizzard Reveals The Mysterious Demon Hunter 'Relics' in Murder at Castle Nathria
Recasting them would be too similar to Jace. I said shuffle into the deck because I think the devs want the Questline to be the engine of the deck where given enough turns everything you draw will basically be free.
Spoiler Alert! Leaked Names and Art for Upcoming Murder at Castle Nathria Cards
Unless this set has a subtheme of the Maw I'm going to call it now that the Miniset will be called Trial In Torghast.
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
We have the technology!
I know the name for Tri-Cast Orbs isn't great, but I literally couldn't think of anything else better and I was spending a long time on it already.
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Idea is that you can either buff up your stuff or destroy 1 minion. if the minion has 1 gift from a previous cast of this spell, receiving another will kill them. issue is finding a mana cost/gift number balance. 3 mana destroy a minion felt ok since priest can do it for 2 but what do you guys think?
Blizzard Reveals 9 More Murder at Castle Nathria Cards in a Hearthside Chat, Including Warlock Legendary
Oh boy, can't wait to pull out more of my hairs from mages playing Solid Alibi.
New Upgrade Available - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Top card going into the finals, bottom card of the end results.
Sigh.
...
Anyway, congratulations to Mr. Rhapsody! You're really collecting those wins this Season :D
Stay On Target - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Competition Theme: Stay On Target
We need you to keep on target this week, so... wait, I have an idea!
Demonxz95 is looking for us to expand our goals this week, or at least hit a few more targets!
As always, I can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.
Competition Phases
Here are the phases of this card design competition
Discussion Thread Rules
No thread rules were added to this season. Please populate and manually edit this thread with them.
Blizzard Reveals New Murder at Castle Nathria Hunter Legendary Card - Huntsman Altimor
Infused only activates if a friendly minion dies right? It's going to be pretty hard to maximize the effect but it is just straight up Call of the Wild.