Here's a list, of which nearly all variants of demon seed+fools bane came from later. I prefer mine with some extra draws. After a while I ended up just ditching Glacial Shard for Backfire. Fire Stomp as signature treasure.
Basically, his was the first deck I saw that abused the power of Fool's Bane for easy wins, which is why I noted that board based decks simply cannot win against this list unless they get really lucky with board spam, or you get extremely unlucky with your draws.
Im not sure what list you're running, but this deck absolutely needs minions to get anywhere, because of the power of Raise Dead, Shadowblade Slinger and various armor gain minions. Best treasures are stuff like grommash's armguards (yes this is not a joke. Just dont pick buckets with weapons because fool's bane is all you really need). Best pool 2 can vary from battle totem to legendary loot, depending on what you get off buckets.
Below 4 wins are easy enough, because you have consistent armor gain, and if you have fools bane in hand its near impossible for a board deck to beat you. Past 5 wins its really down to card draw and control, but generally if you have the weapon in hand you're really not going to lose to a board. I get easily to 7 wins, usually losing to only mind tether priests, various mages, and other burn strats. Or losing because my opponent got the nuts treasure like party replacement or massive battle totem value decks.
Pick control and pain buckets, but if you can find some card draw its worth picking it depending on what you have. The deck plays control 90% of the time, then when tamsin is out its just 6+ damage every turn. If your opponent spams board just fire stomp for safety or fools bane with tamsin for the easy 30+ damage. Even big boards is basically just going to turbo your quest completion and then its massive damage every turn from there.
Edit: should have noted that if you're aiming for consistency, you can ditch some cards for extra card draw, at the cost of a small disadvantage in the early rounds. But ultimately, from my experience its not a consistent deck because of polarising matchups. I cant recall ever losing to a board. My best is 11 wins, I think I lost the last one because I didn't draw my fools bane. Most of my matches end around 7-8 wins, mostly losing to mind tether + fireshaper, the very definition of broken.
I miss Bob. I changed it to the robot lady and even though she often gives me her petty insults I'm too lazy and forget to change it back to him. Shrug
I know of the general idea, and was asking for a specific list that manages to pull this off consistently.
I disagree with your points about the lists strengths and weaknesses. From my experience, later on in the run, it's not common to be offered the right control tools and so the deck thickens and becomes worse. From what I see, it's generally board based decks that actually end up beating it after the early rounds, because their passives are so strong and much more synergetic with their strat. Obviously you can highroll with it, maybe get Oops, All Spells! etc - but you can highroll with any deck in duels.
Early-rounds strategies can be frustrating to face, but ultimately those kind of decks average around 5 wins (just my experience, I don't have data to back this up) and struggle to get past 7.
Would love to see those Diablo lists, from my experience the demon-seed is only strong in the early rounds (and even then you could easily die to a pirate warrior or elemental shaman).
You can probably find it easily on the web. The most famous, and probably most successful list Ive seen so far, would be primal power hp along with The Demon Seed, full on armor gain and control, with Fool's Bane as the only weapon, which is practically broken with demon seed.
Play it right and no list that runs minions will ever get close to victory, not with Fire Stomp and so many control tools.
This list doesn't suffer in the early or late game, its only weakness is its polarising matchups. If you run into decks that doesn't play minions, or run burn strats you'll start with such a massive disadvantage that your only chance of winning would be by claiming a few value buckets along the way. Or your opponent screws up big, which honestly tends to happen more often than not.
Would love to see those Diablo lists, from my experience the demon-seed is only strong in the early rounds (and even then you could easily die to a pirate warrior or elemental shaman).
Definitely crafting Lightforged Cariel if I don't get her in packs. As for big paladin itself. I think it'll be much more consistent if you include Vanndar Stormpike.
Yes, that's a big if. I tend to look at Duels for comparison - started out shaky, with hero powers and treasures gated behind having enough cards of X expansion, and multiple other problems, but still eventually course correcting to an extent and enjoying a little resurgence. So Mercenaries could still make up for a somewhat rough start, hopefully it won't take them forever.
TL;DR: These are my two times 100 cents. I've noted a number of changes to Big Paladin, but am not optimistic about its success. Similarly, the proposed Aggro Paladin could see some changes, but I don't see it being much better than existing aggressive Paladin lists. I believe Paladin is likely to stick to its well-established roots: Libram, Secret, Handbuff, maybe Stealth too.
On the Big Paladin theorycraft, I've made a number of substitutions to consider. I've based my theorycraft on the old Darkmoon build of Duel Paladin that popped up for a time, and taken some inspiration from the theorycraft listed here. For reference, here's my theorycraft: https://playhearthstone.com/deckbuilder?deckcode=AAECAZ8FAuCLBJTkAw72pASLjQT4pAT3pAT0pAT34wOezQPS0QPzuwPKwQP1pASF3gOV%2BQOQ0AMA
Lokholar the Ice Lord, for instance, I think would be better substituted for Runaway Blackwing, which presents a huge threat with potential to completely swing the game in your favour, whereas the former would likely die or come close to dying upon summon. Whether or not Blackwing should be a two-of is a good question, and I suspect it likely will take a slot from Brasswing, which likely has a worse effect overall than Blackwing. I agree with all other minion choices.
As for other substitutions, Noble Mount makes way for Hold the Bridge, which this deck can better take advantage of as you summon a rather sizable number of big minions, and provides a way to stabilise as the game goes on better than Noble Mount does. Speaking of big minions, I've also added Hammer of the Naaru in for Wave of Apathy; it's just a solid card which creates a sizable minion while giving you three-damage pings, whereas the latter has no clear use other than stalling for a turn without offering any immediate way to deal with the board/take the initiative.
I've also substituted Lightbringer's Hammer for Ceremonial Maul which, while it is a worse weapon overall, can give you the same effect Protect the Innocent would have if you healed beforehand. Additionally, should you also stick a heal later in the game, you can get a whopping 15/15 stats in Taunt with the Maul equipped! The synergy with Barricade is also notable. Lightbringer's Hammer might end up being the better choice here, admittedly, but the inability to hit your opponent as well as the heal being conditional on your opponent having played some minion might render the weapon useless in certain matchups.
The biggest issue with my proposed list is the weapon redundancy. There are 7 different weapons in this list, which might lean towards the deck being too clunky. At the same time, the deck has the potential to make effective use of all of these weapons, so I'd want to try before dismissing some of them, if at all. Other, final notes on Big Paladin: Blessed Goods is the best substitution available for Desperate Measures used in Darkmoon Faire's Duel Paladin, and while not as good at providing immediate value, can give you even MORE weapons or other things to create value later on the game, so we'll see how it goes. Also, First Day of School and Hand of A'dal had not yet been nerfed in Darkmoon Duel Paladin, and we also lost Air Raid, so our early-game is overall much worse, and A'dal is much harder to stick early, but is retained due to it providing much needed card draw.
I will say that overall, Big Paladin probably won't succeed in the long run due to the clear difficulties in seizing early-game initiative, which Paladin usually wants to do as a means of contesting the early board, as well as the lack of high quality cards outside of the new additions from Alterac Valley, which are questionable at best (ex. Cavalry Horn takes two turns to activate, Brasswing's effect is mediocre at the mid-to-late game at best, a number of cards are conditional, either on having the big threats online or on healing). It won't stop me from trying, though, and I may be wrong!
Aggro Paladin
Regarding the Aggro Paladin, first: argh, I picked Alliance, so I can't play with the Aggro Pally theorycraft until I finish the honour chain!!! Nonetheless, I will say that I don't think Dun Baldar Bridge would ever see play in an aggro deck, as you're spending a whopping 4-mana for no immediate effect, which offsets any potential benefit the card provides thereafter. Similarly, as the deck tops out at 4-mana, corrupting Day at the Faire will be difficult, and playing its base form is mediocre at best.
I'd probably add the second copy of Goody Two-Shields as well as Saidan the Scarlet and two copies of Blessing of Authority for a bit of a larger buff package to support Saidan and potentially highroll the game to victory, with or without Drek'thar.
Because this deck is focused on Drek'Thar, there are parallels to Tax Paladin in Wild, which uses Call to Arms; I'm not sure that a similar idea would succeed in Standard, however, as you're lacking Call to Arms, and the given list, while I think can make minor improvements, contains a bunch of minions you'd rather not pull from Drek'thar. Notably, you can't run Murgur Murgurgle because, when it shuffles itself into your deck, it disables Drek'thar's effect!
The lack of high quality minions for Drek'thar to pull from suggests moving away from a Drek'Thar package altogether, and at the point, I'd rather be running the well-established Secret, Handbuff, or even Stealth packages that are already known to perform on ladder.
One final note: there are a few avenues for improvement to existing Libram, Secret, Handbuff, and Stealth lists that I won't go into here, but I feel already exhibit more potential than the proposed lists. Then again, we've seen these lists in action during Stormwind, and the new meta might be such that these archetypes disappear. Given how often Libram has stuck around, however, and the sheer power demonstrated by other aggressive lists this expansion, such as Secret and Handbuff, which have both been consistent laddering choices, they seem like the better lists to build on and improve rather than attempt anything novel offered by Alterac Valley.
If you actually read this whole post, which I made only because of my excessive devotion to and interest in Traditional Hearthstone and love for Paladin, then thanks!
They definitely occupy a strange space. If you're more casual about the game you might never complete the legendary questline that would get you the golden copy of the second one, so for those players there's something intuitive about having Drek'thar and Vanndar work like any other legendary from a pack. But for many players who will complete it (but who can't possibly get 7200 honor in the next 3-4 days), it presents a certain duplicate protection problem.
For folks who don't care about golden cards, you could always just dust the golden copy when you get it. Then at least you still net one legendary from the quest (even though technically you're getting less dust on net).
That's a fair assessment. I just find the demon seed as a whole to be a rather un-fun part of hearthstone, regardless of the mode it's played in. I can deal with the other quests to some degree and don't mind their strength now that most have been tuned. (mage is still kinda nuts but at least slow enough to give you a chance). But the demon seed just circumvents mechanics entirely which...makes me extremely frustrated with the meta.
So I chose the Horde and got Drek'thar. Today in a Fireside Gathering I opened a normal copy of Vanndar. I feel like this shouldn't happen since we will get both Legendaries anyway, as long as we complete the Questline. So, was i scammed or will I get a full dust refund? Feels like a wasted Legendary
You can open drekthar/Vandar from packs and unlike Korak theyre not desenchantable for full dust, deqpirz that the questline will give you the other one gold (+one of them diamond later on for evryone)
Diablo in Duels
Here's a list, of which nearly all variants of demon seed+fools bane came from later. I prefer mine with some extra draws. After a while I ended up just ditching Glacial Shard for Backfire. Fire Stomp as signature treasure.
https://twitter.com/Gregoriusil_/status/1456656634697113601
Basically, his was the first deck I saw that abused the power of Fool's Bane for easy wins, which is why I noted that board based decks simply cannot win against this list unless they get really lucky with board spam, or you get extremely unlucky with your draws.
Im not sure what list you're running, but this deck absolutely needs minions to get anywhere, because of the power of Raise Dead, Shadowblade Slinger and various armor gain minions. Best treasures are stuff like grommash's armguards (yes this is not a joke. Just dont pick buckets with weapons because fool's bane is all you really need). Best pool 2 can vary from battle totem to legendary loot, depending on what you get off buckets.
Below 4 wins are easy enough, because you have consistent armor gain, and if you have fools bane in hand its near impossible for a board deck to beat you. Past 5 wins its really down to card draw and control, but generally if you have the weapon in hand you're really not going to lose to a board. I get easily to 7 wins, usually losing to only mind tether priests, various mages, and other burn strats. Or losing because my opponent got the nuts treasure like party replacement or massive battle totem value decks.
Pick control and pain buckets, but if you can find some card draw its worth picking it depending on what you have. The deck plays control 90% of the time, then when tamsin is out its just 6+ damage every turn. If your opponent spams board just fire stomp for safety or fools bane with tamsin for the easy 30+ damage. Even big boards is basically just going to turbo your quest completion and then its massive damage every turn from there.
Edit: should have noted that if you're aiming for consistency, you can ditch some cards for extra card draw, at the cost of a small disadvantage in the early rounds. But ultimately, from my experience its not a consistent deck because of polarising matchups. I cant recall ever losing to a board. My best is 11 wins, I think I lost the last one because I didn't draw my fools bane. Most of my matches end around 7-8 wins, mostly losing to mind tether + fireshaper, the very definition of broken.
Quest Trading - Play A Friend!
Battletag: ShadowDancer#21495
Region: NA
Trade Only?: Yes
Druids Are Going Beasts & Choose One in Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
Shadows! Thanks for the theory-thoughts.
I am also looking forward to filling a deck with beasts and seeing what happens.
Let's goooo!
Bob must hate me
I miss Bob. I changed it to the robot lady and even though she often gives me her petty insults I'm too lazy and forget to change it back to him. Shrug
Diablo in Duels
I know of the general idea, and was asking for a specific list that manages to pull this off consistently.
I disagree with your points about the lists strengths and weaknesses. From my experience, later on in the run, it's not common to be offered the right control tools and so the deck thickens and becomes worse. From what I see, it's generally board based decks that actually end up beating it after the early rounds, because their passives are so strong and much more synergetic with their strat. Obviously you can highroll with it, maybe get Oops, All Spells! etc - but you can highroll with any deck in duels.
Early-rounds strategies can be frustrating to face, but ultimately those kind of decks average around 5 wins (just my experience, I don't have data to back this up) and struggle to get past 7.
Diablo in Duels
You can probably find it easily on the web. The most famous, and probably most successful list Ive seen so far, would be primal power hp along with The Demon Seed, full on armor gain and control, with Fool's Bane as the only weapon, which is practically broken with demon seed.
Play it right and no list that runs minions will ever get close to victory, not with Fire Stomp and so many control tools.
This list doesn't suffer in the early or late game, its only weakness is its polarising matchups. If you run into decks that doesn't play minions, or run burn strats you'll start with such a massive disadvantage that your only chance of winning would be by claiming a few value buckets along the way. Or your opponent screws up big, which honestly tends to happen more often than not.
Hearthstone Duels Has 15 New Passive Treasures - Here’s What We Think About Them and How They Can Be Used
I tried Unholy Gift and the Death Knight cards did NOT cast-when-drawn.
Stormwind Duels Meta Update #7 - Best 12-Win Hearthstone Duels Decks for All Classes in December Week 1
Had some nice success with Regis's boar quest priest, but as a second passive got Bronze Signet. Collecting boars was never that easy.
On the relevant note: how people are linking passives in normal manner and not like an animal?
Diablo in Duels
Would love to see those Diablo lists, from my experience the demon-seed is only strong in the early rounds (and even then you could easily die to a pirate warrior or elemental shaman).
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
Definitely crafting Lightforged Cariel if I don't get her in packs. As for big paladin itself. I think it'll be much more consistent if you include Vanndar Stormpike.
Diablo in Duels
I hate it with passion myself, so you're not alone on this one.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Zai, the Incredible
And a year later, the copy I opened is patiently awaiting for its time to shine ... will it come?
Only dust can tell ^^
4 New Playable Mercenaries Are Coming to Hearthstone Including Valeera Sanguinar and Vanessa VanCleef
Yes, that's a big if. I tend to look at Duels for comparison - started out shaky, with hero powers and treasures gated behind having enough cards of X expansion, and multiple other problems, but still eventually course correcting to an extent and enjoying a little resurgence. So Mercenaries could still make up for a somewhat rough start, hopefully it won't take them forever.
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
People are really sleeping on Irondeep Trogg in Handbuff Paladin.
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
Best cards of the set along with Shaman
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
TL;DR: These are my two times 100 cents. I've noted a number of changes to Big Paladin, but am not optimistic about its success. Similarly, the proposed Aggro Paladin could see some changes, but I don't see it being much better than existing aggressive Paladin lists. I believe Paladin is likely to stick to its well-established roots: Libram, Secret, Handbuff, maybe Stealth too.
Proposed changes to Big Paladin:
- 1x Runaway Blackwing for Lokholar the Ice Lord
- 2x Hold the Bridge for 2x Noble Mount
- 2x Hammer of the Naaru for 2x Wave of Apathy
- 2x Ceremonial Maul for 2x Lightbringer's Hammer
Proposed changes to Aggro Paladin:
- 1x Goody Two-Shields and Saidan the Scarlet for 2x Dun Baldar Bridge
- 2x Blessing of Authority for 2x Day at the Faire
Big Paladin
On the Big Paladin theorycraft, I've made a number of substitutions to consider. I've based my theorycraft on the old Darkmoon build of Duel Paladin that popped up for a time, and taken some inspiration from the theorycraft listed here. For reference, here's my theorycraft: https://playhearthstone.com/deckbuilder?deckcode=AAECAZ8FAuCLBJTkAw72pASLjQT4pAT3pAT0pAT34wOezQPS0QPzuwPKwQP1pASF3gOV%2BQOQ0AMA
Lokholar the Ice Lord, for instance, I think would be better substituted for Runaway Blackwing, which presents a huge threat with potential to completely swing the game in your favour, whereas the former would likely die or come close to dying upon summon. Whether or not Blackwing should be a two-of is a good question, and I suspect it likely will take a slot from Brasswing, which likely has a worse effect overall than Blackwing. I agree with all other minion choices.
As for other substitutions, Noble Mount makes way for Hold the Bridge, which this deck can better take advantage of as you summon a rather sizable number of big minions, and provides a way to stabilise as the game goes on better than Noble Mount does. Speaking of big minions, I've also added Hammer of the Naaru in for Wave of Apathy; it's just a solid card which creates a sizable minion while giving you three-damage pings, whereas the latter has no clear use other than stalling for a turn without offering any immediate way to deal with the board/take the initiative.
I've also substituted Lightbringer's Hammer for Ceremonial Maul which, while it is a worse weapon overall, can give you the same effect Protect the Innocent would have if you healed beforehand. Additionally, should you also stick a heal later in the game, you can get a whopping 15/15 stats in Taunt with the Maul equipped! The synergy with Barricade is also notable. Lightbringer's Hammer might end up being the better choice here, admittedly, but the inability to hit your opponent as well as the heal being conditional on your opponent having played some minion might render the weapon useless in certain matchups.
The biggest issue with my proposed list is the weapon redundancy. There are 7 different weapons in this list, which might lean towards the deck being too clunky. At the same time, the deck has the potential to make effective use of all of these weapons, so I'd want to try before dismissing some of them, if at all. Other, final notes on Big Paladin: Blessed Goods is the best substitution available for Desperate Measures used in Darkmoon Faire's Duel Paladin, and while not as good at providing immediate value, can give you even MORE weapons or other things to create value later on the game, so we'll see how it goes. Also, First Day of School and Hand of A'dal had not yet been nerfed in Darkmoon Duel Paladin, and we also lost Air Raid, so our early-game is overall much worse, and A'dal is much harder to stick early, but is retained due to it providing much needed card draw.
I will say that overall, Big Paladin probably won't succeed in the long run due to the clear difficulties in seizing early-game initiative, which Paladin usually wants to do as a means of contesting the early board, as well as the lack of high quality cards outside of the new additions from Alterac Valley, which are questionable at best (ex. Cavalry Horn takes two turns to activate, Brasswing's effect is mediocre at the mid-to-late game at best, a number of cards are conditional, either on having the big threats online or on healing). It won't stop me from trying, though, and I may be wrong!
Aggro Paladin
Regarding the Aggro Paladin, first: argh, I picked Alliance, so I can't play with the Aggro Pally theorycraft until I finish the honour chain!!! Nonetheless, I will say that I don't think Dun Baldar Bridge would ever see play in an aggro deck, as you're spending a whopping 4-mana for no immediate effect, which offsets any potential benefit the card provides thereafter. Similarly, as the deck tops out at 4-mana, corrupting Day at the Faire will be difficult, and playing its base form is mediocre at best.
I'd probably add the second copy of Goody Two-Shields as well as Saidan the Scarlet and two copies of Blessing of Authority for a bit of a larger buff package to support Saidan and potentially highroll the game to victory, with or without Drek'thar.
Because this deck is focused on Drek'Thar, there are parallels to Tax Paladin in Wild, which uses Call to Arms; I'm not sure that a similar idea would succeed in Standard, however, as you're lacking Call to Arms, and the given list, while I think can make minor improvements, contains a bunch of minions you'd rather not pull from Drek'thar. Notably, you can't run Murgur Murgurgle because, when it shuffles itself into your deck, it disables Drek'thar's effect!
The lack of high quality minions for Drek'thar to pull from suggests moving away from a Drek'Thar package altogether, and at the point, I'd rather be running the well-established Secret, Handbuff, or even Stealth packages that are already known to perform on ladder.
One final note: there are a few avenues for improvement to existing Libram, Secret, Handbuff, and Stealth lists that I won't go into here, but I feel already exhibit more potential than the proposed lists. Then again, we've seen these lists in action during Stormwind, and the new meta might be such that these archetypes disappear. Given how often Libram has stuck around, however, and the sheer power demonstrated by other aggressive lists this expansion, such as Secret and Handbuff, which have both been consistent laddering choices, they seem like the better lists to build on and improve rather than attempt anything novel offered by Alterac Valley.
If you actually read this whole post, which I made only because of my excessive devotion to and interest in Traditional Hearthstone and love for Paladin, then thanks!
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
Paladin got some really sweet cards in this set, especially Lightforged Cariel, can't wait to play with it!
How to Create a Private Fireside Gathering to Open Card Packs for a New Hearthstone Expansion - TITANS
They definitely occupy a strange space. If you're more casual about the game you might never complete the legendary questline that would get you the golden copy of the second one, so for those players there's something intuitive about having Drek'thar and Vanndar work like any other legendary from a pack. But for many players who will complete it (but who can't possibly get 7200 honor in the next 3-4 days), it presents a certain duplicate protection problem.
For folks who don't care about golden cards, you could always just dust the golden copy when you get it. Then at least you still net one legendary from the quest (even though technically you're getting less dust on net).
Hearthstone's Battle for Alterac Valley Event Has Begun In Earnest - Legendary Questline In-Game, Earlier Honor Gains Not Being Counted
Earned 950 honor points before the legendary quest started, but no exams for me next week. Still hurts though.
Diablo in Duels
That's a fair assessment. I just find the demon seed as a whole to be a rather un-fun part of hearthstone, regardless of the mode it's played in. I can deal with the other quests to some degree and don't mind their strength now that most have been tuned. (mage is still kinda nuts but at least slow enough to give you a chance). But the demon seed just circumvents mechanics entirely which...makes me extremely frustrated with the meta.
Hearthstone's Upcoming Alterac Valley Faction War Legendary Questline Requires Over 300 Games to Get Golden Card Rewards
So I chose the Horde and got Drek'thar. Today in a Fireside Gathering I opened a normal copy of Vanndar. I feel like this shouldn't happen since we will get both Legendaries anyway, as long as we complete the Questline. So, was i scammed or will I get a full dust refund? Feels like a wasted Legendary
How to Create a Private Fireside Gathering to Open Card Packs for a New Hearthstone Expansion - TITANS
Pretty sure but not 100% positive you can d/e the one you opened.
How to Create a Private Fireside Gathering to Open Card Packs for a New Hearthstone Expansion - TITANS
You can open drekthar/Vandar from packs and unlike Korak theyre not desenchantable for full dust, deqpirz that the questline will give you the other one gold (+one of them diamond later on for evryone)
Hope they will change this, but i have my doubts
Paladins Bring Big Holy Buffs to Fractured in Alterac Valley - Hearthstone Card Review & Theorycraft Deck
100% correct predictions.
New Targon Spell - Against the Odds
This get one star for flavor but seriously don't run this.