All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Quote From Sykomyke
    Inspire's issue is that at the time (and even now) hero powering is usually a sign of a "bad turn".   And often the card would have a weak inspire effect.  Take for example take Recruiter.  
    ...

    Right, and none of that is a problem with the keyword as much as with the balancing of specific cards (which happened to be nearly all inspire cards specifically :P). But Phase Stalker and Dragonbane demonstrated the effectiveness of the keyword when applied to appropriately powerful minions.

    Using the hero power doesn't generally equate to a bad turn though. A low tempo turn, yes, but even then only really with base 2-cost hero powers, and even then it's not rare for that to be part of your overall game plan... well, back when we had some long games anyway. Besides, there are so many ways good ways to change hero powers or make them cheaper now, and we have DH which begins with a hero power that is designed to be easily slotted into turns. Both Lowly Squire and, more importantly, Spawn of Shadows have shown TGT was just lacking the actual hero powers to make inspire worthwhile. So I've long felt like inspire is a keyword that has aged really well, even though most of the cards it's attached to haven't. It was just ahead of its time I guess.

  • Golems Galore - A Full Guide to Jade Shaman on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    Yeah Bolner is pretty powerful, you can put in Armor Vendors instead for more survival early game and The Lurker Below if you have him.

  • Alterac Valley Theorycraft Streams Bring Free Hearthstone Packs to Twitch This Thursday

    If they limit it perfectly per HS account, I would think: "No." (though I hope it will work)

    However, my side question is: "Can we obtain both packs by 'watching' the streams on both Twitch and YouTube simultaneously in just 2 hours time?" (this would be very useful information since the event window is just 6 hours in total and I will experiment)

    EDIT: This article has been updated with information stating that there are NO YouTube drops unfortunately and the event window lasts 36 hours.

  • Golems Galore - A Full Guide to Jade Shaman on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    Jade Druid is going to be awesome with Wildheart Guff, being able to ramp faster and then draw 2 cards a turn in your Jade Idol endgame.

  • Question about honor

    Yeah, But It got me confused when the New rank gave me the "Card obtained" notification.

     

    Thank you very much for all your answers!

     

     

     

  • Question about honor

    True, so ultimately it does not affect the eventual outcome of obtaining the golden legendary.

    It is just that the previously already acquired honor points are not counted towards the rank progression which is just for bragging rights anyways.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Quote From AngryShuckie

    I'd argue twinspell is better than echo for being made evergreen because it isn't limited to 1-3 mana cards and hence has much larger design space worth exploring over a long period of time. While echo has popped up a few times outside Witchwood, its too narrow to really be common.

    That being said, I'd expect either inspire or magnetic to be the one being made evergreen. Inspire is open-ended enough to make sense in the game when there is a lot more support for hero powers than back in TGT, while magnetic is the only thing that distinguishes mechs from other tribes, so they probably should have it long term.

    Inspire's issue is that at the time (and even now) hero powering is usually a sign of a "bad turn".   And often the card would have a weak inspire effect.  Take for example take Recruiter.  

    A 5 mana 5/4 by today's standards is horrible.  Hell, we have 5 mana 5/6's that do something and still don't play them.  Secondly. Requires you to use your hero power so it's "really" a turn 7 play.  And on top of everything, it's a 1 mana 2/2 "inspire reward".  (effectively making it a 3 mana 2/2 that is "free").

    Inspire is a great idea mechanically, its just that it needed to have better effects attached to it.  Or have inspire minions have lower stats and cost to have stronger inspire effects.  

    If the "Recruiter" card were printed today.  I would make it a 3 mana 3/4, add a 1 mana 2/2 to your hand.  This way it's used as a tempo play, and can then be inspired the next turn, or it can played on turn 5 to generate hand value.

    Alternatively It could be printed as a 4 mana 3/4 with the keyword "Inspire: *Summon* a 2/2 squire"  (that way you aren't paying for any costs from hand, but you are paying for an understatted body with a stronger inspire effect.

     

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    All her hero portraits show the typical head tentacles that Draenei have, but none of her actual cards do.

    It's not that noticeable on her previous cards but on the new hero card it's kind of annoying. I thought they just don't care about inconsistencies because of the Scabbs thing but now they show that they do and now I'm annoyed.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    What's wrong with Xyrella ?

  • Question about honor

    On the other hand, the achievment still keep the track of previously acquired points

  • Fight The Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Wow, this competition is moving slow. I was going to wait for feedback until there were enough cards to make a good post and that took quite a while, but I'm glad to finally be able to get there.

    Wailor
    Nice overall. The effect isn't too intrusive, but it can still disrupt your opponent badly when used at the right time. I like it.

    BloodMefist
    Great idea. Balance I'm not too sure about, though it does rely on your opponent needing to use their Hero Power and ideally against a deck that wants to use it a lot which I think works well for it.

    MenacingBagel
    I'm gonna have to agree with everybody else here and say that this does nothing for me. The art for the first version does not fit Hearthstone at all and the effect in general just seems way too weird to work.

    Neoguli
    I'm not exactly the biggest fan of "Marin the Fox but different". At least Toggwaggle was a bit different in that he just skipped the Treasure Chest entirely and let you choose a Treasure. The card otherwise is fine though.

    DestroyerR
    I think the effect is a neat idea, but it doesn't really feel like a Paladin card to me other than the artwork. I feel like it could very well just be a Neutral card.

    Arkasaur
    I do think the card design is a bit too narrow since it, on baseline anyway, only affects Mage and Hunter. Use as a tech card for Hero Powers from hero cards and such is fine, but then it should exist in a set where those cards actually exist. It is a little bit weird to have both this and Overconfident Orc in the same set when the latter has the same stats, cost, Taunt, and is generally just a better card most of the time.

    Anchorm4n

    A simple, but fine idea. I think you could possible phrase it as "Battlecry: Your opponent's Hero Power costs (1) more this game" to avoid the overlapping problem.

    I do see the 1/1/4 statline as slightly controversial which is why I thought about changing it anyway.

    BasilAnguis
    A funky idea, but I do agree that it's too risky to use for the comp.

  • Question about honor

    Good question, I was wondering the same, but my impression is that it probably does not unfortunately.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Based on the mechanics of the mode, I think it would be a waste of resources to have a dedicated team for it. All that Arena needs is balance work, and they can do that based largely on data collected soon after a new season starts.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Since Echo, Inspire, Recruit and Twinspell all are used lately with different wording, my guess would be Magnetic. Adapt was cool, but feels more exclusive to it's own expansion.

  • Question about honor

    So... Yesterday I got 1000 honor and today I appear as a Grunt. 

    Does the old 1000 count towards unlocks?

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Cosmetics, while we would consider them successful to expectations, do not monetize like gameplay focused products. I imagine this is true for any game.

    Now this is just plain wrong. Look at Fortnite, League of Legends, Dota 2, CS:GO: all of these are giants in the industry, having esports tournaments with massive budgets, and they are all 100% free to play with cosmetic only purchases.

    Celestalon's argument does not hold up in justifying Hearthstone's enormous cost of cards and the terrible game economy. I really wish they would move away from packs being the main source of income, and prioritize cosmetics, just like Runeterra. A shift like that would make the game so much more enjoyable for everyone.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    I'm hoping for Spellburst myself, one of the coolest keywords in general and I feel like we haven't even scratched the surface of how interesting it can become (especially with the recent addition of spell schools).

  • Golems Galore - A Full Guide to Jade Shaman on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    Fond memories :) I was always more on the Jade Druid side. I would argue that Jade Idol is the strongest jade card, but overall Shaman is looking stronger (especially as it received much better support cards in the following expansions).

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    So we know that honor kill only triggers in your turn, but does it trigger on killing your own minions? On blizz's own website they spelled it out as 'killing an enemy minion". I believe this to not be the case, that it also triggers with your own minions, but obviously I can't test it. Guess we'll find out on the theorycraft stream.

    On the question about questlock, I really think at some point something will be done about it, not because its very oppressive, but because of its sheer power it more or less pushes everything else warlock has aside, at least anything that even resembles a win condition. Doesnt help a lot that the warlock set this time round doesn't look particularly great.

    Wouldn't be too surprised if The Demon Seed gets another nerf, and this time it may just kill it. Likely going to see lifesteal dhunter and garrote rogue on that list as well.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Staff Pro

    Yeah, its nice to have finally have it said out loud. Not nice that it is actually a reality.

  • Golems Galore - A Full Guide to Jade Shaman on the Wildest of Wednesdays

    I love this article, thank you! I've always wanted to build/play this deck, and have "most" of cards. But I can't bring myself to craft bolner, aya, and fireheart... I might try without them for fun, although I suspect Bolner in particular would be missed 

  • Chess Grandmaster Garry Kasparov Takes on Hearthstone

    Corny but cute at the same time. This would have been a great ad when HS was originally released back in 2014. 

    PC gamer also had an interview with him: https://www.pcgamer.com/garry-kasparov-is-diamond-5-in-hearthstone-but-reckons-if-i-make-a-push-i-can-go-to-legend-rank/ 

  • Hearthstone Duels Has 15 New Passive Treasures - Here’s What We Think About Them and How They Can Be Used

    Great write-up on each of the new passives. Keen to see the 12-win decks that use them

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    That's actually not a new Information. Iksar also mentioned many months ago that some cool cards didn't made it to the live version because it would break wild.

  • Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More

    Quote From Caro

    Good thing this was in bold:

    An older non-evergreen keyword will be making a return in the future.

    There's a few keyword that fit this:

    Adapt - Was pretty fun and I'm sure can be used in other themes, I'm sure not only beast can adapt right?

    Inspire - The effects would need to be much better than in TGT

    Echo - This mechanic was abused in some circumstances but the entire expansion didn't showcase the mechanic well enough. 

    Magnetic - Probably one of the best mechanics and I know Dean and several devs really enjoying designing this mechanic. This one will probably be the keyword they talking about.

    Twinspell - Wasn't bad, but Echo is just way better right?

    Recruit aswell, since they like constantly keep using it