Medivh playing Medivh isn’t weird because Medivh is an alternate hero, not a base hero. I think they have a strict rule that the 10 base heroes shouldn’t have minion counterparts, while alternate heroes are allowed to have them (Medivh, Maiev, Prestor, Vanndar, N’Zoth to name a few)
Illidan Stormrage was changed to Xavius because they thought he might receive play in Demon Hunter and it would be weird to have Illidan playing Illidan.
And Medivh playing Medivh wasn't weird at all.
Gnomes are supposed to only have 4 fingers.
Really? I played WoW 8 years and never noticed this (mostly because I was playing Horde and was seeing gnomes squished on the ground only).
I'd argue twinspell is better than echo for being made evergreen because it isn't limited to 1-3 mana cards and hence has much larger design space worth exploring over a long period of time. While echo has popped up a few times outside Witchwood, its too narrow to really be common.
That being said, I'd expect either inspire or magnetic to be the one being made evergreen. Inspire is open-ended enough to make sense in the game when there is a lot more support for hero powers than back in TGT, while magnetic is the only thing that distinguishes mechs from other tribes, so they probably should have it long term.
While I do love Magnetic and Mechs in general, I doubt this is the one he was hinting at because Magnetic is essentially nothing but Charge and therefore hard to balance. Wouldn't mind in the least to be wrong though :-)
An older non-evergreen keyword will be making a return in the future.
There's a few keyword that fit this:
Adapt - Was pretty fun and I'm sure can be used in other themes, I'm sure not only beast can adapt right?
Inspire - The effects would need to be much better than in TGT
Echo - This mechanic was abused in some circumstances but the entire expansion didn't showcase the mechanic well enough.
Magnetic - Probably one of the best mechanics and I know Dean and several devs really enjoying designing this mechanic. This one will probably be the keyword they talking about.
Twinspell - Wasn't bad, but Echo is just way better right?
I'm really torn in this case. It's a very cool card overall - disruptive, strong, great flavor, fitting art. But as you've said yourself, the effect is pretty much symmetrical so might not make the cut for this comp. You should send Shadows a DM to clarify things quickly.
Arkasaur
I'm not completely sold on the statline, but everything else looks cool. I'm a big fan of simple designs so you'll get a good rating from me ;-)
DestroyerR
I like the flavor of the card (name/art/idea for the effect), but the card needs to be even stronger to work for me. Giving it Charge looks like the most obvious solution to me.
Neoguli
Now this one confuses me. If I just look at this card without much thought, it doesn't appear very attractive, I wouldn't be happy to pull this from a pack. When I take a closer look though, it offers a nice body, HP disruption and a high chance of getting a Treasure. Maybe you can make it a bit more attractive at first glance by lowering the cost to 4 and adjusting the stats accordingly.
MenacingBagel
I'd definitely go with the Rush version if you really are sold on the idea of attacking the Hero Power, but honestly, I'm not. It's not so much the fact that the mechanic isn't in the game yet, but that it doesn't make sense from a flavor point of view. Hero Powers are abilities so you can't really attack them, just like spells. I know that affecting them with spells and battlecries is a thing, but an attacking minion is a very physical thing in my mind and therefore doesn't work out in this case. Maybe other folks don't consider this an issue, just my 2 cents.
BloodMefist
Awesome idea, my favorite card so far! Balance seems just fine for me.
Demonxz95
Quite hard to judge as a whole… I'll start with the simple part: Your reasoning for putting it in DH is solid, it fits the classes flavor very nicely. Your statement about the 1/1/4 statline makes sense for me as well, but the upside of this card is just to big in this case. I'd go with 1/1/3 or 2/1/4. It's also too strong and too complicated for a common, I'd prefer it being a rare. The effect itself might be stronger than it looks since Hero Powers are especially useful in the early stages of the game and DH can very easily attack face each turn due to their 1 Mana HP, so it shouldn't be too hard to remove. All that said, it's a nice idea but my advice would be making it a 1/1/3 rare.
Wailor
Quite creative idea, nice one!
linkblade91
I'd go with 2 turns but use the "disable" wording. The idea is nice overall, but maybe you should look for different art and a new name since the current flavor is a bit too nice for Rogue imho.
The effect basically bounces between players, buffing each one up turn by turn. It can also sometimes act as a soft lock for the enemy hero power if they don't want you to deal more damage to them, they can't use it.
Edit: Not sure if this counts as a symmetrical effect or not, in my head it didn't but now i'm thinking it might.
Bit late to the party this week. I'm following Arkasaur's example and go with a simple approach. Let me know what you think! Will add feedback later today myself.
Sidenote: I'm struggling with the textbox a bit. If I make the font smaller than -2, the text gets split into 4 lines. I tried adding an empty line at the bottom, but that looks weird as well. Guess I'll just go with -2 and accept the overlap with the Attack and Health symbols.
Funnyly enough, the textbox works out well if I give the card the Highlander treatment, so that's defintely an option if you people think the card's too powerful.
LoR art lead shared some concept art of the Aberration on Twitter and confirmed that it's NOT Void ("Ionian Spirit Realm aberration who feeds off of material energy") so that settles it.
I hear that the only way she plays hearthstone is by sitting on a carved wooden throne, looking imperiously down upon her tablet, and occasionally smirking, ever so slightly, at the curious struggle of her opponent.
It’s going to remain the same. Aggro and Combo will remain supreme while control/midrange are left to eat shit. Aggro will still be able to race down control decks because the new tools they are given cost too much and they will still have 0 game against combo decks and questlines.
Much better Initiation (though that's not hard,) it seems alright for holding off board aggression if you can get the Honor Kill consistently, and also as a sneaky way garner extra value out of your own Deathrattle minions.
Also ranking this at 3 stars seemed pretty appropriate.
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
Medivh playing Medivh isn’t weird because Medivh is an alternate hero, not a base hero. I think they have a strict rule that the 10 base heroes shouldn’t have minion counterparts, while alternate heroes are allowed to have them (Medivh, Maiev, Prestor, Vanndar, N’Zoth to name a few)
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
LOL - no team for Arena - for those few that play it, that was obvious
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
And Medivh playing Medivh wasn't weird at all.
Gnomes are supposed to only have 4 fingers.
Really? I played WoW 8 years and never noticed this (mostly because I was playing Horde and was seeing gnomes squished on the ground only).
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
So they adress Scabbs but ignore Xyrella?
Alterac Valley Theorycraft Streams Bring Free Hearthstone Packs to Twitch This Thursday
Alterac Valley Theorycraft Streams Bring Free Hearthstone Packs to Twitch This Thursday
The event is six hours.
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
I'd argue twinspell is better than echo for being made evergreen because it isn't limited to 1-3 mana cards and hence has much larger design space worth exploring over a long period of time. While echo has popped up a few times outside Witchwood, its too narrow to really be common.
That being said, I'd expect either inspire or magnetic to be the one being made evergreen. Inspire is open-ended enough to make sense in the game when there is a lot more support for hero powers than back in TGT, while magnetic is the only thing that distinguishes mechs from other tribes, so they probably should have it long term.
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
Poisouness not causing a honorable kill reminds me of Garrosh vs Cairne.
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
While I do love Magnetic and Mechs in general, I doubt this is the one he was hinting at because Magnetic is essentially nothing but Charge and therefore hard to balance. Wouldn't mind in the least to be wrong though :-)
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
"When designing a new set they do so with Standard in mind first but they do also consider wild."
I could have sworn they said they did not design with wild in mind. Maybe the most recent expect changed that.
Celestalon's Hearthstone Community Q&A #1 - Old Keyword to Return in the Future, Scabbs Fingers Mistake, EDM Playlists, & More
Good thing this was in bold:
There's a few keyword that fit this:
Adapt - Was pretty fun and I'm sure can be used in other themes, I'm sure not only beast can adapt right?
Inspire - The effects would need to be much better than in TGT
Echo - This mechanic was abused in some circumstances but the entire expansion didn't showcase the mechanic well enough.
Magnetic - Probably one of the best mechanics and I know Dean and several devs really enjoying designing this mechanic. This one will probably be the keyword they talking about.
Twinspell - Wasn't bad, but Echo is just way better right?
Fight The Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback:
Get a Taste of Fractured in Alterac Valley Early With Hearthstone Duels - New Cards Are Now Available in Buckets
I don't know if Questine Hunter will be a thing in the upcoming meta, but I have high expectations for the Secret package.
Kennen: New Bandle City & Ionia Champion Reveal - 4 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
Right...I really hope that's not the way it turns out being used...I'd not thought about things like summoning tokens though.
Fight The Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
All out shootout!
The effect basically bounces between players, buffing each one up turn by turn. It can also sometimes act as a soft lock for the enemy hero power if they don't want you to deal more damage to them, they can't use it.
Edit: Not sure if this counts as a symmetrical effect or not, in my head it didn't but now i'm thinking it might.
Alterac Valley Theorycraft Streams Bring Free Hearthstone Packs to Twitch This Thursday
Well... found this funny, it's not even that mean 🤣🤣🤣
Fight The Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Bit late to the party this week. I'm following Arkasaur's example and go with a simple approach. Let me know what you think! Will add feedback later today myself.
Sidenote: I'm struggling with the textbox a bit. If I make the font smaller than -2, the text gets split into 4 lines. I tried adding an empty line at the bottom, but that looks weird as well. Guess I'll just go with -2 and accept the overlap with the Attack and Health symbols.
Funnyly enough, the textbox works out well if I give the card the Highlander treatment, so that's defintely an option if you people think the card's too powerful.
Kennen: New Bandle City & Ionia Champion Reveal - 4 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
And probably much more that i can't remember right now.
Kennen: New Bandle City & Ionia Champion Reveal - 4 New Runeterra Cards Revealed
LoR art lead shared some concept art of the Aberration on Twitter and confirmed that it's NOT Void ("Ionian Spirit Realm aberration who feeds off of material energy") so that settles it.
Chess Grandmaster Garry Kasparov Takes on Hearthstone
I hear that the only way she plays hearthstone is by sitting on a carved wooden throne, looking imperiously down upon her tablet, and occasionally smirking, ever so slightly, at the curious struggle of her opponent.
Hearthstone's December 2021 Card Back, Scarf of the Hearth, Has Arrived! Important Events to Expect This Month
Definitely NOT ;)
Love how cozy and "christmasy" this whole expansion feels =)
What is the Alterac Valley Meta going to be?
It’s going to remain the same. Aggro and Combo will remain supreme while control/midrange are left to eat shit. Aggro will still be able to race down control decks because the new tools they are given cost too much and they will still have 0 game against combo decks and questlines.
New Priest Minion - Spirit Guide
Barrens Priest just might be making a comeback in Alterac.
Greetings.
New Priest Spell - Deliverance
Much better Initiation (though that's not hard,) it seems alright for holding off board aggression if you can get the Honor Kill consistently, and also as a sneaky way garner extra value out of your own Deathrattle minions.
Also ranking this at 3 stars seemed pretty appropriate.