Most of the time you're playing cards for the Battlecry or some other effect, so a little weaker Attack is not going to matter one bit. The cost reduction will be huge though. Especially when you do it twice (or more with recast effects.)
So theoretically your spells could have +14 Spell Damage. That is, if Kobold Geomancer is in Core after rotation, and you would want to put it in your deck. Is Solar Eclipse going away?
In standard, we're only left with Hunter and Mage secrets, and honestly I think the former of the two has been consistently good. Probably just filling out Highlander lists.
Feels like (4) 4/4 is a bit slow, but squeezing out an extra turn of Crusader's or Deputization Aura is pretty good, especially when they made the rule change to allow stacking multiples of the same aura.
We're losing some of the stronger divine shield cards with rotation, so idk. Definitely something to keep an eye on for alter expacs though.
Cards that are already strong don't benefit from the buff as much as smaller minions. I'd often rather bump a 2/3 up to 4/6 than make an 8/8 into a 10/11. The big guy was already killing anything it might fight, but the little guy is now an actual threat where it wasn't before.
Honestly really good at maintaining the pressure/presenting the threat of buffing a dude. Even there are quite a few duds (Origami Dragon comes to mind), just having an extra dude on board when people are trying to deny Shroomcavate + Buff lethals can make the difference.
I'm not a fan of any of the "Wind-up" cards this expansion, mostly because Stormwind's miniset has already shown how slow the whole Trade to Upgrade can really be. That said, probably more potential in Highlander since you can sort of fetch the minion out with Mirages (just don't trade the Mirage into your deck).
These days, there are more potential handbuff/deckbuff targets than ever. Cheating this out is a worthwhile goal, but I'm pretty sure you'll be happy to play it at full Cost in many cases -- assuming you built your deck correctly.
Probably just an Okay card, certainly will make appearances here and there in Highlander lists, but somehow I doubt there will be a dedicated Handbuff Paladin deck. But hey, Lifesteal weapon, potentially setting up a buffed up Leeroy for lethal later, I'm all in for that.
Even ignoring the Miniaturize Keyword, if Shudderblock isn't broken this expansion, he's almost certain to break the next one. The fact that you also get a (1) 1/1 that does the exact same tripler effect is similarly crazy. I'm just glad that the balance team had the forethought to add that "can't damage enemy heroes" as the only drawback, and force people to be more creative.
New Mage Spell - Yogg in the Box
PRAISE BE UNTO YOGG-SARON!
*Blows up own deck with Wheel of Doom*
...HIS WAYS ARE AS MYSTERIOUS AS THEY ARE POWERFUL!
New Neutral Minion - Joymancer Jepetto
Obviously meant to get extra Minis, but I think the reload comes in way too late and potentially too filling to be useful.
New Neutral Minion - Colifero the Artist
Fun, but the deck building of trying to keep a wide token board to turn into Ragnaroses or the like has proven a bit too much to actually use.
New Druid Spell - Ensmallen
Most of the time you're playing cards for the Battlecry or some other effect, so a little weaker Attack is not going to matter one bit. The cost reduction will be huge though. Especially when you do it twice (or more with recast effects.)
New Neutral Minion - Splendiferous Whizbang
A flavorful retrained 5 star card, regardless of how good the decks actually are.
New Neutral Minion - Factory Assemblybot
Kind of an odd "Big" card, since cheating this out means that you often miss out on the Mini.
New Neutral Minion - Origami Dragon
Good way to punish opponents for having big things by stealing the stats first, but I don't think it's worth hard running this card.
New Druid Minion - Sky Mother Aviana
Well, normally a bunch of random Legendaries would be crap, but when they all cost 1, I really doubt that will be the case.
New Druid Minion - Owlonius
So theoretically your spells could have +14 Spell Damage. That is, if Kobold Geomancer is in Core after rotation, and you would want to put it in your deck. Is Solar Eclipse going away?
New Neutral Minion - Observer of Mysteries
In standard, we're only left with Hunter and Mage secrets, and honestly I think the former of the two has been consistently good. Probably just filling out Highlander lists.
New Paladin Minion - Pipsi Painthoof
Seems like a good Big Paladin card, albeit a rather weak pull from Dancing King Kangor.
New Paladin Minion - Cardboard Golem
Feels like (4) 4/4 is a bit slow, but squeezing out an extra turn of Crusader's or Deputization Aura is pretty good, especially when they made the rule change to allow stacking multiples of the same aura.
New Paladin Spell - Fancy Packaging
Cards that are already strong don't benefit from the buff as much as smaller minions. I'd often rather bump a 2/3 up to 4/6 than make an 8/8 into a 10/11. The big guy was already killing anything it might fight, but the little guy is now an actual threat where it wasn't before.
New Shaman Minion - Sand Art Elemental
Normally I'd think this is just an Okay card, but combining it with Turn the Tides does give out a lot of damage.
New Shaman Minion - Shudderblock
Can't wait to see the n00bs wasting the Battlecry on the mini. (Spoiler: It won't do anything.)
New Shaman Spell - Pop-Up Book
Fantastic value when played just before Wish Upon a Star, but still quite good without it.
New Paladin Spell - Crafter's Aura
Honestly really good at maintaining the pressure/presenting the threat of buffing a dude. Even there are quite a few duds (Origami Dragon comes to mind), just having an extra dude on board when people are trying to deny Shroomcavate + Buff lethals can make the difference.
New Shaman Location - Fairy Tale Forest
I love Locations, and I especially love Locations that draw cards. Now we have one that can tutor?! This is an absolute game-changer.
New Shaman Spell - Baking Soda Volcano
I have a feeling 10 damage is going to feel very small and pitiful in the coming year, especially if you're counting on this as a full clear.
New Paladin Minion - Wind-Up Enforcer
I'm not a fan of any of the "Wind-up" cards this expansion, mostly because Stormwind's miniset has already shown how slow the whole Trade to Upgrade can really be. That said, probably more potential in Highlander since you can sort of fetch the minion out with Mirages (just don't trade the Mirage into your deck).
New Shaman Spell - Wish Upon a Star
These days, there are more potential handbuff/deckbuff targets than ever. Cheating this out is a worthwhile goal, but I'm pretty sure you'll be happy to play it at full Cost in many cases -- assuming you built your deck correctly.
New Paladin Weapon - Painter's Virtue
Probably just an Okay card, certainly will make appearances here and there in Highlander lists, but somehow I doubt there will be a dedicated Handbuff Paladin deck. But hey, Lifesteal weapon, potentially setting up a buffed up Leeroy for lethal later, I'm all in for that.
New Shaman Minion - Shudderblock
Even ignoring the Miniaturize Keyword, if Shudderblock isn't broken this expansion, he's almost certain to break the next one. The fact that you also get a (1) 1/1 that does the exact same tripler effect is similarly crazy. I'm just glad that the balance team had the forethought to add that "can't damage enemy heroes" as the only drawback, and force people to be more creative.
New Shaman Minion - Shining Sentinel
Get it buffed up with Wish Upon a Star and suddenly the opponent needs to start hard running Twisted Nether or Brawl.
New Shaman Spell - Once Upon a Time...
Just a board filler. Not a bad one mind you, you do get a good amount of stats for the cost, but it doesn't really have much utility outside of that.