While this card has no rush, remember that Hunter has access not only to [Hearthstone Card (Broomstick) Not Found], but also [Hearthstone Card (Trueaim Bow) Not Found] and Devouring Swarm. Will this suffice? I do not think so, but less because of this card not having rush but the trickiness of sticking a wide board of beasts that curves well into this card. Sin'dorei Scentfinder and Rodent Nest require effort to pull off as well and that just asks for too much.
Elemental Shaman has it all. Aggression, removal, manacheat and healing. The deck can take whichever direction it wants and there is noone to stop it. Besides, this card is pretty much required in Quest Shaman to both survive until the quest completion and enhance the quest.
Ok i guess i have to rework my card are little - overall it is fine but a few people said it has not enough Tradeable flavour.
I mean the OP said:
You must create a card with Tradeable, or that synergises with the Tradeable mechanic
We're looking for direct synergies like Auctioneer Jaxon, not something more tangential.
I mean it is a Tradeable card - the OP said make this or that not both … but i guess if it will hurt my rating im going to rework it.
Edit:
Here is my first rework:
Hopefully it now has enough Tradeable Flavour :) - even tough im not sure if it is not too strong now - maybe get rid of the Immune? … also had the Idea that whenever this gets traded that the Attack will increase or something like that.
That's not what I meant by "Tradeable flavor". What I mean by "Tradeable flavor" is that most cards with Tradeable represent some aspect of acquisition whether it be something that acquire (such as Heavy Plate, Fire Sale, or Imported Tarantula) or a person that you acquire the item from (such as Impatient Shopkeep, Persistent Peddler, or Shady Bartender). Some of these are a little bit more broad when it comes to their theme of acquisition like City Tax or Overdraft, but the flavor idea is still there. You can argue some exceptions may exist, but for the most part, Tradeable cards all share this style of flavor.
Your card lacks Tradeable flavor because it doesn't have the flavor of acquisition that existing Tradeable cards have. It's not an item or service to buy, or a person who would offer that item or service. It's just a big hulking demon. Is he going to trade his axe with you? Is that why your hero gets the +1 Attack from when you Trade him? I could reasonably buy that, but the general flavor of the card doesn't make this too apparent. It would do a better job if the card had different art or even just a different name to suggest that he's a demonic ally who can trade weapons with you.
And I also agree with AeroJulwin. Another problem with the card is that the only reason you'd ever use it is just to use its on-Trade effect since you would never want to play a 5 mana 4/4 with no other effect. I like Tradeable cards that have a bonus effect when Traded, but there should probably also be a reason to actually play the card as opposed to just using it for trading.
This is basically giving rush to all of your minions or windfury, if they can already attack and "draws" cards, while being some sort of hardremoval. This card will shine in Deathrattle Hunter, Rat Hunter, Boar Hunter and as a random discover in other decks. 0 Mana Spells are also great fodder for the quest, Kolkar and Lock and Load.
Worse Scorpid. You only discover "bad" cards. I also do not see this in normal priest decks due to screwing up Raise Dead. Shadow Priest might want it though, to get access to certain holy spells.
So, it's easy to finish the quest, but the reward is a bit lacking... true you keep a board replenish, some damage and a weapon always equipped, but by that time, a Pirate Warrior deck should have already an advantage over the opponent (I'm a wild player, so dunno about in standard).
Maybe in a Pirate Control archetype, but it's not very convincing.
Not an amazing card, but it can net you some "tutoring" for something you want that you don't need to run in your deck... Still, almost every class has access to other Discover mechanics (even with neutrals), that are better.
Why does a card like this exists? Even if Recruit was the best keyword out there... It's too costly, it has bad stat distribution, and doesn't even have Taunt...
New Warlock Minion - Entitled Customer
Nice, I think it enables handlock again :D
New Warlock Minion - Entitled Customer
Insane Boardclear with a body -> This must be included in every Control WL.
New Hunter Minion - Stormwind Piper
While this card has no rush, remember that Hunter has access not only to [Hearthstone Card (Broomstick) Not Found], but also [Hearthstone Card (Trueaim Bow) Not Found] and Devouring Swarm. Will this suffice? I do not think so, but less because of this card not having rush but the trickiness of sticking a wide board of beasts that curves well into this card. Sin'dorei Scentfinder and Rodent Nest require effort to pull off as well and that just asks for too much.
New Warrior Minion - Stormwind Freebooter
Similar to Scalerider, which saw play. A bit less flexible but it also has no condition. Yes, this is a solid card.
New Warrior Minion - Harbor Scamp
Overstatted card, especially if you consider the tutor. This is bonkers in any deck that runs pirates.
New Shaman Minion - Canal Slogger
Elemental Shaman has it all. Aggression, removal, manacheat and healing. The deck can take whichever direction it wants and there is noone to stop it. Besides, this card is pretty much required in Quest Shaman to both survive until the quest completion and enhance the quest.
The Best Deals Anywhere - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
That's not what I meant by "Tradeable flavor". What I mean by "Tradeable flavor" is that most cards with Tradeable represent some aspect of acquisition whether it be something that acquire (such as Heavy Plate, Fire Sale, or Imported Tarantula) or a person that you acquire the item from (such as Impatient Shopkeep, Persistent Peddler, or Shady Bartender). Some of these are a little bit more broad when it comes to their theme of acquisition like City Tax or Overdraft, but the flavor idea is still there. You can argue some exceptions may exist, but for the most part, Tradeable cards all share this style of flavor.
Your card lacks Tradeable flavor because it doesn't have the flavor of acquisition that existing Tradeable cards have. It's not an item or service to buy, or a person who would offer that item or service. It's just a big hulking demon. Is he going to trade his axe with you? Is that why your hero gets the +1 Attack from when you Trade him? I could reasonably buy that, but the general flavor of the card doesn't make this too apparent. It would do a better job if the card had different art or even just a different name to suggest that he's a demonic ally who can trade weapons with you.
And I also agree with AeroJulwin. Another problem with the card is that the only reason you'd ever use it is just to use its on-Trade effect since you would never want to play a 5 mana 4/4 with no other effect. I like Tradeable cards that have a bonus effect when Traded, but there should probably also be a reason to actually play the card as opposed to just using it for trading.
New Hunter Spell - Devouring Swarm
This is basically giving rush to all of your minions or windfury, if they can already attack and "draws" cards, while being some sort of hardremoval. This card will shine in Deathrattle Hunter, Rat Hunter, Boar Hunter and as a random discover in other decks. 0 Mana Spells are also great fodder for the quest, Kolkar and Lock and Load.
New Neutral Minion - Pandaren Importer
Worse Scorpid. You only discover "bad" cards. I also do not see this in normal priest decks due to screwing up Raise Dead. Shadow Priest might want it though, to get access to certain holy spells.
New Hunter Spell - Devouring Swarm
Elwynn Boar support.
Reno Hunter support.
Deathrattle Hunter support.
Even synergises with the questline being at 0 mana, great card overall.
New Shaman Minion - Canal Slogger
Wow, now the Elemental package receives healing also. I guess Elemental Shaman will stick around for at least another expansion, which I like though!
New Warrior Minion - Harbor Scamp
2 mana 2/2 draw something you need.
Excellent card for the archetype.
New Warrior Minion - Stormwind Freebooter
Tempo card for a quick deck in a strong archetype.
There's gonna be a lot of new "Yahar!" this expansion.
New Hunter Minion - Stormwind Piper
If this had rush, it'd be 5/5. Without it, 2/5, nobody is going to ignore this when it comes into play.
New Warlock Minion - Entitled Customer
Even, Control, Reno, Handlock... every Warlock deck could use this, so I guess it could become staple in the class?
New Warrior Minion - Remote-Controlled Golem
Either Wild or arena/duels card.
The Dr. can always make use of cheap board clears and control tools.
New Warrior Spell - Raid the Docks
So, it's easy to finish the quest, but the reward is a bit lacking... true you keep a board replenish, some damage and a weapon always equipped, but by that time, a Pirate Warrior deck should have already an advantage over the opponent (I'm a wild player, so dunno about in standard).
Maybe in a Pirate Control archetype, but it's not very convincing.
New Hunter Spell - Devouring Swarm
Potential to be very dangerous, especially in Boar and Rat King decks.
New Neutral Minion - Nobleman
Empty your hand and copy a specific card... but is that worth it?
New Neutral Minion - Northshire Farmer
I guess you can have some 3/3 boars for the Sword of Thousand Truths "quest". Still... dunno, not convinced by it.
New Neutral Minion - Pandaren Importer
Not an amazing card, but it can net you some "tutoring" for something you want that you don't need to run in your deck... Still, almost every class has access to other Discover mechanics (even with neutrals), that are better.
New Warrior Minion - Cowardly Grunt
Why does a card like this exists? Even if Recruit was the best keyword out there... It's too costly, it has bad stat distribution, and doesn't even have Taunt...
I guess they needed a filler card.
New Neutral Minion - Royal Librarian
Spellbreaker is crying in a corner now.
New Neutral Minion - Deeprun Engineer
Meh card. Not worth a place in any deck ATM.
New Warrior Minion - Cargo Guard
They might as well add Taunt to this card. No way this card does not get removed asap.