Tradeable cards need to be situational. If the right situation might be coming up, you keep the card. Otherwise you trade it. Hero Immunity is something Demon Hunter can profit from in many situations (the first card didn't have a lot of value to trade), so I understand as to why a change was necessary.
The issue I see with the new version is the exact opposite: it doesn't have any value to play. Who would want a 5-cost 4/4 if you can get a different card AND Attack/Immunity for the turn for only 1 Mana instead?
I hope this explanation helps you with your final design. I think you're on to something!
I assume the final reward takes a permanent spot on your board. I've said on some other questlines that they have weaker rewards but are easier to complete. This one looks pretty easy to complete, and the reward looks very powerful.
If the power was “draw from your deck”, you’d get whatever the card is, and it wouldn’t matter whether she was golden. But as I read the power, she basically eats the card, then her deathrattle creates a new copy of the card in your hand—so I think it would follow the rule of “golden cards generate golden cards”.
Also, if you trigger her deathrattle early (e.g. with Feign Death) I think you’d get all her stored cards then, and then get those cards *again* when she dies?
New Shaman Minion - Canal Slogger
Amazing elemental to add in a control shaman archetype.
New Neutral Minion - Lion's Guard
A nice control tool, amazing arena card, but if you need to play it in arena it means you're behind 50% of the time.
It's Hurt Warlock support.
New Shaman Minion - Granite Forgeborn
Absurdly powerful card in a cool archetype.
New Priest Minion - Voidtouched Attendant
Could be decent in Standard. It's got 3 health for 1 mana, and it works with more than just the Shadow stuff.
Wild: Razakus Priest will have a Field Day with this.
New Neutral Minion - Royal Librarian
Run in Zoolock, but you're probably too focused on your own strategy to remember to include this in your deck. Still a good card tho.
New Neutral Minion - Nobleman
If he targeted a specific type of card, I could see running him. As is, he's too random in value, so he is just gold-plated trash.
New Priest Minion - Darkbishop Benedictus
YES. 100% Yes. I don't give a shit whether this is Top-Tier, or some Meme trash, Shadow Priest looks fun. Day 1 craft!
New Warrior Minion - Cargo Guard
They're clearly intending Questline Warrior to be a much slower deck than Pirate Warriors of the past. Also good overall for Control Warrior.
Questing in Stormwind - Better Understanding Druid's Lost in the Park Legendary Questline
Loving your articles, Echo! Great food for thought, indeed. Looking forward to reading all the Quest lines.
New Warrior Spell - Raid the Docks
Easy conditions and an insane payoff. That's just too good...
... there's got to be a Hook to this.
The Best Deals Anywhere - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Feedback for FieselFitz
The issue I see with the new version is the exact opposite: it doesn't have any value to play. Who would want a 5-cost 4/4 if you can get a different card AND Attack/Immunity for the turn for only 1 Mana instead?
I hope this explanation helps you with your final design. I think you're on to something!
New Warrior Spell - Raid the Docks
Perfect addition to Pirate warrior in Standard. In Wild it is too slow and does not add more value to the perfect builds out there.
New Warrior Minion - Cargo Guard
Defensive Pirates? First we had Sword Eater, now this! Maybe there's gonna be some control-ish Pirate Warrior with these cards and Raid the Docks?
New Neutral Minion - Nobleman
Bad card for constructed, but value card for Arena or Duels. Somehow I feel the art does not fit well into HS though.
New Warrior Spell - Raid the Docks
I assume the final reward takes a permanent spot on your board. I've said on some other questlines that they have weaker rewards but are easier to complete. This one looks pretty easy to complete, and the reward looks very powerful.
New Warrior Minion - Remote-Controlled Golem
I could imagine that should get at least two triggers off of this on average, which would mean 4 Tokens. That seems quite solid to me.
If only it weren't for the poor interaction those have with N'Zoth, God of the Deep. That, at least for the moment, kills this card.
New Warrior Minion - Stormwind Freebooter
Decent but also underwhelming, there are plenty of better Pirate options out there. OK when discovered I guess.
Enthusiastic Banker
If the power was “draw from your deck”, you’d get whatever the card is, and it wouldn’t matter whether she was golden. But as I read the power, she basically eats the card, then her deathrattle creates a new copy of the card in your hand—so I think it would follow the rule of “golden cards generate golden cards”.
Also, if you trigger her deathrattle early (e.g. with Feign Death) I think you’d get all her stored cards then, and then get those cards *again* when she dies?
New Warrior Minion - Harbor Scamp
Warrior's version of Investment Opportunity, except with a 2/2 body, and is also the type of card it draws.
New Priest Weapon - Shadowcloth Needle
Auto include in the new Shadow Priest archetype. I will definitely take this weapon for a spin on launch day.
New Warrior Minion - Stormwind Freebooter
Seems decent. Sort of like rush, except your hero takes the damage. Not really sure what else to say about this one.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
You can't miss this fin.
New Hunter Spell - Devouring Swarm
This is good. Great with boars.
New Hunter Minion - Stormwind Piper
Awkward and slow.
New Neutral Minion - Mailbox Dancer
The trick is never let him die. EZ.