Made some changes to Circus Puppeteer and to Opening Act.
I have some doubts about the Puppeteer wording. The way it's now, If he's Sapped ir Silenced, you keep the stoled minion, but I don't know how to correct this, since Hearthstone don't have a "Leave the Battlefield" type of ability.
Changed the effect of Opening Act to be less strong and keep the flavour of a Opening tô a bigger show.
Maybe it's too early for hints, but I want to make this clear: Each of the 3 paragraphs refers to a different card. All three have something in common - the card that is the final solution. Also the first line doesn't matter much, it's just for flavor.
I don't really know that much about WoW lore, but that bit fron WoWpedia makes me like the skin a lot more. Way better than a "baby Anduin" skin that almost no one would want/like. I hope the Anduin Book of Heroes (Whenever it drops, based on the real Book of Heroes order.) will make me like Anduin more, cuz whenever i see play against a priest i just get really mild amounts of ptsd from all my games against Ress & Big Priests.
In WoW, Anduin is one of the most likable guys around. He's the guy that has the will and power to try to make the world a better place, but the world refuses to comply for more than a few months at a time. So he somehow found a way for a king to have an underdog story.
I have my doubts about how well his story translates into the BoH because he's a pacifist, but there have been plenty of 'fights' that have really just been debates/arguments so I'm sure they have worked something out.
That mistake is only made once, and to be honest you would have prior knowledge anyway because it is likely you would have played Anduin's BoH before encountering it in constructed.
Plus, if rogue can use cards from every class, can we not argue that all classes are just a subset of the rogue class? :P
I finally found the artwork for the idea I had in mind. I'm afraid the final result is a bit to wordy, even if I'm quite satisfied with its balance and flavor.
Besides that, I think the most interesting version is the last one, although it is incredibly overpriced. Compare it to Command the Illidari, which summons almost the max amount of Illidaris and costs 1 less. I think a fair price would be 3 or 4 at max.
linkblade91
Show Spoiler
Both versions are neat and flavorful, but I'd say I prefer the second one, since it feels more like a Legendary card.
Demonxz95
Show Spoiler
Solid card. I think it's a bit too strong, though. With the right deck building, it will often draw you two on-curve cards, which is a bit too strong for a body which is not terrible for the mana cost.
ChickyChick
Show Spoiler
Exotic Species is my favorite of the bunch, probably. It's not super faire related, but it's not too big of a stretch.
Circus Trickster is a bit weird, if only because it's a Rogue card that gets you a specific Mage card. I get that Rogue is supposed to be the Burgle class, but getting one specific spell from another class feels a bit random.
Darkmoon Race is even less faire related than Exotic Species, and the fact that it's a Sidequest from an expansion that didn't feature them makes it a bit strange.
shatterstar1998
Show Spoiler
Hey! I remember you from HearthPwn. Glad to see you!
Like most people, I think Knife Trick is your better card, even if I find it a bit weird that it can be used as a Myra's Unstable Element if your enemy has no minions.
anchorm4n
Show Spoiler
ETC Groupie is cool, but it's not faire related.
Goblin Mime, on the other hand, is quite cool, although I'd make it a Priest card. The name could be better, too.
DestroyerR
Show Spoiler
I like it a lot :)
DavnanKillder
Show Spoiler
Circus Puppeteer is definetly the best of the bunch. It's wording is a bit off, though.
Damn this competition is moving SSSSSLLLLLOOOOOWWWWW. I figured people would be more pumped for this comp given that it's the season 2 finale.
But ah well, I guess I should give feedback then.
Nirast
I prefer the second version. The first version seems too OP and the third version is very weak. It would also be in the same set as Expendable Performers which may falter the card a bit.
Linkblade91
The second one might get some negative votes on the basis that it's "choosing on your opponent's turn" even though the way it is right now is technically correct. I like the first version better anyway.
Wailor
I do like Tamer's Whip. The connection is fairly loose (no pun intended), but it's obvious that it's there.
Grim Fortune is kinda cool. I view it kinda like a guaranteed Doomsayer, though I'm not sure the 3 extra mana justifies this as the card is otherwise slow. As Shatterstar pointed out, you are also using the same art as Dark Prophecy.
ChickyChick
Even though Exotic Species does flavorfully make sense, most people are not fans of Zombeasts outside ofDeathstalker Rexxar, and I'd have to say that I'm in the same group (which is slightly hypocritical of me to say since I made a Zombeast card earlier this season, but what can you do?).
Circus Trickster is alright, but I've never been a huge fan of class cards that specifically generate a class card from another class except in very specific situations. It's otherwise not a bad card though.
Darkmoon Race is certainly flavorful, but it seems much more Epic than Common, and it's a Sidequest outside of Galakrond's Awakening (or a custom set) which some people, myself included, will dock points for.
Shatterstar1998
Hey, good to see you back here!
I am in the same boat as everyone else in that I prefer Knife Trick over Hit the Bullseye! My only concern is that while Knife Trick may not be gamebreaking, some people will negatively vote cards that break class weaknesses regardless of how good the card is. This isn't really fair to you as the card is fine, but it is unfortunately the reality of these competitions. I do personally like the card though. One other thing is that the card is called Fan of Knives. Slight wording error there.
Anchorm4n
Goblin Mime is a really cool card. I tried to make a mime card myself with this art, and couldn't do it (because I tried to theme it around Silence), so I'm glad to see that you were able to.
I like that E.T.C Groupie provided Menagerie Warrior another tribe to play with, but the card is quite weak. It is understandable not wanting to make a card like Sorcerer's Apprentice, but Rush minions are quite a bit harder to chain than spells (or Demons in the case of Kanrethad Ebonlocke), so it can probably be 2 mana without any issues.
DestroyerR
Well this card certainly is a destroyer, so your username checks out! (lmao)
I'm surprised we haven't seen a card like this in the game before, so I like it. I do actually like that it doesn't trigger Deathrattles because it makes it different than all the fan-made cards of this design that I've seen before.
DavnanKillder
I don't like that Opening Act can be a 1 mana 4/4 Taunt if you play it on turn 1. And even if you don't, a guaranteed 3 mana 4/4 Taunt is still pretty good.
Clown Fiesta is too weak. As Shatterstar pointed out, it's a worse Potion of Polymorph. I also don't like that it would exist in the same set as Rigged Faire Game since classes never get more than one Secret in any given set unless it's Classic, or if it's Rogue getting new Secrets for the first time in years.
Circus Puppeteer is alright. One weird thing though is the Deathrattle. Does the "give it back" part activate even if the stolen minion dies?
This is a beautiful Priest skin? Well it looks more like a rogue skin.. I'm unsure for which class this skin will be? Wait a second Thief priest is a thing, so probably a priest skin. Although i would LOVE a Dual class skin, that would be AMAZING! But i don't think they would ever do that because it would be "too confusing" :( . I like Thief priest* and i would love to use this skin once the Priest Book of Heroes drops. (Of course depending on when it releases, and what the real Book of Heroes order is.) Sure this most likely will be one of those "no new voicelines/animations" kinda skins, but at least Anduins emotes aren't the worst. (At least it will hopefully keep the memey/annoying "wow" emote.)
I don't really know that much about WoW lore, but that bit fron WoWpedia makes me like the skin a lot more. Way better than a "baby Anduin" skin that almost no one would want/like. I hope the Anduin Book of Heroes (Whenever it drops, based on the real Book of Heroes order.) will make me like Anduin more, cuz whenever i see play against a priest i just get really mild amounts of ptsd from all my games against Ress & Big Priests.
I would say that due to the number of Secret Mages running around top tier these days, that including another Eater of Secrets would be a good thing. Secret hate is key to them not running over your face.
Wouldn't you want to include another way to yank Ragnaros the Firelord out of your deck other than just Shadow Essence? To me this just seems like you only have 3 opportunities to get him out of you deck. Even though it is a substantially higher cost card, why not Blood of G'huun? That way when you rez, if he's in your deck you get another 5/5 that can be rezed as well
Then I simply misunderstood your first comment: "Just don't assume everyone else in the world shares your opinions." thinking you chose a particular side. My apologies for that.
To summarize, you don't care about XP. I do care and that's the end of our discussion.
I think Rune Dagger could do wonders with Ras Frostwhisper in a potential post-rotation Control Shaman: being able to get Spell Damage at will is insane when you have effects like Ras' one.
The support is definitely not here yet and it will take a lot for my idea to be viable, but still...
I am really intrigued by these builds. I've been wanting to knock out a Legend status in Wild with Priest for a while that doesn't necessarily have to use Highlander. I am looking forward to trying these out.
Card Design Conversation - Kith And Kin
I'd play that. I'd play that hard. I'd play that soooo hard.
Fond Fairewell - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks for the feedback guys.
Made some changes to Circus Puppeteer and to Opening Act.
I have some doubts about the Puppeteer wording. The way it's now, If he's Sapped ir Silenced, you keep the stoled minion, but I don't know how to correct this, since Hearthstone don't have a "Leave the Battlefield" type of ability.
Changed the effect of Opening Act to be less strong and keep the flavour of a Opening tô a bigger show.
Maybe some feedback tomorrow.
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
The most useful thing he did in that fight happened when he stopped using his sword...
There's also a difference between talent and skill. If he's any good with heavy weapons it's through hard work, not natural aptitude (aka talent).
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Nope.
Maybe it's too early for hints, but I want to make this clear: Each of the 3 paragraphs refers to a different card. All three have something in common - the card that is the final solution. Also the first line doesn't matter much, it's just for flavor.
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
Runeterra Patch 2.0 - Go Hard Nerfed, New Co-Op vs AI Lab, Cosmic Creation Expedition Bonus Removed
Well, deserved nerf indeed, still a good can in my opinion but has waaaaaay more counter play at 5.
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
In WoW, Anduin is one of the most likable guys around. He's the guy that has the will and power to try to make the world a better place, but the world refuses to comply for more than a few months at a time. So he somehow found a way for a king to have an underdog story.
I have my doubts about how well his story translates into the BoH because he's a pacifist, but there have been plenty of 'fights' that have really just been debates/arguments so I'm sure they have worked something out.
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
That mistake is only made once, and to be honest you would have prior knowledge anyway because it is likely you would have played Anduin's BoH before encountering it in constructed.
Plus, if rogue can use cards from every class, can we not argue that all classes are just a subset of the rogue class? :P
Fond Fairewell - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I finally found the artwork for the idea I had in mind. I'm afraid the final result is a bit to wordy, even if I'm quite satisfied with its balance and flavor.
Feedback:
Nirast
Besides that, I think the most interesting version is the last one, although it is incredibly overpriced. Compare it to Command the Illidari, which summons almost the max amount of Illidaris and costs 1 less. I think a fair price would be 3 or 4 at max.
linkblade91
Demonxz95
ChickyChick
Circus Trickster is a bit weird, if only because it's a Rogue card that gets you a specific Mage card. I get that Rogue is supposed to be the Burgle class, but getting one specific spell from another class feels a bit random.
Darkmoon Race is even less faire related than Exotic Species, and the fact that it's a Sidequest from an expansion that didn't feature them makes it a bit strange.
shatterstar1998
Like most people, I think Knife Trick is your better card, even if I find it a bit weird that it can be used as a Myra's Unstable Element if your enemy has no minions.
anchorm4n
Goblin Mime, on the other hand, is quite cool, although I'd make it a Priest card. The name could be better, too.
DestroyerR
DavnanKillder
Runeterra Patch 2.0 - Go Hard Nerfed, New Co-Op vs AI Lab, Cosmic Creation Expedition Bonus Removed
This is a good start but more work need to be done ( looking at you Fortune Croaker and The Grand Plaza).
Fond Fairewell - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Damn this competition is moving SSSSSLLLLLOOOOOWWWWW. I figured people would be more pumped for this comp given that it's the season 2 finale.
But ah well, I guess I should give feedback then.
I do like Tamer's Whip. The connection is fairly loose (no pun intended), but it's obvious that it's there.
Grim Fortune is kinda cool. I view it kinda like a guaranteed Doomsayer, though I'm not sure the 3 extra mana justifies this as the card is otherwise slow. As Shatterstar pointed out, you are also using the same art as Dark Prophecy.
Even though Exotic Species does flavorfully make sense, most people are not fans of Zombeasts outside ofDeathstalker Rexxar, and I'd have to say that I'm in the same group (which is slightly hypocritical of me to say since I made a Zombeast card earlier this season, but what can you do?).
Circus Trickster is alright, but I've never been a huge fan of class cards that specifically generate a class card from another class except in very specific situations. It's otherwise not a bad card though.
Darkmoon Race is certainly flavorful, but it seems much more Epic than Common, and it's a Sidequest outside of Galakrond's Awakening (or a custom set) which some people, myself included, will dock points for.
Hey, good to see you back here!
I am in the same boat as everyone else in that I prefer Knife Trick over Hit the Bullseye! My only concern is that while Knife Trick may not be gamebreaking, some people will negatively vote cards that break class weaknesses regardless of how good the card is. This isn't really fair to you as the card is fine, but it is unfortunately the reality of these competitions. I do personally like the card though. One other thing is that the card is called Fan of Knives. Slight wording error there.
Goblin Mime is a really cool card. I tried to make a mime card myself with this art, and couldn't do it (because I tried to theme it around Silence), so I'm glad to see that you were able to.
I like that E.T.C Groupie provided Menagerie Warrior another tribe to play with, but the card is quite weak. It is understandable not wanting to make a card like Sorcerer's Apprentice, but Rush minions are quite a bit harder to chain than spells (or Demons in the case of Kanrethad Ebonlocke), so it can probably be 2 mana without any issues.
Well this card certainly is a destroyer, so your username checks out! (lmao)
I'm surprised we haven't seen a card like this in the game before, so I like it. I do actually like that it doesn't trigger Deathrattles because it makes it different than all the fan-made cards of this design that I've seen before.
I don't like that Opening Act can be a 1 mana 4/4 Taunt if you play it on turn 1. And even if you don't, a guaranteed 3 mana 4/4 Taunt is still pretty good.
Clown Fiesta is too weak. As Shatterstar pointed out, it's a worse Potion of Polymorph. I also don't like that it would exist in the same set as Rigged Faire Game since classes never get more than one Secret in any given set unless it's Classic, or if it's Rogue getting new Secrets for the first time in years.
Circus Puppeteer is alright. One weird thing though is the Deathrattle. Does the "give it back" part activate even if the stolen minion dies?
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
This is a beautiful Priest skin? Well it looks more like a rogue skin.. I'm unsure for which class this skin will be? Wait a second Thief priest is a thing, so probably a priest skin. Although i would LOVE a Dual class skin, that would be AMAZING! But i don't think they would ever do that because it would be "too confusing" :( . I like Thief priest* and i would love to use this skin once the Priest Book of Heroes drops. (Of course depending on when it releases, and what the real Book of Heroes order is.) Sure this most likely will be one of those "no new voicelines/animations" kinda skins, but at least Anduins emotes aren't the worst. (At least it will hopefully keep the memey/annoying "wow" emote.)
I don't really know that much about WoW lore, but that bit fron WoWpedia makes me like the skin a lot more. Way better than a "baby Anduin" skin that almost no one would want/like. I hope the Anduin Book of Heroes (Whenever it drops, based on the real Book of Heroes order.) will make me like Anduin more, cuz whenever i see play against a priest i just get really mild amounts of ptsd from all my games against Ress & Big Priests.
*I like the ones in wild with Princess Talanji, Drakonid Operative, Shifting Shade, Cloning Device and so on. Not the annoying "haha Galakrond, the Unspeakable goes [insert Heropower or Invoke noice] decks."
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (The Resurrection Attempt)
Branching Paths
Was the Book of Heroes Anduin Skin Accidentally Leaked?!
Cool art, super weird though..
Inner Fire Priest
On the other hand, that would be two dead draws against all other matchups.
I mean: if you really want to bully Mages then yes, it's a good inclusion; otherwise I think one should be enough.
Inner Fire Priest
I would say that due to the number of Secret Mages running around top tier these days, that including another Eater of Secrets would be a good thing. Secret hate is key to them not running over your face.
CONCERNEDMOM's Ragnaros Priest
Wouldn't you want to include another way to yank Ragnaros the Firelord out of your deck other than just Shadow Essence? To me this just seems like you only have 3 opportunities to get him out of you deck. Even though it is a substantially higher cost card, why not Blood of G'huun? That way when you rez, if he's in your deck you get another 5/5 that can be rezed as well
Opinion: The Current State of Quests in Hearthstone and Its Impact on the Rewards Track
Then I simply misunderstood your first comment: "Just don't assume everyone else in the world shares your opinions." thinking you chose a particular side. My apologies for that.
To summarize, you don't care about XP. I do care and that's the end of our discussion.
Cheers!
Double OTK Priest
Decks like this make me want to craft Prophet Velen
Miracle Priest
IF it's Miracle, why not include Lyra the Sunshard? Combine that with Nazmani Bloodweaver and you should be able to a lot of casting each turn right?
Struggling Against Shaman? Try Our Elemental Mage Deck List & Guide for Darkmoon Faire
I think Rune Dagger could do wonders with Ras Frostwhisper in a potential post-rotation Control Shaman: being able to get Spell Damage at will is insane when you have effects like Ras' one.
The support is definitely not here yet and it will take a lot for my idea to be viable, but still...
The Light Shall Burn You! Priest Darkmoon Faire Wild Deck Spotlight
I am really intrigued by these builds. I've been wanting to knock out a Legend status in Wild with Priest for a while that doesn't necessarily have to use Highlander. I am looking forward to trying these out.
Runeterra Patch 2.0 - Go Hard Nerfed, New Co-Op vs AI Lab, Cosmic Creation Expedition Bonus Removed
why they did not fix hush killing units is that in the card mechanic ?
Throw a Snowball - Complete to earn 25 Snowflakes bug
Hahahha got it! My duty as a developer was to report it :)
Auchenai Soulpriest
Comment.