All Comments

I was expecting no less from year of the Phoenix - maybe more ... - but definitely no less

Murloc pally is once more proven to be tenacious and resilient

Probably a Prime that shuffles in an Extra Thicc Voidlord.

Now Rogue will be able to discover 5 Ice Block in a singe turn (would need a help of Preparation for that, but still)

pretty sure they made it intentionally this time. This is supposed to take a lot to remove since it's a legendary.

The reason Miscreant was nerfed is because it wasn't a continous effect and just gave you overwhelming stats for an already good instant effect.

The only way this would be nerfed is if it literally becomes so hard to deal with that playing it on 2 is basically a free win.

It looked nice for a moment, buuuut

its bad for just one reason - it comes back on your turn, which means that you must wait another turn only to attack with it

This one is legendary, and its usage is limited by the necessity of Secrets.

Miscreant is more versatile and also creates Lackeys, which are huge Tempo minions, while this guy only generates Value.

It is surely over the charts with stats and effects, but its limited versatility will likely keep it in check.

sure, but it boosts the overall consistency while being a good card by itself.

The main point was that once you combo this your Vendetta is immediately active, which helps with protecting it and as long as he's alive you will always have an activator in hand which helps Fence.

Perfect card for a highlander secret rogue deck if the other 3 secrets are ok.

You need two cards, and one of which is a singular copy in the deck. There's better cards to activate vendetta and fencer, if that's the goal.

1/5 easily, just a bad card.

Edit: I will elaborate: it will be easily removed most of the time 3 hp is really nothing to deal with on turn 3, and then deal other 3 that can't retaliate?

Those stats are solid.
The mana cost is solid.
The effect is above average.
If it sticks, it perpetuates card generation.

If the baseline Rogue secrets are worth playing, this is a no brainer include.

I know who you are

NEAT! 5 health for 2 mana will absolutely see play. 

wonder if it'll be nerfed, tho, the EVIL combo minion had the same stat line at 3 mana and he was nerfed for being "too hard to remove" 

This sounds like a pretty reliable way to get non-Rogue cards to activate Vendetta and Fence

Rotation is a good opportunity to try to build toward some kind of archetype like Secret Rogue, and Shadowjeweler Hanar could prove to be interesting support for a Secret/Thief Rogue, but without a sense of the full scope of the available secrets in Rogue, it's pretty hard to judge. At the moment, I think it's a bit underwhelming on its own, but Blackjack Stunner is good enough that this could be a good, but non-critical, reload tool for that deck.

2 Mana 1/5 with synergy. will def see play

Secret Thief Rogue.

And reference to Thanos and the Infinity Gems.

The flavor is over 9000!

Rogue never fails me with insta-crafts.

Sounds funky. 2-mana 1/5s are difficult to get rid off so you can often just slam this on turn 2 and get away with it. Moreover this makes any secret Rogue will get much more playable just because it essentially doubles up.

Technically he also protects himself through discovered secrets. If he wasn't a legendary he'd be broken.

5 Health for 2 Mana is very high. It pretty much makes sure youl get at least 1 Secret from him (or 2 if their from Paladin). 

Never thought we'd be seeing Secret Rogue :p

Stop asking Questions!  >:(

No. That would create an infinite combo with Sorcerer's Apprentice. I know you can already do this with Archmage Antonidas but that combo requires about 6 cards to pull off.