Every class is getting a weapon, so perhaps every class will want to include this. I can only hope because that will say something about the quality of the new weapons.
This should be interesting. The finale guarantees you steal at least one of your opponent's card before this dies, which is nice. Not that I'd want this do stay alive for long as I think I would rather play my own deck.
I don't know what the chances are this will actually put something useful on the top of the opponent's deck. I guess it could still be useful even if they can't play it right away.
All the new special weapons are likely deathrattles, so this doesn't exactly help with those. And for those existing weapons, this card is fine but the fact that this card will be stuck in hand until then sours my opinion on its viability.
There needs to be a really, really good reason to have this in your deck. Most likely we'll see it in DK or warrior. Rogue can use it too, but it might be just too inefficient, and they only really have one good weapon in Swordfish.
I can certainly see this being played, but not sure how impactful it can be.
The fact is that with the duo tribal tags, you're always likely to buff something in hand, and more often than not it'll be more than 1 minion. So if you can spend 2 mana for a crocalisk that buffs two minions for +1+1, will you play it? I'd say sure, if youre aggro or midrange.
Its the first expansion after rotation after all. Things are bound to be slow enough for this to see play.
Need to always respect lifesteal, no matter the convoluted conditions.
Its likely a meta choice, because on its own its fairly crap. Or rather I should say its not worth inclusion into decks, because even without lifesteal it does have rush.
So where will this fit? Most likely DK, unless burn decks are tier 1. Unfortunately its conditions will often prevent any possibility of buffing this on board the same turn. But handbuff suits this fine.
3 mana to do 4 damage, that's what this card is. And with 5 health, on curve this card is monstrously difficult to remove unless you already have board.
Of course, they can always just remove the target, but that's beside the point. Its 3 mana for a minion that's hard to remove, and does 4 damage. I'd be hard pressed to come out with reasons to not play this in any aggro deck.
Gonna have to respect cards like this, even though Im about 70% sure this card would never see any competitive play in the next 2 years.
Arena giant for sure, because at very least you'll likely get a good card out of it. In standard however, we're asking why not just play the legendary you want in your deck? Because surely the chances of a second copy, or anything useful for that fact, is a slim one not worth risking for.
Ironically, if you need 2 damage for 3 mana with an aggressively stated body then likely you're an aggro/midrange deck that usually will have something on board.
A joke of a card that baffling from every standpoint. Why not make it a 2/4 with taunt? Then at least it could have made it into control decks. As it stands, this is so on odds with any gameplan I cant see it ever played except for achievements.
What's so important in standard that you need to use up 4 mana to psuedo-protect anyway? If this is in your deck then you're either pushing for achievements or you're just in for memes.
But once a while it turns up and you win the game because of it. However, that implies this card is actually a deliberate selection in decks, and that I cannot accept. How many games are decided on turn 4 tradings? Most decks are more or less primed to destroy you by turn 5 and this card neither pushes pressure nor reliably relieves it.
Is unlikely, but it may well be the only tradeable card in standard past rotation. For that, I can't help but at least put it on 3 stars.
Because lets be real here, this card is trash 90% of the time. The only good thing is that you can throw it back for another draw, and that's likely the best feature of this card. Dont get why the effect is a finale, because its perfectly reasonable even as a battlecry.
If this is cheated out, its basically a board clear, as long as it doesn't die. Even if it does its still likely clear half the board of stuff.
Unfortunately, if its not cheated out you're playing a 3/10 for 8 that doesn't always do what you need consistently. Not a good start. If your opponent is playing big decks, this card straight out does nothing. And as a third strike, this card is dead in hand until turn 8.
Well then, not very good is it. Might find some peace in warlock with that janky deathrattle deck, but cant see this anywhere else at the moment.
You play this and imagine it being like Leapfrogger. Then you get AoEd, concede, remove this card from your deck and ask the gods why you'd even bother.
There's really no way to describe this other than this being bait for deck builders. Poor stats, doesn't protect against AoE, and perhaps worse of all is the fact that everyone is already jamming starfish into ETC, almost by default. So what chance this card even have?
Nice Spinal Tap reference. I don't know who wouldn't want an extra mana crystal and extra card in their hand. Well, except for decks that don't tend to hold a lot of cards or tend to win before 10 mana.
Still a lot of early stats, even if it gets weaker each turn. I'm assuming even probability for whether this loses attack or health, but 4 damage on your turn 4 is nothing to scoff at.
I'm not sure this is going to be that great for tempo since it starts at 1-Cost. Maybe if this was a 0-Cost minion or the effect started at 3- or 4-Cost.
New Neutral Minion - Instrument Tech
Every class is getting a weapon, so perhaps every class will want to include this. I can only hope because that will say something about the quality of the new weapons.
New Neutral Minion - Tony, King of Piracy
This should be interesting. The finale guarantees you steal at least one of your opponent's card before this dies, which is nice. Not that I'd want this do stay alive for long as I think I would rather play my own deck.
New Neutral Minion - Outfit Tailor
Looks like a nice hand-buff card. In other words, a card for Blood DK and maybe Murloc Warlock.
Frequency Oscillator
Dude spittin' straight fax.
New Neutral Minion - Merch Seller
I don't know what the chances are this will actually put something useful on the top of the opponent's deck. I guess it could still be useful even if they can't play it right away.
New Neutral Minion - Air Guitarist
All the new special weapons are likely deathrattles, so this doesn't exactly help with those. And for those existing weapons, this card is fine but the fact that this card will be stuck in hand until then sours my opinion on its viability.
There needs to be a really, really good reason to have this in your deck. Most likely we'll see it in DK or warrior. Rogue can use it too, but it might be just too inefficient, and they only really have one good weapon in Swordfish.
New Neutral Minion - Rolling Stone
Imagine playing this on curve after a turn 1 elemental play. This card is just solid stuff.
If nothing else, it has rush on default so its not 100% dead outside of triggering. Playable as long as tribal decks are playable.
New Neutral Minion - Party Animal
I can certainly see this being played, but not sure how impactful it can be.
The fact is that with the duo tribal tags, you're always likely to buff something in hand, and more often than not it'll be more than 1 minion. So if you can spend 2 mana for a crocalisk that buffs two minions for +1+1, will you play it? I'd say sure, if youre aggro or midrange.
Its the first expansion after rotation after all. Things are bound to be slow enough for this to see play.
New Neutral Minion - Audio Medic
Need to always respect lifesteal, no matter the convoluted conditions.
Its likely a meta choice, because on its own its fairly crap. Or rather I should say its not worth inclusion into decks, because even without lifesteal it does have rush.
So where will this fit? Most likely DK, unless burn decks are tier 1. Unfortunately its conditions will often prevent any possibility of buffing this on board the same turn. But handbuff suits this fine.
New Neutral Minion - Rowdy Fan
3 mana to do 4 damage, that's what this card is. And with 5 health, on curve this card is monstrously difficult to remove unless you already have board.
Of course, they can always just remove the target, but that's beside the point. Its 3 mana for a minion that's hard to remove, and does 4 damage. I'd be hard pressed to come out with reasons to not play this in any aggro deck.
Outfit Tailor
Is this Tailor swift?
New Neutral Minion - Paparazzi
Gonna have to respect cards like this, even though Im about 70% sure this card would never see any competitive play in the next 2 years.
Arena giant for sure, because at very least you'll likely get a good card out of it. In standard however, we're asking why not just play the legendary you want in your deck? Because surely the chances of a second copy, or anything useful for that fact, is a slim one not worth risking for.
New Neutral Minion - Cowbell Soloist
Ironically, if you need 2 damage for 3 mana with an aggressively stated body then likely you're an aggro/midrange deck that usually will have something on board.
A joke of a card that baffling from every standpoint. Why not make it a 2/4 with taunt? Then at least it could have made it into control decks. As it stands, this is so on odds with any gameplan I cant see it ever played except for achievements.
New Neutral Minion - Obsessive Fan
Arena filler.
What's so important in standard that you need to use up 4 mana to psuedo-protect anyway? If this is in your deck then you're either pushing for achievements or you're just in for memes.
New Neutral Minion - Candleraiser
Arena filler.
But once a while it turns up and you win the game because of it. However, that implies this card is actually a deliberate selection in decks, and that I cannot accept. How many games are decided on turn 4 tradings? Most decks are more or less primed to destroy you by turn 5 and this card neither pushes pressure nor reliably relieves it.
New Neutral Minion - Concert Promo-Drake
Is unlikely, but it may well be the only tradeable card in standard past rotation. For that, I can't help but at least put it on 3 stars.
Because lets be real here, this card is trash 90% of the time. The only good thing is that you can throw it back for another draw, and that's likely the best feature of this card. Dont get why the effect is a finale, because its perfectly reasonable even as a battlecry.
New Neutral Minion - Mish-Mash Mosher
If this is cheated out, its basically a board clear, as long as it doesn't die. Even if it does its still likely clear half the board of stuff.
Unfortunately, if its not cheated out you're playing a 3/10 for 8 that doesn't always do what you need consistently. Not a good start. If your opponent is playing big decks, this card straight out does nothing. And as a third strike, this card is dead in hand until turn 8.
Well then, not very good is it. Might find some peace in warlock with that janky deathrattle deck, but cant see this anywhere else at the moment.
New Neutral Minion - Crowd Surfer
You play this and imagine it being like Leapfrogger. Then you get AoEd, concede, remove this card from your deck and ask the gods why you'd even bother.
There's really no way to describe this other than this being bait for deck builders. Poor stats, doesn't protect against AoE, and perhaps worse of all is the fact that everyone is already jamming starfish into ETC, almost by default. So what chance this card even have?
New Neutral Minion - Audio Amplifier
Nice Spinal Tap reference. I don't know who wouldn't want an extra mana crystal and extra card in their hand. Well, except for decks that don't tend to hold a lot of cards or tend to win before 10 mana.
New Neutral Minion - Static Waveform
Still a lot of early stats, even if it gets weaker each turn. I'm assuming even probability for whether this loses attack or health, but 4 damage on your turn 4 is nothing to scoff at.
New Neutral Minion - Metrognome
I'm not sure this is going to be that great for tempo since it starts at 1-Cost. Maybe if this was a 0-Cost minion or the effect started at 3- or 4-Cost.
New Neutral Minion - Stereo Totem
Should've had a "if you control 2 of this minion" effect.
New Neutral Minion - Frequency Oscillator
When was the last time mech decks were meta? If they are again, this guy should be pretty decent.
New Neutral Minion - Amplified Elekk
It's a taunt with a lot of health and a decent aoe damage deathrattle, but it seems pretty expensive for what it gives you.
Cover Artist
Faceless Manipulator flavor-text 😪