So I play Wild basically exclusively. I'm not a particularly good player—the highest I've ever gotten was about Rank 10—but I still like to think I have a rough idea of how the meta plays out. I wrote all this in about an hour and then spent another hour editing it. Enjoy.
Shrubadier - 1 Star - This is just a bad card.
Aeroponics - 2 Stars - Treant Druid is bad.
Strength in Numbers - 2 Stars - Token Druid will be bad and it's anti-synergistic with current Jade Druid lists.
Treenforcements - 1 Star - Just run Living Roots.
Goru the Mightree - 2 Stars - Treant Druid is bad.
Embiggen - 2 Stars - Assuming the cost modification works on the same principle as Academic Espionage, this is counter-synergistic to Jade Druid and it doesn't fit into any other archetype.
Secure the Deck - 1 Star - Doesn't fit into any deck except *maybe* Token Druid, and Token Druid will be bad.
Breath of Dreams - 3 Stars - Highlander Dragon Druid will be a Tier 3 deck.
Emerald Explorer - 3 Stars - Highlander Dragon Druid will be a Tier 3 deck.
Ysera, Unleashed- 3 Stars - Highlander Dragon Druid will be a Tier 3 deck and you may occasionally see it in Jade Druid because some weirdo thought their Jade Idols needed help pressuring the board in the late game.
Stormhammer - 1 Star - Eaglehorn Bow is better.
Diving Gryphon - 1 Star - Hunter doesn't have enough Rush minions to justify this card.
Veranus - 2 Stars - While cool, Hunter doesn't have enough AoE to justify this card.
Clear the Way - 1 Star - This is just bad.
Corrosive Breath - 1 Star - Dragon Hunter will likely never be a thing.
Primordial Explorer - 1 Star - Dragon Hunter will likely never be a thing. Just run Spider Bomb and Venomizer and play Mech Hunter.
Toxic Reinforcements - 3 Stars - I can imagine a world where some of the more aggressive Hunter decks run this. Also fits into Spell Hunter, although Spell Hunter isn't very good right now.
Dragonbane - 1 Star - Will never hit what you want it to hit.
Dwarven Sharpshooter - 3 Stars - Every non-Spell Hunter deck will at least consider this card.
Phase Stalker - 4 Stars - Really good card in non-Reno Secret Hunter. While that deck isn't good now, I think this raises its power level considerably by greatly improving the decks consistency and early game.
Elemental Allies - 4 Stars - I find it very hard to believe 1-Mana Draw 3 will ever be bad.
Violet Spellwing - 3 Stars - At best, it's the 30th card in your Tempo Mage.
Mana Giant - 5 Stars - Better Arcane Giant.
Rolling Fireball - 3 Stars - It's a removal spell that you'll see occasionally. Weigh the pros and cons of the other removal cards around the same cost when building your deck.
Dragoncaster - 4 Stars - Huge payoff and I think Control Highlander Mage will be able to fit some sort of dragon package into a deck.
Arcane Breath - 2 Stars - Just run Primordial Glyph.
Chenvaala - 5 Stars - This card is the nuts in any aggressive Mage deck.
Malygos, Aspect of Magic - 4 Stars - Will be one of the best cards in Control Highlander Mage.
Azure Explorer - 1 Star - Just run Cosmic Anomaly.
Learn Draconic - 5 Stars - It's a 1-Mana 6/6.
Lightforged Zealot - 5 Stars - Amazing payoff for Pure Paladin. It's a 0-Mana 4/2 attached to a Truesilver Champion.
Lightforged Crusader - 5 Stars - Amazing payoff for Pure Paladin. This is a 7-Mana 7/7 that draws 5 cards.
Sky Claw - 5 Stars - AoE attack buff that also puts 3 new mechs on the board. Mech Paladin is Tier 1 deck already.
Righteous Cause - 4 Stars - Fits nicely into Odd Paladin. You don't mind playing this turn 1 if it starts in your opening hand.
Bronze Explorer- 1 Star - Every Paladin deck has better cards.
Sanctuary - 5 Stars - Every Paladin deck will at least consider this, and every aggressive Paladin deck will run this because it's a 1-Mana 3/6 Taunt.
Amber Watcher - 5 Stars - Antique Healbot sees play in Wild. This is Antique Healbot with +1/+3.
Dragonrider Talritha - 3 Stars - Might see play in Pure Paladin.
Nozdormu the Timeless - 4 Stars - This is actually very relevant for any slow Paladin deck, as all of a sudden you get access to every answer you could have to deal with Aggro.
Sand Breath - 5 Stars - I think this will be a very good card in Pure Paladin.
Whispers of EVIL - 3 Stars - Never ignore 0-Mana spells.
Grave Rune - 3 Stars - This is a very powerful effect, but I don't know if you'll see it in any deck other than Big Priest.
Disciple of Galakrond - 1 Star - Random Priest cards aren't good, and Galakrond Priest isn't good.
Murozond the Infinite - 4 Stars - Counter all the big plays by making the same big play and then also getting an 8/8.
Chronobreaker - 4 Stars - Better Duskbreaker.
[Hearthstone Card (Mindflayer Kaarhj) Not Found] - 2 Stars - This is a good value card, but I don't think it fits into any Priest archetypes.
Breath of the Infinite - 3 Stars - Priest didn't need any more AoE. Pick and choose your AoEs to respond to the meta.
Envoy of Lazul - 1 Star - Curious Glimmerroot wasn't very good, this won't be either.
Fate Weaver - 1 Star - Random Priest cards aren't good and neither is Galakrond Priest. Just run Emperor Thaurissan.
Time Rip - 1 Star - Rnadom Priest cards aren't good, Assassinate isn't good, and Galakrond Priest isn't good.
Galakrond, the Unspeakable - 1 Star - Galakrond Priest isn't good. Just run Shadowreaper Anduin, which lets you keep all your actually good Priest cards.
Bloodsail Flybooter - 5 Stars - Really good in any aggressive Rogue deck. This includes Odd Rogue.
Stowaway - 2 Stars - Would be 1 Star but Academic Espionage Rogue is my favorite meme.
Flik Skyshiv - 4 Stars - You can never have enough Vilespine Slayers.
Necrium Apothecary - 3 Stars - This is a 5 Star card when Dane plays it.
Dragon's Hoard - 4 Stars - Class-specific Legendaries are actually pretty good and the fact that this Discovers means it's less likely to whiff.
Candle Breath - 1 Star - Dragon Rogue will not be a deck.
Waxadred - 2 Stars - Doesn't fit into any Rogue deck and certainly doesn't make its own new archetype.
Umbral Skulker - 4 Stars - I can imagine a Galakrond Tempo Rogue deck and this is a really good payoff for that deck.
[Hearthstone Card (Praise Galakrond) Not Found] - 2 Stars - This is really bad and will only be sometimes run in Galakrond Tempo Rogue.
Galakrond, the Nightmare - 4 Stars - Galakrond Tempo Rogue will be a deck and this card is incredible payoff for such a deck.
Seal Fate - 4 Stars - Galakrond Tempo Rogue.
Squallhunter - 5 Stars - Flamewreathed Faceless wasn't good enough according to Blizzard.
Dragon's Pack - 4 Stars - Really good Invoke lover.
Invocation of Frost - 4 Stars - Glacial Shard with Rush.
Galakrond, the Tempest - 3 Stars - Oddly enough, this is actually not the best payoff card of Galakrond Shaman.
Storm's Wrath - 5 Stars - Mark of the Lotus is a 6-Star card.
Surging Tempest - 1 Star - Just run Tunnel Trogg.
Corrupt Elementalist - 4 Stars - Solid Galakrond support card.
Bandersmosh - 2 Stars - The average Legendary minion is bad.
Nithogg - 1 Star - Very slow.
Cumulo-Maximus - 5 Stars - It's almost a Fireball with a 0-Mana 5/5 on it.
Lightning Breath - 1 Star - Dragon Shaman isn't a deck.
Rain of Fire - 1 Star - Just run Defile.
Dark Skies - 1 Star - Just run Defile.
[Hearthstone Card (Zzeraku) Not Found] - 2 Stars - Not awful, but it doesn't fit into any Warlock archetype and it's too slow.
Valdris Felgorge - 3 Stars - I think it might make it into Renolock but I'm not sure.
Abyssal Summoner - 1 Star - Handlock hasn't been a good deck for years.
Crazed Netherwing - 2 Stars - Control Warlocks don't run dragons and Dragon Warlock isn't a thing.
Nether Breath - 2 Stars - Control Warlocks don't run dragons and Dragon Warlock isn't a thing.
Veiled Worshipper - 3 Stars - Galakrond Warlock has potential.
Fiendish Rites - 1 Stars - Galakrond Warlock has potential, but this doesn't. Just run Grim Rally.
Dragonblight Cultist - 3 Stars - Galakrond Zoolock has potential.
Galakrond, the Wretched - 3 Stars - Galakrond Zoolock has potential.
Ritual Chopper- 5 Stars - Thank God we nerfed Fiery War Axe.
Awaken! - 4 Stars - This is actually pretty good when you compare it to Swipe.
Ramming Speed - 3 Stars - Sure, I guess.
Sky Raider - 4 Stars - This is a bold assumption, but Pirate Warrior might actually be a deck again.
EVIL Quartermaster - 3 Stars - Solid card. Warrior decks will consider it, but not all of them will run it.
Scion of Ruin - 5 Stars - That's a lot of value.
Ancharrr - 4 Stars - Pirate Warrior is back.
Molten Breath - 4 Stars - Dragon Warrior has actually had potential for a while.
Galakrond, the Unspeakable - 5 Stars - The best Galakrond.
Deathwing, Mad Aspect - 1 Star - This is bad when r/customhearthstone made it, and it's bad when Team 5 made it.
Evasive Chimaera - 1 Star - Build-a-Beast can't use this.
Grizzled Wizard - 1 Star - Hero Powers are expensive.
Tasty Flyfish - 1 Star - Dragon Warrior, the only Dragon deck with potential, will not run this.
Fire Hawk - 3 Stars - 3-Mana 6/3 isn't actually that bad. Not great, but not bad.
Goboglide Tech - 1 Star - Just run any Magnetic card.
[Hearthstone Card (Living Dragonhawk) Not Found] - 1 Star - Too hard to use as an effective counter to Frost Nova.
Hippogryph - 2 Stars - Pretty good with Build-a-Beast. That's about it.
Skyfin - 1 Star - Dragon decks aren't aggro decks.
Gyrocopter - 1 Stars - This doesn't have Magnetic.
Blazing Battlemage - 3 Stars - Generally 1/3 minions are better, but this isn't awful.
Hoard Pillager - 4 Stars - Pirate Warrior is back. Really this is good in any aggressive deck that runs weapons.
Parachute Brigand - 4 Stars - Pirate Warrior is back.
Troll Batrider - 3 Stars - It's OK.
Scalerider - 1 Star - Payoff isn't good enough for Dragon decks.
Evasive Wyrm - 3 Stars - Not awful.
Big Ol' Whelp - 3 Stars - Spell Damage +1 and worth more than +1/+1.
Evasive Feywing - 2 Stars - Good filler. Bad card for Wild.
Blowtorch Saboteur - 1 Star - Floaty Unseen Saboteur. Neither will see play.
Dragonmaw Poacher - 3 Stars - Tech card against dragons. Better than Dragonslayer, but still not that great.
Faceless Corruptor - 4 Stars - Big buff but you can't use it as fast face damage.
Platebreaker - 1 Star - It's a 5-Star in my heart because it means Armor Druid will never be good.
Cobalt Spellkin - 4 Stars - Lots of value in a single card.
[Hearthstone Card (Frizz Kindlefrost) Not Found] - 4 Stars - Might see play in Dragon Warrior.
Tentacled Menace- 3 Stars - Potentially a tech card for Midrange decks against Aggro decks? I don't know.
Depth Charge - 1 Star - Just run Doomsayer.
Bad Luck Albatross - 3 Stars - 3-Mana 4/3 Deathrattle: If your opponent is Highlander, win the game.
Dread Raven - 1 Star - Rogue would rather use Pogo-Hopper.
Kobold Stickyfinger - 1 Star - Would be 5 Stars if it was printed during Kobolds and Catacombs.
Transmogrifier - 1 Star - Your cards are better than random Legendaries.
Dragonqueen Alexstrasza - 4 Stars - Will see play in Highlander Dragon Mage and Highlander Dragon Druid.
[Hearthstone Card (Dragonbreeder) Not Found] - 4 Stars - Will see play in Dragon Warrior, Highlander Dragon Mage, and Highlander Dragon Druid.
Chromatic Egg - 1 Stars - Wait when did I start reviewing r/customhearthstone cards?
Hot Air Balloon - 2 Stars - Maybe Mech Paladin? Maybe SN1P-SN4P Warlock? I dunno.
Camouflaged Dirigible - 2 Stars - Maybe SN1P-SN4P Warlock but probably not.
Kronx Dragonhoof - 5 Stars - Best card in the set.
Shu'ma- 2 Stars - Cool card but it probably isn't good.
Sathrovarr - 4 Stars - Surprisingly good in Renolock. All you need to do is get 1 big minion to stick.
Devoted Maniac - 3 Stars - Might make it into a Galakrond deck, but it will be the worst Invoker in your deck.
Evasive Drakonid - 3 Stars - Rest in peace, Soggoth the Slitherer.
Shield of Galakrond - 4 Stars - This is a really good minion in any Galakrond deck.
Twin Tyrant - 3 Stars - OK I guess.
[Hearthstone Card (Utgarde Grapplesnipers) Not Found] - 1 Star - You definitely do not run enough Dragons to make this work.
Wing Commander - 4 Stars - This is a 4-Mana 8/5 in Dragon Warrior.
Wyrmrest Purifier - 2 Stars - Fun with Hakkar, the Soulflayer.
Zul'Drak Ritualist - 1 Star - This card is beyond bad.
