madcat

On the right track, but no. [card]Biteweed[/card] isn't catlike in any way I can think of. And as is frequently the case for my riddles, the catlike card is old, like really old.

Not a druid card. Think stealthy.

R is a little closer, but "like a cat" is actually not a cat (probably, the art isn't clear though it definitely has no beast tribe), though stats do come into it.

Nope. The card is inspired by this week's Tavern Brawl.

Follower of the flower

Stealthy as a cat am I

But in reverse!

Quote From R

Quote From madcat

The 'bane sisters (cousins?): [card]Eydis Darkbane[/card] and [card]Fjola Lightbane[/card]

madcat already wrote the answer...

Oh, I was really confused there. Ha ha, do their …

The 'bane sisters (cousins?): [card]Eydis Darkbane[/card] and [card]Fjola Lightbane[/card]

[card]The Darkness[/card]?

[card]Lucentbark[/card]?

[card]Bewitched Guardian[/card]?

[card]The Darkness[/card]?

Love the story, and of course I love the art!

All correct except that MurlocAggroB has 13, which was my transcribing mistake.

Edit: added mea culpa

Looking at page 43 there is one post at the end from CursedParrot where he states the correct answer. I also recounted Live4vrRdieTryn's points from page 130-136 and there are 5, which added to the 21 from page 1 confirms …

For the riddle, [card]Mutanus the Devourer[/card] is the only murloc who seems to interact with anything the opponent has, so let's try that.

Yup, if we already have CursedParrot's point credited to Live4vrRdieTryn then that point goes away and everything seems ok.

And when I add 51-136 we get the following, and mostly consistent with page 1!

[spoiler]anchorm4n - 39

DestroyerR - 28

Live4vrRdieTryn - 27

R - 26

KANSAS - 18

ArngrimUndying - 16

…

I can start from page 51.

OK, random guess time. It seems to be a "fiend" (demon?) that got changed, maybe to a different card? So the new cards would be [card]Queen of Pain[/card], [card]Felstalker[/card], and [card]Xavius[/card] (are there others?). Of those, maybe [card]Felstalker[/card] since it …

Live4vrRdieTryn, you got it! And I agree with the sentiment :) You're up!