Feedback

Hi

I liked the filter system there was on Hearthpwn. I would like to see the same there, as well as the ability to choose AND/OR connector between filters (and therefore the possibility to make filter groups). Advanced filtering capabilities are very useful for fan card makers (to compare stats and such). I know the regular HS player won't need those but they aren't forced to use it. I still think the current mono-choice system is too restrictive even for a regular player.

Also, choices in the expansion list can't be de-selected. There should be a "--------" option like other select bars.

I would like to share an opinion towards the division in content offered on the homepage. I think forum threads should be more visible, in the main menu as well as the main layout of the homepage.

I understand why decks and cards are so important, but I think the returning members value threads a lot. There are no notifications as of now, which makes having to search for the thread a lot of work (unless I'm missing something).

I have no idea what pages are being visited most, so it might be done this way because of SEO/user-friendly reasons. If so, please ignore my reasoning. I just think it can be visible more.

Greetings Everyone.

i like this site very much and i like hearthpwn too, because of the great staff, so i want to help them as much as possible, considering my self as a loyal member of this website, i want to share my ideas instead of keeping it for my self. 

- Changing the color. 

 Black is a color that brings despair and sadness, it is good and beautiful in term of desgin, but it doesn't have good feelings coming from it. 

  x SUGGESTIONS: 

 - Yellowish color, it's the game's main color. 

 - The color of  the latest expansion, but that would be exhausting for the staff i think. 

- Cards entrace voiceline and intro music.

This was one of the best features Hearthpwn had, but we know they stopped doing this feature, please bring it back here. 

- Card's Winrate through its history. 

 This is a hard one, and i hope they do it but it's really hard.

That's everything for now, and sorry if i made a suggestion the staff are not intending to make, or already made. 

Hi guys!

Recently I've tried using the collectible card filter page here on OoC, and while the filtering function seems to be very efficient and quick, one window in particular was a bit difficult to use. The specific window I'm talking about is the expansion selector - it is rather small compared to the amount of things you can select from. While I do understand that the window is built the way it is because it allows for multiple selections (and not a simple drop-down menu like the rest of the inputs on that page), it is a bit janky to use on the user-side of things.

I've put together a proposed solution (quickly, in paint - don't judge ^_^) in which the "expansion" window is simply enlarged to be the size of 2 "lines" (vertically speaking). This allows for way more lines to be displayed and makes it easier to navigate and select from. I have to preface this by saying I don't possess any technical knowledge regarding implementation - so I might be proposing something which is impossible or just not worth the hassle - but I think it would be great if something like this could be done.

Couldn't find a way to upload an image here, here's a link to imgur: https://imgur.com/9nv7UTs

Would love to hear your opinions!

Hey, quick quality of life request!

Is there any chance you could get the deck code copy feature to include the name of the deck when it's imported into hearthstone.

It works like that on HS Replay and is handier than having to rename "Custom Priest" each time!

Keep up the great work!

I'm seeing a lot of topics being created here, which is great of course, but I wonder how many might be duplicates asking for / reporting the same thing or nearly the same thing? There is no way to see if what you're asking hasn't already been requested or reported.

So my suggestion is to create a sticked topic in this forum where you show the list of most requested features that have already been noted and bugs that have been reported. That way people can quickly check that list and see if their feature request or bug report has already been made. Not everyone is going to read it but hopefully it'll help filter out the duplicates.

As for feature request mine is:

Have an option to show the card images in the Cards section. For me that has always been the easiest way to quickly browse multiple cards. The cards themselves show all their information so it seems like a good way to display a list of cards.

And my bug report:

If you use Shift + Enter in the text editor, then (on my Firefox at least) you can't use the Spacebar anymore. It won't add a space in the text. Could be underlying HTML or something with the editor itself. Shift + Enter is what I use in certain text editors to avoid unneeded space between lines, though I'm not sure if that matters on this forum.

Let's be frank, MTGA is a whole new beast and as such, deserved another OOC entirely for it. Do you guys think you'll ever have men power to launch a robust MTGA Section here? With all it deserves: meta reports, decks, articles, guides, etc? Or is OOC destined to a "mmochampion" fate, to have MMO in the name but be actually a gigantic WoW fan site?

I mean, I love HS, it's my old wife by MTGA is my new 18yo lover so... Thirsty for more!

The forum MTGA section is dead... I wrote 3 posts including a new thread and almost a week later, not a single reply.

on mobile, decks are not that important, i think.

on mobile i'm mostly here for news and the forums.

Within the race filter of cards there are a lot of inclusions which seem odd like: goblin2, but also things like orc or night elf, which we don't have in Hearthstone.

Would be nice if the filter could be improved

Are we going to have same type of program for this website?

I know we dont even have deck list for our selfs, its comming soon, but i had to ask

I think the following might be very useful:

• A more in-depth deck filtering system. Right now there's six options, and for example, if I'm searching for Brawl, I can't pick what type of brawl the deck is for. Same with Adventure, etc. I'd have to rely on deck titles, and if it's "Easy Brawl win", then it doesn't tell me much.
• Popular decks at the top of the front page in a boxed layout, and Tavern Brawl starting on Wednesdays.
• Card catalog, where we can add our card collection (doesn't have to be a separate app like Innkeeper) including regular and golden cards. Additionally, an ability to get suggested decks based on cards we already have.

Hi ! (bad english incoming)

Do you already have any plans on the SEO for the website? Because outof.cards seems hard to reference and for now it's pretty hard to find on google. 

The logic would be to search outof on google (what is pretty weird) because the extension of the website is never researched (we do not type "facebook com" on google).

And if you research out of cards you are gonna be so doomed by house of cards that have a lot of news/infos and is pretty similar.

I don't know if your plan is to only bring old heathpwn community (in this case no problem, they probably all have the URL somewhere) but if you are willing to have new users and community, I think you'll need to think about that name and SEO. For example hearthstation was way easier to remember and research.

That said, I know that there are other words to be reference on like hearthstone, deck etc so you can bet your SEO on that, but still it could be nice to have a good SEO on your own name.

Don't know where or how, but title says it all. This game is really good, it would attract more community members, should this topic/game be sticked. Maybe a trivial request, but a nice one nonetheless.

While using the mobile version of the site - the side menu is of course a necessity. Problem is, at least for my Android phone, that when you expand one of the menus into its sub-menus, causing the menu to collapse back requires you to hit the main "side menu" button. This may seem like a personal inconvenience but it was very unintuitive for me, and I'm sure to many others as well.

Personally, I think adding the option of closing the sub-menus back by clicking the little arrow thing (or just adding a small button next to the text instead) would be great.

P.S. Love what you are doing with the site! keep up the amazing work!!!  

I've noticed that Replies are indented a bit, but between the small indent and the site's color scheme, it's very difficult to tell at a glance that a given post is a reply. I think it would scan better if the indent were increased on Replies, or possibly give them a slightly different background color/border -- just something, so that it's easier to tell just by looking at a post that it's a Reply rather than an independent post.

Hey there! First post here, dragged here from hearthpwn.

Love to see the idea, the progress and the milestone you guys set ahead.

But among the things that you plan to do, i did not see the Legendary crafitng tier list sticky post, and that's a bummer for me.

I think would be useful, and should be improved as a single page on the main  menu with a lot of content more (statistic, grading, main interaction in standard or wild...)

How many decks -among each tier- use that legendary?

How the users scored it? Will it be useful in the future?

What you guys think about?

Is this something you will implement? I usually like to have my decks private because they are shitty, and more functions as a tool for keeping track of my decks.

Presently in the card search function, the "expansion" filter works differently from the others: it's not a drop-down list with a scroll bar, rather, it's just a teeny tiny scroll bar that can only display three options at a time. Furthermore, there doesn't seem to be a "null" option, so once you've selected an expansion, and you want to search for cards from multiple expansions, or you're not sure of the expansion, you have to reload the search tool.

I don't really see a reason for that filter to work differently from the others, which are much more convenient.

Hey, OutOfCards!

Post previews in all modes (thread creation and post creation/editing) would be highly appreciated.

Great Job on the site, and thanks in advance!

Writing to suggest that the Decks and Card pages have a more robust filtering process, I'm guessing it's "on the list" but wanted to offer suggestions.

Having filter values of "unknown" as default values is bad design, IMO.  Don't think you should have "unknown" as a choice at all.

Same with the Archetypes, none or blank instead of "unknown".  Also who defines the archetypes? Is it a self assigned thing? Do people pick from a list or do they just make it up on the fly?

It would be nice if it was possible to sort decks like "the site that will not be named" does by "Hot", "New", "Top-Week", "Top-month", "Top-all-time".

Cards don't have the ability to search by minion effects (deathrattle, battlecry, etc).

Will we have the ability to view the cards in a list (as it currently is) or as images?

Do you have a list or schedule of all of the up and coming changes on the radar?

Thanks for all of the work you do on this site!