Being able to draw 3 cards is nice, but four things need to die before you can do that and this is one very horrible top deck, meaning aggro decks might steer clear of it for consistency reasons.
If you need to draw three cards, just build your deck around Gorloc Ravager instead. At very least that card will always do what it needs to do, rather than subject yourself to card draw rng.
Had this been designed 2 years back it would be the most broken card ever made.
But in hearthstone nowadays, it suffers from redundancy. Backstab, once a card that never once been dropped, has indeed been dropped, so will a slightly better backstab see play? I'd much rather play Tooth of Nefarian because it can at very least hit face.
However, that said, this card might* make inclusion simply because it functions somewhat similar to Foxy Fraud, in that you're playing it just to add to the 'total cards played' pool for the turn. And since that's rogue's identity now, I guess for that reason this will see play. But the minute there's better ways to do that, this card would be quietly dropped.
Probably the best pally card so far, and that's saying a lot seeing how Sinful Sous Chef and Elitist Snob are both excellent cards in their own right.
Just play it because why not? You get a paladin card, a 2/4 taunt for 3 mana. It'll only ever be dropped because you're playing aggro and/or paladin sucks.
Traditionally cards that give opponent stuff tend to be shit, and that's what this is: quite trash honestly.
Its not really difficult to guess what your opponent has taken, unless he's really cheeky and picks a useless card, in which case he now has a useless spell so all's fair I guess.
I just dont see mage ever playing this card. They're rarely running out of stuff to do, so what niche does this serve other than taking up space?
Likely you'll still play it, because for what its worth its still two minions for 1 mana that can potentially infuse other cards. But in no way remarkable.
The wildseed generator for hunter seems really cool for a 2 drop. The secret guy has been made for rogue. But the First thing that come up in my mind Is this one. We saw: 1) a 4/4 for 2 mana that can be considered thrash, 2) a spell that create a 6/6 for 2 mana that Is considered hm and 3) the second card for the secondary paladin archetipe (the pure One) have been designed ad waaaaaaay stronger than any other dude pally card we have seen until now (as well as the elitist, obviously). If team5 would have wanted the dude paladin to be a thing, they should have designed its cards to have the Power of those two ones, and they could do it but they didn't. We are "happy" or scary to see steward and promotion but those cards are not that strong compared to other cards that are not considered that strong.
Despite its random nature, its still probably one of hunter's best cards revealed so far, and if available right now in standard I'd be playing it in all my hunter decks.
The key here is the fact that its a 2 drop. So you can just play it on 2, and whatever it spawns you'll likely not go behind on tempo too much and can recover easily on turn 3. Besides, all three choices are quite good, not to mention that one of the random wildseeds literally grants you 8 damage over 2 turns, cannot be interrupted, develops a 5/4 and all you really need to do is wait 3 turns for it.
If hunters are tier 1, I wouldn't be too surprised this card would be in it, and in contention for a nerf.
Its a good card because it covers where druids tend to be weak at, and that's early game removal and early game tempo.
The problem is whether druids can offer enough deck slots to fit this in and still go ahead with their game plan and then there's also the issue with most ramp decks not even bothering to mulligan for this card unless Irondeep Trogg becomes meta again.
Its a meta dependent card for druid, in my opinion. Because sometimes druids just ignore early game for ramp and play to win. But sometimes there's just cards you cant ignore without dying.
It’s definitely a meta depending card. But i just can’t see this not getting played in a probably minion based meta, because of stuff like infused being pushed. Even in the current meta right now, this card would do so much. Stuff like prestor druid, naga priest would completly skip their turn. And sure Mutanus in many instances is better, but that card is still 7 mana. And Snowfall is a good card and also 6 mana, but its not that good playing it on a small board. So Forensic Duster has the potential to win certain matchups and it isn’t a bad card at all just playing on curve.
On one hand, played early this card will almost always hit once, which means its 2 mana deal 4 damage. But on the other, you lose one card which to an aggro deck can mean quite a lot, especially given how efficient removals are, and more reliant aggro is on longer games nowadays.
I personally don't like it. Not even in a class that can draw like dhunter. Hearthstone 2022 rarely ever allows you to put a bunch of useless cards in your deck like how old zoo used to work so this always end up dumping a good card, and a 4/4 played early isn't really going to matter too much, especially if your opponent is running Prince Renathal
Perhaps, if you generate enough shit in your hand, especially on 1, you can justify its inclusion. if Fire Fly were in standard for example you'd play this card because dumping a generated 1/2 for 4/4 stats on 2 is still an insane play. But otherwise Im not optimistic of this card's viability.
Good. Simply good. All these "2-mana deal 3 to a minion plus a little upside" cards (Frostbolt, Quick Shot, Penance) were and are pretty viable. And Rogue really likes discounting cards.
Its just powercreep over 2 drops in terms of stats, because most of the time you'll be getting a vanilla stated minion plus a 1/1. If you're playing aggro then you probably just put these 2 cards in your deck and go from there.
There is a small chance of backfiring, but its still 2 tokens for 2 mana and I'd still rate it as good enough for most if not all aggro decks. Above that, however, you'd probably be better off playing a 2 drop you need rather than this.
Felstalker with one more health. And theoretically, the card isn't even lost. Which will probably not matter with the common length of games but chances are a class like Demon Hunter can draw the shuffled card again.
Because most of the top level decks tend to be more reliant on spells to end games, maintain tempo, or in some cases just rely on them completely for everything. That's why Cult Neophyte saw play throughout its lifetime in standard despite only bumping spells by 1.
Only in aggro matchups or minion centric combo decks can this really do damage. But Im not optimistic that we'll see much of this card.
On your example. If my opponent plays his bolner or macaw on this thing, then I'd be laughing. That's significantly better than seeing it repeat mutanus or snowfall guardian. Unless Im playing aggro, I'll just remove them with a spell and you're 2-3 cards short doing jack.
Some of the preview art of to be revealed cards hint at further treant support. I kind of like the archetype so maybe it'll be enough to make it viable. Card is okay but not broken. Can go face and combines two 1-mana effects in a 2-mana card. So probably too fair for modern hearthstone.
The horse kicking back as the deathrattle has a nice flavor. But as the previous poster wrote: no taunt, no rush. so I doubt it'll see play. And I don't really like the artwork.
Its legit a premium statted minion that also screws up your opponents curve. It can also disrupt oppponent combo plays, and this in shaman with bolner and macaw can potenially make your opponent skip the next turn
Feel free to hate me but imagine the glory of this card's effect lasting "for the rest of this game" and combining it with OG Benedictus. I'm sure it's healthier this way for reasons you've all pointed out, but Thief Priest is a fun archetype in Wild and this won't help much because you can't reasonably expect to steal more than one card.
They don't have a rarity gem so they seem to be just tokens. There might be other Hunter cards to synergize with them though so not just Spirit Poacher.
It's an okay disruptor to mess with your opponent's curve. Could see play as a tech card, though it could also be useful in delaying aggro or board-based opponents, buy yourself a turn or two.
New Neutral Minion - Famished Fool
I honestly dont like it.
Being able to draw 3 cards is nice, but four things need to die before you can do that and this is one very horrible top deck, meaning aggro decks might steer clear of it for consistency reasons.
If you need to draw three cards, just build your deck around Gorloc Ravager instead. At very least that card will always do what it needs to do, rather than subject yourself to card draw rng.
New Rogue Spell - Serrated Bone Spike
Had this been designed 2 years back it would be the most broken card ever made.
But in hearthstone nowadays, it suffers from redundancy. Backstab, once a card that never once been dropped, has indeed been dropped, so will a slightly better backstab see play? I'd much rather play Tooth of Nefarian because it can at very least hit face.
However, that said, this card might* make inclusion simply because it functions somewhat similar to Foxy Fraud, in that you're playing it just to add to the 'total cards played' pool for the turn. And since that's rogue's identity now, I guess for that reason this will see play. But the minute there's better ways to do that, this card would be quietly dropped.
New Paladin Minion - Muckborn Servant
Probably the best pally card so far, and that's saying a lot seeing how Sinful Sous Chef and Elitist Snob are both excellent cards in their own right.
Just play it because why not? You get a paladin card, a 2/4 taunt for 3 mana. It'll only ever be dropped because you're playing aggro and/or paladin sucks.
New Mage Minion - Suspicious Alchemist
Traditionally cards that give opponent stuff tend to be shit, and that's what this is: quite trash honestly.
Its not really difficult to guess what your opponent has taken, unless he's really cheeky and picks a useless card, in which case he now has a useless spell so all's fair I guess.
I just dont see mage ever playing this card. They're rarely running out of stuff to do, so what niche does this serve other than taking up space?
New Hunter Minion - Batty Guest
Just decent, I guess. Could be a lot worse.
Likely you'll still play it, because for what its worth its still two minions for 1 mana that can potentially infuse other cards. But in no way remarkable.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
The wildseed generator for hunter seems really cool for a 2 drop. The secret guy has been made for rogue. But the First thing that come up in my mind Is this one. We saw: 1) a 4/4 for 2 mana that can be considered thrash, 2) a spell that create a 6/6 for 2 mana that Is considered hm and 3) the second card for the secondary paladin archetipe (the pure One) have been designed ad waaaaaaay stronger than any other dude pally card we have seen until now (as well as the elitist, obviously). If team5 would have wanted the dude paladin to be a thing, they should have designed its cards to have the Power of those two ones, and they could do it but they didn't. We are "happy" or scary to see steward and promotion but those cards are not that strong compared to other cards that are not considered that strong.
New Hunter Minion - Spirit Poacher
Despite its random nature, its still probably one of hunter's best cards revealed so far, and if available right now in standard I'd be playing it in all my hunter decks.
The key here is the fact that its a 2 drop. So you can just play it on 2, and whatever it spawns you'll likely not go behind on tempo too much and can recover easily on turn 3. Besides, all three choices are quite good, not to mention that one of the random wildseeds literally grants you 8 damage over 2 turns, cannot be interrupted, develops a 5/4 and all you really need to do is wait 3 turns for it.
If hunters are tier 1, I wouldn't be too surprised this card would be in it, and in contention for a nerf.
New Druid Spell - Natural Causes
Its a good card because it covers where druids tend to be weak at, and that's early game removal and early game tempo.
The problem is whether druids can offer enough deck slots to fit this in and still go ahead with their game plan and then there's also the issue with most ramp decks not even bothering to mulligan for this card unless Irondeep Trogg becomes meta again.
Its a meta dependent card for druid, in my opinion. Because sometimes druids just ignore early game for ramp and play to win. But sometimes there's just cards you cant ignore without dying.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
It’s definitely a meta depending card. But i just can’t see this not getting played in a probably minion based meta, because of stuff like infused being pushed. Even in the current meta right now, this card would do so much. Stuff like prestor druid, naga priest would completly skip their turn. And sure Mutanus in many instances is better, but that card is still 7 mana. And Snowfall is a good card and also 6 mana, but its not that good playing it on a small board. So Forensic Duster has the potential to win certain matchups and it isn’t a bad card at all just playing on curve.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Bibliomite
Im two ways about this.
On one hand, played early this card will almost always hit once, which means its 2 mana deal 4 damage. But on the other, you lose one card which to an aggro deck can mean quite a lot, especially given how efficient removals are, and more reliant aggro is on longer games nowadays.
I personally don't like it. Not even in a class that can draw like dhunter. Hearthstone 2022 rarely ever allows you to put a bunch of useless cards in your deck like how old zoo used to work so this always end up dumping a good card, and a 4/4 played early isn't really going to matter too much, especially if your opponent is running Prince Renathal
Perhaps, if you generate enough shit in your hand, especially on 1, you can justify its inclusion. if Fire Fly were in standard for example you'd play this card because dumping a generated 1/2 for 4/4 stats on 2 is still an insane play. But otherwise Im not optimistic of this card's viability.
New Mage Minion - Suspicious Alchemist
So the Suspicious Usher got a friend. Wonder if we'll see more suspicious cards with this mechanic, discover a weapon for Warrior for example.
New Rogue Spell - Serrated Bone Spike
Good. Simply good. All these "2-mana deal 3 to a minion plus a little upside" cards (Frostbolt, Quick Shot, Penance) were and are pretty viable. And Rogue really likes discounting cards.
New Neutral Minion - Maze Guide
Its just powercreep over 2 drops in terms of stats, because most of the time you'll be getting a vanilla stated minion plus a 1/1. If you're playing aggro then you probably just put these 2 cards in your deck and go from there.
There is a small chance of backfiring, but its still 2 tokens for 2 mana and I'd still rate it as good enough for most if not all aggro decks. Above that, however, you'd probably be better off playing a 2 drop you need rather than this.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Bibliomite
Felstalker with one more health. And theoretically, the card isn't even lost. Which will probably not matter with the common length of games but chances are a class like Demon Hunter can draw the shuffled card again.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
Because most of the top level decks tend to be more reliant on spells to end games, maintain tempo, or in some cases just rely on them completely for everything. That's why Cult Neophyte saw play throughout its lifetime in standard despite only bumping spells by 1.
Only in aggro matchups or minion centric combo decks can this really do damage. But Im not optimistic that we'll see much of this card.
On your example. If my opponent plays his bolner or macaw on this thing, then I'd be laughing. That's significantly better than seeing it repeat mutanus or snowfall guardian. Unless Im playing aggro, I'll just remove them with a spell and you're 2-3 cards short doing jack.
New Druid Spell - Natural Causes
Some of the preview art of to be revealed cards hint at further treant support. I kind of like the archetype so maybe it'll be enough to make it viable. Card is okay but not broken. Can go face and combines two 1-mana effects in a 2-mana card. So probably too fair for modern hearthstone.
New Hunter Minion - Batty Guest
Reminiscent of cards like Mecharoo, Possessed Villager, Spawnpool Forager, or a smaller Kindly Grandmother. They all saw play and so will this.
New Neutral Minion - Sinrunner
The horse kicking back as the deathrattle has a nice flavor. But as the previous poster wrote: no taunt, no rush. so I doubt it'll see play. And I don't really like the artwork.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
How is forensic duster bad?
Its legit a premium statted minion that also screws up your opponents curve. It can also disrupt oppponent combo plays, and this in shaman with bolner and macaw can potenially make your opponent skip the next turn
New Paladin Minion - Muckborn Servant
So, we've got the mandatory [Hearthstone Card (Silverback Patriach) Not Found] power creep card of the set.
The Harvester of Envy is a New Legendary Priest Card Revealed by RPP for Castle Nathria
Feel free to hate me but imagine the glory of this card's effect lasting "for the rest of this game" and combining it with OG Benedictus. I'm sure it's healthier this way for reasons you've all pointed out, but Thief Priest is a fun archetype in Wild and this won't help much because you can't reasonably expect to steal more than one card.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
They don't have a rarity gem so they seem to be just tokens. There might be other Hunter cards to synergize with them though so not just Spirit Poacher.
14 New Castle Nathria Cards Revealed by SaveFile17, Dreads, Redbeard, & TrumpSC
Are wildseeds separate cards that you can build into a deck? Or is it strictly only summoned by the "Spirit Poacher" minion?
New Neutral Minion - Forensic Duster
It's an okay disruptor to mess with your opponent's curve. Could see play as a tech card, though it could also be useful in delaying aggro or board-based opponents, buy yourself a turn or two.
New Hunter Minion - Batty Guest
Really good card for Hunter. This will see a lot of play for any aggro or board-based Hunter deck.