Would Murloc Tidecaller be good enough to run if it only triggered off of other... Murloc Tidecallers? And had only one health? Even with Rush.
I mean other cards will apparently be able to generate these. How many? How common will they be? And will those cards be any good?
I can envision being in a situation where you need at least four damage, but can only manage to summon two of these (a 1/1 and a 2/1). And it will feel bad. If you can keep the momentum up--they'd probably be a viable part of a zoo strategy that wants to keep stuff on the board. With a lot of other support. But topdecking this will be the weakest possible zoo inclusion. Not sure at this point.
Of all the cards to get alt skins its this one. Just a palette swap, mind you. A dip into the waters before one day selling alt arts for other cards Im sure.
Probably see it generated more often than actually existing in the deck. Because this card is carp, I mean crap. Its outdone by Emerald Skytalon for god's sake.
There's probably a minion down the pipelines that summon a bunch of these to fill the board. Because I doubt team5 would give this an alt art without having a card to justify it all. And also because in what world will anyone actually put this in their deck deliberately?
There was a time where I doubted SI:7 Skulker could even feature in standard. Proven wrong then. And this card is an even bigger version and more consistent with its effect.
So if nothing else, if midrange comes back so will this card be playable. And honestly, sometimes having a 1 mana discount is all you need to gain an insurmountable advantage.
The more I think about Dredge, the more I'm starting to think of it as being like an ever-ready second 'hand' to use for storing cards and retrieving them...
Is a River Crocolisk good enough to keep in your deck if it gives you the ability to Dredge? Not if the rest of your cards are only as good as River Crocolisk. (Maybe its Pirate status improves it a bit.) This feels more like an Arena card than a Constructed one, but it depends on whether or not the other Dredge options are worth their salt. Maybe you want to be able to Dredge as often as possible. I doubt it, but it could be the case. Sir Finley, Sea Guide shenanigans feel like a more efficient way of doing that, but not everyone will have him.
Its an arena card. Because if Lifedrinker actually does make it to standard, this card just lost all reason there is to even get a second glance at all.
Vanilla stats plus draw a naga. If you squint hard enough it actually reads, draw the second copy or your win con.
Good card I guess. It does have a condition that makes it unplayable on curve most of the time, but if you can tutor your win con that's perhaps enough that this card gets a second look.
As it currently stands, getting (1) off of the cost of a card 'sunk' in this way is a pretty minimal benefit. Azsharan Sweeper creates a Sunken Sweeper that allows you to, yes, generate a lot more mechs--but the change from 3 to 2 doesn't make an enormous difference in your ability to then play more mechs. If this is played on turn 4, you still wouldn't be able to play the Sunken Sweeper until the following turn; and if played much later, the cost change is still just a very minimal bonus.
Same goes for Colossal minions off of Ambassador Faelin. They are all currently priced at at least 7 mana. You could, feasibly, play this on turn 10 and Dredge up a 6-cost Colossal as a result, which could work. But then you'd have to wait until turn 10 and have played Faelin first. Good luck with that. It'll happen, but it will require a lot of support and I'm not sure the payoff is worth it. It will depend on the overall quality of the Colossals.
What you figure out how to do with Sir Finley, Sea Guide is anyone's guess. Obviously mana reductions for combo decks are very important. We'll have to wait and see if this is the most efficient way to do that, or if it's better to just keep your combo pieces in your hand... without a mana reduction from this one.
Looks like this is where shaman is heading towards this expansion: murlocs and swarming piranhas.
Forget the piranhas for a second, and this card is unusual in that its a murloc and that it actually has a decent chance to survive for more than the turn its played. For that reason alone, should murloc shaman make an entrance, this would likely be one of the most important card in it.
It basically tutors your win con, or itself. Even at its worst, it will draw you a card while having decent stats to survive for more than a turn.
But Ive a feeling it'll likely be supplanted by Field Contact one way or another. This card is nice, but field contact can and will draw your entire deck given the chance, while this only allows one additional draw per turn.
At least this card can exist in a midrage deck while contact can't. Still, why would I be playing a midrange deck instead of a deck that allows me to draw 10 cards per turn?
Arcane Intellect for priest that occasionally creates good memes.
That's it really. It does what it needs to do - Draw two minions. Maybe that's good enough in the grand scheme of things. The secondary effect will only occasionally be a factor, but I doubt it ever going to do much.
This is a strong card. Gormok the Impaler (a favorite of mine from playing Dude Paladin) is an unexpected burst of damage with a way harder condition to fulfill. This deals one less damage but only needs to have had a spell cast. That could include the coin that allows you to drop this on Turn 3. (Or earlier if you're a filthy Druid.)
Unless there's more stuff behind that we're not seeing, this is one of the worst colossal minions so far. Not because of its stats and potential healing, because those certainly tick the boxes, but because its in a class that has absolutely no reason to ever want this in the deck.
Had this had a simple rush or taunt below its name, then there's still something in it. But the attacks are random, and only happens at the end of the turn, so this can easily clear a good 8/8 minion or crash its massive head into an Annoy-o-Tron, doing nothing whatsoever. Not to mention that despite its huge bulk, it can never realistically attack more than twice and not die, and even if it could courtesy of priest's healing, no one will ever let it survive more than the turn its played.
The sheer mundane description on this card and its legendary status makes me wonder if team5 is deliberately revealing this card first and then its OP support later. Because Ive not seen a legendary card this boring in priest for a long time.
We haven't yet seen enough naga to know if they're a control-oriented tribe or an aggressive tribe. I could see this working either way--either to draw you more minions for your board (a powerful effect in zoo) or to draw your key combo pieces. Tutoring for specific kinds of draws is always a powerful effect.
So far, we've seen cards featuring several different tribes: mechs, murlocs, pirates, elementals, beasts, and of course, naga--which Blizzard really wants to push as the new evergreen tribe.
Is there going to be a heavy menagerie synergy to this expansion? The Sunken City is the land of N'Zoth, God of the Deep, which is clearly directly referenced in this card's name. If there is a menagerie deck in this expansion, this card will be in it. Of course, it could be a part of any given tribal deck, but this seems to push resource generation and flexibility.
Which leads me to wonder--what happens if you play an Amalgam of the Deep on another Amalgam of the Deep? Do you discover from a random pool of three different types? Are all of your choices just more amalgams?
I would assume that the number of cards that you draw with this card will depend on the number of cards in your hand when you play it. In that case, this will favor either a hand-heavy deck--like a handbuff deck, or a handlock, or something like that--or you will play this as a means of digging for a combo piece or win condition. In either case, you'll want more cards, not less, when you play him.
I mean I guess you could drop him on Turn 1 as an aggro move. 1/3 for 1 is nothing to scoff at--Dire Mole proved that well enough--but I think that's probably a worst-case scenario for most decks running him.
Either that or Murloc-generating decks (definitely in Wild; possibly in Standard) will generate multiple copies of him and cycle through their deck options that much faster. There's probably a way you can break that with a combo of some sort.
Colossal minions will serve to replace the Prime minions that are rotating out. And much like how Envoy Rustwix's power level depended on the effectiveness of Primes, Ambassador Faelin's power level will depend on the power of Colossal minions.
Also, Dredge. I think Dredge as a mechanic is probably a safe bet--'scry'-style powers are almost always effective in other games--but the downside is that unless you draw into your Dredge tools, Faelin is essentially a Chillwind Yeti--not terrible, but not generally Constructed-worthy.
Of course, playing Faelin into a subsequent Sir Finley, Sea Guide will be fantastic, and it will happen, and you will be sad when it happens for your opponent and not for you. Calling it now.
2/2 for two mana is bad enough. That it'll grant the next card a 2/2 buff is quite something, but your opponent will be able to sniff it a mile away, and you're still giving tempo off to do it, because this card won't really accomplish much on its own, where even simple 1 drops can kill it.
But give it some buffs, and then this one's actually doing something. Too bad it won't be on turn 2, and what are the chances of anyone holding this card in their hand just so this can fulfill its potential? Not much, is my answer.
I like it because it cheapens The Garden's Grace. On its own, at least it'll make 3 taunts, so that's not completely a hopeless card.
But if the next paladin archetype is quest, or buff, then this card has not a chance in hell. Its way too slow to be useful most of the time, and the taunts, while good, are still small enough that a simple AoE will wipe at least two out. In terms of blocking the enemy from attacking, even a simple Annoy-o-Tron would do, and that only costs 2 mana.
Potentially broken card, depending on the mechs available. If Replicating Menace is in core then this card is just completely nuts. Otherwise, it'll likely just be as good as Defias Cannoneer in that it'll fire once and then never again.
Still, a good start for a possible mech mage archetype. And crucial too, because if such stuff do not exist we're looking at yet another meta where mage plays nothing but spells, again.
A crucial card for any mage that's not playing that god forsaken archetype that's spell mage.
But you do have to play nagas though, and whether this card rises up to be cream would be if there's enough nagas to choose from, and if a minion heavy mage is actually worth playing at all.
It'll likely be in all aggressive hunter decks and quest hunter as well.
Why? I mean it doubles your spells. Aimed Shot alone deals a massive 12 damage for 5 mana the next turn after this one. Need there be more justification?
Piranha Swarmer
Would Murloc Tidecaller be good enough to run if it only triggered off of other... Murloc Tidecallers? And had only one health? Even with Rush.
I mean other cards will apparently be able to generate these. How many? How common will they be? And will those cards be any good?
I can envision being in a situation where you need at least four damage, but can only manage to summon two of these (a 1/1 and a 2/1). And it will feel bad. If you can keep the momentum up--they'd probably be a viable part of a zoo strategy that wants to keep stuff on the board. With a lot of other support. But topdecking this will be the weakest possible zoo inclusion. Not sure at this point.
New Neutral Minion - Piranha Swarmer
Of all the cards to get alt skins its this one. Just a palette swap, mind you. A dip into the waters before one day selling alt arts for other cards Im sure.
Probably see it generated more often than actually existing in the deck. Because this card is carp, I mean crap. Its outdone by Emerald Skytalon for god's sake.
There's probably a minion down the pipelines that summon a bunch of these to fill the board. Because I doubt team5 would give this an alt art without having a card to justify it all. And also because in what world will anyone actually put this in their deck deliberately?
New Neutral Minion - Excavation Specialist
There was a time where I doubted SI:7 Skulker could even feature in standard. Proven wrong then. And this card is an even bigger version and more consistent with its effect.
So if nothing else, if midrange comes back so will this card be playable. And honestly, sometimes having a 1 mana discount is all you need to gain an insurmountable advantage.
Tuskarrrr Trawler
The more I think about Dredge, the more I'm starting to think of it as being like an ever-ready second 'hand' to use for storing cards and retrieving them...
Is a River Crocolisk good enough to keep in your deck if it gives you the ability to Dredge? Not if the rest of your cards are only as good as River Crocolisk. (Maybe its Pirate status improves it a bit.) This feels more like an Arena card than a Constructed one, but it depends on whether or not the other Dredge options are worth their salt. Maybe you want to be able to Dredge as often as possible. I doubt it, but it could be the case. Sir Finley, Sea Guide shenanigans feel like a more efficient way of doing that, but not everyone will have him.
New Neutral Minion - Baba Naga
Its an arena card. Because if Lifedrinker actually does make it to standard, this card just lost all reason there is to even get a second glance at all.
New Neutral Minion - Crushclaw Enforcer
Vanilla stats plus draw a naga. If you squint hard enough it actually reads, draw the second copy or your win con.
Good card I guess. It does have a condition that makes it unplayable on curve most of the time, but if you can tutor your win con that's perhaps enough that this card gets a second look.
New Warrior Minion - Blackscale Brute
That's a lot of stats for a measly condition.
But Mor'shan Elite never did make the playoffs. Will this one share its fate? At least it has taunt by default, I guess.
Don't know if that's enough, because its looking a lot like we'll never actually see this card outside of arena right now.
Excavation Specialist
At this point, we've only seen a few cards that allow you to meaningfully put things at the bottom of your deck: Azsharan Sweeper, Ambassador Faelin, and Sir Finley, Sea Guide. I'm sure there'll be more.
As it currently stands, getting (1) off of the cost of a card 'sunk' in this way is a pretty minimal benefit. Azsharan Sweeper creates a Sunken Sweeper that allows you to, yes, generate a lot more mechs--but the change from 3 to 2 doesn't make an enormous difference in your ability to then play more mechs. If this is played on turn 4, you still wouldn't be able to play the Sunken Sweeper until the following turn; and if played much later, the cost change is still just a very minimal bonus.
Same goes for Colossal minions off of Ambassador Faelin. They are all currently priced at at least 7 mana. You could, feasibly, play this on turn 10 and Dredge up a 6-cost Colossal as a result, which could work. But then you'd have to wait until turn 10 and have played Faelin first. Good luck with that. It'll happen, but it will require a lot of support and I'm not sure the payoff is worth it. It will depend on the overall quality of the Colossals.
What you figure out how to do with Sir Finley, Sea Guide is anyone's guess. Obviously mana reductions for combo decks are very important. We'll have to wait and see if this is the most efficient way to do that, or if it's better to just keep your combo pieces in your hand... without a mana reduction from this one.
New Shaman Spell - Scalding Geyser
Fits neatly into burn shaman. That alone makes it playable no matter what the meta would be next.
And this being a fire spell means that's one more card you can draw from Multicaster. The dredge effect is just icing on the cake.
A good solid card that'll never be missing in action.
New Shaman Minion - Piranha Poacher
Looks like this is where shaman is heading towards this expansion: murlocs and swarming piranhas.
Forget the piranhas for a second, and this card is unusual in that its a murloc and that it actually has a decent chance to survive for more than the turn its played. For that reason alone, should murloc shaman make an entrance, this would likely be one of the most important card in it.
New Rogue Minion - Cutlass Courier
It basically tutors your win con, or itself. Even at its worst, it will draw you a card while having decent stats to survive for more than a turn.
But Ive a feeling it'll likely be supplanted by Field Contact one way or another. This card is nice, but field contact can and will draw your entire deck given the chance, while this only allows one additional draw per turn.
At least this card can exist in a midrage deck while contact can't. Still, why would I be playing a midrange deck instead of a deck that allows me to draw 10 cards per turn?
New Priest Spell - Switcheroo
Arcane Intellect for priest that occasionally creates good memes.
That's it really. It does what it needs to do - Draw two minions. Maybe that's good enough in the grand scheme of things. The secondary effect will only occasionally be a factor, but I doubt it ever going to do much.
Baba Naga
Blackwing Corruptor weeps in his sleep out of fear of Baba Naga.
This is a strong card. Gormok the Impaler (a favorite of mine from playing Dude Paladin) is an unexpected burst of damage with a way harder condition to fulfill. This deals one less damage but only needs to have had a spell cast. That could include the coin that allows you to drop this on Turn 3. (Or earlier if you're a filthy Druid.)
New Priest Minion - Blackwater Behemoth
Unless there's more stuff behind that we're not seeing, this is one of the worst colossal minions so far. Not because of its stats and potential healing, because those certainly tick the boxes, but because its in a class that has absolutely no reason to ever want this in the deck.
Had this had a simple rush or taunt below its name, then there's still something in it. But the attacks are random, and only happens at the end of the turn, so this can easily clear a good 8/8 minion or crash its massive head into an Annoy-o-Tron, doing nothing whatsoever. Not to mention that despite its huge bulk, it can never realistically attack more than twice and not die, and even if it could courtesy of priest's healing, no one will ever let it survive more than the turn its played.
The sheer mundane description on this card and its legendary status makes me wonder if team5 is deliberately revealing this card first and then its OP support later. Because Ive not seen a legendary card this boring in priest for a long time.
Blackwater Behemoth is a New Priest Legendary Card in Hearthstone's Voyage to the Sunken City Expansion
Hardly ever play Priest because of how often I become disgusted playing against one.
Now I may have to join them in order to beat 'em.
Crushclaw Enforcer
We haven't yet seen enough naga to know if they're a control-oriented tribe or an aggressive tribe. I could see this working either way--either to draw you more minions for your board (a powerful effect in zoo) or to draw your key combo pieces. Tutoring for specific kinds of draws is always a powerful effect.
Blackwater Behemoth is a New Priest Legendary Card in Hearthstone's Voyage to the Sunken City Expansion
This is going to be fun again
Amalgam of the Deep
So far, we've seen cards featuring several different tribes: mechs, murlocs, pirates, elementals, beasts, and of course, naga--which Blizzard really wants to push as the new evergreen tribe.
Is there going to be a heavy menagerie synergy to this expansion? The Sunken City is the land of N'Zoth, God of the Deep, which is clearly directly referenced in this card's name. If there is a menagerie deck in this expansion, this card will be in it. Of course, it could be a part of any given tribal deck, but this seems to push resource generation and flexibility.
Which leads me to wonder--what happens if you play an Amalgam of the Deep on another Amalgam of the Deep? Do you discover from a random pool of three different types? Are all of your choices just more amalgams?
Sir Finley, Sea Guide
I would assume that the number of cards that you draw with this card will depend on the number of cards in your hand when you play it. In that case, this will favor either a hand-heavy deck--like a handbuff deck, or a handlock, or something like that--or you will play this as a means of digging for a combo piece or win condition. In either case, you'll want more cards, not less, when you play him.
I mean I guess you could drop him on Turn 1 as an aggro move. 1/3 for 1 is nothing to scoff at--Dire Mole proved that well enough--but I think that's probably a worst-case scenario for most decks running him.
Either that or Murloc-generating decks (definitely in Wild; possibly in Standard) will generate multiple copies of him and cycle through their deck options that much faster. There's probably a way you can break that with a combo of some sort.
Ambassador Faelin
Colossal minions will serve to replace the Prime minions that are rotating out. And much like how Envoy Rustwix's power level depended on the effectiveness of Primes, Ambassador Faelin's power level will depend on the power of Colossal minions.
Also, Dredge. I think Dredge as a mechanic is probably a safe bet--'scry'-style powers are almost always effective in other games--but the downside is that unless you draw into your Dredge tools, Faelin is essentially a Chillwind Yeti--not terrible, but not generally Constructed-worthy.
Of course, playing Faelin into a subsequent Sir Finley, Sea Guide will be fantastic, and it will happen, and you will be sad when it happens for your opponent and not for you. Calling it now.
New Paladin Minion - Seafloor Savior
2/2 for two mana is bad enough. That it'll grant the next card a 2/2 buff is quite something, but your opponent will be able to sniff it a mile away, and you're still giving tempo off to do it, because this card won't really accomplish much on its own, where even simple 1 drops can kill it.
But give it some buffs, and then this one's actually doing something. Too bad it won't be on turn 2, and what are the chances of anyone holding this card in their hand just so this can fulfill its potential? Not much, is my answer.
New Paladin Spell - Immortalized in Stone
I like it because it cheapens The Garden's Grace. On its own, at least it'll make 3 taunts, so that's not completely a hopeless card.
But if the next paladin archetype is quest, or buff, then this card has not a chance in hell. Its way too slow to be useful most of the time, and the taunts, while good, are still small enough that a simple AoE will wipe at least two out. In terms of blocking the enemy from attacking, even a simple Annoy-o-Tron would do, and that only costs 2 mana.
New Mage Minion - Mecha-Shark
Potentially broken card, depending on the mechs available. If Replicating Menace is in core then this card is just completely nuts. Otherwise, it'll likely just be as good as Defias Cannoneer in that it'll fire once and then never again.
Still, a good start for a possible mech mage archetype. And crucial too, because if such stuff do not exist we're looking at yet another meta where mage plays nothing but spells, again.
New Mage Spell - Gifts of Azshara
A crucial card for any mage that's not playing that god forsaken archetype that's spell mage.
But you do have to play nagas though, and whether this card rises up to be cream would be if there's enough nagas to choose from, and if a minion heavy mage is actually worth playing at all.
New Hunter Minion - Twinbow Terrorcoil
It'll likely be in all aggressive hunter decks and quest hunter as well.
Why? I mean it doubles your spells. Aimed Shot alone deals a massive 12 damage for 5 mana the next turn after this one. Need there be more justification?