For Wild, I'd nerf Ignite to shuffle itself at the end of your turn instead of on cast, [Hearthstone Card (Twin Fire) Not Found] to 2 mana and 2 dmg per use so that it cannot be used in Quest Hunter that runs Baku, and [Hearthstone Card (Parachute Brigade) Not Found] to remove the amount of cheap stats Pirate Warrior generates in an instant.
I'm not nerfing Sorcerer, since she's... too integral to Mage. Yes, we had Secret Mage not rely hard on the card, but I am certain a lot of appeal for Wild Mage players IS otk combos with her. I just think she needs to stay only within realms of OG Quest Mage, sometimes Flamewaker Mage.
Question. Why does it matter to us, the player what mobalytics say? It seems like it would make more sense for us gauge our enjoyment of the game off of whether the decks we are playing are entertaining us. As a player, why would I care how statistically good a deck is if it’s not one I enjoy or play?
People generally use mobalytics to find decks that look interesting and are also competitive. Why? Because most people suck at building decks, me included. I get an idea, build it - doesn't really work. Go check mobalytics, find a better list, and it works better.
It's a tool, just like any other tool. It's useful in many different ways - but how you use it all depends on what you want to accomplish with it.
There's a problem with this extrapolation. People tend to play more at expansion launch than on its fifth week. Add to that the state of Constructed over the last week (pepole playing a lot less) and you'll see it's hard to compare a day on this week to a day of week 1 of the expansion. That's a reasonable caveat to that computation, I believe.
Question. Why does it matter to us, the player what mobalytics say? It seems like it would make more sense for us gauge our enjoyment of the game off of whether the decks we are playing are entertaining us. As a player, why would I care how statistically good a deck is if it’s not one I enjoy or play?
Nifty, I think you're playing a different game from the rest of us. Either that, or you're hyper focused on just one thing, and you can't see the rest of the landscape.
1. Champion wincons are just as numerous as they've ever been. Yeah, sure, Lee Sin isn't meta currently (though I guarantee you, people are still playing decks with him - I saw one just last night during the only 15 minutes I've watched Twitch in the last month - and it wasn't the streamer playing it). The fact that Lee Sin is not meta does not mean that no champion wincons are meta. That's like saying, "Well, Thralls fell out of the meta, so I guess Riot doesn't want anyone to be able to win with landmarks." The Mobalytics tier list (about which you created this entire thread) has at least half of the decks being heavily dependent on their champions. And incidentally, two of them have Poppy.
2. Just to digress briefly, you were raging about Plunder Midrange in another thread. And there it is, listed as A tier. 53% winrate.
3. You seem to think that decks with champion wincons are more interesting to build. That's actually just plain false. Most of the decks that feature champion wincons are so obvious that they build themselves (or else they come essentially pre-built by Riot). How much has the Lee Sin deck shell changed since he became meta a year ago?
4. I haven't seen any forum threads complaining about champions, D-tier or otherwise. Except yours, of course.
Had to submit something tonight despite being past my bedtime, 'cause I'll be at work all day tomorrow. Didn't make any additional changes, so...yeah. Guess we'll see how the Sigil does *shrugs*
@Wailor: I like the Mine card, although it might be too good in a Final Showdown/Lion's Frenzy deck. Not necessarily something one can balance, though: yeah you could up the cost, but it might be a situation where it's too good at 2 but too bad at 3.
@AeroJulwin: I prefer the new version, without the Arcane stuff. I think it was too finicky before.
So, the Alliance won simply because they had more players.
One interesting fact though, is that the Horde was responsible for 45% of the Honor having 43% of the player base. Horde never disappoints, even when they lose.
I don’t think Apprentice is in Standard now. So if anything it wouldn’t be banned, but nerfed. Likely she’d get the “not less than 1” text added so she can’t reduce spells to be 0 mana.
If that happens… So long OG Exodia Mage deck as well.
Hell, even Diamond 4 Wild earlier today I was expecting a QL Pirate Warrior because of the portrait being used. Got Odd Armor Bot instead. Hurray for the free win…
How about a Merc that could create a (one turn only) friendly copy of an enemy character? That might be a fun ability. Who could pull off a trick like that? Archmage Vargoth?
And it seems like there are plenty of tribe gaps to fill in. There are (treasures) buffs for elementals, but only a couple Mercs have that tag.
I have a job, a wife, a 2 year old, a house to clean and maintain, I am the main cook in the house, and a home workout routine I (try to) stick to. I occasionally miss a day or two, but try to at least finish dailies. My wife works nights so a large part of my playing time is probably when it’s just me and my sleeping child at the house.
So yeah… I am on a lot I suppose but still taking care of everything else I need to.
I have no clue what to address in Standard but for Wild, there are two very different lists of changes in my head. One that I wish would happen and one that is likely to happen.
What's likely to happen is they just lengthen the time it takes to complete the Warrior and Hunter questlines by a card or two and be done with it. It's rather boring, unimaginative, and, more importantly, doesn't really fix the format. It's likely to just usher in an age of OTK, with the possible exception of Freeze Shaman, if that survives the downfall of Questline Warrior it used to farm.
If they just nerf the two questlines, the meta doesn't really improve that much. Cause if it won't be the two questlines destroying you, it''ll be just normal Pirate Warrior, which even without the Questline has still been supercharged by the last few expansions. In that respect, they'd have to nerf the entire Neutral "free" pirate package (Patches + Parachute Brigand), otherwise Pirate aggro will always be the best type of aggro. If it's not that, it'll be Shadow Priest (also pirates) or the various Drek'Thar aggro decks (many, like Embiggen Druid, also running Pirates). But hey, those, at least, are good old-fashioned aggro decks that can be run out of resources by control. Or they would be, if control wasn't D.E.D. in Wild. Flamewaker Mage, Ignite Mage, Mozaki Mage, Pillager Rogue, Alignment Druid,. Mechathun Lock, Owl Lock, you name it, they all make control mostly unplayable if they're given room to breathe by the absence of the two Questline decks. And even if you were to nerf ALL of that. Wind the clocks back two years. You're right back to control being D.E.D. because Raza Priest can exist again and makes all control irrelevant. In that respect, so many nerfs would need to happen. Scabbs Cutterbutter + Spirit of the Shark is broken in Rogue, Sorcerer's Apprentice is broken in Mage, Runed Mithril Rod, after two mana nerfs, is still like 10 net negative mana. So is Incanter's Flow and Darkglare, btw, it's just that when it comes to mana cheating, the two respective classes have better options to cheat right now. Alignment + Anakondra is what Sorcerer's Apprentice is to Mage, what Kun Aviana used to be to Druid. Shadowreaper Anduin + Raza is just as unreasonable as it's always been, it's just unplayable right now due to the inevitability present in the meta right now. They would need to nerf/kill almost all of the mana cheating to truly, meaningfully improve the Wild format. Otherwise, they're just kicking two oppressive decks in the nuts to make room for other oppressive decks those two were holding back. That's not really addressing the core issue they've been gradually creating since Scholomance.
My last post in this thread was 1.5 years ago, and a lot has changed: I reached 1,000 wins in 3 classes (and got that long coveted Shadow Gul'dan portrait for Warlock). The ironic thing about that is I have been using the Tamsin "Triumphant" portrait exclusively since United in Stormwind a) for flavor and b) because it's a pretty cool piece of art too!
Here are my class tallies as of today:
DH: 565 wins
Druid: 508 wins (my newest golden hero)
Hunter: 1,019 wins (still rocking Sylvanas, the only non-rewards track portrait I have ever bought)
Mage: 725 wins
Paladin: 1,196 wins
Priest: 463 wins (the last non-golden hero. I am thinking I will try and grind a minimum of 10 wins a month unless Priest is meta again and if I am lucky enough to have the right cards)
Rogue: 707 wins
Shaman: 883 wins
Warlock: 1,086 wins
Warrior: 606 wins (Pirate Quest Warrior in standard and wild has been good to this total, haha)
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
No. Previous answer is almost right. Just wrong class.
Hearthstone's Battlegrounds and Duels Modes Get Community Content Reveals Next Week
They might expand the armor system with a coin or coins. That would definitely change how you play almost every hero.
New Hunter Minion - Wing Commander Ichman
I'm pretty sure it is still a very weak card barely usable in a tier 4 deck. And it certainly does not carry anything.
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
For Wild, I'd nerf Ignite to shuffle itself at the end of your turn instead of on cast, [Hearthstone Card (Twin Fire) Not Found] to 2 mana and 2 dmg per use so that it cannot be used in Quest Hunter that runs Baku, and [Hearthstone Card (Parachute Brigade) Not Found] to remove the amount of cheap stats Pirate Warrior generates in an instant.
I'm not nerfing Sorcerer, since she's... too integral to Mage. Yes, we had Secret Mage not rely hard on the card, but I am certain a lot of appeal for Wild Mage players IS otk combos with her. I just think she needs to stay only within realms of OG Quest Mage, sometimes Flamewaker Mage.
New Mobalytics Tier List
People generally use mobalytics to find decks that look interesting and are also competitive. Why? Because most people suck at building decks, me included. I get an idea, build it - doesn't really work. Go check mobalytics, find a better list, and it works better.
It's a tool, just like any other tool. It's useful in many different ways - but how you use it all depends on what you want to accomplish with it.
Blizzard Shares Stats on the Battle for Alterac Valley, At Least 215 Million Games of Hearthstone Played
"10.7 Million games logged from the past week"
There's a problem with this extrapolation. People tend to play more at expansion launch than on its fifth week. Add to that the state of Constructed over the last week (pepole playing a lot less) and you'll see it's hard to compare a day on this week to a day of week 1 of the expansion. That's a reasonable caveat to that computation, I believe.
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
She's cute.
New Mobalytics Tier List
Question. Why does it matter to us, the player what mobalytics say? It seems like it would make more sense for us gauge our enjoyment of the game off of whether the decks we are playing are entertaining us. As a player, why would I care how statistically good a deck is if it’s not one I enjoy or play?
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
I wonder why the herocard Cariel is in the header of this article. I don't think that needs nerf? Libram Paladin basicly relies on it.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
Lightforged Cariel?
New Mobalytics Tier List
Nifty, I think you're playing a different game from the rest of us. Either that, or you're hyper focused on just one thing, and you can't see the rest of the landscape.
1. Champion wincons are just as numerous as they've ever been. Yeah, sure, Lee Sin isn't meta currently (though I guarantee you, people are still playing decks with him - I saw one just last night during the only 15 minutes I've watched Twitch in the last month - and it wasn't the streamer playing it). The fact that Lee Sin is not meta does not mean that no champion wincons are meta. That's like saying, "Well, Thralls fell out of the meta, so I guess Riot doesn't want anyone to be able to win with landmarks." The Mobalytics tier list (about which you created this entire thread) has at least half of the decks being heavily dependent on their champions. And incidentally, two of them have Poppy.
2. Just to digress briefly, you were raging about Plunder Midrange in another thread. And there it is, listed as A tier. 53% winrate.
3. You seem to think that decks with champion wincons are more interesting to build. That's actually just plain false. Most of the decks that feature champion wincons are so obvious that they build themselves (or else they come essentially pre-built by Riot). How much has the Lee Sin deck shell changed since he became meta a year ago?
4. I haven't seen any forum threads complaining about champions, D-tier or otherwise. Except yours, of course.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Had to submit something tonight despite being past my bedtime, 'cause I'll be at work all day tomorrow. Didn't make any additional changes, so...yeah. Guess we'll see how the Sigil does *shrugs*
@Wailor: I like the Mine card, although it might be too good in a Final Showdown/Lion's Frenzy deck. Not necessarily something one can balance, though: yeah you could up the cost, but it might be a situation where it's too good at 2 but too bad at 3.
@AeroJulwin: I prefer the new version, without the Arcane stuff. I think it was too finicky before.
New Mage Minion - Coldarra Drake
Fun in other classes especially with rogue Scabbs :P
Blizzard Shares Stats on the Battle for Alterac Valley, At Least 215 Million Games of Hearthstone Played
So, the Alliance won simply because they had more players.
One interesting fact though, is that the Horde was responsible for 45% of the Honor having 43% of the player base. Horde never disappoints, even when they lose.
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
Please throw ignite mage to the garbage bin. That deck is the worst deck to play against in my entire time of playing hearthstone.
Blizzard Shares Stats on the Battle for Alterac Valley, At Least 215 Million Games of Hearthstone Played
At least in Hearthstone, the Alliance finally grew some balls.
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
I don’t think Apprentice is in Standard now. So if anything it wouldn’t be banned, but nerfed. Likely she’d get the “not less than 1” text added so she can’t reduce spells to be 0 mana.
If that happens… So long OG Exodia Mage deck as well.
”A-HA!!” ~ Tony
Blizzard Shares Stats on the Battle for Alterac Valley, At Least 215 Million Games of Hearthstone Played
Hell, even Diamond 4 Wild earlier today I was expecting a QL Pirate Warrior because of the portrait being used. Got Odd Armor Bot instead. Hurray for the free win…
Hearthstone's Battlegrounds and Duels Modes Get Community Content Reveals Next Week
Are we getting timers for this on HS front page?
Hearthstone's Next Major Patch Brings New Mercenaries, Zones, Bounties, and More to the Tavern on January 25
How about a Merc that could create a (one turn only) friendly copy of an enemy character? That might be a fun ability. Who could pull off a trick like that? Archmage Vargoth?
And it seems like there are plenty of tribe gaps to fill in. There are (treasures) buffs for elementals, but only a couple Mercs have that tag.
Blizzard Shares Stats on the Battle for Alterac Valley, At Least 215 Million Games of Hearthstone Played
I have a job, a wife, a 2 year old, a house to clean and maintain, I am the main cook in the house, and a home workout routine I (try to) stick to. I occasionally miss a day or two, but try to at least finish dailies. My wife works nights so a large part of my playing time is probably when it’s just me and my sleeping child at the house.
So yeah… I am on a lot I suppose but still taking care of everything else I need to.
Hearthstone's Battlegrounds and Duels Modes Get Community Content Reveals Next Week
Totems? Can I has totems at last?
Hearthstone's Standard and Wild Modes are Getting Balance Changes on January 25
I have no clue what to address in Standard but for Wild, there are two very different lists of changes in my head. One that I wish would happen and one that is likely to happen.
What's likely to happen is they just lengthen the time it takes to complete the Warrior and Hunter questlines by a card or two and be done with it. It's rather boring, unimaginative, and, more importantly, doesn't really fix the format. It's likely to just usher in an age of OTK, with the possible exception of Freeze Shaman, if that survives the downfall of Questline Warrior it used to farm.
If they just nerf the two questlines, the meta doesn't really improve that much. Cause if it won't be the two questlines destroying you, it''ll be just normal Pirate Warrior, which even without the Questline has still been supercharged by the last few expansions. In that respect, they'd have to nerf the entire Neutral "free" pirate package (Patches + Parachute Brigand), otherwise Pirate aggro will always be the best type of aggro. If it's not that, it'll be Shadow Priest (also pirates) or the various Drek'Thar aggro decks (many, like Embiggen Druid, also running Pirates). But hey, those, at least, are good old-fashioned aggro decks that can be run out of resources by control. Or they would be, if control wasn't D.E.D. in Wild. Flamewaker Mage, Ignite Mage, Mozaki Mage, Pillager Rogue, Alignment Druid,. Mechathun Lock, Owl Lock, you name it, they all make control mostly unplayable if they're given room to breathe by the absence of the two Questline decks. And even if you were to nerf ALL of that. Wind the clocks back two years. You're right back to control being D.E.D. because Raza Priest can exist again and makes all control irrelevant. In that respect, so many nerfs would need to happen. Scabbs Cutterbutter + Spirit of the Shark is broken in Rogue, Sorcerer's Apprentice is broken in Mage, Runed Mithril Rod, after two mana nerfs, is still like 10 net negative mana. So is Incanter's Flow and Darkglare, btw, it's just that when it comes to mana cheating, the two respective classes have better options to cheat right now. Alignment + Anakondra is what Sorcerer's Apprentice is to Mage, what Kun Aviana used to be to Druid. Shadowreaper Anduin + Raza is just as unreasonable as it's always been, it's just unplayable right now due to the inevitability present in the meta right now. They would need to nerf/kill almost all of the mana cheating to truly, meaningfully improve the Wild format. Otherwise, they're just kicking two oppressive decks in the nuts to make room for other oppressive decks those two were holding back. That's not really addressing the core issue they've been gradually creating since Scholomance.
Hearthstone's Battlegrounds and Duels Modes Get Community Content Reveals Next Week
I’m hoping for a new pandaren tribe to hopefully lead into a Pandaria-themed expansion.
Golden Hero Portrait - Completionist & Grind
My last post in this thread was 1.5 years ago, and a lot has changed: I reached 1,000 wins in 3 classes (and got that long coveted Shadow Gul'dan portrait for Warlock). The ironic thing about that is I have been using the Tamsin "Triumphant" portrait exclusively since United in Stormwind a) for flavor and b) because it's a pretty cool piece of art too!
Here are my class tallies as of today:
DH: 565 wins
Druid: 508 wins (my newest golden hero)
Hunter: 1,019 wins (still rocking Sylvanas, the only non-rewards track portrait I have ever bought)
Mage: 725 wins
Paladin: 1,196 wins
Priest: 463 wins (the last non-golden hero. I am thinking I will try and grind a minimum of 10 wins a month unless Priest is meta again and if I am lucky enough to have the right cards)
Rogue: 707 wins
Shaman: 883 wins
Warlock: 1,086 wins
Warrior: 606 wins (Pirate Quest Warrior in standard and wild has been good to this total, haha)