One potential solution for things getting too wild in... Wild, would be to have another game mode that acts similarly to the Brawl Blocks with rotating card pool sets. If any particular rotation they put into play has a deck or combo that is too strong they could actually just ban the problematic card(s) from that mode during that time.
I know one of the arguments has always been that another new mode like this would further divide the Wild player base and make queue times longer. But I'm already seeing a lot of Wild streamers starting to play Standard on stream because they are annoyed with the state of Wild. So what's the harm if Wild's player base is already starting to leave?
Not to mention I feel they are already at a point of critical mass in the number of cards making it nearly impossible to keep things balanced in Wild while still printing new cards meant for Standard. So it's either 1) Let all cards be and just let Wild be wild with very few if any balance changes, 2) Nerf certain cards straight to hell to essentially delete them from the game once they hit Wild and banning them until they leave Standard (ex: The Demon Seed), or 3) Make balance changes sparingly similar to option 1, but also have a "Limited" mode where they can ban certain cards, rotate through old sets for different metas, etc. The "Limited" format could even just go off the current Arena rotation list to make it a little easier.
A WILD non-curated Wild would be a nightmare and a wasteland, just as Classic. It's doing relatively fine as is now, it just needs the same attention Standard gets in terms of balance. How on earth warrior and hunter questlines weren't dealt with yet? Or [Hearthstone Card (Sorceress Apprentice) Not Found]? Why no Wild tournaments, even smaller scale ones... They're being stupid to neglect their Eternal mode. Still, here we are... since Beta and Wild-only player.
Still, I'm hoping they'll finally address it this next patch.
Seems like there's plenty inspiration to go around this week.
Feedback
linkblade91
Twilight Hammer's Den doesn't seem like it needs to be spread out, since it already doesn't give any immediate benefits.
Wave of Ooze is okay, but I feel like it should really belong to Warlock or Warrior.
Sigil of Momentum is my favorite. It's quite unique and doesn't seem OP, since you have to pay upfront.
Wailor
I feel like this should probably be a Dormant minion.
Demonxc95
Voodoo Grounds is good, but indeed not very original.
Icewing Bunker is definitely more original, but I'm not sure how to balance its cost.
BasilAnguis
The Questline phrases it as "Deal damage with 2 spells.", so this is fine. I like how the effect works, although I'm not sure 1 damage makes this card worth it to me.
Buried in Ice is simple, but still a good option.
I'm not sure how I feel about Pacifism. I know Druid uses Taunt, but they also have a lack of removals and I'm not sure how often the draw will be worth it. I also don't like that it affects your opponent, which should probably make it a 1-cost.
BloodMefist
I like both of these. Rain of Chaos is very interesting, but needs a few turns to get strong and could backfire, but it's still a great control tool. I like Massive Hoard slightly better, because it seems really fun.
A daring 0-cost. It fits Arcane's resourcefulness perfectly. Normally it would be a bit unconventional, which is how I got the inspiration for this prompt.
Works like Tracking, but you'll have to get the draw yourself. The counter shows how many uses it gives and how many have already triggered.
BloodMefist - I like Rain of Chaos: it's a good play on the Warcraft III subtitle, while also being a neat ramp-up clear.
BasilAnguis - I like Freeze Shaman a lot, but Freeze Mage is a pain in the ass; I think they're doing different things, though, which is where the hatred partially stems from. Shaman is (supposed to be) playing for the board, while the Mage is just stalling for its OTK. Anyway, I like Pacifism the most even though you can circumvent the condition with hero attacks.
Demonxz95 - Voodoo Grounds could win the whole thing, but that would be very disappointing to me because I think it's too on-the-nose. "They gave the Rogue Baron Rivendare; I'll give the Shaman Brann Bronzebeard." It's low-hanging fruit :/ Icewing Bunker is more interesting, IMO, giving the Warrior some draw.
Wailor - I believe the "three" should be a number, but beyond that it's a neat idea. The payoff is way too low for such a long time to wait, in my opinion; one of those should be fixed. I'd lower the turn count, as you suggested.
The first one is an ode to the most fun aspects of Thief Rogue and an homage to Dragon's Hoard. The second is a bit more out there, caring about how long it has been on the board and ramping in intensity.
3 ideas for this! Buried in Ice is probably gonna get hated because people hate freeze mage and frost in general (hello shaman). Cover Fire might be broken with the quest, but i envision since it's only 1 spell only the first time it deals damage counts. Pacifism is my favorite but might not be everyone's flavor.
Two Shaman ideas for this week, both placed in earlier expansions:
Shaman never got a C'Thun card for whatever reason, so I gave it one in Twilight Hammer's Den. Wave of Ooze is a Control card to deny stuff like Dudeadin, Zoolock or a Hunter summoning a bunch of small Beasts. Edit: Added in a Sigil, Sigil of Momentum. Finding art for Sigils is hard, with the added difficulty of trying to phrase it right. My example is, if you have 7 Attack at the end of your current turn, next turn you would go back up to 7 Attack again for that turn (before adding in anything else). You carried your momentum into the next swing.
Not sure how I feel about using the "Lasts X turns" formatting since it didn't exist back then, but it definitely allows me room to fit the effect. When I came up with two Alraune cards using a multi-turn effect over a year ago, I explained the whole thing more verbosely:
It's time for a different kind of counting this week, but don't worry - your cards will be keeping track for you this time!
You must create a card which uses a counter similar to those of the Objective spells or the Sigils
That's the little marker above your hero that counts down how long an Objective lasts for, or how long until a Sigil activates. So long as your card is counting something, you're good to go!
AeroJulwin is counting on us to do some counting this week - so make sure your cards are keeping track of it!
As always, I can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.
Competition Phases
Here are the phases of this card design competition
Submission Phase: Starts on Mon, Jan 10 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Sat, Jan 15 17:00 EST (GMT -0500)
Voting Phase: Starts on Sat, Jan 15 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Sun, Jan 16 16:00 EST (GMT -0500)
Finalist Phase: Starts on Sun, Jan 16 17:00 EST (GMT -0500). Runs until Mon, Jan 17 17:00 EST (GMT -0500)
Winner Selected: After finalist voting concludes and we validate votes.
Discussion Thread Rules
No thread rules were added to this season. Please populate and manually edit this thread with them.
I mean, I hope they are working on known issues and glitches as much as they do for trying to conferr cosmetics. I would not say no to a nice skin(depends on me, obviously) but I would be very upset about the patch if there will be no solution for the majority of those bugs. We'll see.
I used a example of decks people know about that featured Champs as primary win cons.
But like sure if we are dreaming let's go top tier Ash Thres, Thaliyah Malphite, top tier deep.
I just want champ focused win cons to actually win games.
Most decks that win seen to win despite any Champs they are running as opposed to because of them.
Ezreal Kenin used to win because kenin burned opponents down to 0.
Now Kenin delays the game until Ahiri can elusive swing you down to 0. Like if she just was a vanilla 2/3 elusive quick attack follower it would literally change nothing.
Good Champs, with unique play styles and wincons, over grindy value wars where you just swing over ans over again with hard to remove stuff for value.
Edit: Champs are supposed to be Runeterras plainswalkers (mtg) and unfortunately Legends doesn't work as a card game if 95% of those planeswalkers (aka the characters you care about) are just a joke. Like they hit the board and they are less threatening than 1 one mana fur ball...that's the game right now.
Champions are about fulfilling a particular fantasy regardless of their region. I guess it's a big part of why I got frustrated with the game, but for folks that have no issue with that, the game is probably totally reasonable.
I agree with you here, I think they care more about champion identity than region identity, which is a philosophy that, while not inherently bad, I disagree with. I made a video all about it, the research for that video being what led me to this thread. The Shurima and Bandle City sets prove your post from 2 years ago 100% correct.
That just like saying hey let's replace this trash with garbage.
Twisted Fate/Fizz didn't play that much different from elusive poro it was mostly about spamming a bunch of zero mana elusives and buffing them. TF was just their to make the deck more consistent and offer a secondary win con.
Fiora/Shen was never toxic, it didn't make control or aggro unplayable and even at it's most powerful the deck had a mostly a 50/50, 45/55 match up table but it was a top tier for a long time so people got tired or it same thing happened to Ezreal/Draven.
The frustrating part to me is that they are lot's of fun deck in this meta Senna/Veigar, Taliyah/Ziggs, Pantheon/Taric, Turbo Thralls but they are overshadowed yet another elusive deck.
I like Diablo being a "dual class" hero (and an outside IP character at that) in Duels. What I don't like is the insane fucking synergy that demon seed has with the claws hero power.
Demon seed needs to be nerfed heavily (or banned from Duels) because it's just too much of a warping factor, especially with Diablo around. It creates a situation where you can't even play big minions, because you actually help accelerate their quest completion.
I'm not trying to bitch for the sake of bitching, but the quest specifically with Diablo creates a polarizing situation where playing no-minions or going wide will cause you to lose. Playing big minions will....also cause you to lose, just faster.
I just really hate the Demon Seed as a mechanic as a whole, it circumvents a core mechanic, and should never have existed in the first place.
Also, since I'm ranting in this thread: Fuck Pirate Quest: I know it's low skill in both duels and standard, but I'm so sick and tired of seeing it. I'm sick of seeing cannoneer on turn 4, and I'm sick of highrolls with Smite/Gorehowl.
On the next rotation Blizzard needs to tone down the mana cheating, tone down the card draw, and bring back resource management and actual decisions. When 90% of your playerbase currently is just speedrunning through their deck for their quest completion/OTK/aggro curve without any consideration to resources (because they never have to worry about running out of cards) then there is a fundamental problem with the game.
[Game] Card Treasure Hunt (Hearthstone Riddles)
Bees... a druid deck? Linecracker maybe.
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
I think the announcement will be about the winner of the Horde/Alliance honor battle, and then the patch will include the diamond card and such.
Probably later this week?
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
One potential solution for things getting too wild in... Wild, would be to have another game mode that acts similarly to the Brawl Blocks with rotating card pool sets. If any particular rotation they put into play has a deck or combo that is too strong they could actually just ban the problematic card(s) from that mode during that time.
I know one of the arguments has always been that another new mode like this would further divide the Wild player base and make queue times longer. But I'm already seeing a lot of Wild streamers starting to play Standard on stream because they are annoyed with the state of Wild. So what's the harm if Wild's player base is already starting to leave?
Not to mention I feel they are already at a point of critical mass in the number of cards making it nearly impossible to keep things balanced in Wild while still printing new cards meant for Standard. So it's either 1) Let all cards be and just let Wild be wild with very few if any balance changes, 2) Nerf certain cards straight to hell to essentially delete them from the game once they hit Wild and banning them until they leave Standard (ex: The Demon Seed), or 3) Make balance changes sparingly similar to option 1, but also have a "Limited" mode where they can ban certain cards, rotate through old sets for different metas, etc. The "Limited" format could even just go off the current Arena rotation list to make it a little easier.
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
A WILD non-curated Wild would be a nightmare and a wasteland, just as Classic. It's doing relatively fine as is now, it just needs the same attention Standard gets in terms of balance. How on earth warrior and hunter questlines weren't dealt with yet? Or [Hearthstone Card (Sorceress Apprentice) Not Found]? Why no Wild tournaments, even smaller scale ones... They're being stupid to neglect their Eternal mode. Still, here we are... since Beta and Wild-only player.
Still, I'm hoping they'll finally address it this next patch.
Does each region have enough of an identity?
Shup up clown
New Legends of Runeterra Balance Changes Coming This Week Focus on Dominant Decks and Improving Region Diversity
Shup up clown
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Seems like there's plenty inspiration to go around this week.
Wave of Ooze is okay, but I feel like it should really belong to Warlock or Warrior.
Sigil of Momentum is my favorite. It's quite unique and doesn't seem OP, since you have to pay upfront.
Icewing Bunker is definitely more original, but I'm not sure how to balance its cost.
Buried in Ice is simple, but still a good option.
I'm not sure how I feel about Pacifism. I know Druid uses Taunt, but they also have a lack of removals and I'm not sure how often the draw will be worth it. I also don't like that it affects your opponent, which should probably make it a 1-cost.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
A daring 0-cost. It fits Arcane's resourcefulness perfectly. Normally it would be a bit unconventional, which is how I got the inspiration for this prompt.
Works like Tracking, but you'll have to get the draw yourself. The counter shows how many uses it gives and how many have already triggered.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Some early feedback:
BloodMefist - I like Rain of Chaos: it's a good play on the Warcraft III subtitle, while also being a neat ramp-up clear.
BasilAnguis - I like Freeze Shaman a lot, but Freeze Mage is a pain in the ass; I think they're doing different things, though, which is where the hatred partially stems from. Shaman is (supposed to be) playing for the board, while the Mage is just stalling for its OTK. Anyway, I like Pacifism the most even though you can circumvent the condition with hero attacks.
Demonxz95 - Voodoo Grounds could win the whole thing, but that would be very disappointing to me because I think it's too on-the-nose. "They gave the Rogue Baron Rivendare; I'll give the Shaman Brann Bronzebeard." It's low-hanging fruit :/ Icewing Bunker is more interesting, IMO, giving the Warrior some draw.
Wailor - I believe the "three" should be a number, but beyond that it's a neat idea. The payoff is way too low for such a long time to wait, in my opinion; one of those should be fixed. I'd lower the turn count, as you suggested.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
The first one is an ode to the most fun aspects of Thief Rogue and an homage to Dragon's Hoard. The second is a bit more out there, caring about how long it has been on the board and ramping in intensity.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
3 ideas for this! Buried in Ice is probably gonna get hated because people hate freeze mage and frost in general (hello shaman). Cover Fire might be broken with the quest, but i envision since it's only 1 spell only the first time it deals damage counts. Pacifism is my favorite but might not be everyone's flavor.
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Got two quick Objectives here.
Counting On You - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
...what!? I won!? :o
Well i certainly didn't expect that. The one week i post on a whim last minute with no feedback and i did it at last haha! Thanks everyone!
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I did this as a Secret long before Sigils were a thing, but it definetly fits this mechanic way better.
I don't know if the numbers are well adjusted. Maybe 2 turns would be more balanced?
Counting On You - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Congratulations to BasilAnguis! Almost came back for the win, but it was not to be :P
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Two Shaman ideas for this week, both placed in earlier expansions:
Shaman never got a C'Thun card for whatever reason, so I gave it one in Twilight Hammer's Den. Wave of Ooze is a Control card to deny stuff like Dudeadin, Zoolock or a Hunter summoning a bunch of small Beasts. Edit: Added in a Sigil, Sigil of Momentum. Finding art for Sigils is hard, with the added difficulty of trying to phrase it right. My example is, if you have 7 Attack at the end of your current turn, next turn you would go back up to 7 Attack again for that turn (before adding in anything else). You carried your momentum into the next swing.
Not sure how I feel about using the "Lasts X turns" formatting since it didn't exist back then, but it definitely allows me room to fit the effect. When I came up with two Alraune cards using a multi-turn effect over a year ago, I explained the whole thing more verbosely:
Keep On Ticking - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Competition Theme: Keep On Ticking
It's time for a different kind of counting this week, but don't worry - your cards will be keeping track for you this time!
AeroJulwin is counting on us to do some counting this week - so make sure your cards are keeping track of it!
As always, I can be reached through Discord or here on the site via PM if you have any issues to report.
Competition Phases
Here are the phases of this card design competition
Discussion Thread Rules
No thread rules were added to this season. Please populate and manually edit this thread with them.
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
I mean, I hope they are working on known issues and glitches as much as they do for trying to conferr cosmetics. I would not say no to a nice skin(depends on me, obviously) but I would be very upset about the patch if there will be no solution for the majority of those bugs. We'll see.
Up To Date Winrates Post Patch
I used a example of decks people know about that featured Champs as primary win cons.
But like sure if we are dreaming let's go top tier Ash Thres, Thaliyah Malphite, top tier deep.
I just want champ focused win cons to actually win games.
Most decks that win seen to win despite any Champs they are running as opposed to because of them.
Ezreal Kenin used to win because kenin burned opponents down to 0.
Now Kenin delays the game until Ahiri can elusive swing you down to 0. Like if she just was a vanilla 2/3 elusive quick attack follower it would literally change nothing.
Good Champs, with unique play styles and wincons, over grindy value wars where you just swing over ans over again with hard to remove stuff for value.
Edit: Champs are supposed to be Runeterras plainswalkers (mtg) and unfortunately Legends doesn't work as a card game if 95% of those planeswalkers (aka the characters you care about) are just a joke. Like they hit the board and they are less threatening than 1 one mana fur ball...that's the game right now.
Does each region have enough of an identity?
I agree with you here, I think they care more about champion identity than region identity, which is a philosophy that, while not inherently bad, I disagree with. I made a video all about it, the research for that video being what led me to this thread. The Shurima and Bandle City sets prove your post from 2 years ago 100% correct.
Up To Date Winrates Post Patch
That just like saying hey let's replace this trash with garbage.
Twisted Fate/Fizz didn't play that much different from elusive poro it was mostly about spamming a bunch of zero mana elusives and buffing them. TF was just their to make the deck more consistent and offer a secondary win con.
Fiora/Shen was never toxic, it didn't make control or aggro unplayable and even at it's most powerful the deck had a mostly a 50/50, 45/55 match up table but it was a top tier for a long time so people got tired or it same thing happened to Ezreal/Draven.
The frustrating part to me is that they are lot's of fun deck in this meta Senna/Veigar, Taliyah/Ziggs, Pantheon/Taric, Turbo Thralls but they are overshadowed yet another elusive deck.
Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!
I like Diablo being a "dual class" hero (and an outside IP character at that) in Duels. What I don't like is the insane fucking synergy that demon seed has with the claws hero power.
Demon seed needs to be nerfed heavily (or banned from Duels) because it's just too much of a warping factor, especially with Diablo around. It creates a situation where you can't even play big minions, because you actually help accelerate their quest completion.
I'm not trying to bitch for the sake of bitching, but the quest specifically with Diablo creates a polarizing situation where playing no-minions or going wide will cause you to lose. Playing big minions will....also cause you to lose, just faster.
I just really hate the Demon Seed as a mechanic as a whole, it circumvents a core mechanic, and should never have existed in the first place.
Also, since I'm ranting in this thread: Fuck Pirate Quest: I know it's low skill in both duels and standard, but I'm so sick and tired of seeing it. I'm sick of seeing cannoneer on turn 4, and I'm sick of highrolls with Smite/Gorehowl.
On the next rotation Blizzard needs to tone down the mana cheating, tone down the card draw, and bring back resource management and actual decisions. When 90% of your playerbase currently is just speedrunning through their deck for their quest completion/OTK/aggro curve without any consideration to resources (because they never have to worry about running out of cards) then there is a fundamental problem with the game.
/endrant
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
Let's hope part of the big plans is to actually release a big patch without introducing yet more bugs into the system.
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
Don`t get me wrong, I think it is a good thing that we get more bundles and skins.
Still I wish there would be "more love" for Wild from the defs :/ ...
No Hearthstone Patch Planned This Week, Blizzard Has Bigger Plans for the Lead-up
Oh boy, I can't wait for the Darkmoon Mini-set.