I'd say commit to Wednesday, as tuesday is almost always patch/announcement day for Blizzard so being overshadowed is a lot more common than on wednesday.
This card I find very interesting. Cards with drawbacks are always a fine balance, when is the drawback too big and the card unplayable, and when is the drawback too small or even not really a drawback (Soul Rend)? This is a very interesting design, also interacting differently with each class. A very deserved winner.
I will definitely be trying to find something else to use. But here's some feedback.
Wailor
Sunfire being almost a better Fireball for Druid seems off to me. True, this version can't target face which is actually sort of a big deal, but I'd probably still lower the damage to 5. Makes more sense for Druid since they're not supposed to be as good at single-target damage as Mage is.
Frostwolf Blademaster is kinda cool. I like the fact that it can potentially clear a board of minions with exactly 4 Health.
Linkblade91
A fine card when looked at in a vacuum, but its flavor doesn't really fit with Fractured in Alterac Valley.
AeroJulwin
Fierce Cub is a really nice design that's simple but not boring. I quite like this card.
Magic Instructor Charon is a pretty cool card that works nicely with Magister Dawngrasp.
Grumpymonk
Vendetta is a fine card, though as pointed out by Wailor, its name is already used so you should change it if you choose to go with it.
Commander Karl Philips is pretty cool, so I'd go with that. More Karl lore.
DestroyerR
"why would I not be happy abou…. oh, I see why."
And yeah, you're right. I'm not happy about it. XD
We may have been told about an old set-exclusive keyword making a return as an evergreen mechanic, but we don't know what that mechanic is. And it sure as hell isn't going to be Overkill, I can tell you that much.
The juxtaposition between the Overkill and Honorable Kill effect is cute, but the Honorable Kill effect is a little bit weird since it can save itself from dying.
New Neutral Minion - Frozen Mammoth
Nice flavor/design. I guess this might see some play in Mage? Shaman seems to go for full on Frost mode.
Card Design Conversation - Early Bird
I'd say commit to Wednesday, as tuesday is almost always patch/announcement day for Blizzard so being overshadowed is a lot more common than on wednesday.
This card I find very interesting. Cards with drawbacks are always a fine balance, when is the drawback too big and the card unplayable, and when is the drawback too small or even not really a drawback (Soul Rend)? This is a very interesting design, also interacting differently with each class. A very deserved winner.
New Priest Minion - Najak Hexxen
Seems like a pretty solid card. If you can silence it in any way, it becomes absolutely bonkers!
New Neutral Minion - Abominable Lieutenant
Abonimably bad, might see some play in Arena where most bad cards give their appearance.
New Priest Spell - Shadow Word: Devour
It seems a little too weak to warrant a deck slot.
New Neutral Minion - Piggyback Imp
Pack filler. Only sees play in Arena and in the Magma Rager section of the expansion compendum.
New Priest Minion - Luminous Geode
Good stats, and it shouldn't be too hard for it to grow out of control if not dealt with quickly. I can imagine it being specially nasty in arena.
New Priest Spell - Bless
Bit more expensive Inner Fire, but has a small buff to go with it. Seems strong.
New Neutral Minion - Frantic Hippogryph
Bad card, seems like they intentionally make Windfury cards bad. The new legendary Windfury minion is kind of an exception to this rule.
New Neutral Minion - Irondeep Trogg
Can become very sticky and annoying paired with Guardian Augmerchant.
New Neutral Minion - Herald of Lokholar
Neutral tutor card, so should be good or decent at least.
Seems like a trend that these tutor on a stick cards will appear in the future for 4 mana and on a 3/5 body.
New Neutral Minion - Popsicooler
Not bad, would have been great if it was a battlecry effect. Will see play in Arena and to complete the new XP achievement.
New Mage Hero - Magister Dawngrasp
The hero power is really good, with a lot of scaling potential. Will definitely see some play.
New Neutral Minion - Vanndar Stormpike
A good control tool, but I can't imagine it being that useful in such aggro-heavy metas.
New Neutral Minion - Lokholar, the Ice Lord
Amazing card, and one of N'Zoth's new best friends, for sure!
New Neutral Minion - Ivus, the Forest Lord
Crazy card, will definitely see play because there is no way that there is no new XP achievements related to this.
New Mage Spell - Mass Polymorph
Great flavor, I love the concept of this card. It can be a game turner just by itself.
Honourable Mentions - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I will definitely be trying to find something else to use. But here's some feedback.
Sunfire being almost a better Fireball for Druid seems off to me. True, this version can't target face which is actually sort of a big deal, but I'd probably still lower the damage to 5. Makes more sense for Druid since they're not supposed to be as good at single-target damage as Mage is.
Frostwolf Blademaster is kinda cool. I like the fact that it can potentially clear a board of minions with exactly 4 Health.
Fierce Cub is a really nice design that's simple but not boring. I quite like this card.
Magic Instructor Charon is a pretty cool card that works nicely with Magister Dawngrasp.
Vendetta is a fine card, though as pointed out by Wailor, its name is already used so you should change it if you choose to go with it.
Commander Karl Philips is pretty cool, so I'd go with that. More Karl lore.
"why would I not be happy abou…. oh, I see why."
And yeah, you're right. I'm not happy about it. XD
We may have been told about an old set-exclusive keyword making a return as an evergreen mechanic, but we don't know what that mechanic is. And it sure as hell isn't going to be Overkill, I can tell you that much.
The juxtaposition between the Overkill and Honorable Kill effect is cute, but the Honorable Kill effect is a little bit weird since it can save itself from dying.
New Mage Spell - Build a Snowman
A strong card overall, might see some play. I can imagine it being specially nasty in arena.
New Neutral Minion - Lokholar, the Ice Lord
This has to be an auto include in Evenlock or Reno Evenlock, reaching 15 health is no issue in those decks.
New Shaman Minion - Cheaty Snobold
Given how many freeze effects Shaman is getting access to, this seems like a very strong card. Good stats on top of that, too.
New Shaman Minion - Snowfall Guardian
It has elemental synergy, and a Frost Nova with buff potential. Seems quite strong.
New Neutral Minion - Vanndar Stormpike
Great card which enables big minion decks. I had to pick Drek'Thar though, simply because: FOR THE HORDE!!!
New Shaman Minion - Sleetbreaker
Awesome elemental, specially since it also gives access to a freeze and card draw. Will see play in most (if not all) Shaman decks.
New Paladin Hero - Lightforged Cariel
An amazing card. It has consecration, damage reduction, and minion buffing all in one. A staple in any Paladin deck.