I love this card, Freezing Trap but for spells. For playing the card I like the ability to counter a spell and for this being played against me I like that you don't just lose the spell. It just gets delayed a little bit and you still get to try and work it in.
Playing 8 mana fro recasting 4 spells is not a bad tempo play, as always, it depends on spells you are getting, but you can control it via deck bulding. It is very stron imho
Not quite strong enough to be a finisher on its own, but good enough to give you a little more burst to get through taunts and such. I think it gets included just for ramping up damage.
Nice board buff for beast decks. If you can manage to put this on Moonfang he gets really tough to deal with outside transform effects. Maybe beast druid works, but I'm not expecting it to.
More support for the token (maybe mid-range) beast druid. I'm not sure this makes enough happen since it is a deathrattle and not a battle cry. I don't think it is fast or strong enough, which of course means that it will do just fine.
Already submitted my idea, but here's some feedback nonetheless.
Show Spoiler
linkblade91
I think I like the first version better. I do believe it would be better if it had an immediate effect. Currently it triggers after they use their Hero Power. Perhaps replace 'after' with 'when'.
Wailor
I believe the cards are suppose to hinder/help your opponent. Unless using your opponents Hero Power disables it during their turn, this doesn't exactly match. I still think it's a good card, but I have previously had a card be disqualified because it only counted on a technicality, so you've been warned.
Demonxc95
Great card! I think you're spot-on with the value and class identity. I think the 1/4 is fitting.
BloodMefist
The effect has good potential, but I'm a concerned about its value. A 3/2 is considerably better than any Hero Power (although ping still holds it's value), so playing this simply means your opponent won't want to use their Hero Power for the rest of the game, which seems pretty boring. And then there's the exceptions like Hunter and Mage, against which this is a hard-counter.
MenacingBagel
Definitely go with the second art. Based on the name I assume it's a reference to something else, which is fine, but the first art just doesn't fit in with Hearthstone.
The 'attacking' effect is quite unconventional without introducing an entirely new keyword. Therefore, it might be best if you made it a Battlecry and use the phrasing Wailor suggested.
Neoguli
It's not that big of a deal for your opponent to stop using their Hero Power. This effect doesn't work well if your opponent is aware of it. It only really works against Hunter/Mage decks that use their Hero Power a lot, because for them the trade is worth it.
DestroyerR
Simple, but effective. That's what makes this a great card! Not sure the effect needs to be a class card, but since the art fits Paladin, I think you're set.
I suppose this is supposed to help with reducing the cost of Frostsaber Matriarch. It also just puts consistent minions on board for several consecutive turns. I kind of wish it wasn't end of turn as that loses you the chance to buff that minion.
I like this a lot. It allows you to get both effects at different times. It will play similar to the minion that draws a Choose One and splits it except this lets you save some mana on the bigger ones. Very solid.
More mana discounts that are not specific to the turn it is played. This is another strong card. Chaining it up with Nourish followed by Pathmaker makes for a really strong sequence of turns.
I really like the flexibility of this card. Tutor cards always find play and this one can tutor any card, not just a minion/spell/tribe etc. Add that it is flexible for a big card or a small card and this will be nice to have.
Do you pair this with the legendary for extra beasts? Beast druid has tried and muddled through for a bit. There are a few other beast support cards in this expansion so maybe this makes it in.
It seems ok, but that doesn't work for a legendary card. I guess it can help control against aggro. It just doesn't seem to fill a need that druid has right now. I'm planning to try to get every card for this expansion but I won't be planning what to do with this one.
This card leaves me with many questions. Like others have said, it feels very slow. The effects are bonkers, but how often will you get to that payoff? Will your mana keep increasing by one per turn after you hit 10? Or, do you have to hero power after hitting 10 mana to make the increase happen? I presume that regular ramp cards will get that for you but it is still 10 mana worth of ramping to get to the important stuff. This can enable some really crazy plays with both eclipses and Survival of the Fittest.
This is a fascinating DH weapon. On the one side its a one mana 1/3 for DH that just lets you go a little more aggro. One the other hand, it sort of discourages the outrageous weapon attack buffs to let you control the board and still damage face. I think it will take a little bit of thinking to play this one properly.
I don't know what the down votes are for. That was one of the better posts I've seen online in a while. I loved the linguistic and demogougic (I think I just made that word up) analysis. Bonus points for the use of the word 'assonance'. It serves the dual purpose of making the kiddies giggle and the word smiths nod their heads knowingly.
I think this one is solid. We have seen other token generators that see play and get annoying. As easy as it is for DH to attack, this will turn into a must remove target.
Another decent synergy card for token DH. Any token deck will benefit from a card that buffs based on something happening to large numbers of small minions. The stat line makes it so there is a decent chance it can survive for at least one turn.
Playing Wild last night, Almost every opponent I fought was Alliance (like me). Made me wonder what they AvH balance looks like when comparing players who mostly play Standard vs players who mostly play Wild?
Personally I chose Alliance because I thought Vanndar would have more potential for crazy Wild shenanigans. But figured everyone would gravitate towards Drek’thar simply because he’s a better tempo play and HS meta has been fast lately, especially in Wild.
But after yesterday I’m thinking either 1) more Wild players went with Alliance for the same reasons as me or 2) at end of month I was just getting matched up with the players in Wild that enjoy off meta and/or meme decks like me and it’s those players who went with Vanndar, not necessarily a reflection of a Wild majority.
This card obviously telegraphs to your opponent that they need to clear the board this turn, but they also need to clear the board every turn for the next three. It will be a nice face off to see if the clears can match the refills on consecutive turns. Also, it isn't a sigil, so you could play both on one turn.
I really like the fact that this isn't a demon. It helps to provide some early control support for the big demon set up, without polluting the cards that interact with the demons. I think I may actually try to play and level up my Demon Hunter this expansion.
This will always be used for the double summon effect. I guessing mainly to clear out one big minion or remove a couple smaller ones. Possibly it is used for removing taunts to push face damage. This is another flexible card that fits tokens or big demons. It helps create minions (and deaths of them for those relevant cards) and it provides an earlyish spell for control.
It is a one turn [Hearthstone Card (Skull of the Ma'nari) Not Found]. I think for big demons, this is just fair enough to make plays without being always broken. You will surely hit some nut draw occasionally, but I don't think it ends game by itself. If played on curve, you essentially make something like 'save your mana crystals for next turn with a little bit of extra cash back'.
New Demon Hunter Hero - Kurtrus, Demon-Render
Wow very powerful hero power, and the tokens are 5/4 if played on curve and attacke all turns. It has a great potential
New Hunter Spell - Ice Trap
I love this card, Freezing Trap but for spells. For playing the card I like the ability to counter a spell and for this being played against me I like that you don't just lose the spell. It just gets delayed a little bit and you still get to try and work it in.
New Mage Hero - Magister Dawngrasp
Playing 8 mana fro recasting 4 spells is not a bad tempo play, as always, it depends on spells you are getting, but you can control it via deck bulding. It is very stron imho
New Druid Minion - Clawfury Adept
Not quite strong enough to be a finisher on its own, but good enough to give you a little more burst to get through taunts and such. I think it gets included just for ramping up damage.
New Druid Spell - Heart of the Wild
Nice board buff for beast decks. If you can manage to put this on Moonfang he gets really tough to deal with outside transform effects. Maybe beast druid works, but I'm not expecting it to.
Hearthstone's December 2021 Card Back, Scarf of the Hearth, Has Arrived! Important Events to Expect This Month
Also two bundles will be released with 5 portraits each - Winter cheer and Winter chill bundle
New Druid Minion - Dire Frostwolf
More support for the token (maybe mid-range) beast druid. I'm not sure this makes enough happen since it is a deathrattle and not a battle cry. I don't think it is fast or strong enough, which of course means that it will do just fine.
Fight The Power - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Already submitted my idea, but here's some feedback nonetheless.
The 'attacking' effect is quite unconventional without introducing an entirely new keyword. Therefore, it might be best if you made it a Battlecry and use the phrasing Wailor suggested.
New Druid Spell - Frostwolf Kennels
I suppose this is supposed to help with reducing the cost of Frostsaber Matriarch. It also just puts consistent minions on board for several consecutive turns. I kind of wish it wasn't end of turn as that loses you the chance to buff that minion.
New Druid Minion - Pathmaker
I like this a lot. It allows you to get both effects at different times. It will play similar to the minion that draws a Choose One and splits it except this lets you save some mana on the bigger ones. Very solid.
New Druid Minion - Pride Seeker
More mana discounts that are not specific to the turn it is played. This is another strong card. Chaining it up with Nourish followed by Pathmaker makes for a really strong sequence of turns.
New Druid Spell - Capture Coldtooth Mine
I really like the flexibility of this card. Tutor cards always find play and this one can tutor any card, not just a minion/spell/tribe etc. Add that it is flexible for a big card or a small card and this will be nice to have.
New Druid Minion - Frostsaber Matriarch
Do you pair this with the legendary for extra beasts? Beast druid has tried and muddled through for a bit. There are a few other beast support cards in this expansion so maybe this makes it in.
New Druid Minion - Wing Commander Mulverick
It seems ok, but that doesn't work for a legendary card. I guess it can help control against aggro. It just doesn't seem to fill a need that druid has right now. I'm planning to try to get every card for this expansion but I won't be planning what to do with this one.
New Druid Hero - Wildheart Guff
This card leaves me with many questions. Like others have said, it feels very slow. The effects are bonkers, but how often will you get to that payoff? Will your mana keep increasing by one per turn after you hit 10? Or, do you have to hero power after hitting 10 mana to make the increase happen? I presume that regular ramp cards will get that for you but it is still 10 mana worth of ramping to get to the important stuff. This can enable some really crazy plays with both eclipses and Survival of the Fittest.
New Demon Hunter Weapon - Dreadprison Glaive
This is a fascinating DH weapon. On the one side its a one mana 1/3 for DH that just lets you go a little more aggro. One the other hand, it sort of discourages the outrageous weapon attack buffs to let you control the board and still damage face. I think it will take a little bit of thinking to play this one properly.
Fractured in Alterac Valley's Legendary Questline is Starting Early in a Hotfix - Unlock New Golden Cards Early
I don't know what the down votes are for. That was one of the better posts I've seen online in a while. I loved the linguistic and demogougic (I think I just made that word up) analysis. Bonus points for the use of the word 'assonance'. It serves the dual purpose of making the kiddies giggle and the word smiths nod their heads knowingly.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Battleworn Vanguard
I think this one is solid. We have seen other token generators that see play and get annoying. As easy as it is for DH to attack, this will turn into a must remove target.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Flag Runner
Another decent synergy card for token DH. Any token deck will benefit from a card that buffs based on something happening to large numbers of small minions. The stat line makes it so there is a decent chance it can survive for at least one turn.
Fractured in Alterac Valley's Legendary Questline is Starting Early in a Hotfix - Unlock New Golden Cards Early
Playing Wild last night, Almost every opponent I fought was Alliance (like me). Made me wonder what they AvH balance looks like when comparing players who mostly play Standard vs players who mostly play Wild?
Personally I chose Alliance because I thought Vanndar would have more potential for crazy Wild shenanigans. But figured everyone would gravitate towards Drek’thar simply because he’s a better tempo play and HS meta has been fast lately, especially in Wild.
But after yesterday I’m thinking either 1) more Wild players went with Alliance for the same reasons as me or 2) at end of month I was just getting matched up with the players in Wild that enjoy off meta and/or meme decks like me and it’s those players who went with Vanndar, not necessarily a reflection of a Wild majority.
Probably #2.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Field of Strife
This card obviously telegraphs to your opponent that they need to clear the board this turn, but they also need to clear the board every turn for the next three. It will be a nice face off to see if the clears can match the refills on consecutive turns. Also, it isn't a sigil, so you could play both on one turn.
New Demon Hunter Minion - Warden of Chains
I really like the fact that this isn't a demon. It helps to provide some early control support for the big demon set up, without polluting the cards that interact with the demons. I think I may actually try to play and level up my Demon Hunter this expansion.
Fractured in Alterac Valley's Legendary Questline is Starting Early in a Hotfix - Unlock New Golden Cards Early
If you earn an achievement now you can wait until the reward track refresh to click it. If you do that, the xp should go towards the new reward track.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Flanking Maneuver
This will always be used for the double summon effect. I guessing mainly to clear out one big minion or remove a couple smaller ones. Possibly it is used for removing taunts to push face damage. This is another flexible card that fits tokens or big demons. It helps create minions (and deaths of them for those relevant cards) and it provides an earlyish spell for control.
New Demon Hunter Spell - Sigil of Reckoning
It is a one turn [Hearthstone Card (Skull of the Ma'nari) Not Found]. I think for big demons, this is just fair enough to make plays without being always broken. You will surely hit some nut draw occasionally, but I don't think it ends game by itself. If played on curve, you essentially make something like 'save your mana crystals for next turn with a little bit of extra cash back'.