All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • forcemajeure

    Amazing post! I found your perspective on this issue very compelling. Your writing always leaves me with something to think about. iforgot.apple.com

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    Captchas (the one with the check marks) are really simple and work really well at detecting bots, I don't see how it wouldn't be here. If they know what they are looking for they know how to make it work. They can't tell everyone because it would be really easy to work around it.

  • Caverns of Time

    Shark Puncher is a powerful card. I love using it to win fights in 2 player games. Defile is missing from Warlock.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Well the fact that the post only shows 4 cards (I assumed it would have been every treasure like Kazakusan), this yes Wondrous Wand would be the best and absolutely broken. Need to confirm in the game now 

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Glad to see Blizzard learnt their lesson with the early access cards attached to pre-orders. Let's hope no more future Corridor Sleeper drama

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    Pro

    "Starting with Patch 29.6, most Diamond cards will be able to be disenchanted..."

    Huh. I have 23 diamond cards in my collection, only one of them can be disenchanted. It's the Patches I got from the Twist bundle. Contrary to that, the Helya I got from another bundle can not be disenchanted. Too bad we can't dust the ones from reward tracks and such, there are quite a few that I never use.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    New Marin is busted. Being able to choose wand at all times means its never redundant. A case where the reward is so overpowered that all other considerations (lack of rush, taunt etc.) are just secondary.

    As for the tourist cards, its clearly just a gimmick because we've already seen this before in the form of dual class cards. And like dual class cards, Im saying the result will likely fall into two categories: either the cards are very specifically strong in one class but unplayable in the other, and if that is not the case it will likely get nerfed. I personally dont like the idea but that the flavour of the design is good cannot be denied

     

    Other cards:

    A. F. Kay - What this really does is simply giving your non-rush/charge minions a +2+2. As such its never likely to ever stay beyond the turn its played but at the cost of 5, its so unusually slow for something that supposed to work in tempo decks that I simply dont see where this card ever fits in. Just play and pray is about the only strat thats possible with this.

    Corpsicle - This card is just frozen touch but without the possibility of firing twice a turn per card. A core card in any frost-tempo deck and might actually single handedly bring back that archetype.

    Travel agent - Its the sort of card that may actually get puppet theater the fking nerf it deserves. On its own unimpressive. But get puppet theater out of this card can easily flip games which means every reno deck would play it.

    Volleymaul - Unless theres rogue cards that takes advantage of that sunscreen it'll never be played because why bother when you can just play painter's virtue and get your entire hand buffed without any extra costs.

    Malted Magma - Its main purpose is to hit face. There's literally no reason to play this over aftershocks otherwise. Thankfully, its not a nature spell

    Buttons - Its such a weird card because its only ever really powerful on its own in a rainbow shell. Its just not good value drawing any less than 3. You'd think a card like this should at least be useable in all DK archetypes since its obvious its main purpose is to allow shaman cards in your deck.

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    Perhaps the most concerning thing is the fact that bots are simply getting more sophisticated. Ive encountered legions of supposed players playing basic decks all over bronze wild, even as the core set allows them to play better decks.

    Im not sure if all these measures actually discourages botting, more likely it just make botters do better.

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    Celestalon already addressed some concerns, including this one.

    "I spend time thinking on my turns, will I lose XP?" No. This only affects extreme cases where someone is completely inactive for whole turns.

    So if you rope out an entire turn, sure.  But if you take actions during your turn, no.  You shouldn't be affected.  Ultimately this seems like it only combats bots that do nothing, and maybe the bots that would hero power and rope out every turn.

    I don't really play a lot of BGs, but if people are idle botting there to try and get XP for doing nothing, this measure would also combat bots like that.

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    If somehow by this XP change the game starts to falsely classify slow or careful players as bots, I think Hearthstone is beyond salvation.

    With all this ongoing cumulative effort to combat bots, I really wonder if replacing the entire XP system would not be a better solution instead.

    I hope this new expansion will spark some much needed rejuvenation in the game.

  • Hearthstone's 29.6 Update Brings Back Genn & Baku, Adds More Twist Heroes, Buddies in Battlegrounds, & More

    Pro

    Am I wrong to be concerned about the reduced XP for bots? Might it be possible for the game to think I'm a bot because I'm taking a while to decide on a play, or if I get disconnected during my turn?

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    I don't see why they'd be any more problematic than the dual cards of Scholomance. They know which classes will get what, so presumably they'll be balanced around that. You can think of every card as if it had a dual-class frame, but each class gets double the cards but only dual with one class instead of two.

    EDIT: Actually, scratch, this mechanic is more restrictive than normal dual-class. With dual-class cards, you can just slot in the good cards with no restrictions. With Tourists, you have to commit a deck slot to your Tourist. That makes this a lot weaker, especially for Wild. Consider Totem Shaman: would they want to give themselves another dead draw to include Jam Session and Needlerock Totem if they had to? I dunno, it's interesting.

  • New Neutral Minion - Marin the Manager

    Staff Pro
    Quote From sule

    One question: do you get to choose from all four treasure, or do they give you only three choices. Because the difference between guaranteed instant Wondrous Wand and 75% chance of Wondrous Wand does matter.

    It doesn't say "Discover", it says "Choose". Based on prior usage of the term, it should allow you to pick from all four.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Pro

    Marin lets you CHOOSE Wondrous Wand? That's INSANE! I hate to be a knee-jerk nerf guy but if either Marin or Dorian comes out of this unscathed I'll be surprised.

    Lynessa seems really strong.

    Buttons looks good in a Rainbow DK/Shaman.

    The two new Shaman cards (Headliner and Magma) look good for Burn Shaman.

    The rest of the cards are fine, no real thoughts on them right now.

  • New Neutral Minion - Marin the Manager

    Pro

    As a 7-Drop, this card is decent. Treasures are really great, and choosing them is even better. However, in combination with Dorian this card is exceptional. I imagine that a lot of Reno decks and other slow decks (most of which are already running Dorian for extra value) will slot this in immediately. At worst, I see it as an extra value generator for control decks that will excel in that role. At best, it's going to enable some powerful combos and maybe might get Dorian nerfed.

    One question: do you get to choose from all four treasure, or do they give you only three choices. Because the difference between guaranteed instant Wondrous Wand and 75% chance of Wondrous Wand does matter.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Staff Pro

    We noticed, and fixed it while you were typing haha :D

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Staff Pro

    I'm immediately scared shitless for Tourists.

    Even if they only allow other cards from this set and nowhere else, mixing class cards still opens up so many possibilities for something to be broken. It's really hard for me to imagine that Tourists will last their entire Standard lifespan without creating some type of murderously broken combo.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion is Perils in Paradise! Launches July 23

    Pro

    I think the tourist description is wrong. It's not that  Buttons can be placed in a shaman deck; if a DK places Buttons in his deck, then he can add to said deck ALL the PIP shaman cards as they were DK cards, except the shaman tourist legendary.

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion to be Announced Tomorrow, June 17

    News just out: PiP stands for Perils in Paradise

  • Golden Hero Portrait - Completionist & Grind

    Pro

    New year's resolutions done!

  • Hearthstone's Next Expansion to be Announced Tomorrow, June 17

    I was thinking, the pack symbol is surely a HS swirl, but it looks kind of like a Horde emblem.  Reminded me of Forged in the Barrens.  Could some old characters from that year return in this set?  Maybe going on a vacation together with some hopes of treasure hunting while there?!

  • Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn Comes Out July 18th

    Staff Pro

    Just learned there's a contest via Gleam to win a pair of Flintlock-inspired headphones and/or a Steam key of the game; you can still participate, but not for long!

    https://gleam.io/X2hyd/flintlock-the-siege-of-dawn-steam-next-fest-sweepstakes

  • Flintlock: The Siege of Dawn Comes Out July 18th

    Staff Pro

    Played the demo during Steam's current Next Fest, and I am very interested in this one! Never heard of it before this trailer...even though it was technically supposed to release two years ago D:

  • Actor's Leaked Resume Teases Future Hearthstone Cards, Possible Expansion Acronym

    I don't think RSI will publish Star Citizen on 2025.

    For hearthstone, It is NDA so SMR probably means summer.

  • Actor's Leaked Resume Teases Future Hearthstone Cards, Possible Expansion Acronym

    On my Hearthstone vacation I went: 

     - fishing (callback to the Nat Pagle/Pat Nagle cards)

     - sailing (gotta toss a few Pirates in this expansion)

     - lounging by the beach (callback to some of the crab cards, maybe some sand Elementals)

     - on a treasure hunt (that map makes me sure there will be a callback to the League of Explorers)

     - snorkeling (the better to admire little Beasts of the sea)

     

    What else? 

    •