I agree with Demon in-that the Lifesteal version has that "well I just won't swing, then" feeling that makes things murky. I also agree that maybe the Charge iteration could be cheaper/smaller to proc it easier; like a 3/3/2? That'll give more leeway to summon SHRs, buff them a bit with...something, and play the weapon itself.
Just saw your submission; apologies for the late feedback 😕 I like the new card a lot.
Random elemental support. I guess this forshadows elemental shaman in a future set? (I HOPE) Seems meh in standard/wild. In arena it might be nice though.
Seems like a good combo card. Repeat this a bunch, get more with Rewind and Infinitize the Maxitude (Only this expansion, cuz of the small spell pool.) Also you can use Grand Magister Rommath as a finisher if you recast/discovered a bunch of Lightshows.
Seems better than you might think. Seems good for burst decks. And it's a 4 mana 4/8 and +2 spell damage. That's pretty good stats, and the effect is not that bad to trigger. Seems good to me.
Such a good card, will simply see play in a LOT of mage decks for quite some time. After all, spells you play are probably pretty good ones AND because you discover them you also recast them with Grand Magister Rommath.
Seems bad considering you have to discover last, however this does refill your hand a lot alongside Grand Magister Rommath, and of course helps you recast a bunch of spells you discovered.
I feel like this will certainly see play during festival of legends, because of the small spell pool. But it will probably fall off once more sets release.
DJ Manastorm, and next turn 2x Pyroblast + 2 Fireball or Firelands Portal For 30-32 damage. It's quite slow, but i feel like this is a good finisher for some mage decks. But hey, at least OTK mage is back i guess?
Banana's, but they dont clog up your hand? This seems pretty good. Especially with Jungle Jammer or simply to get a few more buffs. Worst case scenario it's 3 mana give a minion +3/+3. Not that bad.
MONKE. Okay this seems really good actually. This works well with midrange hunter decks like Beast hunter, as this doesn't mess with the ress pool and the summon from deck cards.
Rating this a MONKE/5 stars. Glad to see Silverback Patriarch return to standard.. in a playable form.
This simply looks bad to me. Just 1 damage? Meh. Compare this to Deathchiller. Sure Arrow Smith targets lowest health enemy, but i feel like you prefer more damage over that.
Alright, so horrible condition considering Hunter loves putting stuff on board AND the Wild seed package is still in standard. And hunter doesn't really have a secret pay-off deck in standard, and all secret support cards are rotating. Pretty sure Emergency Maneuvers, Explosive Trap, Freezing Trap, ZOMBEEEES!!! and Motion Denied are the only secrets in standard post rotation. Sure that's a smal pool of secrets, but i feel like it's simply not good enough for most hunter decks.
Seems decent in a rampy druid deck? Maybe ramp druid will now go into some kind of Convoke the Spirits package? I'm not that convinced about this card.
5 star card. This seems nuts for only 1 mana. Just with Foul Egg this becomes quite scary, and in Unholy DK you of course have the obvious Cage Head synergy. In Rainbow DK you can also just use this + a good deathrattle like Foul Egg. This is going to see a lot of play.
5 corpses seems like a lot. But Unholy DK can probably afford it. Also Rainbow DK might just use this as well, as long as there is a good enough deathrattle to repeat. (And in Rainbow DK it also upgrades Climactic Necrotic Explosion.) I'm not 100% sure about this card, but it does seem pretty good.
Very slow wincondition, but once you play it it's going to be very scary for your opponent. It HAS to be silenced or even better: Transformed. Otherwise Boneshredder, Mosh Pit and Death Growl will make your life hell. (Especially if they Mosh Pit it the turn they play Cage Head.)
Hmm this seems really nice, as long as you activate the Finale. 3 mana 2/1 that deals 2 damage doesn't seem that good.
Not sure if Frost DK will use this card.
Rainbow DK on the other side, will probably use this card. Why? Decent board clear in a rainbow deck seems pretty good. The only OTHER board clears Rainbow DK has acces to are Remorseless Winter and Howling Blast. So having Hardcore Cultist in the deck might be really helpful with you know, staying alive.
This seems nuts in Triple Blood DK. Vampiric Blood = 2 5/5s, Blood Boil = potentially 6 2/2 minions, Death Strike = 6/6 minion. This seems like a good enough card for triple blood DK just to occupy the board more. Also this can just summon more minions, if your opponent trades minions into it. (Because it has lifesteal as well)
The problem with this card: It NEEDS you to be below Full health i think? Except for Vampiric Blood of course. So that's pretty much the only problem i can see with this card. Also Mosh Pit could make this a lot more sticky.
In Rainbow DK i don't see this being that good. I feel like that deck will prefer other minions.
Triple Blood DK doesn't want this card. It's already doing fine... Unless Blood DK REALLY wants to change their health a bunch for pay-off cards like Arcanite Ripper and Screaming Banshee. That's the only situation in which i can see this seeing play.
I feel like Rainbow and Triple Blood DK might experiment with this card. Using this without any other health changing cards = probably a 3/3 lifesteal minion on the deathrattle. So that seems pretty good.
Hard Core - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I agree with Demon in-that the Lifesteal version has that "well I just won't swing, then" feeling that makes things murky. I also agree that maybe the Charge iteration could be cheaper/smaller to proc it easier; like a 3/3/2? That'll give more leeway to summon SHRs, buff them a bit with...something, and play the weapon itself.
Just saw your submission; apologies for the late feedback 😕 I like the new card a lot.
New Mage Spell - Volume Up
4 mana sprint that tutors is insane. 5/5 star card, this will see play for a long time.
New Mage Minion - Audio Splitter
Good in Big spell mages, especially for more Pyroblasts alongside DJ Manastorm.
In mech mage you might just include it to get more Seafloor Gateways.
Seems alright to me.
New Mage Spell - Synthesize
Random elemental support. I guess this forshadows elemental shaman in a future set? (I HOPE) Seems meh in standard/wild. In arena it might be nice though.
New Mage Spell - Lightshow
Seems like a good combo card. Repeat this a bunch, get more with Rewind and Infinitize the Maxitude (Only this expansion, cuz of the small spell pool.) Also you can use Grand Magister Rommath as a finisher if you recast/discovered a bunch of Lightshows.
New Mage Minion - Holotechnician
Very good with Shooting Star and Spectral Trainee. Sounds strong, but it might be a bit slow. And i'm not sure if this card is what mage needs.
New Mage Minion - Keyboard Soloist
Seems better than you might think. Seems good for burst decks. And it's a 4 mana 4/8 and +2 spell damage. That's pretty good stats, and the effect is not that bad to trigger. Seems good to me.
New Mage Weapon - Cosmic Keyboard
Pretty good card. Helps mage fight for board, while also rewarding you for playing spells. This seems pretty decent.
New Mage Spell - Rewind
Such a good card, will simply see play in a LOT of mage decks for quite some time. After all, spells you play are probably pretty good ones AND because you discover them you also recast them with Grand Magister Rommath.
New Mage Spell - Infinitize the Maxitude
Seems bad considering you have to discover last, however this does refill your hand a lot alongside Grand Magister Rommath, and of course helps you recast a bunch of spells you discovered.
I feel like this will certainly see play during festival of legends, because of the small spell pool. But it will probably fall off once more sets release.
New Mage Minion - DJ Manastorm
DJ Manastorm, and next turn 2x Pyroblast + 2 Fireball or Firelands Portal For 30-32 damage. It's quite slow, but i feel like this is a good finisher for some mage decks. But hey, at least OTK mage is back i guess?
New Hunter Spell - Bunch of Bananas
Banana's, but they dont clog up your hand? This seems pretty good. Especially with Jungle Jammer or simply to get a few more buffs. Worst case scenario it's 3 mana give a minion +3/+3. Not that bad.
New Hunter Minion - Thornmantle Musician
Good one drop, and these buffs are nice. Seems good to me.
New Hunter Spell - Barrel of Monkeys
MONKE. Okay this seems really good actually. This works well with midrange hunter decks like Beast hunter, as this doesn't mess with the ress pool and the summon from deck cards.
Rating this a MONKE/5 stars. Glad to see Silverback Patriarch return to standard.. in a playable form.
New Hunter Minion - Arrow Smith
This simply looks bad to me. Just 1 damage? Meh. Compare this to Deathchiller. Sure Arrow Smith targets lowest health enemy, but i feel like you prefer more damage over that.
New Hunter Weapon - Jungle Jammer
Good weapon. 4 attack is nice damage for SMOrcing, and hunter likes casting spells. So this will certainly see play.
New Hunter Minion - Harmonica Soloist
Alright, so horrible condition considering Hunter loves putting stuff on board AND the Wild seed package is still in standard. And hunter doesn't really have a secret pay-off deck in standard, and all secret support cards are rotating. Pretty sure Emergency Maneuvers, Explosive Trap, Freezing Trap, ZOMBEEEES!!! and Motion Denied are the only secrets in standard post rotation. Sure that's a smal pool of secrets, but i feel like it's simply not good enough for most hunter decks.
New Druid Minion - Summer Flowerchild
Seems decent in a rampy druid deck? Maybe ramp druid will now go into some kind of Convoke the Spirits package? I'm not that convinced about this card.
New Death Knight Spell - Death Growl
5 star card. This seems nuts for only 1 mana. Just with Foul Egg this becomes quite scary, and in Unholy DK you of course have the obvious Cage Head synergy. In Rainbow DK you can also just use this + a good deathrattle like Foul Egg. This is going to see a lot of play.
New Death Knight Minion - Boneshredder
5 corpses seems like a lot. But Unholy DK can probably afford it. Also Rainbow DK might just use this as well, as long as there is a good enough deathrattle to repeat. (And in Rainbow DK it also upgrades Climactic Necrotic Explosion.) I'm not 100% sure about this card, but it does seem pretty good.
New Death Knight Minion - Cage Head
Very slow wincondition, but once you play it it's going to be very scary for your opponent. It HAS to be silenced or even better: Transformed. Otherwise Boneshredder, Mosh Pit and Death Growl will make your life hell. (Especially if they Mosh Pit it the turn they play Cage Head.)
New Death Knight Minion - Hardcore Cultist
Hmm this seems really nice, as long as you activate the Finale. 3 mana 2/1 that deals 2 damage doesn't seem that good.
Not sure if Frost DK will use this card.
Rainbow DK on the other side, will probably use this card. Why? Decent board clear in a rainbow deck seems pretty good. The only OTHER board clears Rainbow DK has acces to are Remorseless Winter and Howling Blast. So having Hardcore Cultist in the deck might be really helpful with you know, staying alive.
New Death Knight Minion - Screaming Banshee
This seems nuts in Triple Blood DK. Vampiric Blood = 2 5/5s, Blood Boil = potentially 6 2/2 minions, Death Strike = 6/6 minion. This seems like a good enough card for triple blood DK just to occupy the board more. Also this can just summon more minions, if your opponent trades minions into it. (Because it has lifesteal as well)
The problem with this card: It NEEDS you to be below Full health i think? Except for Vampiric Blood of course. So that's pretty much the only problem i can see with this card. Also Mosh Pit could make this a lot more sticky.
In Rainbow DK i don't see this being that good. I feel like that deck will prefer other minions.
New Death Knight Minion - Death Metal Knight
Triple Blood DK doesn't want this card. It's already doing fine... Unless Blood DK REALLY wants to change their health a bunch for pay-off cards like Arcanite Ripper and Screaming Banshee. That's the only situation in which i can see this seeing play.
New Death Knight Weapon - Arcanite Ripper
I feel like Rainbow and Triple Blood DK might experiment with this card. Using this without any other health changing cards = probably a 3/3 lifesteal minion on the deathrattle. So that seems pretty good.