All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • New Neutral Minion - Paparazzi

    Most legendaries in Death Knight are pretty useful. I wouldn’t sleep too hard on cards like this when Discover is basically a DK mechanic atm lol.

  • New Neutral Minion - Mish-Mash Mosher

    Decent if you have Attorney-at-Maw but slightly useless anywhere outside of that two-card combo

  • New Death Knight Spell - Death Growl

    Thassarian meta engaged.

  • New Paladin Minion - Annoy-o-Troupe

    I’m gonna give this card probably a little more than it’s due only because of OG Giggling Inventor at 5-mana. This has decent potential to stop aggro right in its tracks with a cheat of some sort (unless they start teching silence cards, which seems likely for this expansion).

    I can’t say how consistent that will be yet, but I’m willing to keep an open mind that this card may be a lot more annoying to deal with than it looks

  • New Hunter Spell - Barrel of Monkeys

    Monke Returns

  • Dies To Removal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro
    Quote From Dolphinslayer

    As a side note, the way I think this would work, obviously, is the minion would take damage equal to your total attack after hitting you, but I'm not 100% positive on that, so if it doesn't work, then I obviously would do something else. 

    I'm inclined to say it does not count in its current form, because the hero is the one doing the damage with the counterattack, and not the spell. Maybe nit-picky, but we want the spell to be the one that inflicts damage/destroys/disappears.

  • Dies To Removal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Transmute is super cool, yet i think 2 mana and just common quality is too low. 3 mana and at least rare or even epic should be better i think. Roar of Time's "bad effect" is barely noticeable as at 6 mana very rarely you can even do something else that turn.

    Thanks for your feedback, Basil! I'll probably submit Transmute, but still thinking on whether the card should be 2 or 3 Mana, which people seems to be divided on.

    However, I also wanted to comment on your feedback the rarity, because I'm not sure what it should represent. As I understand it, cards should have high rarity when they're complicated or when their effect is very synergistic/build-around. However, many people (like you) also think it's a matter of power, but I'm not really sure.

    I don't know if this is the best place to talk about this (maybe a dedicated thread would work better?), but it's a question that has been in my head for some time.


    Anyways, more feedback:

    BasilAnguis
    "Fresh" Ingredients seems to be the preferred option, so I'd recommend going with it. I'd probably slap a Nature tag on it, though, as it seems to imply the minion is attacked with poison.

    I also wanted to say that I really enjoy EXTINCTION, it's a very funny card :)

    linkblade91
    I like the new version of Fan the Hammer, it's more polished than the original, even if the crammed text isn't great. Still, one of my favorite cards of the thread.

    Living Flame is also cool, but I prefer the other card.

    Demonxz95
    I'll list your cards from most favorite to least (although I'm pretty divided between the first two options).
    • Spectacular Entrance: I've grown to appreaciate this card. At first, I didn't realised how well all three effects fit into Mage, and it has aged very well since DJ Manastorm was revealed, as it's a relatively big spell and leans a lot into the early-2010s DJ vibe Mage seems to be going for.
    • Volcanic Cataclysm: Very creative and flavorful card. Maybe the effect is a bit outlandish, but it's part of the appeal, IMO.
    • Fireblade Spin: Solid card, but I prefer the other two.
    • Crystal Blast: Not a bad card, but I find it a bit boring.

    Dolphinslayer
    I'd say it doesn't count, but a Gain Attack + Savagery effect would be more or less the same thing and would definetly count. The name should definetly change, though.

  • Ranking Every Series 3 Card in MARVEL SNAP - Choose Your Card Tier List

    A lot of wrong #s in here.  Off the top of my head, Ghost rider is 4-3, Black Bolt is 5-8, Leader is 6-7......

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    I don't particularly appreciate how they changed Crimson Clergy and Holy Champion to be completely different cards than they used to be. They want some overheal cards in the Core set as well, and that's understandable, but why don't they just print some new cards? The latest version of Holy Champion seems even worse than way back when it was released in The Grand Tournament. Crimson Clergy might be slightly better, but still, whenever they see play in Arena or a new rotating format if that's ever going to be a thing, I want to feel that nostalgia which the new versions won't bring. More cards have had card text updates, but none as major as these two. All the other updates are fine and Catrina Muerte is even more flavourful now. So good changes overall, except for the aformentioned two. Probably sounds nitpicky to some, as these two cards have never seen any ranked play, but I remember them quite fondly thanks to many, many Arena runs.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Quote From Auspicious

    Shadowjeweler Hanar seems so much better than what most classes got that it seems almost deliberately perverse. This and [Hearthstone Card (Poisonmaster Putricide) Not Found] give Rogue more value than Priests and all but the greediest Warriors. 

    Rogue has had arguably the most value of any class for most of HS's existence. It's the entire basis of thief rogue, and many of its control-killer decks down the years. People just forget it because the class has pretty rubbish defensive tools so the value cards are usually left for off-meta decks.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    I think team5 might be getting better at choosing the core cards, because in comparison with the previous two years I think there's a definite chance most of these will see some sort of play, as compared to the playerbase mostly ignoring core previously.

    Some of the bests;

    - Immolation Aura (probably the most important card dhunter can ever ask for), Cat Trick, Darkbishop Benedictus, Shard of the Naaru, Overdraft, Ancestral Knowledge (the only important overload card for shaman), Thing from Below, Defile, Dirty Rat, Cult Neophyte, Tour Guide

     

    Comments;

    - Cult Neophyte in especially is needed, because I cant handle yet another 4 months of drakas and Sinstone Graveyard.

    - Not sure how good Zilliax would be in 2023. Will it see play in every deck now as it did prior? But at very least with magnetic back it'll see play in mech decks.

    - Warrior not getting any sort of draw engine is a mistake. Sword Eater is the only card here I can see that's anywhere remotely good. Ironically, with so many good mechs and magnetic coming back, Dyn-o-matic might actually never see play.

    - Shaman undisputedly got the best core set. Carving Chisel got a hell lot better, but its Overdraft that takes the cake here. What with so many overload cards being introduced, if overdraft isnt back nothing would be done of it.

    - No more Radiant Elemental = :)

    - Dread Corsair back in standard might be a mistake. But quest warrior is gone, and no one plays pirate rogue anymore, I guess.

  • New Demon Hunter Minion - Eye of Shadow

    Alright, so now that Aldrachi is confirmed to still be in Core I have no idea what the point of this is supposed to be.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Priest can build Control Shadow now that Cannibalize is a pretty good stabilizer. You can also run ETC to get some specific counter spells (like Shard) and Svalna is still around as a lategame option (even though I hope they eventually buff her Vision to 2-mana now that radiant is finally gone)

    Plus you can actually build a deck with Catrina that has her constantly resummoning herself thanks to Bonecaller (nvm she can't summon herself)

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Pretty sure Boom, much like the Explorers or Ragnaros, is just added as a callback because there's very few Neutral legendaries you can add into Core that aren't just generally useless or just too meta-warping (to the point where they would overshadow actual new cards)

     

  • All Day 6 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion - 8 New Hunter & Death Knight Cards!

    First playable Rager confirmed?

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    What an absolutely great way to start off the year. I'M genuinely happy they did something with Core now instead of just having it be Classic 2.0 with a bunch of baseline cards you're not actually supposed to play, but rather just compare to the better expansion cards.

    Benedictus in Core is something I was hoping for this entire time because he's such an amazingly well-designed card. No pidgeonholing, just gives you a different way to play for an interesting deck-building requiremenet. Can be aggro, midrange or Control, depending on the current support.

    Everything else is just too much to sum up briefly, I'm honestly thinking about doing a deedicated forum post,  just because there's so many interesting possibilites now

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Printing Discard support in the last expansion of the year and then never supporting it through the next one is a call-back to Rastakhan's Rumble.

    They're really going all out with those references, huh?

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    High Priestess Jeklik Card Image

    enters Core
    receives basically no functional support for an entire year
    refuses to elaborate
    leaves

     

    Jeklik my balls, Blizzard

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Dr. Boom looks so bad now. Compare it to Crabatoa and it is pathetically weak. Dr. Boom is 1-mana more, has no immediate board impact, and the Boom Bots' damage is random.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Demon Hunter getting Immolation Aura and Illidari Studies is better than any of the new cards coming the class' way. The only thing that would have been better would have been getting back Silence and Blade Dance -- but I'd settle for sub-mediocrity at this rate. Kayn Sunfury has no home but okay.

    Priest is looking intriguing. It gets Shard of the Naaru back which will straight-up be the best reason to play non-Shadow Priest if the reveals are any indication. Unholy DK has better recursion than Priest and Silencing that crap will be vital. Darkbishop Benedictus keeps the most competitive deck in Standard. The problem is is that all of Priest's value is dead, with most of that recursion gone. Catrina Muerte can't bring back anything that really matters until you have 9+ mana. I don't think that either Priest will have a decent control deck after rotation for awhile.

    Paladin seems to be getting the previously-ubiquitous Hand of A'dal to make up for the ultra-ubiquitous Alliance Bannerman. The buffed Grimestreet Outfitter seems to be kinda the same idea. Definitely a step-down, power-wise.

    Shadowjeweler Hanar seems so much better than what most classes got that it seems almost deliberately perverse. This and Potionmaster Putricide give Rogue more value than Priests and all but the greediest Warriors.

    I like a lot of Warrior's early anti-aggro offerings in Core and I have (foolish, naïve) hope for its value options, but the new stuff so far doesn't pick up where Core leaves off. But since everybody else's power level goes down ('cept DK and maybe Undead Priest) maybe Core plus value is good enough.

    All anti-aggro decks get Zilliax again, so there's that.

     

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Quote From linkblade91

    I mean, sure, I agree it is wishful thinking, but Brann's impact must have taught them something.

    lolololol. You got me to actually laugh out loud, not euphamistically. They can and will do the same thing twice if it doesn't affect sales. They'll do a hundred must-be-nerfed-day-one-and-playtesters-told-you-so SN1P-SN4Ps but Rastakhan's Rumble can never happen again.

    So, in this case, innocent cards can and will pay for Shadowstep's sins, as if Team 5 didn't already have enough self-imposed design limitations.

  • New Hunter Minion - Arrow Smith

    Image if the text also read (Improved by spell damage) so it would also synergise with the previous expansion...now that would be a playable card, maybe.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Staff Pro

    I mean, sure, I agree it is wishful thinking, but Brann's impact must have taught them something. The whole "We’re also looking to be more flexible about the Core Set throughout the year" section implies to me that they won't let that happen again...hopefully.

  • Blizzard Reveals Hearthstone's New Core Set for 2023 - Year of the Wolf

    Wishful thinking, as they left Brann in standard for the entire year - a card that caused countless others to get nerfed 

  • New Warrior Spell - Verse Riff

    All these riffs might be 1 mana more expensive than they should be. Perhaps there's something we don't know, because I don't think the finale effect justifies an extra 1 mana cost.