All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    Rifts are nice.

    But I doubt its as good as it is in practice. The card only truly gains in value as a finale card, because at baseline its slightly under-balanced. In this respect its substantially weaker than relics or concoctions.

    Pretty sure the legendary would have something to do with the rifts as well. Perhaps play all three? Or just play all the rifts played before. That'll make them all playable, if nothing else.

  • New Demon Hunter Weapon - Glaivetar

    Forget the outcast upgrade shit. If this card simply draws you a card for 4 mana that does 8 damage over two turns, its already a decent enough aggro card that'll see play.

    Realistically, it'll never draw you more than 2 cards, unless drawing a ton of cards is the exact gameplan from the start. Because no one will hold on to this just to charge it up, and there's always a chance your opponent burns your deck by popping it for you.

  • New Demon Hunter Minion - Eye of Shadow

    Its crap if Im honest.

    Why put a 2 mana 2/3 that you have no intention of playing on curve, and that its effect is made completely redundant by Unleash Fel

    Unless this means all your spells have lifesteal as well, this card is just a poor tech choice at best.

  • New Demon Hunter Minion - Instrument Smasher

    4 mana 3/6 is decent and respectable, but the fact that this practically equips another weapon for you, and is somewhat a soft taunt makes it a decent, solid card that can fit anywhere that isn't spell dhunter.

    And no, you're not going to combo this with Going Down Swinging, because that would be stupid.

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Going Down Swinging

    What the hell. If there isn't strong support for hitting minions repeatedly, then this is just complete garbage.

    Judging the card at the moment, without further reveals, this card is doing something Immolation Aura did for 2 mana ages ago. Not to mention the fact that you'll likely lose your weapon hitting minions and not face. Seriously, you can down this to 3-4 mana and it'll still be quite shit.

    Im cautiously optimistic that there's something unrevealed that will immediately make this better, because this is starting to look like a sure-win for the lady liadrin award of this expansion.

  • New Warrior Spell - Blackrock 'n' Roll

    This card is just baffling to me. Not its power level, but the fact that warrior is so screwed and yet team5 thinks this is the answer.

    Well, let's just go through the positives. There are certain warrior cards that can take full advantage of this card. Trenchstalker, Decimator Olgra, Fleshshaper are but a few that will absolutely full utilize the stats given to them. Fleshshaper can also be tutored by Last Stand, and potentially put two 18/28s on board that'll demand answers.

    But the mitigating circumstances make this highly unattractive. Firstly, those cards have to be in the deck when you play this, and secondly, warrior draws like shit. In fact you cant tutor this card by any means, making it inconsistent to begin with. And ironically, this sort of deck just folds to control decks, whilst being somewhat better against aggro with or without the buff.

     

    Dont understand why didnt team5 just make it so it buffs your hand. Surely they've plenty of historical evidence to show that cards like these never work. Lady in White, Deck of Chaos, etc. Is this any different?

  • New Mage Minion - DJ Manastorm

    Its a ramped up Kalecgos, but crucially requires you to have spells in hand rather than discovering on right away.

    Im having lots of doubt about this card. Its an obvious support for big spells, but what are those spells? Rune of the Archmage is rotating, and so is Drakefire Amulet. And there's a point to be made about putting too many big spells in your deck, because you'll get rolled over by aggro.

    So play medium-small spells then? Well, you can already play these by the time you reach 10 mana. What about combo potential? That's fine, but you've lasted 10 turns. How many combo decks actually survives 11 turns? Hell, this card is pretty much somewhat made redundant by Barbaric Sorceress, who also allows cheating mana but does one thing extra in screwing your opponent.

    But for all my complaints, this card will certainly see play because of its power level. Just not too sure how well it'll do.

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    The rifts all seem like cool cards, until you realise that Demon Hunter’s Relic package does the same thing but is so much better

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Quote From Fluxflashor
    Quote From griffior

    That is true, but that doesn’t stop them from playing Standard, Wild, and BG’s. Why not throw the players who pay to play the game a bone and give them something that makes them keep playing?

    Yeah that's my thing with a rotating format. Every format doesn't have to be for every person; Wild certainly doesn't cut it for most and Duels is in the same boat. Standard is there to keep players engaged without a huge investment so give old cards a chance to shine again in a rotating format.

    Hell, I'd even be okay if they wanted to make a format where you could optionally rent the card pool for the rotation. $10 or 1000 gold gets you access to all the cards in that season's pool. It lets people who have huge collections take advantage of them but newer players can go try something new too. Maybe they dump a pass for it in the pre-order too. So many ways they could go about boosting engagement, but I believe that no matter what, they're going to be super concerned about standard queues declining so we'll get nothing.

    Blizzard will half-ass it like they did with the release of Classic (they had zero plan outside of make Classic a thing again) and then cite poor engagement as a reason to stop updating it. All they had to do was push Naxx into Classic 2 months in, and then Goblins vs Gnomes a couple months after that and they could have had repeated engagement. 

    Expansions launch, 2 months later a mini-set launches. The perfect time to do something like a Classic swap is between those two events and between a mini-set and the next expansion. Why they don't rotate Duels even on a more regular basis blows my mind. They've made so many improvements and they finally figured out their cosmetics pipeline (which took an embarrassing amount of time) so what's up with the part that matters - playing the game.

    Also, no new Tavern Brawls ever when it is probably one of the easiest modes to do shit with is beyond hilarious.

    Push out Brawl Blocks once a month. There's a rotating format every 4-5 weeks and the engagement potential is huge. It requires minimal effort to think of the theme too.

    It’s crazy how many good ideas are scattered within OoC, almost like the devs don’t know what they’re doing

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    Phew. It's a good thing the Riff spells don't have the Fire keyword. That way Warrior won't have to suffer from all the excessive amount of synergetic theming they've been suffering from. Y'know, because of how everyone complains that all the Warrior cards just work too well together.

    More seriously, the Riff spells are overcosted, they absolutely need a synergetic card to justify them, and they're another example of the really bad package design that Team 5 has wallowed in for years now. Even if the One True Deck that gets created by the missing synergetic effect is good, its support will disappear by the next set and power creep might well crush it before we're a third more through the year (definitely by the end). These would be better cards if they stood on their own two feet. As it stands, even if these cards become good because of The Missing Synergy, the best we can hope for is a Warrior deck that doesn't suck for 4 months.

    Outside of the lack of keywording, the theming is fine.

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    Staff Pro

    Oh hey, those Riff Finales are like my Encore keyword from the last custom-competition haha. Don't know if they're good, but they're cool.

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Staff Pro
    Quote From griffior

    That is true, but that doesn’t stop them from playing Standard, Wild, and BG’s. Why not throw the players who pay to play the game a bone and give them something that makes them keep playing?

    Yeah that's my thing with a rotating format. Every format doesn't have to be for every person; Wild certainly doesn't cut it for most and Duels is in the same boat. Standard is there to keep players engaged without a huge investment so give old cards a chance to shine again in a rotating format.

    Hell, I'd even be okay if they wanted to make a format where you could optionally rent the card pool for the rotation. $10 or 1000 gold gets you access to all the cards in that season's pool. It lets people who have huge collections take advantage of them but newer players can go try something new too. Maybe they dump a pass for it in the pre-order too. So many ways they could go about boosting engagement, but I believe that no matter what, they're going to be super concerned about standard queues declining so we'll get nothing.

    Blizzard will half-ass it like they did with the release of Classic (they had zero plan outside of make Classic a thing again) and then cite poor engagement as a reason to stop updating it. All they had to do was push Naxx into Classic 2 months in, and then Goblins vs Gnomes a couple months after that and they could have had repeated engagement. 

    Expansions launch, 2 months later a mini-set launches. The perfect time to do something like a Classic swap is between those two events and between a mini-set and the next expansion. Why they don't rotate Duels even on a more regular basis blows my mind. They've made so many improvements and they finally figured out their cosmetics pipeline (which took an embarrassing amount of time) so what's up with the part that matters - playing the game.

    Also, no new Tavern Brawls ever when it is probably one of the easiest modes to do shit with is beyond hilarious.

    Push out Brawl Blocks once a month. There's a rotating format every 4-5 weeks and the engagement potential is huge. It requires minimal effort to think of the theme too.

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Staff Pro

    I'm inclined to agree. It may sound heartless, but the people who decide to dust their cards as they rotate are making a choice. They could have kept their investment and held onto those cards, but they did not; those of us who maintained their collection should not be punished because a subset of people only play Standard. You can say "that's what Wild is for", but that would require Wild to not be such a shit-show :/

    So...yeah. I say 'bring on the rotating block'; you can even fold Classic into it, letting it reappear on occasion for those who want that.

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    Quote From BasilAnguis

    A rotating set format is in theory amazing. The issue is that it will be just like when duels first came out and make people mad and not wanna play. Those rich enough to afford buying pre order bundles each expansion and keep their old cards intact will dominate and have an immediate advantage. Most players disenchant the vast majority of cards when they rotate to wild and only keep the really powerful stuff. Even wild players only have around 5 to 20 cards from each expansion, the most powerful and broken shit.

    If they make a block mode where it's Grand Tournament, Witchwood and one night in Karazan... who the hell has those cards? The game mode won't be played by anyone because no one wants to buy a bunch of packs and only be able to play with them for 3 months this year, then maybe again in another year and a half when the set rotates back in.

    You need to give people a ton of freebie temporary cards, at which point you make buying packs worthless.

    That is true, but that doesn’t stop them from playing Standard, Wild, and BG’s. Why not throw the players who pay to play the game a bone and give them something that makes them keep playing?

    Like I said I’m a whale, what I’m about to say will come off as crass; (you= F2P/players with little to no monetary investment into the game) If you’re not putting money into the game, I don’t care what you can or can’t play in it because you have no investment. Keeping people who don’t spend money on the game happy while not keeping those who do pay happy is a recipe for disaster. If you have criticisms on balance that’s fine but don’t expect the whales to keep paying for a subpar product.

    Again, I hate to sound crass, but if you didn’t bring your nerf gun to the nerf war, you can’t play. Sure we can play tag or hide and go seek while you’re here, but you can’t expect us to keep you happy when we want to play with nerf

    Freebie Temporary cards would just be the rotating standard set.

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    Going Down Swinging is sending me straight back to middle school. Fel Out Boy. The flavour of this set is phenomenal.

  • Going Down Swinging

    Fel Out Boy

  • What's Up With Out Of Cards? [Staff Responses]

    A rotating set format is in theory amazing. The issue is that it will be just like when duels first came out and make people mad and not wanna play. Those rich enough to afford buying pre order bundles each expansion and keep their old cards intact will dominate and have an immediate advantage. Most players disenchant the vast majority of cards when they rotate to wild and only keep the really powerful stuff. Even wild players only have around 5 to 20 cards from each expansion, the most powerful and broken shit.

    If they make a block mode where it's Grand Tournament, Witchwood and one night in Karazan... who the hell has those cards? The game mode won't be played by anyone because no one wants to buy a bunch of packs and only be able to play with them for 3 months this year, then maybe again in another year and a half when the set rotates back in.

    You need to give people a ton of freebie temporary cards, at which point you make buying packs worthless.

  • Dies To Removal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    I really couldn't think of anything on my own, so here's 3 random custom expansion cards that I chose with no real system. Maybe one of these will jump out at you.

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    Instrument Smasher while neat has the unfortunate caveat of being tied to dh weapons, which while they are all good cards are generally unfortunately not great weapons. In wild there’s 3 1/2 weapons + Dreadprison Glaive, [Hearthstone Card (Lion’s Frenzy) Not Found], and Trueaim Crescent. In standard atleast most of those are leaving standard so it might see play so demon hunters can turn their [Hearthstone Card (Calamity’s Grasp) Not Found]s into 4-5 attack weapons. If Umberwing is in core it probably cold be classified as deliberate sabotage. Either way I think it’s an improvement over Suckerhook.

    Going Down Swinging - Ignoring the fact that its name is a barefaced lie given that it makes you immune. Is a solid option for Dh. It shares a decent amount of utility with Warglaives of Azzinoth with the bonus of preserving your health total. Speaking of warglaives it probably enables some Gonk, the Raptor-style otk with those.

    Eye of Shadow is an okay card. It does suggest to me that Aldrachi Warblades are rotating. Maybe this makes the cut somewhere, but I’m not confident.

    Glaivetar - while I do like myself a 4/2 thanks to my fond memories of Hooked Scimitar I’m not entirely certain this is fast enough for dh. Especially in outcast demon hunter, a deck that the last thing it probablywants is a 4 mana card without much in the way of immediate payoff gunking up its plays. Is an incentive to run Instrument Smasher in unrelated decks though.

     

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    So we get dhunter going full on weapon swings now.

    Its not too bad, but its really starving for a weapon that does face damage per swing, because as it stands Im not sure what the point of all this cards leads to. Going Down Swinging is basically just a poor man's AoE that can backfire because you'll likely lose whatever weapon you're holding clearing board. Glaivetar supports outcast, and will never realistically draw you more than 2 cards. And then you have Instrument Smasher, probably the better card of this lot. At very least it replaces your weapon, which given the small pool isn't a joke.

    As for the two legendary spells...

    I'll say one thing, mage's doesn't look too bad, although Im sure the win rates cant be good. The idea is that you get to play lots of impactful, expensive spells at once, but the requisite is actually holding on to so many expensive spells in the first place.

    Warrior's...good god someone's trolling. Yes there is a pathway for this to be good. Decimator Olgra, Fleshshaper, Trenchstalker, and even grom packs a massive punch. But the pathway towards there is just riddled with holes. These cards need to be in deck for this to work, playing a 5 mana do nothing, but ultimately it might all be just redundant because...

    ...warrior's best deck may actually be a retarded combo of The Fires of Zin-Azshari and Tony, King of Piracy. Yes, warrior cards are so shittingly poor that the best thing to do is curse your opponents with it.

  • Whose got the most Achievement Points! Bragging Rights right here!

    Game Modes:

    Mercenaries - 97%. Missing "Mutiny on the Bounty - Sucessfully complete a level 500 Bounty (260/500)"; "Boss Rush Bounty - Complete 500 Boss Rush Mode Bounties (250/500)"; and "I Beat the Bot - Win 1000 games in the Fighting Pit (945/1000)". I'll be done with the mode after I finish those achievements and max all the new mercenaries. After all it was a good run, but with the mode being put in maintenance mode there's no much reason to keep playing it moving forward.

    Duels - 88%. Missing the Flawless Duelist achievements for Darius, Diablo, Finley, Lilian and Stelina. I think Diablo will return to the game after Diablo IV officially launches. Also, there's some images indicating that both Shaw and Tess will be added to the mode, so more achievements to grind. I started my Duels achievements hunting december last year, so I'm pretty happy with my performance so far. But I'll take a break from it until they fix the Turalyon hero power. That thing is game-breaking.

    Battlegrounds - 75%. From time to time I play BG's for a week or two, but I'm not fully commited to it yet. I just play with the heroes that I still don't have a 1st place with. If I win, that's great, but if not, at least a top 4 is ok so other achievements progress a little bit.

    Arena - 54%. Arena is something else. So far I think only Shtan Udachi has the Flawless Azeroth Gladiator achievement. A 12-0 run is a rare thing even among the best players in the world, so I can't really expect to get all arena achievements. Maybe I'll try 12 wins with everyclass and hope to get extra lucky in some of these runs. I currently just have 12 wins with Warrior and Warlock. After I'm done with the Duels achievements I'll fully commit to improve my game at Arena and see how it goes.

    Still missing a couple of Gameplay - General achievements, which I'll grind a little bit alongside the Mercenaries and Book of Faelin ones, at least until they fix the Turalyon hero power in Duels. I'm having so much fun with Duels, both Casual and Heroic.

     

  • All Day 5 Card Reveals for Hearthstone's Festival of Legends Expansion

    If you get to play it on turn 5 then yes, its not as bad as it looks.

    The problem is not being able to do that, and the fact is that you're playing a 5 mana do nothing, not even to your hand or board. Most games are pretty much on the cusp by turn 5, so doing something like that is kinda crazy. Plus, warrior cant draw for shit (for now anyway).

  • Dies To Removal - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread

    Staff Pro

    Just in case I don't go with Fan the Hammer, I made a backup; I present to you: Living Flame!

    Kill a minion so that it might be reborn like the phoenix! Feeding Time was garbage, Flanking Strike was quite good, but they're both old, so I'm trying to find an acceptable cost/damage ratio for this one, as well. There's also Arcane Overflow to consider. Rush makes for good flavor, but if that's too strong Taunt might be more balanced. What do you think?

  • New Demon Hunter Minion - Instrument Smasher

    Staff

    A new Epic Demon Hunter Minion, Instrument Smasher, has been revealed!

    Instrument Smasher Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Festival of Legends

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Festival of Legends!


    Get Cheaper Card Packs

    This section contains affiliate links.

    If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.

  • New Demon Hunter Spell - Going Down Swinging

    Staff

    A new Legendary Demon Hunter Spell, Going Down Swinging, has been revealed!

    Going Down Swinging Card Image

    Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!


    Learn more about Festival of Legends

    Head on over to our dedicated guide for Festival of Legends!


    Get Cheaper Card Packs

    This section contains affiliate links.

    If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.