I feel that point about quests polarizing the game. Especially as Sire Denathrius, sometimes the quests you draft are it. Getting the quest that upgrades when you buy a minion plus the quest that puts sold minions' stats into the Tavern - it doesn't matter what you buy after that!
That's a highroll, obviously, but there are very obvious differences in power from one reward to another. Because you're only offered them once, it feels bad to continue after getting three mediocre quest options.
I've added both the link and the relevant quote now in the Armor section (sorry, it's been on my mind to do so and must've slipped) listing all the tiers and their values.
Probably a good idea to include this in the future whenever such changes take place, who can even remember all these numbers off the top of their head! (Okay, apparently MurlocAggroB could at least some)
Where do I find info on armor tiers again? I know that was explained a long time ago, but I didn't really pay attention. . . is Tier one a lot of armor, or no armor?
So this should really surprise no one but the highest winrate card post expansion isn't a champion like bard or Annie.
Its a 1 mana follower.
Simon wind is a 2 mana cycle on paper this balanced.
Zoe cycles at 2 mana right?
Wrong she cycles at 4 because dog costs 2
So monkey is a better Zoe.
This is really bad, like really really bad.
Like we've seen cards like shadow assassin break the format and she costs 3 freaking mana.
Because when card advantage costs too little tempo, like say 1 mana, then 2 mana at burst over and over you essentially negate tempo loss with Dragonling and can just bounce and stun everything else.
Idk it's a head scratcher it's like if the 1 mana cycle in bilgewater could go infinite by design.
Like its not a question of if nerfed to 2 mana plus 2 mana to put under par with Zoe (buffed to a 2/1 to compensate) but when.
But like I just dont get it Riot like ask any card game player hey should we print an Infinite cycle at 1 mana at the equivalent of a common card, you would say plz God God plz God no.
You would say 2 mana plus 2 mana with the spell proc is fair plz maths oh God I'm having an aneurysm. So to sum up Riot less stupids more card counting plz go ask a blackjack player.
Here's a pretty good example of Majin Bae showing off in game 1 how old school removal decks ie Katarina and ezreal can not beat Ionia currently regardless of what they do.
Now valid he is either A an excellent meta abuser which allows him to be one of the best players at the game but B he also has a track record for being terrible with any deck that isn't meta across the board.
So typically if he running something day 1 it's pretty much guarteed to be brokenly competitive.
1. Ionia gets a infinite 1 mana card generator that unlike droplet does not require synergy or allow room for interaction.
2. 1 mana burst spells hard buffed, don't try to remove or answer things ever
3. Tempo tempo everywhere playing an equipment card that tutors a sheperds crook and becomes a batista with overwhelm something like 7/5 overwhelm stats on 3 is game breaking from a control perspective.
4. Akshan essentially playing the roll of the infinite card generator for shurima, with equipment providing infinite landmark procs, swap 1 mana equipment for 1 mana equipment etc.
5. Bounces being the only in curve answer to equipment in the game, further solidifying Ionia as the only valid control region.
6. Removal nerfs across the board killing freijord and shadow and noxious
7. Champs are bad again, essentially have no place in the game other then to tutor and draw and cycle
Like I have to laugh that pre-expansion the most broken thing in the game was "darkness" aka I play dmg spells to remove your stuff.
Now the most broken stuff in the game is I draw infinite cards (A) or deck (B) I play infinitely power creeped on curve threats.
Like come on guys I can't be the only person who sees when World Waker and now Awakening comes out with this broken stuff its basically dumbs down the game to hearthstone levels, with only 2 valid play patterns.
Grand Apothecary Putress is cool. I thought some Poisons were way better than others at first, but the more I think about it, the more I realize that they're all pretty good and could in a vacuum, be seen as relatively close to equal in value. It is also a long-term value card which is not as powerful in Rogue as it could be in other classes, so I'm tempted to say that it's fine.
Lord Blackhand is definitely easier to use. Warrior doesn't have that many ways of enchanting weapons, but the re-equip effect enough is easy enough to get value of it, so I think this is good.
Whichever one is the better of the two to go with is not quite so clear.
Wailor
Well you've already submitted it, so I can't help you further. Unfortunately, I do feel like the "add a Banana to your hand and cast it" effect almost sounds like a way to circumnavigate the rules of having your card play a card. The way the card is phrased in relation to the way the effect works is a bit too weird.
FooBars
My favorite of the three is Stormlash Totem. I like the way it makes you consider how you design your deck to take advantage of it optimally and the plays you can make with the proper deck are pretty cool.
I don't like Goblin Dealer because of how much it limits design space and can create lots of potential swing turns. Admittedly Warlock doesn't have a lot of spells that can become problematic with this, but that doesn't mean that they won't get more later. Even just casting Shadow Waltz with this thing on turn 1 or 2 is incredibly good.
Bazaar Plunderer is quite solid. It's not as overpowered in Rogue as it could be in other classes since Rogue doesn't have the huge spells to take advantage of it by itself (which is the same reason why Swiftscale Trickster is not overpowered in Rogue even though it absolutely would be in other classes), so you're mostly relying on either copying something incredibly specific that you play, or on your opponent to cast something huge that you can safely take advantage of.
BasilAnguis
A "cute" idea flavorwise, but I feel like it has too much text and also just generally doesn't interest me that much.
The best answer for this is support on the site staff's part. Echo was the only person on the team who was really well-versed in Magic enough to be able to write good articles about it, and she recently left our team to focus on her personal life. And when you have no one on the team who focuses on a specific game, then you can't really cover it very well. I'm not even sure how much she'd played Arena recently (the internal systems of the game in general are not known to be especially great).
All things considered, our team on Out of Cards is quite small. We all pretty much play Hearthstone so that's easy to cover, but not everyone on it plays Legends of Runeterra for example, which is one reason why LoR articles in general are not as numerous as Hearthstone ones. When you don't have anyone on the team that can really support the game on the site, then it becomes impossible to cover and that's basically what happened with MTG Arena.
After a long time, I came back to MTG Arena (again) and even though I couldn't had time to write and staying around in the site because of my irl stuff, I was following here everyday for news and such.
Yesterday, I downloaded MTG:Arena again and wanted to check Outofcards' MTG:Arena Side and i was surprised when i saw the last thread which is 1 month's ago and comments surprised me more because the nearest is almost 2 years old and it is new expansion time for the game.
So I wondered it is about the site's support or the game itself. Is it the game that has the rough times or did just outofcards stop supporting it ?
Normal Mercenaries bounty reward: Haha, no coins of the legendary for you!
Trying to farm a specific bounty for the epic and/or rare coins associated: There you go, three times the legendary coins for the merc you've long maxed out.
My first impression after a decent bunch of games is that this expansion is pushing LoR further into highroll grounds. Jax decks seems consistent but Ornn/Trundle Timeline and any portal deck are highroll af. Especially the later. Sometimes it's T7 and your Norra is 2/6 and sometimes you got a full board with Sneezy Biggledust! by T4 and your opponent insta give up. Back to Trundle, the set definitely gave a huge second breath to the deck. Improvise allies are a god send since they keep the weapon while transforming, resulting in some absurbly stated followers.
Yi seems a bit less represented, I don't meet him often, but I'm not surprised with such a board dominion based set where having a 6/5 overhelm on T4 is the new standard.
Balance considerations aside, I really love to play with Norra. Sure it's RNG, it won't please everyone, but it's acceptably deterministic due to the fact it's on your 4 first cards and that her pack isn't that strong (Portalpalooza is a good example, it's both a key card and a rather sluggish one). Haven't found the sweet duo yet (Nami is meh due to meta being heavy with challenger keyword, same with Zoe). Rn I'm trying with Evelynn. The board can be a bit tricky to manage but the fact portals goes in hand if board full make it combo decently with Husks. Another perk is that Evelynn smoothen your mid game, which seems like the weak point of a Norra deck (your early game is played, you haven't summoned much portals and opponent start to do powerplays). And well Husks help shitton in Norra evolve with minimal PP invested.
I check the site regular to look for news about hs en mercs, new topics to read or replies ;) Also checking to see if there's a new "word search", i love that stuff.
Honestly, this card should simply not exist in it's current unhealthy form in the game. You are obligated to run this card in competitive XL decks and even regular sized decks often also run it because it's simply too good. I think a considerable amount of players (myself included) feel either relieved or bad after playing Theotar, the Mad Duke. There is just no real sense of accomplishment or enjoyment to be gained with this minion.
Actually, I believe the general trend in Hearthstone is quite similar. In this (recurring) rock-paper-scissors meta, you either high or low roll into a favorable or non favorable deck/archetype. The outcome of the matchup was already pretty much decided in most cases. The skill level usually only matters when encountering a mirror match.
That's definitely the first time I hear of such a strange interaction, although the explanations above make some sense (in the weird "Hearthstone coding" sort of way). Still, could be worth checking with devs whether it's actually intended. Unless one of them has already covered this scenario back when these cards were being released, and I missed it.
Yes, if you want maximum combo disruption, use both and double them. But this thread is about whether Theotar is a healthy card for the game. I think he is too powerful at stopping big plays, and it feelsSObadman to lose to this.
Hearthstone Rolls Out Hotfix Patch 24.2.1 - Various Battlegrounds Quests Changes, Duels Buckets Adjusted, Bug Fixes
I feel that point about quests polarizing the game. Especially as Sire Denathrius, sometimes the quests you draft are it. Getting the quest that upgrades when you buy a minion plus the quest that puts sold minions' stats into the Tavern - it doesn't matter what you buy after that!
That's a highroll, obviously, but there are very obvious differences in power from one reward to another. Because you're only offered them once, it feels bad to continue after getting three mediocre quest options.
Hearthstone Rolls Out Hotfix Patch 24.2.1 - Various Battlegrounds Quests Changes, Duels Buckets Adjusted, Bug Fixes
I've added both the link and the relevant quote now in the Armor section (sorry, it's been on my mind to do so and must've slipped) listing all the tiers and their values.
Probably a good idea to include this in the future whenever such changes take place, who can even remember all these numbers off the top of their head! (Okay, apparently MurlocAggroB could at least some)
Hearthstone Rolls Out Hotfix Patch 24.2.1 - Various Battlegrounds Quests Changes, Duels Buckets Adjusted, Bug Fixes
Higher the tier, the lower the armor. Tier 1 is no armor.
Hearthstone Rolls Out Hotfix Patch 24.2.1 - Various Battlegrounds Quests Changes, Duels Buckets Adjusted, Bug Fixes
Where do I find info on armor tiers again? I know that was explained a long time ago, but I didn't really pay attention. . . is Tier one a lot of armor, or no armor?
The Highest Winrate Card Post Awakening
So this should really surprise no one but the highest winrate card post expansion isn't a champion like bard or Annie.
Its a 1 mana follower.
Simon wind is a 2 mana cycle on paper this balanced.
Zoe cycles at 2 mana right?
Wrong she cycles at 4 because dog costs 2
So monkey is a better Zoe.
This is really bad, like really really bad.
Like we've seen cards like shadow assassin break the format and she costs 3 freaking mana.
Because when card advantage costs too little tempo, like say 1 mana, then 2 mana at burst over and over you essentially negate tempo loss with Dragonling and can just bounce and stun everything else.
Idk it's a head scratcher it's like if the 1 mana cycle in bilgewater could go infinite by design.
Like its not a question of if nerfed to 2 mana plus 2 mana to put under par with Zoe (buffed to a 2/1 to compensate) but when.
But like I just dont get it Riot like ask any card game player hey should we print an Infinite cycle at 1 mana at the equivalent of a common card, you would say plz God God plz God no.
You would say 2 mana plus 2 mana with the spell proc is fair plz maths oh God I'm having an aneurysm. So to sum up Riot less stupids more card counting plz go ask a blackjack player.
What happened to MTG:Arena and its support on the site ?
Echo's amazing math brain is and will be missed! Best regards to her.
High Roll City
https://youtu.be/0M2ObL9QAeM
Here's a pretty good example of Majin Bae showing off in game 1 how old school removal decks ie Katarina and ezreal can not beat Ionia currently regardless of what they do.
Now valid he is either A an excellent meta abuser which allows him to be one of the best players at the game but B he also has a track record for being terrible with any deck that isn't meta across the board.
So typically if he running something day 1 it's pretty much guarteed to be brokenly competitive.
High Roll City
Here are all the big problematic cards.
1. Ionia gets a infinite 1 mana card generator that unlike droplet does not require synergy or allow room for interaction.
2. 1 mana burst spells hard buffed, don't try to remove or answer things ever
3. Tempo tempo everywhere playing an equipment card that tutors a sheperds crook and becomes a batista with overwhelm something like 7/5 overwhelm stats on 3 is game breaking from a control perspective.
4. Akshan essentially playing the roll of the infinite card generator for shurima, with equipment providing infinite landmark procs, swap 1 mana equipment for 1 mana equipment etc.
5. Bounces being the only in curve answer to equipment in the game, further solidifying Ionia as the only valid control region.
6. Removal nerfs across the board killing freijord and shadow and noxious
7. Champs are bad again, essentially have no place in the game other then to tutor and draw and cycle
Like I have to laugh that pre-expansion the most broken thing in the game was "darkness" aka I play dmg spells to remove your stuff.
Now the most broken stuff in the game is I draw infinite cards (A) or deck (B) I play infinitely power creeped on curve threats.
Like come on guys I can't be the only person who sees when World Waker and now Awakening comes out with this broken stuff its basically dumbs down the game to hearthstone levels, with only 2 valid play patterns.
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Late feedback.
Grand Apothecary Putress is cool. I thought some Poisons were way better than others at first, but the more I think about it, the more I realize that they're all pretty good and could in a vacuum, be seen as relatively close to equal in value. It is also a long-term value card which is not as powerful in Rogue as it could be in other classes, so I'm tempted to say that it's fine.
Lord Blackhand is definitely easier to use. Warrior doesn't have that many ways of enchanting weapons, but the re-equip effect enough is easy enough to get value of it, so I think this is good.
Whichever one is the better of the two to go with is not quite so clear.
My favorite of the three is Stormlash Totem. I like the way it makes you consider how you design your deck to take advantage of it optimally and the plays you can make with the proper deck are pretty cool.
I don't like Goblin Dealer because of how much it limits design space and can create lots of potential swing turns. Admittedly Warlock doesn't have a lot of spells that can become problematic with this, but that doesn't mean that they won't get more later. Even just casting Shadow Waltz with this thing on turn 1 or 2 is incredibly good.
Bazaar Plunderer is quite solid. It's not as overpowered in Rogue as it could be in other classes since Rogue doesn't have the huge spells to take advantage of it by itself (which is the same reason why Swiftscale Trickster is not overpowered in Rogue even though it absolutely would be in other classes), so you're mostly relying on either copying something incredibly specific that you play, or on your opponent to cast something huge that you can safely take advantage of.
High Roll City
So similar to world waker when it first came out ladder is basically a complete mess.
Not sure if internal testing basically doesn't exist at Riot anymore.
But its getting a little tiring having to wait 3 months for a new set to get balanced just so I can climb to diamond.
Things like concurrent timelines, the infinite amount of Ionia running around, equipment decks everywhere, basically makes the game unplayable.
So here we go wake me up for the next major game fixing patch and I'll see you guys in diamond.
Zzzzzzz
What happened to MTG:Arena and its support on the site ?
The best answer for this is support on the site staff's part. Echo was the only person on the team who was really well-versed in Magic enough to be able to write good articles about it, and she recently left our team to focus on her personal life. And when you have no one on the team who focuses on a specific game, then you can't really cover it very well. I'm not even sure how much she'd played Arena recently (the internal systems of the game in general are not known to be especially great).
All things considered, our team on Out of Cards is quite small. We all pretty much play Hearthstone so that's easy to cover, but not everyone on it plays Legends of Runeterra for example, which is one reason why LoR articles in general are not as numerous as Hearthstone ones. When you don't have anyone on the team that can really support the game on the site, then it becomes impossible to cover and that's basically what happened with MTG Arena.
What happened to MTG:Arena and its support on the site ?
Hello guys !
After a long time, I came back to MTG Arena (again) and even though I couldn't had time to write and staying around in the site because of my irl stuff, I was following here everyday for news and such.
Yesterday, I downloaded MTG:Arena again and wanted to check Outofcards' MTG:Arena Side and i was surprised when i saw the last thread which is 1 month's ago and comments surprised me more because the nearest is almost 2 years old and it is new expansion time for the game.
So I wondered it is about the site's support or the game itself. Is it the game that has the rough times or did just outofcards stop supporting it ?
Can someone light a candle for me ? :)
Control Warlock Steals Mage's Hero Card And Shatters Its Dreams! Castle Nathria | Hearthstone
Awesome!
A Mysterious Recipe!
Managed to have some fun, stole Warlock Rafaam and location using Priest legendary.
Ik brawls you dont make deck are usually just RNG, but i find better this way, you wont end facing only broken stuff (FTK druid, Pogo only deck)
Group Therapy! Need to blow off some steam? Mega salty? Here's the place!
Normal Mercenaries bounty reward: Haha, no coins of the legendary for you!
Trying to farm a specific bounty for the epic and/or rare coins associated: There you go, three times the legendary coins for the merc you've long maxed out.
Early Expansion Impressions
My first impression after a decent bunch of games is that this expansion is pushing LoR further into highroll grounds. Jax decks seems consistent but Ornn/Trundle Timeline and any portal deck are highroll af. Especially the later. Sometimes it's T7 and your Norra is 2/6 and sometimes you got a full board with Sneezy Biggledust! by T4 and your opponent insta give up. Back to Trundle, the set definitely gave a huge second breath to the deck. Improvise allies are a god send since they keep the weapon while transforming, resulting in some absurbly stated followers.
Yi seems a bit less represented, I don't meet him often, but I'm not surprised with such a board dominion based set where having a 6/5 overhelm on T4 is the new standard.
Balance considerations aside, I really love to play with Norra. Sure it's RNG, it won't please everyone, but it's acceptably deterministic due to the fact it's on your 4 first cards and that her pack isn't that strong (Portalpalooza is a good example, it's both a key card and a rather sluggish one). Haven't found the sweet duo yet (Nami is meh due to meta being heavy with challenger keyword, same with Zoe). Rn I'm trying with Evelynn. The board can be a bit tricky to manage but the fact portals goes in hand if board full make it combo decently with Husks. Another perk is that Evelynn smoothen your mid game, which seems like the weak point of a Norra deck (your early game is played, you haven't summoned much portals and opponent start to do powerplays). And well Husks help shitton in Norra evolve with minimal PP invested.
Cast On, Cast Off - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Hello, I'm back. Here's my idea for this prompt
I wanted to make a worgen that switches from light to dark but I couldn't quite fit in all the words. Hope it's OK like this.
Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption
lol, that indeed is the only positive thing about having him in golden ^_^ enjoy the big arcane dust refund!
Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption
The only good thing I have to say about the guy is that I have a golden copy of him :)
What do you do on Out of Cards?
I check the site regular to look for news about hs en mercs, new topics to read or replies ;)
Also checking to see if there's a new "word search", i love that stuff.
Early Expansion Impressions
Well yeah, if you're a net decker you shouldn't net deck till the decks are netted.
The reality is a lot of the new decks are so strong they require hard counters.
Things like quietus shadow (kill equipment or Zoe or like a heimer on curve) or silence and surpress demacia(deals with fated followers and equipment)
Here's a list of the best new decks so far:
1. Jax forge - just midrange good stuff, slam jam and blam should easily win you the game
2. Lee Sin Ip Master - cataclysm, rally rally rally, counter, burst protect your Champs are leveled. Strongest combo deck, besides Kaisa.
3. Portals - hasn't been properly built yet so yes this one is "bad" right now but it's only inches away.
4. Sythe Grapple - saying that akshan decks are good is a pretty big understatement largely better then the old akshan spellshield decks.
So thats 3 great decks, and 1 "Fun" deck pretty normal for a new expansion. If you want lists I can share either mine or popular streamers.
Shadow isles
Why all the feels bad to play aggainst cards are from this region?
Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption
Honestly, this card should simply not exist in it's current unhealthy form in the game. You are obligated to run this card in competitive XL decks and even regular sized decks often also run it because it's simply too good. I think a considerable amount of players (myself included) feel either relieved or bad after playing Theotar, the Mad Duke. There is just no real sense of accomplishment or enjoyment to be gained with this minion.
Actually, I believe the general trend in Hearthstone is quite similar. In this (recurring) rock-paper-scissors meta, you either high or low roll into a favorable or non favorable deck/archetype. The outcome of the matchup was already pretty much decided in most cases. The skill level usually only matters when encountering a mirror match.
Sorry, I digressed a bit at the end.
Suspicious Interaction
That's definitely the first time I hear of such a strange interaction, although the explanations above make some sense (in the weird "Hearthstone coding" sort of way). Still, could be worth checking with devs whether it's actually intended. Unless one of them has already covered this scenario back when these cards were being released, and I missed it.
Mutanus vs Theotar: opinion on combo disruption
Yes, if you want maximum combo disruption, use both and double them. But this thread is about whether Theotar is a healthy card for the game. I think he is too powerful at stopping big plays, and it feelsSObadman to lose to this.