Murder at Castle Nathria Community Compendium

You've arrived at a snapshot of community voting data for the Murder at Castle Nathria Hearthstone expansion. Over the expansion's card reveal period, we asked our community to vote on all the cards. Here are the results from those votes, taken before the expansion released.

This is how good, or bad, we thought these cards were going to be.


Top 10 Rated Cards

Sylvanas, the Accused Card Image
The Jailer Card Image
Prosecutor Mel'tranix Card Image
Defense Attorney Nathanos Card Image
Tight-Lipped Witness Card Image
Afterlife Attendant Card Image
Dew Process Card Image
Scribbling Stenographer Card Image
Habeas Corpses Card Image
Theft Accusation Card Image

Class Highlights

  • Death Knight

  • Demon Hunter

    Prosecutor Mel'tranix Card Image
    All Fel Breaks Loose Card Image
    Sightless Magistrate Card Image
  • Druid

    Dew Process Card Image
    Incarceration Card Image
    Attorney-at-Maw Card Image
  • Hunter

    Defense Attorney Nathanos Card Image
    Shadehound Card Image
    Motion Denied Card Image
  • Mage

    Life Sentence Card Image
    Objection! Card Image
    Contract Conjurer Card Image
  • Paladin

    Class Action Lawyer Card Image
    Order in the Court Card Image
    Jury Duty Card Image
  • Priest

    Theft Accusation Card Image
    Clear Conscience Card Image
    Incriminating Psychic Card Image
  • Rogue

    Scribbling Stenographer Card Image
    Murder Accusation Card Image
    Perjury Card Image
  • Shaman

    Framester Card Image
    Torghast Custodian Card Image
    Totemic Evidence Card Image
  • Warlock

    Habeas Corpses Card Image
    Arson Accusation Card Image
    Imp-oster Card Image
  • Warrior

    Weapons Expert Card Image
    Call to the Stand Card Image
    Mawsworn Bailiff Card Image

The Perfect Location

Cathedral of Atonement Card Image
72
Nightcloak Sanctum Card Image
72
Muck Pools Card Image
70
Sinstone Graveyard Card Image
63
Vile Library Card Image
58

Intelligent Infusions

Sylvanas, the Accused Card Image
Afterlife Attendant Card Image
Shadehound Card Image
Totemic Evidence Card Image
All Fel Breaks Loose Card Image

Magma Rager Award

Sinfueled Golem Card Image
22
Stoneborn Accuser Card Image
25
Roosting Gargoyle Card Image
30
Sinstone Totem Card Image
31
Priest of the Deceased Card Image
34

Comments

  • DoctorDoom's Avatar
    180 90 Posts Joined 07/03/2022
    Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

    Some of the Magma Rager award cards aren't that bad.

     

    Stoneborn Accuser isn't that bad especially if you find a way to cast it twice.

    Sinstone Totem When Totem Shaman is good that card will be real hard to deal with if it gets buffed. 

    Priest of the Deceased in a hyper aggro deck with good card draw this card would be great, cheap minion with good stats for the cost perfect for flooding the board. 

    1
  • VooDooSaurus's Avatar
    E.V.I.L. Dragon 280 64 Posts Joined 11/21/2019
    Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

    Crazy implock cards (the location and impending catastrophe) arent ranked higher. Early gameplay has shown they can be super crazy

    0
  • h0lysatan's Avatar
    Zombie 1065 790 Posts Joined 12/03/2019
    Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

    I think this is all first impressions when they reveal it.

    Nothing to do with later gameplay, right? We could all be wrong. And it often happened

    0
    • Horus's Avatar
      Detective Pikachu 2575 3348 Posts Joined 05/29/2019
      Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

      What do you mean? Our track record is impeccable ..! ^^

      0
  • edennnnnn's Avatar
    325 108 Posts Joined 11/16/2020
    Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

    insane to leave off impending catastrophe lol. wonder if it will get nerfed to 4 or higher.

     

    0
  • Caro's Avatar
    Draconic Rager 2225 2544 Posts Joined 03/12/2020
    Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

    Quite the surprising top 10 list. Impending Catastrophe isn't there which makes me think most players don't know how scary it'll be or they didn't watch the theorycrafting streams xD

    4
    • sinti's Avatar
      Senior Writer Chocolate Cake 2070 2792 Posts Joined 10/20/2018
      Posted 2 years, 4 months ago

      This was votes during the reveal season, before the launch, so ppl usually tend to rate low cards that need you to have a board, sometimes those cards can then turn out to be quite good.

      1

Leave a Comment

You must be signed in to leave a comment. Sign in here.