You're not wrong, and it is arguably the least informative wording they have ever put on a card. At least until you see the Sack token, which makes it all super apparent. I suspect there was no way of squeezing "that returns the minion to the opponent's hand when destroyed" onto the card without going way beyond the 4-line limit.
Besides, I find there's something deeply satisfying about just saying "stuff it in a 0/4 Sack." Sure, it doesn't technically say everything that entails, but it does imply you can get them back out again, and doing that would mean the Sack has to be on the rogue's side. You could also reason from cards like Sap costing 2 and secret effects generally being stronger than normal spells of the same cost, that it probably returns to the opponent's hand rather than their board.
You've just got to tap into your inner Murloc Holmes to work it all out. After all, Kidnapping is a crime that needs solving.
He's a super salt mine and honestly, it would be better if he just stopped playing Hearthstone at this point. I'm sure his mental health would improve too.
Prime example of how to engage. I'm surprised Blizzard even bothers to engage with him anymore.
At least it's not all bad. If you Shadowstep the Sack, then your opponent can no longer grab that minion. Even if you can't free it from the Sack, neither can they if you play the Sack.
I assumed Cora meant the minion returns to their hand after they kill the sack, which would be a 0/4 deathrattle on your side of the board. Either way, it occurs to me you wouldn't be able to get the minion out of the sack even if you can Shadowstep it, so there's no Stockholm Syndrome here.
He's a super salt mine and honestly, it would be better if he just stopped playing Hearthstone at this point. I'm sure his mental health would improve too.
Prime example of how to engage. I'm surprised Blizzard even bothers to engage with him anymore.
They are definitely fine together. I wonder if the biggest reason they don't generally do it is because they want to strongly incentivise combo activation as the core part of rogue gameplay, and having a half-strength version as a battlecry means players would often not need to.
When looking through the combo spells, even they don't typically scale with combo, with the closest since Classic being tutoring an extra card type. (With Swindle you often didn't pay too much attention to the fact you got a spell and a minion, hence why I counted it above. But it feels more significant with, say, Raiding Party.) So there must be some design preference to make combo activate truly new effects.
If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.
Lol. That butterknife isn't helping him get out of that bind.
I assume you can Shadowstep the sack and make the opponent cry. Would that be like HS's version of Stockholm syndrome when you then play the minion on your side?
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
You're not wrong, and it is arguably the least informative wording they have ever put on a card. At least until you see the Sack token, which makes it all super apparent. I suspect there was no way of squeezing "that returns the minion to the opponent's hand when destroyed" onto the card without going way beyond the 4-line limit.
Besides, I find there's something deeply satisfying about just saying "stuff it in a 0/4 Sack." Sure, it doesn't technically say everything that entails, but it does imply you can get them back out again, and doing that would mean the Sack has to be on the rogue's side. You could also reason from cards like Sap costing 2 and secret effects generally being stronger than normal spells of the same cost, that it probably returns to the opponent's hand rather than their board.
You've just got to tap into your inner Murloc Holmes to work it all out. After all, Kidnapping is a crime that needs solving.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
He sounds a lot like his character in Seinfeld.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Who's this Alex guy anyways?
New Rogue Minion - Private Eye
This... kind of makes me want to play with Secrets.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
The wording on this makes me angry. Why explaining what a card does if you can write something which explains absolutely nothing?
Wasn't there a recent Twitter thread about this topic? The player should be 90% knowing what a card does? Well, here I'm at mostly 10%.
On which side is the sack summonend? What happens exactly when the sack is killed? This leaves more questions than answers
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
At least it's not all bad. If you Shadowstep the Sack, then your opponent can no longer grab that minion. Even if you can't free it from the Sack, neither can they if you play the Sack.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Being rude gives him more popularity I assume. Sad and too bad :(
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Yup, sadly no shenanigans to be had.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
I assumed Cora meant the minion returns to their hand after they kill the sack, which would be a 0/4 deathrattle on your side of the board. Either way, it occurs to me you wouldn't be able to get the minion out of the sack even if you can Shadowstep it, so there's no Stockholm Syndrome here.
New Rogue Spell - Kidnap
This is truly hilarious. It can get passed those damned illusive minions.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
The flavor this expansion is 10/10. I can't wait to see the token for this. Hilarious.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
It shouldn't, secrets like Explosive Runes trigger after the battlecry has triggered.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
He's a super salt mine and honestly, it would be better if he just stopped playing Hearthstone at this point. I'm sure his mental health would improve too.
Prime example of how to engage. I'm surprised Blizzard even bothers to engage with him anymore.
Two New Castle Nathria Rogue Cards Revealed by Xeno - Private Eye & Sticky Situation
They are definitely fine together. I wonder if the biggest reason they don't generally do it is because they want to strongly incentivise combo activation as the core part of rogue gameplay, and having a half-strength version as a battlecry means players would often not need to.
When looking through the combo spells, even they don't typically scale with combo, with the closest since Classic being tutoring an extra card type. (With Swindle you often didn't pay too much attention to the fact you got a spell and a minion, hence why I counted it above. But it feels more significant with, say, Raiding Party.) So there must be some design preference to make combo activate truly new effects.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Assuming it works the way that other Secrets + Battlecry interactions do, which should be the case, Battlecry resolves before the Secret. See Snipe.
The way it works is:
New Rogue Spell - Kidnap
A new Epic Rogue Spell, Kidnap, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Murder at Castle Nathria
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Murder at Castle Nathria!
Get Cheaper Card Packs
This section contains affiliate links.
If you want to save money when buying Hearthstone packs, you should check out Amazon Coins! It's an easy way to save up to 25% off Hearthstone packs so you can get into the new expansion without worrying about your wallet too much. We've got a detailed guide on how to Get Started with Amazon Coins, but if you've already dealt with them in the past, you can buy some more by clicking right here.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
It does not trigger before the opponent's battlecry, does it ? :-(
EDIT : Shame. I'd love to have at least one silencing secret in hearthstone.
Thanks for your answers.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
No, the minion goes back to their hand in a 0/4 sack according to Cora.
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Lol. That butterknife isn't helping him get out of that bind.
I assume you can Shadowstep the sack and make the opponent cry. Would that be like HS's version of Stockholm syndrome when you then play the minion on your side?
Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard
Wow dude, you may not like the cards, but there's no reason to get this angry at the developers..
New Bandle City Spell - Sneezy Biggledust!
A new Epic Bandle City Spell, Sneezy Biggledust!, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Worldwalker
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!
New Shurima Spell - Glory's Call
A new Rare Shurima Spell, Glory's Call, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Worldwalker
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!
New Bilgewater Spell - Swindle
A new Rare Bilgewater Spell, Swindle, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Worldwalker
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!
New Bilgewater Spell - Ransom Riches
A new Epic Bilgewater Spell, Ransom Riches, has been revealed!
Discuss this card below or head on over to the card page to give it a rating!
Learn more about Worldwalker
Head on over to our dedicated guide for Worldwalker!