All Comments

The latest comments from across the whole site. Jump into any conversation by clicking where it was posted.

  • Halkias is a New Rogue Legendary Card Revealed by Flurry for Murder at Castle Nathria

    And now the first Rogue deathrattle since Stormwind...is Secret supports.

    They have to be doing this on purpose, right?

  • Riot Reveals 6 New Cards from the Upcoming "Forces from Beyond" Expansion

    Yeah. Part of me feels like I don’t need a major shake-up, because the current expansion is only two months old and seem pretty fresh. But even so, this one doesn't feel like it’s offering much…

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    Anti deathrattle synergy? Looks very much like it. This is the level where deathrattle support for rogue has sunken to.

    As for the card itself. Its fairly bad, but with so few secrets if you're playing secret rogue you'll probably just play this in your deck to mess with your opponent's play rather than rely on the card itself.

    The point is that much like Blademaster Okani and cards of the like, no player worth their salt would gamble on it so its only main job is preventing your opponent from playing efficiently. Unfortunately, they can easily just play a spell to test for Sticky Situation and will then know exactly what this is. Or alternatively, just let you kidnap a useless minion and thereafter forget about it, and you're one slot smaller on board, on top of having your deathrattle synergy completely ruined.

  • Rewards Track: Current progress 5.0

    I´m at lvl 200 right now (with full log) with 95% SC achievements done (thankfully they´ve finally fixed the Immolate one), expecting to end the season more or less around lvl 230, which would be my lowest yet - my previous end levels were 250+. I´ve missed a couple Ranked Weeklies (not feel like playing these past weeks), and haven´t had a friend quest for a half a year now, so there´s that. I´ve maxed another merc, so I´m at 19 now, with 25 hoarded merc packs. My gold count is at 8,3k which is nice I guess, getting ready/excited for the new expansion. I even left an Arena run opened just in case, heh. Let´s goooo :D

    @NebuchadnezzarHS Grats mate! You did it again. WP :)

  • The Problem With Bard

    A lot of people are overestimating Annie's capabilities imo, especially in Control decks. The only reason she's there is because of Ravenbloom Conservatory which is a strong card but not overpowered. However, I'm also biased since I find it a fun build-around card. If it does become an issue anyways, it's relatively easy to tweak its number by increasing the countdown.

    As for Bard, I had a feeling this was coming the moment I saw his Origin. The issue with Bard is that he has 6 cards in his "region" so they gave him a really strong effect in return to balance it out, resulting in a very awkward card to play deckbuild if his effect is not strong enough but too easy if his effect is too strong (like rn). I feel like they could make his start of round effect into something more like Jhin's where you get Chimes when you behold him and when you play something.

    Probably something like:

    For each Bard that started the game in your deck, plant a Chime in your deck when you play a unit while you Behold Bard.

    A bit wordy but I think it's a lot better than what it is right now.

  • New Shaman Minion - The Stonewright

    This with Witchwood Piper in wild can make some good tutor for enabling the totem party later on

  • New Druid Spell - Nightshade Bud

    Quote From Topandito
    Quote From YourPrivateNightmare

    Looks weak to me but maybe getting Neptulon or Onyxia  2-turns early is strong enough for it to matter.

    Not sure you'd want Onyxia since she would just be an 8/8 with rush

    You know what, I just sort of forgot that Onyxia isn't a Colossal

  • New Shaman Spell - Primordial Wave

    Ver powerful tool for board control and an nerf cadidate on the first round

  • New Shaman Minion - Party Favor Totem

    I think there will be some hybrid between totems and evolve targets

  • New Shaman Spell - Convincing Disguise

    I love to see again Bru'kan in shadowlands, I hope it gets some development

  • New Shaman Location - Muck Pools

    I think the evolve shaman will be somekind of broken...... again

  • New Neutral Minion - Theotar, the Mad Duke

    Very powerful to disrupt combo decks or steal a combo piece

  • The Problem With Bard

    Quote From Nifty129

    So for those who have looked at the stats lately they will know that Annie and Bard are the two highest played Champs in the game in terms of the number of high tier lists they are present in.

    I've already spoken about why ravembloom is a problematic and poorly designed card in its current iteration aka should buff spells not creatures, both is too powerful for a 1 mana landmark.

    Ravenbloom is neither problematic nor poorly designed, currently the card is only being used in one meta deck and said deck winrate and playrate are both reasonable, and while the landmark itself only cost 1 mana you still need to play the 6 mana Tybaulk to get the buffs so that 7 mana in total. Limiting the buff to spell only won't change much since that deck tend to kill you with burn damage anyway.

    Quote From Phaseshifter

    I don't see anything wrong with Annie. She can't be traded by 2 defense guys, but she also can't block and trade with anything. It honestly feels like Annie is a card used to level up RavenBloom, rather than the opposite. If Tibaulk was a 5/5, it would still be worhth playing, same if he didn't gave overwhelm.

     

    The main issue with Bard as you said, is that you get value essentially for free. You don't really have to do anything, and it can create board states that are impossible to deal with early game. SOmething as simple as Bandle Commando  coming out as a 3/4 or even 2/3 has a pretty huge impact.

    Basically, Bard allows you to have underpriced, over the curve units...for free.

    Annie not being able to block is not a real weakness, Annie/Jhin is a burn aggro those type of deck don't look for trades they only care about pushing damage since you are never beating them in race, as for Annie/TF that deck has enough removal to get rid of your unit.

    I do however agree with everything you said on Bard.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    This wording just about fits onto the card:

    Secret: After your opponent
    plays a minion, stuff it in a
    0/4 sack. Return it to their
    hand when the sack dies.

    Albeit barely, and resulting some of the smallest text we see on a card. I can imagine why they decided against it

  • New Rogue Minion - Halkias

    I'm not a fan of this, it'll difficult to have this killed before your opponent procs the secrets, the only real good secret to work with this is Fluffy Betrayal.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    A streamer.  That's all I really know, because I personally never watch him. I've tried, but he's always in a shitty mood and complaining about everything whenever I have tried.  So I'm not sure if that's him playing a character or if he subjects himself to playing a game he absolutely hates for the sake of Twitch views.  Either way, I agree with Flux that it would be better for all involved if he just stopped playing HS.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    Not going to disagree with your point.  With that said, to me it is obvious the sack will be placed on your side.  Which give gives the strategy of giving you the chance to silence the sack.  It will be your side cause your opponent will have to kill the sack to get it back in hand

  • Is deep the best anti-meta deck?

    What do you usually win with? Maokai?

  • What is the best unit to have two of on the board?

    Why that one specifically?

  • The Problem With Bard

    I don't see anything wrong with Annie. She can't be traded by 2 defense guys, but she also can't block and trade with anything. It honestly feels like Annie is a card used to level up RavenBloom, rather than the opposite. If Tibaulk was a 5/5, it would still be worhth playing, same if he didn't gave overwhelm.

     

    The main issue with Bard as you said, is that you get value essentially for free. You don't really have to do anything, and it can create board states that are impossible to deal with early game. SOmething as simple as Bandle Commando  coming out as a 3/4 or even 2/3 has a pretty huge impact.

    Basically, Bard allows you to have underpriced, over the curve units...for free.

     

  • Riot Reveals 6 New Cards from the Upcoming "Forces from Beyond" Expansion

    There are fun shenanigans that you could pull with Evil Imperfectionist other than that that these cards looks underwhelming.

  • Hearthstone Designers Gallon and Songbird Share Insights on Huntsman Altimor - Callbacks, Tavish & More

    Weirdos downvoting but if Blizzard made these exact changes then anyone calling the changes bad is wrong....

    World of Hypocrisy.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    The dev team has explained once that fitting text on card was an incredibly strenuous process; mainly due to the variety of language they try to support. (in some article about updating deathstalker rexxar's hero power with last published beast if I remember correctly)

    I guess that's them giving up...

     

    The Rokara hero card was a big offender for me.

    First, it states that you get a weapon, but won't elaborate on what makes it special.

    Then you play it, get the weapon; but again, it won't elaborate on what "smashing" means.

    So you attack with it, and you think you understand : it cause the stroke minion to deals damage equal to its attack to your opponent.

    But no, you're wrong : in fact you actually cause the minion to perform an actual attack against the opponent, triggering on-hit and on-attack effects. Which does not always make sense. :-/ And that fact can elude you for a long time if you never get to hit one of those minion where it matters. Infuriating.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    Came here to say the same thing. Really looking forward to this expansion.

  • Kidnap is a New Rogue Secret Coming to Hearthstone in the Castle Nathria Expansion - Revealed by Blizzard

    You're not wrong, and it is arguably the least informative wording they have ever put on a card. At least until you see the Sack token, which makes it all super apparent. I suspect there was no way of squeezing "that returns the minion to the opponent's hand when destroyed" onto the card without going way beyond the 4-line limit.

    Besides, I find there's something deeply satisfying about just saying "stuff it in a 0/4 Sack." Sure, it doesn't technically say everything that entails, but it does imply you can get them back out again, and doing that would mean the Sack has to be on the rogue's side. You could also reason from cards like Sap costing 2 and secret effects generally being stronger than normal spells of the same cost, that it probably returns to the opponent's hand rather than their board.

    You've just got to tap into your inner Murloc Holmes to work it all out. After all, Kidnapping is a crime that needs solving.