Demonxz95 - It's strange seeing Darius on a hunter card lol. Volcanic Forging seems a bit op as it's Mind Blast each turn at worst, and even more toxic immovable object at best (Bulwark of Azzinoth!!!). Legion Expedition seems ok balance wise but i'd suggest different art. The crystal alcoves i like cause it reminds me of Dragon Soul. This at least seems to be playable. One day my precious....
Well shit. I really should've thought of that, but I didn't. I'm absolutely going to need to think of some change to that.
If your complaint is that deck environment is polarised and that you need to address multiple archetypes at once, forcing you make tradeoffs between archetypes then that is just how cardgames evolve that don't want to be as vanilla as basegame LoR
There will always be the go to lategame/control the go to midrange and go to aggro archetype. The challenge ALLWAYS is to build decks that fit into the metagame and I don't struggle to come up with fitting lists right now.
The only aspect about the meta that I find to be a problem is that noxus (one of if not the best region of the patch) relies very heavily on fast skills/spells right now and that Rite of Negation is just insane against it therfore while Quicksand answers pretty much every combat based strategy a bit too well and both are in shurima.
Afterall it's good to have interaction but riot should make sure that a region doesn't get too universal answers as it seems to be the case with shurima right now
This deck and other decks like it are meant to be played in casual or after you reach legend in low mmr legend. It’s not meant to be used for climbing.
Made the quest a bit more interesting and hard to complete. The different mana cost requirement works better with the actual reward and it asks you to keep track of the values yourself. Of course it's possible the enemy does not have minions of 5 different costs but most shadow spells can target friendly minions too, or damage them anyway as they are bilateral boardclears. Could use this to resummon specific minions you want with L'ura for just 5 mana and do some combo!
New idea. No one here decided to go down the hero power reward path of Uldum so i made this. Why warrior and druid? Well, worgens are connected to druids lore wise. As for warrior... idk, armor and attacking stuff i guess. The idea is that you basically have a 2 part her power. You can only use the human form if you triggered the worgen form. Of course you can just go face with the worgen form, but the quest is viable as both control and aggro strategies.
Demonxz95 - It's strange seeing Darius on a hunter card lol. Volcanic Forging seems a bit op as it's Mind Blast each turn at worst, and even more toxic immovable object at best (Bulwark of Azzinoth!!!). Legion Expedition seems ok balance wise but i'd suggest different art. The crystal alcoves i like cause it reminds me of Dragon Soul. This at least seems to be playable. One day my precious....
CursedParrot - Not a fan of cards that are basically "add this older cooler card to your hand".
linkblade91 - Mad Summoner into Hagatha's Scheme otk. Idea is cool, near impossible to balance sadly. And i think shaman has had enough game winning quest rewards, right? xD
MrRhapsody - Giving all minions charge is a really bad idea (see Mr. Smite). The second reward doesn't really have synergy with the quest requirements. I guess it works for eggs but on the warrior side the enrage and self damage minions kinda suffer.
Patches that balance every aspect of the entire champion and deck archetype roster are good
We got 2 of those.
Expansions that result in the meta boiling down to 3 Annie decks, 3 Bard decks, 3 Illoi decks and Viego card piles are bad.
Meanwhile established archetypes drop 3-5% winrate which are largely more interesting
So pretty sure this is as calculated and accurate as a meta oppinion can get.
Like the fact that Illoi has Tahm Kench stats while being an Elise is dumb she puts up 56% winrates in every deck.
Bard and Annie are problematic for different reasons for restricting deck building. One guarantees you outscale your opponent and the other has guaranteed lethal in certain situations.
None of this is good and healthy for the game, and I wouldn't be surprised to see players taking a solid break till this stuff gets tweaked.
Don't expect any rational discussion from Nifty the guy post has been nothing but hot takes and knee jerk reactions plus getting all passive aggressive whenever someone disagree with him. As you said it's just ranting for rant sake.
Theres one very weird bug with the passives granted to nagas in mercs. Its supposed to grant all nagas +3 speed and reduce damage by 3, but what it does instead is to grant one merc this passive and then it jumps to another merc each turn.
Really makes the naga build unviable in pve, simply because its just more efficient to run other builds that actually benefit from passives.
@Cursed the new requirement is much better I think, as it's something that ties into the reward and both classes like to do. For the reward, though, I'd go with the previous one, but removing the Stealth and Lifesteal.
@Demon the DH/Warrior Quest is my fav of all you posted so far.
If you put bold coding in the middle of the word, it should get rid of the bolding, so for example, if you write "Corr[b][/b]upter" instead of "Corrupter" into the textbox, then it'll display "Corrupter" on the text of the card without bolding "Corrupt".
I do feel like this new Quest is probably better designed, but I don't really see a practical reason to run the Quest and go through the objective over just running one of those Old Gods in your deck instead. I suppose for the time it's in Standard, it would give you a way to play them again.
I just got TPK'd by these assholes. I've lost to plenty of bounty bosses and heroic encounters, but I don't think I've ever had a TPK on NORMAL to a random encounter. Can't believe how unbalanced these guys are.
What do you mean?! Targon's peak? What meemer is playing this right now?
Viego might be a bit boring as it wins 90% of times through flinging a legion desserterBADCARDNAME into the opponent's face but "synergistic crap"?! I thought synergy was the point of deckbuilding.
To me the expansion made many decks much more viable, not just thralls and I am far from bored from it.
But then it might be that you simply don't like noxus to be the new bandle city of the set, don't like how Disintegrate removes Lee Sin from any viability don't like how games now actually aren't about cycling at all (or was it you who hated that aswell?)
Whoever told you that Illaoi is the only true champion of the patch gave you pretty bad information as aside of Jhin all champions found a decent place in the meta and I really don't see how worldweaker failed on the pvp side
Welcome everybody to my latest solo project, my new custom Hearthstone expansion, The Secrets of Volcania. This is a 135-card expansion that takes place on the islands of the Volcania. Volcania is a mysterious volcanic island filled with very unique wildlife, ancient crypts, and a lot of forgotten secrets to uncover. You partake on a journey to Volcania to discover exactly what lies on this volcanic island.
Along the way, you'll come across some things on the island that you won't be quite sure what they are. You're going to have to inspect a little bit further. Inspect is the new mechanic in the set, in which cards with Inspect can be dragged from your hand to your deck to put it on top of your deck and give it an upgrade. Think of it like a cross between Tradeable and Corrupt, though Inspecting doesn't cost any mana.
Let's look at Felspiked Tracker for example.
Felspiked Tracker can be played as simply a 3 mana 3/4 Demon with Taunt, but in its base form, you can also drag it from your hand to the top of your deck to give it the Inspect upgrade. When a card is Inspected, it cannot be Inspected again (with one exception), and its card text will change to say "Inspected" on it. Inspect upgrades are treated as part of the card and not an enchantment, meaning that extra stats will not be lost when Silenced, and the effect will not reset if the card is returned to your hand. Inspect cards have a red eye banner under the mana cost symbol which goes away when the card is Inspected.
Felspiked Tracker is also an example of where Elusive is now keyworded. Elusive is the effect found on cards like Faerie Dragon, now keyworded and all cards that use the effect will be retroactively changed to use Elusive.
Dual-class cards also make a return. There are 10 all-new pairings in the set, which each get a Legendary Quest. You have two different paths to take for each Quest, so the one you choose it up to you.
Demon Hunter
Archetypes: Taunt, Handbuff, Hero Attack.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Demon Hunter/Warrior
Archetype: Taunt, Weapons.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Warrior
Archetypes: Rush, Taunt, Weapons.
Show Spoiler
Warrior/Hunter
Archetypes: Rush.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Hunter
Archetypes: Rush, Secrets.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Hunter/Rogue
Archetypes: Secrets.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Rogue
Archetypes: Secrets, Cards that didn't start in your deck.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Rogue/Priest
Archetypes: Cards that didn't start in your deck.
Show Spoiler
Token
Priest
Archetypes: Cards that didn't start in your deck, Casting multiple spells in a turn.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Priest/Mage
Archetypes: Casting multiple spells in a turn.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
Mage
Archetypes: Casting multiple spells in a turn, Fire spells.
Show Spoiler
Token
Mage/Warlock
Archetypes: Fire spells.
Show Spoiler
Token
Warlock
Archetypes: Fire spells, Murlocs.
Show Spoiler
Tokens
"Destroy your opponent's board" isn't merely just destroying all their minions, but it destroys their entire side of the board as a gameplay mechanic. While your opponent's board is destroyed, their maximum board size effectively becomes 0 for the rest of the game. They cannot play minions from their hand, and effects that summon minions will fizzle and have no effect.
For the sake of Flame Invocator's effect, your "last spell's damage" is not the same thing as the total of amount of damage it dealt, but rather what it's damage value is. For example, the damage value of Arcane Shot and Consecration are both 2. Assuming no Spell Damage is used, both of these spells will result in the Invoked Drake being a 2/2 regardless of how much total damage either of the spells dealt.
Other Neutrals
Show Spoiler
Tokens
This is my first fully completed solo project in a really long time, and it was certainly fun making it and triumphant to finish it.
Thanks for all of the feedback, I streamlined the design a bit (hearthcards automatically makes the "Corrupt" in Corruptor bold, so if someone has a solution to that I'd appreciate that too):
For the redesign I basically just focused it on specifically Yogg Saron and N'Zoth, so now the quest requirement and the quest reward should be more in line with one another. This does shift the synergy from Thief Rogue to Deathrattle/Spell Rogue and Priest, but I think it makes the deckbuilding more open and causes the design to make a lot more sense.
Feedback:
Demonxz95- I really like your concept but I do see how it might allow for too many combos with increased attack. I think you could either make the reward only double health buffs, or do something like "For the rest of the game, your stat buffs give an extra +1|+1 and Taunt," which would remove the overpowered combos (though it might make small buffs too good and big buffs a little weak).
MrRhapsody- I agree with other commentators that the balance seems way off, Charge would be way too good and Rush+Taunt would be awful. I think a better reward might be something like "When you summon a unit with 2 or more health, deal 1 damage to it and give it +3 attack" which still has some of the same flavor but isn't as hard to balance (though with this change it would likely be too weak at 5 mana)
Linkblade91- I don't really have any feedback since your designs seem pretty good, my only worry is that in terms of gameplay the Overkill quest might be a bit frustrating since the gameplan would just be tons of removal and then a burn finisher that discourages the opponent from playing minions.
Questing For Two - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Well shit. I really should've thought of that, but I didn't. I'm absolutely going to need to think of some change to that.
When The Meta Is Sweaty Butt
If your complaint is that deck environment is polarised and that you need to address multiple archetypes at once, forcing you make tradeoffs between archetypes then that is just how cardgames evolve that don't want to be as vanilla as basegame LoR
There will always be the go to lategame/control the go to midrange and go to aggro archetype. The challenge ALLWAYS is to build decks that fit into the metagame and I don't struggle to come up with fitting lists right now.
The only aspect about the meta that I find to be a problem is that noxus (one of if not the best region of the patch) relies very heavily on fast skills/spells right now and that Rite of Negation is just insane against it therfore while Quicksand answers pretty much every combat based strategy a bit too well and both are in shurima.
Afterall it's good to have interaction but riot should make sure that a region doesn't get too universal answers as it seems to be the case with shurima right now
Ambassador Faelin's Colossal Army - Wild Hearthstone Full Deck & Guide on Making Mummies Paladin on the Wildest of Wednesdays
This deck and other decks like it are meant to be played in casual or after you reach legend in low mmr legend. It’s not meant to be used for climbing.
How to Complete Y'Shaarj Mercenaries Event Task 2 "Sustained No More" - Tips & Parties Inside
Thanks for the comp -- I was able to complete the quest on my second try (I was a little [ahem] aggressive on my first attempt).
My Hero Power Mage Deck 3.0 Is Better At Throne of the Tides Mini-Set | Hearthstone
Elaborate, explain your affirmation.
What do you consider wrong and "doesnt synergize with anything found in this decklist"
Until then, your affirmation is invalid and incorrect.
Questing For Two - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Made the quest a bit more interesting and hard to complete. The different mana cost requirement works better with the actual reward and it asks you to keep track of the values yourself. Of course it's possible the enemy does not have minions of 5 different costs but most shadow spells can target friendly minions too, or damage them anyway as they are bilateral boardclears. Could use this to resummon specific minions you want with L'ura for just 5 mana and do some combo!
New idea. No one here decided to go down the hero power reward path of Uldum so i made this. Why warrior and druid? Well, worgens are connected to druids lore wise. As for warrior... idk, armor and attacking stuff i guess. The idea is that you basically have a 2 part her power. You can only use the human form if you triggered the worgen form. Of course you can just go face with the worgen form, but the quest is viable as both control and aggro strategies.
When The Meta Is Sweaty Butt
I'm very rational.
Patches that balance every aspect of the entire champion and deck archetype roster are good
We got 2 of those.
Expansions that result in the meta boiling down to 3 Annie decks, 3 Bard decks, 3 Illoi decks and Viego card piles are bad.
Meanwhile established archetypes drop 3-5% winrate which are largely more interesting
So pretty sure this is as calculated and accurate as a meta oppinion can get.
Like the fact that Illoi has Tahm Kench stats while being an Elise is dumb she puts up 56% winrates in every deck.
Bard and Annie are problematic for different reasons for restricting deck building. One guarantees you outscale your opponent and the other has guaranteed lethal in certain situations.
None of this is good and healthy for the game, and I wouldn't be surprised to see players taking a solid break till this stuff gets tweaked.
How to Complete Y'Shaarj Mercenaries Event Task 1 "Mountain Hikers" - Tips & Parties Inside
The Orc build worked like a charm, in spite of my sloppy climb. Thanks for the comp!
Ambassador Faelin's Colossal Army - Wild Hearthstone Full Deck & Guide on Making Mummies Paladin on the Wildest of Wednesdays
This is a very very nice deck, but is literally unplayable in this aggro meta, no way to comeback on board against pirate rogue or similar
When The Meta Is Sweaty Butt
Don't expect any rational discussion from Nifty the guy post has been nothing but hot takes and knee jerk reactions plus getting all passive aggressive whenever someone disagree with him. As you said it's just ranting for rant sake.
Hearthstone Patch 23.4.2 Brings Arena Adjustments, Bug Fixes for Cards & Mercenaries, Plus Lord Barov’s Return as Diablo Departs Battlegrounds
It was terrible to discover that Golden Minions from Bigglesworth did not work.
Hearthstone Patch 23.4.2 Brings Arena Adjustments, Bug Fixes for Cards & Mercenaries, Plus Lord Barov’s Return as Diablo Departs Battlegrounds
Oh man, I was having fun with shattershambler and Necrium Blade. Ah well
How to Complete Y'Shaarj Mercenaries Event Task 5 "No Shivers" - Tips & Parties Inside
He is, but only at heart!
Hearthstone Patch 23.4.2 Brings Arena Adjustments, Bug Fixes for Cards & Mercenaries, Plus Lord Barov’s Return as Diablo Departs Battlegrounds
Theres one very weird bug with the passives granted to nagas in mercs. Its supposed to grant all nagas +3 speed and reduce damage by 3, but what it does instead is to grant one merc this passive and then it jumps to another merc each turn.
Really makes the naga build unviable in pve, simply because its just more efficient to run other builds that actually benefit from passives.
Questing For Two - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
@Cursed the new requirement is much better I think, as it's something that ties into the reward and both classes like to do. For the reward, though, I'd go with the previous one, but removing the Stealth and Lifesteal.
@Demon the DH/Warrior Quest is my fav of all you posted so far.
Hearthstone Patch 23.4.2 Brings Arena Adjustments, Bug Fixes for Cards & Mercenaries, Plus Lord Barov’s Return as Diablo Departs Battlegrounds
Nice, I can play Battlegrounds again
Questing For Two - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
I just posted my expansion (which you should totally check out by the way). I'm just going to say fuck it and throw three more of my Quests into the fray of this competition.
I do feel like this new Quest is probably better designed, but I don't really see a practical reason to run the Quest and go through the objective over just running one of those Old Gods in your deck instead. I suppose for the time it's in Standard, it would give you a way to play them again.
My Hero Power Mage Deck 3.0 Is Better At Throne of the Tides Mini-Set | Hearthstone
Worst Hero power mage doesnt synergize with anything found in this decklist
I just got TPK'd by these assholes. I've lost to plenty of bounty bosses and heroic encounters, but I don't think I've ever had a TPK on NORMAL to a random encounter. Can't believe how unbalanced these guys are.
The Dawning Cataclysms - A Custom Hearthstone Expansion (FINISHED)
Eyyyy tysm!
Baba Naga
This is a play on Baba Yaga, a witch from Slavic lore who lives in the forest and either helps, imprisons, or eats those she encounters.
GvG Rebalance Patch
I was expecting doctor boom
When The Meta Is Sweaty Butt
What do you mean?! Targon's peak? What meemer is playing this right now?
Viego might be a bit boring as it wins 90% of times through flinging a legion desserterBADCARDNAME into the opponent's face but "synergistic crap"?! I thought synergy was the point of deckbuilding.
To me the expansion made many decks much more viable, not just thralls and I am far from bored from it.
But then it might be that you simply don't like noxus to be the new bandle city of the set, don't like how Disintegrate removes Lee Sin from any viability don't like how games now actually aren't about cycling at all (or was it you who hated that aswell?)
Whoever told you that Illaoi is the only true champion of the patch gave you pretty bad information as aside of Jhin all champions found a decent place in the meta and I really don't see how worldweaker failed on the pvp side
The Secrets of Volcania - Custom Hearthstone Expansion (Finished!)
Welcome everybody to my latest solo project, my new custom Hearthstone expansion, The Secrets of Volcania. This is a 135-card expansion that takes place on the islands of the Volcania. Volcania is a mysterious volcanic island filled with very unique wildlife, ancient crypts, and a lot of forgotten secrets to uncover. You partake on a journey to Volcania to discover exactly what lies on this volcanic island.
Along the way, you'll come across some things on the island that you won't be quite sure what they are. You're going to have to inspect a little bit further. Inspect is the new mechanic in the set, in which cards with Inspect can be dragged from your hand to your deck to put it on top of your deck and give it an upgrade. Think of it like a cross between Tradeable and Corrupt, though Inspecting doesn't cost any mana.
Let's look at Felspiked Tracker for example.
Felspiked Tracker can be played as simply a 3 mana 3/4 Demon with Taunt, but in its base form, you can also drag it from your hand to the top of your deck to give it the Inspect upgrade. When a card is Inspected, it cannot be Inspected again (with one exception), and its card text will change to say "Inspected" on it. Inspect upgrades are treated as part of the card and not an enchantment, meaning that extra stats will not be lost when Silenced, and the effect will not reset if the card is returned to your hand. Inspect cards have a red eye banner under the mana cost symbol which goes away when the card is Inspected.
Felspiked Tracker is also an example of where Elusive is now keyworded. Elusive is the effect found on cards like Faerie Dragon, now keyworded and all cards that use the effect will be retroactively changed to use Elusive.
Dual-class cards also make a return. There are 10 all-new pairings in the set, which each get a Legendary Quest. You have two different paths to take for each Quest, so the one you choose it up to you.
Demon Hunter
Archetypes: Taunt, Handbuff, Hero Attack.
Tokens
Demon Hunter/Warrior
Archetype: Taunt, Weapons.
Tokens
Warrior
Archetypes: Rush, Taunt, Weapons.
Warrior/Hunter
Archetypes: Rush.
Tokens
Hunter
Archetypes: Rush, Secrets.
Tokens
Hunter/Rogue
Archetypes: Secrets.
Tokens
Rogue
Archetypes: Secrets, Cards that didn't start in your deck.
Tokens
Rogue/Priest
Archetypes: Cards that didn't start in your deck.
Token
Priest
Archetypes: Cards that didn't start in your deck, Casting multiple spells in a turn.
Tokens
Priest/Mage
Archetypes: Casting multiple spells in a turn.
Tokens
Mage
Archetypes: Casting multiple spells in a turn, Fire spells.
Token
Mage/Warlock
Archetypes: Fire spells.
Token
Warlock
Archetypes: Fire spells, Murlocs.
Tokens
Warlock/Shaman
Archetypes: Murlocs.
Tokens
Shaman
Archetypes: Murlocs/Minion summoning.
Tokens
Shaman/Paladin
Archetypes: Minion summoning.
Tokens
Paladin
Archetypes: Minion summoning, Minion enchanting.
Tokens
Paladin/Druid
Archetypes: Minion enchanting.
Tokens
Druid
Archetypes: Minion enchanting, Taunt, Hero Attack.
Token
Druid/Demon Hunter
Archetypes: Taunt, Hero Attack.
Tokens
Neutral Commons
Tokens
Other Neutrals
Tokens
This is my first fully completed solo project in a really long time, and it was certainly fun making it and triumphant to finish it.
Questing For Two - Card Design Competition Discussion Thread
Thanks for all of the feedback, I streamlined the design a bit (hearthcards automatically makes the "Corrupt" in Corruptor bold, so if someone has a solution to that I'd appreciate that too):
For the redesign I basically just focused it on specifically Yogg Saron and N'Zoth, so now the quest requirement and the quest reward should be more in line with one another. This does shift the synergy from Thief Rogue to Deathrattle/Spell Rogue and Priest, but I think it makes the deckbuilding more open and causes the design to make a lot more sense.
Feedback:
Demonxz95- I really like your concept but I do see how it might allow for too many combos with increased attack. I think you could either make the reward only double health buffs, or do something like "For the rest of the game, your stat buffs give an extra +1|+1 and Taunt," which would remove the overpowered combos (though it might make small buffs too good and big buffs a little weak).
MrRhapsody- I agree with other commentators that the balance seems way off, Charge would be way too good and Rush+Taunt would be awful. I think a better reward might be something like "When you summon a unit with 2 or more health, deal 1 damage to it and give it +3 attack" which still has some of the same flavor but isn't as hard to balance (though with this change it would likely be too weak at 5 mana)
Linkblade91- I don't really have any feedback since your designs seem pretty good, my only worry is that in terms of gameplay the Overkill quest might be a bit frustrating since the gameplan would just be tons of removal and then a burn finisher that discourages the opponent from playing minions.